Showing posts with label JP's choices. Show all posts
Showing posts with label JP's choices. Show all posts

Monday, 4 May 2015

May book: Only Child (Stranglehold) by Jack Ketchum


Only Child (Stranglehold) 

by Jack Ketchum 

(Chosen by JP)

Theme: One that would shock your grandmother



Some background links to get you started:


What we discussed about the book:
- is this 'one that would shock your gramdmother"?
- is that one that would shock everyone??
- how distressing was this book?
- the statistics of family violence
- role of censorship in books/movies...is anything off limits?
- did we know what 'side' the author was on?
- was Arthur's behaviour the mother's fault?
- was it a realistic ending? why did it shock us? was the ending the book's biggest flaw?
- statistics about reoffending over generations
- does the justice system adequately protect those that need it?
- how much of this story is from Robert's point of view?
- was the relationship between the judge and lawyers a boy's club?
- can we feel sorry for Arthur?
- was it realistic that Robert would be given to Ruth after the shooting?
- in what ways was character development driven in the book?

Ratings
Range: 7 to 8.5
Average: 7.625

Sunday, 31 August 2014

Minutes August book: The Secret History

The Secret History

by Donna Tartt

(chosen by JP)

Theme: To sir with love. Reliving school days.




In choosing her book, JP initially looked at all the books she had read at school herself, but then she embraced a wider interpretation and looked for books set in schools. Most were children's or young adult titles, but then a friend recommended The Secret History.

About the author:

Donna Tartt was born in Greenwood, Mississippi and is a graduate of Bennington College. She is the author of the novels The Secret History, The Goldfinch and The Little Friend, which have been translated into thirty languages.

She does not like to discuss personal details about her life as she says it draws attention away from the books, and the books are the main thing.

(general biographical detail from the publisher's website and article in The LA Times)

What the publisher says about the book:
Donna Tartt, winner of the 2014 Pulitzer Prize for her most recent novel, The Goldfinch, established herself as a major talent with The Secret History, which has become a contemporary classic.
Under the influence of their charismatic classics professor, a group of clever, eccentric misfits at an elite New England college discover a way of thinking and living that is a world away from the humdrum existence of their contemporaries. But when they go beyond the boundaries of normal morality their lives are changed profoundly and forever, and they discover how hard it can be to truly live and how easy it is to kill.
What we discussed about the book:
  • The structure of the book - is it appealing? how does it create apprehension rather than surprise? In what ways does it create a cool, classical inevitability of tragedy?
  • What was the 'fatal flaw' (viz. Greek tragedy) that leads to the hero's downfall?
  • Richard's need for belonging - despite poverty and fabrication of lies, the prize was the beauty of belonging
  • How were we convinced that Bunny should be murdered?
  • What was Julian's role in encouraging the group behaviour?
  • What factors lead a group to kill one of their own?
  • Was there any guilt and/or redemption for any of the characters?
  • Is the narrator manipulating the reader?
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • The storytelling conventions of traditional Greek tragedy - 'hurbis', 'ate' and 'nemisis'.
  • Does the idea of a 'fatal flaw' exist outside literature?
  • What constitutes an evil person?
  • The idea of religious fanaticism and belonging to a group/cult/organisation?
  • The difference (legally) between manslaughter and murder in Australia
  • What does this novel highlight about youth drug and alcohol use?
In other news, we discussed:
  • Schools, leadership, parenting, school choices...all the usual...
  • Friends who have cult-like habits
  • The status of smoking in Australia
  • The concept of a 1pm-2pm 'lawyer's lunch'
  • Dreams
  • Redemption
Ratings:
Range: 6.5 to 10
Average: 9

Next book: The Ancestor Game by Alex Miller (chosen by Fairlie)

Sunday, 17 August 2014

August book: The Secret History by Donna Tartt

The Secret History 

by Donna Tartt 

(chosen by JP)

Theme: To sir with love, reliving school days




Some background links to get you started:




Tuesday, 23 July 2013

Minutes July book: The In-Between World of Vikram Lall

The In-Between World of Vikram Lall

by M.G. Vassanji

(chosen by JP)

Theme: "Power does not corrupt, fear corrupts. Perhaps fear of the loss of power."


