Wednesday, 15 June 2011

Minutes June book: Franklin and Eleanor: An Extraordinary Marriage

Franklin and Eleanor: An Extraordinary Marriage

by Hazel Rowley

(chosen by KE)





KE chose this book after reading several articles in The Age about the book itself, and then around a month later, the author's sudden untimely death.  KE says that "people books" are her thing, and therefore biography is an appealing genre for her.

About the author:

Hazel Rowley was brought up in England and Australia, and was living in New York City at the time of her sudden, unexpected death in March of this year.

Previous books include Tête-à-Tête: The Tumultuous Lives and Loves of Simone de Beauvoir and Jean-Paul Sartre, Richard Wright: The Life and Times and Christina Stead: A Biography. The latter was published in Australia in 1993, where it won the 1993 National Book Award for Nonfiction.

A passionate speaker, she appeared at numerous book festivals and literary events in the United States, Canada, the UK, France, and Australia. She was on a US nationwide book tour for Franklin and Eleanor at the time of her death, and had planned to tour Australia later in the year.

(general biographical details from the author's website)

What the publisher says about the book:

Franklin Delano and Eleanor Roosevelt’s marriage is one of the most celebrated and scrutinized partnerships in presidential history. It raised eyebrows in their lifetimes and has only become more controversial since their deaths. From FDR’s lifelong romance with Lucy Mercer to Eleanor’s purported lesbianism—and many scandals in between—the American public has never tired of speculating about the ties that bound these two headstrong individuals. Some claim that Eleanor sacrificed her personal happiness to accommodate FDR’s needs; others claim that the marriage was nothing more than a gracious facade for political convenience. No one has told the full story until now.

In this groundbreaking new account of the marriage, Hazel Rowley describes the remarkable courage and lack of convention—private and public—that kept FDR and Eleanor together. She reveals a partnership that was both supportive and daring. Franklin, especially, knew what he owed to Eleanor, who was not so much behind the scenes as heavily engaged in them. Their relationship was the product of FDR and Eleanor’s conscious efforts—a partnership that they created according to their own ambitions and needs.

In this dramatic and vivid narrative, set against the great upheavals of the Depression and World War II, Rowley paints a portrait of a tender lifelong companionship, born of mutual admiration and compassion. Most of all, she depicts an extraordinary evolution—from conventional Victorian marriage to the bold and radical partnership that has made Franklin and Eleanor Roosevelt go down in history as one of the most inspiring and fascinating couples of all time
What we discussed about the book:
  • The domestic life of FDR and Eleanor seemed to be based around a model of communal living with many family outsiders. Why? How did this work for them?
  • What were the differences in the way the media and the political process interacted then compared with now? Would it be possible now to keep a secret such as not being able to walk from the public? Why does/doesn't this fact matter?
  • Would FDR (or anyone else with severe physical disability) be voted President of the US today?
  • What was the nature of Eleanor's relationships with Louis Howe and Earl Miller?  What influence did they have on her?
  • What was the nature of FDR's relationships with various women? What evidence does Rowley show as to the nature of the relationships?
  • In what way was his relationship with Lucy different? Why was Eleanor upset that she had been there when he died?
  • How did FDR's mother manipulate the marriage and the course of the family's lives? Was it purely a financial power over them, or was there more to it?
  • Why was FDR able to achieve so much in his first 100 days of office? How has that "100 days" mythology now permeated all politicians plans of action when first elected?
  • What kind of mother was Eleanor? What evidence did Rowley illuminate on this question?
  • Did Eleanor always seek reassurance in her interactions with others? Was she a people-pleaser? Did we think she was charismatic?
  • How did this book add flesh to the story of Churchill, Stalin and Roosevelt's interactions? Did we feel we understood the machinations of the Second World War better reading it from a personal perspective?
  • Was the continued employment of Henrietta Nesbit and her horrendously bad cooking a passive-aggressive ploy on the part of Eleanor? Did FDR have to put up with it in order not to upset the balance of power in their relationship?
  • Was Eleanor a feminist role-model?
  • Was there too much, too little or just right amount of politics in this book?
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • From the background reading we had done, what were the themes that united the biographies that Rowley wrote? (courage, risk taking, interest in outsiders, relationships that enlarged people’s lives, politically left leaning)
  • What parallels did we see between Eleanor's story and that of Hilary Clinton?
  • How complex the Roosevelt family tree was - did any of us understand exactly how FDR and Eleanor were related?
  • Why girls will often adore dysfunctional fathers regardless of their behaviour.
  • The 'harem' model of domestic arrangement - multiple women co-habiting - can this work? Why/how does it work?
In other news, we discussed:
  • How Domestic Goddess listened to this book on her iPhone. She feel asleep at one stage and woke up with Missy in a wheelchair.
  • KE's youthful Cadillac drive from Detroit to Boston, with a washing line strung across the back seat drying off their smalls.
  • Agnostics vs atheists: what is the difference?
  • Fairlie's badly-behaved Bengals one of whom took a shine to Gypsy's furry coat and plonked himself on her lap, while the other stood commandingly at a window asking to be let in. Effing cats.
  • We congratulated the new Doctor in the house.

