Monday, 26 October 2015

November book: The Most Good You Can Do by Peter Singer

The Most Good You Can Do 

by Peter Singer

(chosen by CH)

Theme: The price of privilege is poverty

Some background links to get you started:


What we discussed about the book:

- is the book's core essentially a pessimistic one?
- How do you define 'the most good'?
- the difference between simple interest and compound interest - is what Singer is describing, a simple interest approach?
- generational differences in approaches to philanthropy and philosophies underpinning it
- is stopping extinction of the human race the 'ultimate good' you can do?
- the differences between donating time and donating money to organisations. Which would they prefer?

Ratings:
Range: 7 to 9 
Average: 7.83

Tuesday, 13 October 2015

October book: A Personal Matter by Kenzaburo Oe

A Personal Matter
by Kenzaburo Oe

chosen by KM

Theme: Translated from...




Some background links to get you started:



What we discussed about the book:
- is he an unreliable narrator?
-How does the translation affect the story? Without being bilingual is there any way of telling who authentic the story is?
- How does the translator mimic writing style
- the idea of parallel universes - death
- is this a dark and grotesque book?
- western vs eastern concepts of life/death
- the shame in past times / other cultures of having a disabled child
- are aspects of this book autobiographical?


Ratings
Range: 4 to 8
Average: 5.5

Monday, 14 September 2015

September book: The Rehearsal by Eleanor Catton

The Rehearsal 
by Eleanor Catton

chosen by JM

Theme: Author under 30




Some background links to get you started:


Tuesday, 18 August 2015

August Book: The Museum of Extraordinary Things by Alice Hoffman



The Museum of Extraordinay Things

by Alice Hoffman

(Chosen by Elster)

Theme: A fairytale ending









Some background links to get you started: 

What we discussed about the book:
- chosen because MC wanted something dark and gothic 
- device of magic realism
- themes of strong women and Judaism
- is there always historical fact underlying fairy tales?
- why did the fonts swap?
- hoe (practically) do you wear gloves when you have webbed fingers?
- was Maureen her mother?
- does every criminal see themselves as the hero of the story?
- what was the role of the hermit?
-was the ending too neat?

Ratings:
Range: 5 to 9
Average: 7.36

Tuesday, 14 July 2015

July book: Hello, Beautiful! by Hannie Rayson



Hello, Beautiful!

by Hannie Rayson

(Chosen by LD)

Theme: A good laugh is sunshine in a house 



Some background links to get you started: 

What we discussed about the book:
- why is it called, "Hello, beautiful!"?
- was it particularly Australian?
-What did we think of the structure of the book, like a series of scenes?
- how enjoyable was the humour in the book?
- how much as East Brighton changed as a suburb since then?
- were we expecting there to be some issue with the father that never eventuated?
- how honest was the book? if her purpose was to tell the tale in its entirety, did she do that?
- what does she say about relationships between husbands and wives?
- how have crime statistics changed between the 1960s and now?
- those of us who heard her voice on the ABC interview - were we surprised at it?


Ratings:
Range: 6 to 8.5
Average: 7.38

Tuesday, 16 June 2015

June Book: The Coat Route by Meg Lukens Doonan



The Coat Route

by Meg Lukens Doonan

(Chosen by Domestic Goddess) 







Some background links to get you started: 

What we discussed about the book:

- did different versions of the book's cover change our expectations of it?
- was it surprising how much of a story was spun out of a single coat?
- why would someone pay $50,000 for a coat? What type of person is this?
- why, in such a technologically advanced age, do specialist craftsmen still exist (and even flourish?)
- is the point of a coat like this that other people notice the quality, or that you (the owner) notice the quality?
- how shocking are the landfill statistics - disposable society...?
- what is the difference between bespoke and tailored?
- why do the top tailors stick just to men's suits?
- how has the apprenticeship process changed over the years? Is it still seen as a desirable thing for young people?
- what trades no longer exist?
- do people still have the patience to train for so long to master a skill?
- how cute are Vicuna??
- in what ways did the old-fashioned patronage system support true artists and craftsmen to master their crafts?
- when did wedding dresses become one-off wear garments?
- was this a good STORY?