JP researched the theme for her book choice, and realised that it was a John Steinbeck quote from the novel, The Short Reign of Pippin IV, a political satire. She decided that any book she chose should focus on the WHY of power and corruption. Some initial options she examined were: The Betrayal by YA Erskine,  No Fear: A Whistlebowers Triumph over Corruption and Retaliation at the EPA by Marsha Coleman-Abedayo and The Story of My Assassins: a Novel by Tarun J Teijpal. In each of those cases, the story was told by a victim or an observer of corruption. JP wanted to choose one told through the eyes of the perpetrator - so eventually she found The In-Between World of Vikram Lall.

About the author:

M.G. Vassanji was born in Kenya, and raised in Tanzania. He took a doctorate in physics at M.I.T. and came to Canada in 1978. While working as a research associate and lecturer at the University of Toronto in the 1980s he began to dedicate himself seriously to a longstanding passion: writing. His first novel, The Gunny Sack, won a regional Commonwealth Writers Prize, and he was invited to be writer-in-residence at the University of Iowa. The novel’s success was a spur, Vassanji has commented: “It was translated into several languages. I was confident that this was what I could do, that writing was not just wishful thinking. In 1989 I quit my full-time job and began researching The Book of Secrets.” That celebrated, bestselling novel won the inaugural Giller Prize, in 1994. Vassanji’s other books include the acclaimed novels No New Land (1991) and Amriika (1999), and Uhuru Street (1991), a collection of stories. His unique place in Canadian literature comes from his elegant, classical style, his narrative reach, and his interest in characters trying to reconcile different worlds within themselves. The subtle relations of the past and present are also constants in his writing: “When someone asks you where you are from or who you are, there is a whole resume of who you are. I know very few people who do not have a past to explain. That awareness is part of my work.” M.G. Vassanji was awarded the Harbourfront Festival Prize in 1994 in recognition of his achievement in and contribution to the world of letters, and was in the same year chosen as one of twelve Canadians on Maclean’s Honour Roll. He lives in Toronto with his wife and two sons.

(general biographical detail from the publisher's website)