Ratings:
Range: 7.5 to 9
Average: 8.35

Next book: Freedom by Jonathon Franzen (chosen by Dr LC)

Sunday, 12 June 2011

June book: Franklin and Eleanor. An Extraordinary Marriage by Hazel Rowley

Franklin and Eleanor. An Extraordinary Marriage

by Hazel Rowley

(chosen by KE)








Some background links to get you started:

Minutes May book: The Secret Scripture by Sebastian Barry

The Secret Scripture

by Sebastian Barry

(chosen by Gypsy)





 
(ed note: Thanks to KM for taking the minutes in my absence!)

Gypsy started the meeting by sharing that after the 'trauma' of her last choice (Twilight), she spent lots of time on the selection of this book.

About the author:

Sebastian Barry was born in 1955 in Dublin, the son of the late Irish actress Joan O’Hara. He was educated there at Trinity College. He has held academic posts including Honorary Fellow in Writing at the University of Iowa and Writer Fellow at Trinity College, Dublin, as well as working as a playwright, novelist and poet. His play The Steward of Christendom (1995), was first staged at the Royal Court Theatre Upstairs in March 1995, and subsequently transferred to Broadway. His 2005 novel A Long Long Way was shortlisted for the Man Booker Prize. He now lives in County Wicklow, Ireland, with his family.

(general biographical detail from the publisher's reading guide)

 What the publisher says about the book:

Roseanne McNulty, perhaps nearing her one-hundredth birthday - no one is quite sure - faces an uncertain future, as the Roscommon Regional Mental Hospital where she's spent the best part of her adult life prepares for closure. Over the weeks leading up to this upheaval, she talks often with her psychiatrist Dr Grene. This relationship, guarded but trusting after so many years, intensifies and complicates as Dr Grene mourns the death of his wife.

Told through their respective journals, the story that emerges - of Roseanne's family in 1930s Sligo - is at once shocking and deeply beautiful. Refracted through the haze of memory and retelling, Roseanne's story becomes an alternative, secret, history of Ireland. Exquisitely written, it is the story of a life blighted by terrible mistreatment and ignorance, and yet marked still by love and passion and hope.

What we discussed about the book:

  • Sebastian Barry was a catholic who married a protestant and his great grandfather was his inspiration for John Clear
  • Barry weaved lots of personal family stories into his book, in particular he wanted to rescue the 'lost' women
  • Memory - from different perspectives - both are "truthful"
  • Can memory rescue us from the past?
  • Mental health - how were they treated.
And we were side-tracked into:
  • Apparently best practice suggests to deal with post traumatic events 3 months after the event
  • The Irish plan for independence from Britain - 1919 - 1921. Then Ireland went into a civil war between the free staters and republicans (IRA)
  • The catholic church was very strong and influential
  • The Presbyterian church started in Scotland 1707. Some of their doctrines are different. They have baptism and communion. Their churches have austere interiors.
In other news, we discussed: 

  • The clever Breville kettle that moderates the heat of the water according to the hot drink - i.e. tea, coffee
  • The wonderful dessert made by Elster. (Maggie Beer's recipe of chocolate and quince tart served with ice cream. We were also spoilt with nougat and home made coconut cupcakes)
  • The Royal Wedding.......yes, we discussed Fergie's girls and THAT hat

Ratings:
Range  7 - 9
Average 7.9

Next book:
Franklin and Eleanor. An extraordinary marriage. by Hazel Rowley (chosen by KE)