Ratings:
Range: 5 to 9
Average: 8.11

Monday, 4 May 2015

May book: Only Child (Stranglehold) by Jack Ketchum


Only Child (Stranglehold) 

by Jack Ketchum 

(Chosen by JP)

Theme: One that would shock your grandmother



Some background links to get you started:


What we discussed about the book:
- is this 'one that would shock your gramdmother"?
- is that one that would shock everyone??
- how distressing was this book?
- the statistics of family violence
- role of censorship in books/movies...is anything off limits?
- did we know what 'side' the author was on?
- was Arthur's behaviour the mother's fault?
- was it a realistic ending? why did it shock us? was the ending the book's biggest flaw?
- statistics about reoffending over generations
- does the justice system adequately protect those that need it?
- how much of this story is from Robert's point of view?
- was the relationship between the judge and lawyers a boy's club?
- can we feel sorry for Arthur?
- was it realistic that Robert would be given to Ruth after the shooting?
- in what ways was character development driven in the book?

Ratings
Range: 7 to 8.5
Average: 7.625

Thursday, 30 April 2015

Minutes April book: Foe by J.M. Coetzee

Foe

by J.M.Coetzee

(chosen by Gypsy)

Theme: A classic rewritten




Gypsy chose this book to fit the theme, without reading it first (very unlike her!) So it was with a degree of trepidation that she started to read it.

About the author:

JM (John Maxwell) Coetzee was born in Cape Town, South Africa, in 1940. He studied at Cape Town and later at the University of Texas at Austin, where he earned a Ph.D. degree in literature. Since 1972 he has worked as an academic in the  University of Cape Town. He has written many works of fiction, and was awarded his first Booker Prize in 1983. In 1999 he again won Britain’s prestigious Booker Prize for Disgrace, becoming the first author to win the award twice in its 31-year history. In 2003, he was awarded the Nobel Prize in Literature..

(general biographical detail from the publisher's website)

What the publisher says about the book:
With the same electrical intensity of language and insight that he brought to Waiting for the Barbarians and The Master of Petersburg, J.M. Coetzee reinvents the story of Robinson Crusoe—and in so doing, directs our attention to the seduction and tyranny of storytelling itself.
In 1720 the eminent man of letters Daniel Foe is approached by Susan Barton, lately a castaway on a desert island. She wants him to tell her story, and that of the enigmatic man who has become her rescuer, companion, master and sometimes lover: Cruso. Cruso is dead, and his manservant, Friday, is incapable of speech. As she tries to relate the truth about him, the ambitious Barton cannot help turning Cruso into her invention. For as narrated by Foe—as by Coetzee himself—the stories we thought we knew acquire depths that are at once treacherous, elegant, and unexpectedly moving.

. What we discussed about the book:
  • What happened in the end?
  • What are the implications of changing someone else's story?
  • In what ways is this the story of 'the other' of the Robinson Crusoe story?
  • How does this subvert the 'masculine' focus of Robinson Crusoe?
  • Does this book defy conventional narrative structure? In what ways?
  • Who is Susan?
  • Were the 'O's that Friday wrote supposed to represent omega? If so, what does this mean?
  • What does this book say about the concept of freedom?
  • The role of storytelling
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • The power of an author
  • At what point did female voices appear in literature? At what point were they actually written by female authors? 
  • The role of muses in Greek mythology
  • Was this a typical 'Gypsy' book choice?
  • Different ways of communicating (e.g. literature, art, music...) and how they all have a knowledge underlying them that makes sense of the raw material
  • What does it mean to be the 'author' of a story?
In other news, we discussed:
  • Various travels
  • Communal nudity bathing experiences
Ratings:
Range: 6 to 8
Average: 7.19

Next book: Only Child (Stranglehold) by Jack Ketchum (chosen by JP)

Sunday, 12 April 2015

April book: Foe by J.M. Coetzee

Foe 

by J.M. Coetzee

(Chosen by Gypsy)




Some background links to get you started:



Tuesday, 31 March 2015

Minutes March book: A City Lost & Found: Whelan the Wrecker's Melbourne

A City Lost and Found: Whelan the Wrecker's Melbourne 

by Robyn Annear

(chosen by KE)

Theme: This is Melbourne




KE chose this book as it fulfilled the 'Melbourne' brief...but also because she thought it would be a good choice to dip in and out of, not having to necessarily read it from start to finish. Most Melbournians of our age remember the Whelan the Wrecker was here signs, so it feeds our nostalgia too. 