What the publisher says about the book:
Double Giller Prize winner M.G. Vassanji’s The In-Between World of Vikram Lall is a haunting novel of corruption and regret that brings to life the complexity and turbulence of Kenyan society in the last five decades. Rich in sensuous detail and historical insight, this is a powerful story of passionate betrayals and political violence, racial tension and the strictures of tradition, told in elegant, assured prose. The novel begins in 1953, with eight-year-old Vikram Lall a witness to the celebrations around the coronation of Queen Elizabeth II, just as the Mau Mau guerilla war for independence from Britain begins to gain strength. In a land torn apart by idealism, doubt, political upheaval and terrible acts of violence, Vic and his sister Deepa must find their place among a new generation. Neither colonists nor African, neither white nor black, the Indian brother and sister find themselves somewhere in between in their band of playmates: Bill and Annie, British children, and Njoroge, an African boy. These are the relationships that will shape the rest of their lives. We follow Vikram through the changes in East African society, the immense promise of the fifties and sixties. But when that hope is betrayed by the corruption and violence of the following decades, Vic is drawn into the Kenyatta government’s orbit of graft and power-broking. Njoroge, his childhood friend, can abandon neither the idealism of his youth nor his love for Vic’s sister Deepa. But neither the idealism of the one nor the passive cynicism of the other can avert the tragedies that await them.
What we discussed about the book:
  • The idea of incremental corruption: "Total corruption occurs in inches and travels through many veils of ambiguity."
  • The role of colonial Kenya to this story - how the British society remained a background rather than a key feature.
  • The loose ends that remain unresolved in the reader's mind - e.g. what role did Kenyatta play in Njoroge's death?
  • The idea of identity. Is it possible to be 'African' when your ethnicity is Indian (or British?) How has that issue played out in out societies around the world?
  • How ideas of racism are portrayed in the book - between and within various groups.
  • The roles of the land and the love of the land. How does that affect choices various characters make?
  • What changed within Vic's parents relationship? Where these changes caused by external events?
  • What were the different responses to Deepa's relationship with Njorge? What influenced each response? Particularly, why was her mother so against it?
  • What did we learn of the history of Kenya through the telling of this story?
  • What was the true nature of  the Kenyatta character, particularly with relation to the dichotomy between 'my father'/'your excellency' forms of address?
  • Was Kenyatta motivated by a a fear of a loss of power?
  • What motivated Vic? Was it money, personal safety, opportunism?
  • The different life choices and pathways Njorge, Deepa and Vikram followed.
  • What is the 'in-between' of Vic's world? 
  • What was the point of Joseph's character?
  • Our favorite quotes: e.g. " It was the night that curdled the blood..."(p.46), "Mother left behind a broken and disoriented Papa..." (p.401)
  • What happened in the ending? Is it left to interpretation?
And then we were sidetracked
 into:
  • How does the process of corruption progress - inch by inch, or by grand plan?
  • Is it okay to accept a small amount of corruption to create a large amount of good difference?
  • In what ways can people effect change in a generally corrupt society?
  • The history of Kenya from 1AD to date.
  • Did colonial governments provide a better day-to-day life for the people (i.e. more ordered, predictable)? This this ever a preferable option to self-rule?
In other news, we discussed:
  • How JP's dog literally ate her homework, but that didn't stop her doing a stellar job at research for this month's bookclub.
  • Sex education for teenagers
  • The ethics of charities accepting donations from gambling-related companies 
  • Dan Brown's Inferno and its theme of world over-population, plus the idea that doing nothing when witnessing a transgression is the worst possible crime.
Ratings:
Range: 7.5 to 9.5
Average:  8.79

Next book: The Transit of Venus by Shirley Hazzard (chosen by Fairlie)

Monday, 1 July 2013

July book: The In-Between World of Vikram Lall

The In-Between World of Vikram Lall 

by M.G. Vassanji

(chosen by JP)

Theme: "Power doesn't corrupt. Fear corrupts. Perhaps fear of the loss of power."



Some background links to get you started:


Friday, 9 November 2012

Minutes October Book: The Thirteenth Apostle

The Thirteenth Apostle

by Michel Benoit

chosen by JP





 JP chose this book, because she feels there is a theme that has woven through her reading which traces right back to HSC when her literature reading list was based around the concept of  'the political man'. She likes to read books which examine various forms of power and the ways in which human beings usually create restraints to ensure that power doesn't go unchecked. She is fascinated with whether these same restraints apply to religious power of any denomination. A book which had a huge impact on her was David Yallop's In God's Name.

About the author:

Michel Benoit is a religious scholar and author.  He studied Biochemistry and obtained an PhD in Pharmacology before entering the Benedictine order as an unordained monk. He remained there for 22 years. He eventually quit the Catholic church due to his ideological non-conformity and devoted himself to writing. The Thirteenth Apostle fictionalises the results of his lifetime of research on the life of Jesus.

(general biographical detail from the back cover of the book)

What the publisher says about the book:

When his friend Andrei is mysteriously killed on a train on his way back from Rome, Father Nil, a Benedictine who teaches the Gospel of St John to novices, decides to conduct his own investigation. The dead priest possessed proof of the existence of a thirteenth apostle and an epistle stating that Jesus was nothing more than an inspired prophet, not the Son of God – two things that would spell great danger for the Church. Father Nil then discovers a previously unpublished account of the origins of Christianity. It tells of the Nazoreans – a community excluded from the official Church by Peter and Paul – who appear to have thrived until the 7th century, playing an important role in the birth of Islam. While he pushes ahead with his investigation, the Pope’s advisors, rival factions and secret societies are trying, by any means, to lay their hands on the priest’s findings. From the Mossad to Fatah, everyone seems to have a very good reason to keep the thirteenth apostle a secret... 
The story of an ancient sect detailed within papyrus sheaves hidden in the caves at Qumran forms the basis of this exhaustively researched novel. The Thirteenth Apostle contains lore perhaps more familiar to fans of the Knights Templar than to readers of Dan Brown, but will excite similar passions.
What we discussed about the book:
  • Was this fiction? Was this non-fiction? Could we work out what bits to 'believe' and what bits were fantasy?
  • What was the author's aim in writing this book?
  • Were there enough women characters? Should this matter in a novel?
  • In what ways was this similar to a Dan Brown novel, and in what ways did it differ?
  • Were there points where we thought the translation make have slightly altered the meaning or intent of the original language (French)?
  • Did we think the characters were naive not to suspect the apartment was bugged, or was this credible behaviour from monks who live in a generally very trusting environment?
  • How important is the belief of Jesus as Christ rather than just a prophet to: a. Christianity, b. this novel?
  • How big an impact would irrefutable proof that Jesus's body is buried in the desert have on the way people behave? Is it essential to Christianity that this mystery remain?
  • Who was the narrator? What was his role? 
  • What happened to Father Nil at the end?
  • Some editions of the book had a final section 'The Truth Behind The Thirteen Apostle' which outlined the scholarship on this area and explained where the author had included hypothetical scenarios in the plot of the novel. Did reading this chapter enhance or detract from our experience of reading the book.
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • What is fiction? What is history? How do we make the distinction? 
  • Is it okay to change historical events in a novel? Does an author need to declare this?
  • Why do 'the people' accept the power of a church (of any denomination) without challenging it?
  • Who is the Catholic Church accountable to financially?
In other news, we discussed:
  • Brynne Edelsten. Why is she so bizarrely intriguing?
  • And what is a Khardasian?
  • The dire state of eyesight post-45 years. Do some of us need torches in restaurants in order to read the menu?

Ratings:
Range: 5 to 7.5
Average:  6.56

Next book: Blood, Bones and Butter by Gabrielle Hamilton (chosen by JM)

Monday, 17 September 2012

October book: The Thirteenth Apostle by Michel Benoit

The Thirteenth Apostle

by Michel Benoit

(chosen by JP)



Some background links to get you started:

(will add some more as/if I find them...)


Friday, 25 November 2011

Minutes November book: Bereft

Bereft

by Chris Wolmersley

(chosen by JP)



JP initially chose Cloud Atlas by David Mitchell, but decided to read it first before confirming her choice.  It is a series of independent short stories which are all interlinked, but JP found it very difficult to read, and fearing the other No.1 Melbourne Ladies would find the same she decided not to risk a low rating! In her last minute, frantic scramble to find an alternative, Bereft became her 'it'll do' book.

About the author:

Chris Womersley’s fiction and reviews have appeared in Granta, The Best Australian Stories 2006, 2010 and 2011, Griffith REVIEW, Meanjin and The Age. His debut novel, The Low Road, won the Ned Kelly Award for Best First Fiction. His second novel, Bereft, won the Australian Book Industry Award for Literary Fiction and the Indie Award for Fiction, and was shortlisted for the Miles Franklin Literary Award, The Age fiction prize and the Australian Literature Society Gold Medal.