About the author:

Robyn Annear is an ex-typist who lives in country Victoria with somebody else's husband. She is the author of A City Lost and Found, Bearbrass, Nothing But Gold, The Man Who Lost Himself, and Fly a Rebel Flag. She has also written several pieces for The Monthly magazine.

(biographical detail from the the blurb on the book)

What the publisher says about the book:
The demolition firm of Whelan the Wrecker was a Melbourne institution for a hundred years (1892-1992). Its famous sign – 'Whelan the Wrecker is Here' on a pile of shifting rubble - was a laconic masterpiece and served as a vital sign of the city's progress. It's no stretch to say that over three generations, the Whelan family changed the face of Melbourne, demolishing hundreds of buildings in the central city alone.
In A City Lost and Found, Robyn Annear uses Whelan's demolition sites as portals to explore layers of the city laid bare by their pick-axes and iron balls. Peering beneath the rubble, she brings to light fantastic stories about Melbourne's building sites and their many incarnations. This is a book about the making – and remaking – of a city.
'Old landmarks fall in nearly every block . . . and the face of the city is changing so rapidly that the time is not too far distant when a search for a building 50 years old will be in vain.' Herald, 1925.

What we discussed about the book:
  • Who already knew about Whelan the Wrecker?
  • Was there enough focus on the Whelan family in the book to satisfy us as readers? Was the 'Whelan the Wrecker' focus a vehicle to tell a story about past Melbourne buildings?
  • Occupational health and safety considerations in the past - particularly with regards demolitions.
  • The structure of the book - was there a clear narrative?
  • What were the wider socio-political contexts of some of the demolitions/redevelopments? Was there sufficient about this in the book? 
  • How the 'Whelan the Wrecker was here' signage permeated popular culture...and the references were much wider. 
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • What is the 'lives with someone else's husband' comment in the author's biography about?
  • How did this compare with Bearbrass as far as telling a story of a past city go?
  • What makes a location 'significant'? 
  • Renovations on heritage homes - pros and cons for imitation heritage vs contemporary additions
  • How quickly do you forget previous buildings once they've been demolished and something else built? 
  • Is demolition and redevelopment a necessity? 
  • The tradition of six o'clock closing in the pubs. How that has influenced the development of Australia's drinking culture.  
In other news, we discussed:
  • Rowing - the pros, the cons, the commitment, the parental involvement..
  • Year 11 and 12 formals - all the lowdown on dresses etc 
Ratings:
Range: 6 to 7
Average: 6.5

Next book: Foe by J.M.Coetzee (chosen by Gypsy)

Monday, 23 March 2015

March book: A City Lost & Found: Whelan the Wrecker's Melbourne by Robyn Annear

A City Lost and Found: Whelan the Wrecker's Melbourne

by Robyn Annear

(Chosen by KE)


Some background links to get you started:




Saturday, 28 February 2015

Minutes February book: The Bolter

The Bolter

by Frances Osborne

(chosen by Fairlie)

Theme: Women behaving badly




I chose this book, as I have previously read it and really enjoyed it. With a family connection to that era in Kenyan history, I am fascinated by all the writings about members of the Happy Valley set.

About the author:

Frances Osborne is the author of three books. Her first biography, Lilla's Feast (2004), was about her great-grandmother who wrote a cookery book in a Japanese internment camp in China during the Second World War. The Bolter (2008) is her second biography and was a Sunday Times No. 1 bestseller  Her first novel, Park Lane, is set in a London Mansion in 1914 and will be published this year.