(general biographical detail from publisher's website)

What the publisher says about the book:
It is 1919. The Great War has ended, but the Spanish flu epidemic is raging across Australia. Schools are closed, state borders are guarded by armed men, and train travel is severely restricted. There are rumours it is the end of the world.
In the NSW town of Flint, Quinn Walker returns to the home he fled ten years earlier when he was accused of an unspeakable crime. Aware that his father and uncle would surely hang him, Quinn hides in the hills surrounding Flint. There, he meets the orphan Sadie Fox — a mysterious young girl who seems to know more about the crime than she should.
A searing gothic novel of love, longing and justice, Bereft is about the suffering endured by those who go to war and those who are forever left behind.

What we discussed about the book:
  • How would we describe this novel if asked to pinpoint its genre? Ghost story? Crime fiction? Literary fiction?  Magic realism? Do such labels matter? Do they affect how likely we are to pick up a book in the first place?
  • Did we think Sadie was real? What influenced our thoughts about this?
  • Sadie was originally written as a boy - how would this have changed the story?
  • What were our feelings towards the mother? Did we want her to find out the truth before she died?
  • Could Quinn have done more at the time of Sadie's death? What motivated the actions he took?
  • Did we have any doubts about Quinn's character throughout the story?  Did we believe his version of events?
  • How reliable is the third-person narrator?
  • How multi-dimensional was Robert Dalton? Did we find aspects of him almost a caricature?
  • What was the purpose of the sacrifical lamb scene?
  • How the author used language to paint quite graphic images (e.g. the representation of war, rape scenes, the lamb scene)
  • What was the point of the mystic imagery built up throughout the novel in relation to Sadie? Was it used to the best effect? Were we expecting it to go further and push into the realms of magic realism?
  • Were the horrors at home shown to be worse than the horrors of war?
  • How did we think Dalton had power over Gracie?
  • How did the visits Quinn made to his mother create almost a Scherazade-style telling of the story?
  • The impact of the idea that there isn no word to describe the mother who has lost a child. Is 'bereft' that word?
  • What was the purpose of the seance? Was it a way to connect the living and the dead in a 'plausible' way?
  • Was it credible that Dalton found Sadie in the dark and without a tracker - the two things that Sadie said he wouldn't be able to do?
  • Did Part Four (The Angel of Death) work for us?
  • Was it a satisfying or unsatisfying ending? What did we think had happened?
  • Our favourite passage from the book:
His mother sighed. 'It is a strange bargain one makes with the gods - that in return for the purest love imaginable one must endure the constant fear that something dreadful will happen to your child, and that it will be your fault for bringing them into the world. The number of times I thought of you. Mothers never believe their children are dead. I have seen it in others, the ones with sons killed in the war. God, it's awful. Months after they have received those telegrams they still stand at their kitchen windows and watch the gate for a sign of them. I wake in the night. One's child,' she went on in a trembling voice, 'is always one's child, no matter what age they might be. You worry when your child makes a noise, when he doesn't. It's a terrible kind of love. Terrible.'

And then we were sidetracked into:
  • The concept of love a mother has for a child - the responsibility that comes with that
  • The impact of the Spanish flu on Australia/the world in the post -World War 1 period.
In other news, we discussed:
  • Imported food - the testing requirements...are they stringent enough? Is Australian food subjected to equally stringent testing?
  • How delicious Gypsy's desserts were - especially given her oven was broken, and she'd had to impose on her neighbours to actually cook them!
Ratings:
Range: 7 to 9
Average: 8

Next book: Room by Emma Donoghue (chosen by CH)

November book: Bereft by Chris Wolmersley

Bereft

by Chris Wolmersley

(chosen by JP)




Some background links to get you started:

Sunday, 11 April 2010

Minutes March Book: I'm Not Scared


I'm Not Scared

by Niccolo Ammantiti (translated by Jonathon Hunt)

(Chosen by The New Girl, JP)



JP chose the book because her father is from the North of Italy, from a small town of just 200 people. Aqua Traversa struck a chord with her as being like the town her father grew up in, and she wanted to explore the sense of innocence of children growing up in such small towns. She told us the story of her father and his two friends, who found a live grenade in old trenches in the mountains behind their town, and the tragic outcome of their find.

Niccolo Ammantiti was born in Rome in 1966. He has written three novels and a collection of short stories. He won the Italian Viareggio-Repaci Prize for Fiction with I'm Not Scared, which has become a best-seller and has been translated into forty languages and made into a film.

(General biographical details from the inside back cover of the book)

What the publisher says about the book:

When Michele Amitrano stumbles onto a boy held prisoner in a hole deep in the Italian countryside, he begins a journey that will lead him to a series of startling discoveries.

I’m Not Scared explores the playful and volatile world of childhood through the eyes of nine-year-old Michele, who is forced, again and again, to make the hard choices that will define his character. As the book opens, he must choose between helping his younger sister or winning a race. Later, he must choose between letting his friend Barbara be humiliated or taking the punishment himself. And as the novel approaches its stunning climax, he must choose between obeying his father and fulfilling the oath he swore to him, or following his conscience and keeping his promise to Filippo, the boy who has been kidnapped. But the choices he makes bring him into serious danger, not from the monsters of his childish imagination but from the adults around him who are capable of violence and monstrosities that are all too real.

Written with an immediacy and poignancy which is itself evocative of childhood, I’m Not Scared is a powerful tale of how one boy finds the courage to overcome his fear, risk his life, and make wrenchingly difficult moral choices.

What we discussed about the book:
  • The progression of Michele's discovery - the jigsaw pieces that gradually fell into place and his slow realisation of the actual nature of what he had uncovered.
  • Why did Michele chose helping others over the easier path (his little sister, Barbara, Filippo)? Is this innate character, or is it taught?
  • The idea that Michele kept the discovery a secret so that it would be his only - once he told someone, he would no longer own it.
  • Was the mother a 'good' character? He lioness qualities, her concern for the children...was she responsible for shaping Michele's character?
  • At what point did we think the mother knew about the kidnap?
  • In what ways was Papa the 'boogie man'? How did he reconcile the dichotomy of his personality?
  • Are children innately good? Why did Skull and Salvatore act the way they did?
  • Was Filippo hallucinating or were the wash bears and the Lord of the Worms a madness linked to reality? Did he think he'd already died?
  • Why was Filippo too sacred to get out of the hole?
  • What was Michele scared of and what wasn't he scared of? Is the point of the book that the only thing he wasn't scared of was doing the right thing?
  • Was Michele more scared of imaginary monsters than real ones? "It's men you should be scared of."
  • In what way did his father's drawing of the short match motivate Michele to find Filippo in the gravina?
  • Did we think Michele died at the end? Does it matter to our reading of the novel whether he died or survived?
  • Were we satisfied with the ending? Who needed closure and why? Was the scene in the gravina credible in context of the rest of the book?

And then we were sidetracked into:

  • Comparing the three different cover versions we had around the table - and the different author photos in each.
  • How Italy was in the 1970s, "the years of lead" when kidnapping for ransom was relatively common. In 1978, 600 children were kidnapped. In what ways did the author being a child himself at that time influence the writing of this book?
  • Did this book examine the psychology of terrorism? How do people separate their actions towards 'the other' from their actions towards their friends and families?
  • How do adults who perpetrate such crimes disconnect from the child? What is the process of rationalising their actions?
  • Is this a book about bravery and courage?
  • Is this a horror book?
In other news:
  • We commiserated with JP about the damage done to her beautiful house by Melbourne's freak storm.
  • We mocked the way fashion models walk the catwalk with hips pushed forward and pouty expressions.
  • We admired Gypsy's new renovation.
  • We discussed the necessity or otherwise of telemovies about murders, tragedies etc - i.e Wales-King murders. Why do people seem fascinated by these re-enactments?

Ratings:
Ratings average: 7.17
Ratings range: 5 to 9

Next book: The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo by Steig Larsson (chosen by JM)

Sunday, 14 March 2010