(general biographical detail from the author's own website)

What the publisher says about the book:
'This is a truly astonishing book. Frances Osborne has not just brought to life a dizzyingly rich and scandalous slice of social history, she has produced a tragic and deeply moving tale as well. It is far more gripping than any novel I have read for years' Antony Beevor 
On Friday 25th May, 1934, a forty-one-year-old woman walked into the lobby of Claridge's Hotel to meet the nineteen-year-old son whose face she did not know. Fifteen years earlier, as the First World War ended, Idina Sackville shocked high society by leaving his multimillionaire father to run off to Africa with a near penniless man. 
An inspiration for Nancy Mitford's character The Bolter, painted by William Orpen, and photographed by Cecil Beaton, Sackville went on to divorce a total of five times, yet died with a picture of her first love by her bed. Her struggle to reinvent her life with each new marriage left one husband murdered and branded her the 'high priestess' of White Mischief's bed-hopping Happy Valley in Kenya. 
Sackville's life was so scandalous that it was kept a secret from her great-granddaughter Frances Osborne. Now, Osborne tells the moving tale of betrayal and heartbreak behind Sackville's road to scandal and return, painting a dazzling portrait of high society in the early twentieth century.
What we discussed about the book:
  • Was Idina a bolter or a boltee? What role did her husband's behaviour play in her decision to leave?
  • Is there sufficient evidence that Sakville is Mitford's Bolter?
  • Was the Edwardian 'system' of fidelity in a marriage more workable that current concepts of monogamous marriages?
  • To what extent was the behaviour exhibited class driven?
  • What was Alice's role in the Jos Hay murder?
  • Why is Idina's story interesting to us?
  • What is the author's attitude toward her great-grandmother?
  • Did Idina have her own moral code? e.g. not stealing a husband?
  • What were Idina's most redeeming features?
  • What were the most shocking aspects of her behaviour?
  • How did Alice get away with (attempted) murder in Paris?
  • What would Idina have been like as an old woman? 
  • What was the influence of Idina's own mother's behaviour on her?
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • What is the definition of 'women behaving badly'? Does it change depending on a woman's age? 
  • What is a 'man behaving badly'? What behaviour is unforgivable in a man?
  • The tradition of sending small children to boarding school in England.
  • Sheila Milbank - Australian 'it' girl, and her role in bringing Idina and David together 
  • How would today's psychology label Idina? How would today's media represent her?
  • Is a 'bolter' a more derogatory term than a 'bounder'? What is the appropriate male label for a bolter?
In other news, we discussed:
  • Old telephone exchanges - how operators used to connect the calls
  • The Hep A from frozen berries debacle
  • Various forms of Asian gastros
  • The class system in Cambodia
Ratings:
Range: 7 to 8.5
Average: 7.69

Next book:  A City Lost and Found: Whelan the Wrecker's Melbourne by Robyn Annear

Tuesday, 10 February 2015

February book: The Bolter by Frances Osborne

The Bolter

by Frances Osborne

(chosen by Fairlie)

Theme: Women behaving badly







Some background links to get you started:

Wednesday, 31 December 2014

Books read in 2014

The ratings recorded below reflect an average of the members' ratings (out of ten) of their personal experience of the reading of that book. The links take you to the post that contains the minutes for that book's discussion.

The Fight by Norman Mailer
Rating: 6.61
(Theme: winning isn't everything, but wanting to win is)

One Day by David Nicholls
Rating: 7.66
(Theme: from the page to the screen)

Revolutionary Road by Richard Yates
Rating: 7.75
(Theme: all that glitters is not gold )

The Namesake by Jhumpa Lahiri
Rating: 7.92
(Theme: book with a bird on the cover)

The Go-Between By L.P.Hartley
Rating: 8.83
(Theme: the past is a foreign country)

Poorly Made in China by Paul Midler
Rating: 7.44
(Theme: made in China)

The Secret History by Donna Tartt
Rating: 9.0
(Theme: to sir with love, reliving school days)

The Ancestor Game by Alex Miller
Rating: 6.75
(Theme: Miles Franklin Award Winner)

The Dinner by Herman Koch
Rating: 5.57
(Theme: an author you haven't heard of before)

The Fictional Woman by Tara Moss
Rating: 7.42
(Theme: true life is stranger than fiction)

Thursday, 13 November 2014

November book: The Fictional Woman by Tara Moss

The Fictional Woman

by Tara Moss

(chosen by KE)

Theme: True life is stranger than fiction




Some background links to get you started:

What we discussed about the book:
- how does the photo of the author affect our percetons of the book? Did that change as we read it?
- what conditions out percpetions of appearance
- why do we notice women's clothing/hair/shoes etc but not men's?
- did we feel frustrated with the book?
- what are the dominant types of female characters in TV and film? Has that changed?
- does free speech need limits?
- does a woman do more housework the more paid work she does?
- what are the (good) effects of appearance on opportunity?
- have we read more female or male-authored books? Has anyone noticed?
- would we suggest this book for our daughters to read?
- what are the solutions/alternatives?


Ratings
Range:6.5 to 8
Average: 7.42

Sunday, 19 October 2014

October book: The Dinner by Herman Koch

The Dinner

by Herman Koch 

(chosen by T-Rex)

Theme: An author you haven't heard of before




Some background links to get you started:
What we discussed about the book:
- what *should* a parent do in these circumstances?
- was there elements of (black) humour in the restaurant scenes?
- as the characters are unveiled how is the narrator revealed as unreliable?
- was the bicycle shop scene the first hint of things to come?
- is the brother the only one who brushes with a conscience?
- are we, the readers, tricked into our response to the politician?
- sheen of middle class morality over middle class decay
- was the setting realistic for such a discussion?
- the psychological disease he claims to have doesn't exist (i.e. can be picked up in utereo)
- nature vs nurture, genetic vs environment
- are we just acting out our fates, or do we choose our destinations?
- is Clare a moral compass?
- is the purpose of the book to show us how thin the veneer of respectability is?
- are Paul and Clare nature vs Serge and Babette nurture?
- at what point as parents should you take a stand?
- did it matter that we hated every character?
- did we feel tricked that we didn't realised their true natures initially?
- is this a good translation? how would we know?

Ratings
Range: 3 to 7.5
Average: 5.57

Tuesday, 30 September 2014

Minutes September book: The Ancestor Game

The Ancestor Game

by Alex Miller

(chosen by Fairlie)

Theme: Miles Franklin Award winner




In choosing this book, I looked at the full list of Miles Franklin Award winners. Many of my first choices were too long to fit our page length limit. As we had read and mostly all enjoyed Alex Miller's Lovesong, I thought I would choose another title by the same author.

About the author:

Alex Miller has won the Miles Franklin Literary Award twice, first in 1993 for The Ancestor Game and again in 2003 for Journey to the Stone Country. He is also an overall winner of the Commonwealth Writers' Prize, in 1993 for The Ancestor Game. In 2008 he was awarded the Manning Clark Medal for an outstanding contribution to Australian cultural life. His books are published internationally and widely in translation. In 2012 he was awarded the prestigious Melbourne Prize for Literature and he is a Fellow of the Australian Academy of the Humanities.

(general biographical detail from the publisher's website 

What the publisher says about the book:
Steven Muir, August Spiess and his daughter Gertrude, and Lang Tzu all acknowledge a restless sense of cultural displacement, an ambivalence in their relations with the culture of European Australia. Steven left England for Australia as a young man and his one attempt at returning is unsuccessful. August Spiess, although he speaks frequently of returning to his native Hamburg, fails to make the journey, as does his daughter Gertrude. Lang Tzu's very name defines his fate: 'two characters which in Mandarin signify the son who goes away.'
The 'game', however, does have winners. For despite their yearnings for the home of their ancestral dreams, a desire to belong somewhere that is truly their own, none of Miller's characters leaves Australia, and each in their own way comes to see that to be at home in exile may be a defining paradox of the European Australian condition: the paradox of belonging and estrangement that perhaps lies uneasily at the heart of all European cultures. 
The Ancestor Game, which Robert Dessaix described as 'one of the most engrossing books I've read in a long time', is an enthralling journey into the ancestral dreams and present dilemmas of a rich cast of characters.
What we discussed about the book:
  • The role of myth and storytelling in memory.
  • The relationships between history, fiction and truth.  What constitutes each? 
  • How do others' expectations inform our own memory of identity - e.g. Dorsett?
  • Does the history of intimate and small moments inform our reading of a novel far more than the the history of politics or economics?
  • What were the links between the various characters? How did  know Steven know Lang?
  • How we kept track (or didn't) of the family tree aspect of the Fengs (for instance...who was Feng 3?)
  • Was it immediately obvious that this was a novel, rather than a series of short stories? How did we make those links?
  • Who was Gertrude's mother?
  • Were we able to easily traverse the jumps in chronology?
  • What was the point of the fire on the deck of the boat?
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • Why did so many people who had written on-line reviews (e.g. on Goodreads) give up on this book?
  • Is there some kind of cosmic message that so many of the books we've read this year feature the concept of Janus (looking forwards and looking backwards)?
In other news, we discussed:
  • Concerns about non-stick frying pans and their health implications
  • On-line dating criteria...how specific should you be in your description of what you're looking for?
  • Leadership selection processes at schools...is there a perfect system?
Ratings:
Range: 6 to 8
Average: 6.75

Next book: The Dinner by Herman Koch (chosen by T-Rex)

Friday, 12 September 2014

September book: The Ancestor Game by Alex Miller

The Ancestor Game 

by Alex Miller 

(chosen by Fairlie)

Theme: Miles Franklin Award winner




Some background links to get you started:


Sunday, 31 August 2014

Minutes August book: The Secret History

The Secret History

by Donna Tartt

(chosen by JP)

Theme: To sir with love. Reliving school days.




In choosing her book, JP initially looked at all the books she had read at school herself, but then she embraced a wider interpretation and looked for books set in schools. Most were children's or young adult titles, but then a friend recommended The Secret History.

About the author:

Donna Tartt was born in Greenwood, Mississippi and is a graduate of Bennington College. She is the author of the novels The Secret History, The Goldfinch and The Little Friend, which have been translated into thirty languages.

She does not like to discuss personal details about her life as she says it draws attention away from the books, and the books are the main thing.

(general biographical detail from the publisher's website and article in The LA Times)

What the publisher says about the book:
Donna Tartt, winner of the 2014 Pulitzer Prize for her most recent novel, The Goldfinch, established herself as a major talent with The Secret History, which has become a contemporary classic.
Under the influence of their charismatic classics professor, a group of clever, eccentric misfits at an elite New England college discover a way of thinking and living that is a world away from the humdrum existence of their contemporaries. But when they go beyond the boundaries of normal morality their lives are changed profoundly and forever, and they discover how hard it can be to truly live and how easy it is to kill.
What we discussed about the book:
  • The structure of the book - is it appealing? how does it create apprehension rather than surprise? In what ways does it create a cool, classical inevitability of tragedy?
  • What was the 'fatal flaw' (viz. Greek tragedy) that leads to the hero's downfall?
  • Richard's need for belonging - despite poverty and fabrication of lies, the prize was the beauty of belonging
  • How were we convinced that Bunny should be murdered?
  • What was Julian's role in encouraging the group behaviour?
  • What factors lead a group to kill one of their own?
  • Was there any guilt and/or redemption for any of the characters?
  • Is the narrator manipulating the reader?
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • The storytelling conventions of traditional Greek tragedy - 'hurbis', 'ate' and 'nemisis'.
  • Does the idea of a 'fatal flaw' exist outside literature?
  • What constitutes an evil person?
  • The idea of religious fanaticism and belonging to a group/cult/organisation?
  • The difference (legally) between manslaughter and murder in Australia
  • What does this novel highlight about youth drug and alcohol use?
In other news, we discussed:
  • Schools, leadership, parenting, school choices...all the usual...
  • Friends who have cult-like habits
  • The status of smoking in Australia
  • The concept of a 1pm-2pm 'lawyer's lunch'
  • Dreams
  • Redemption
Ratings:
Range: 6.5 to 10
Average: 9

Next book: The Ancestor Game by Alex Miller (chosen by Fairlie)

Sunday, 17 August 2014

August book: The Secret History by Donna Tartt

The Secret History 

by Donna Tartt 

(chosen by JP)

Theme: To sir with love, reliving school days




Some background links to get you started: