Monday, 27 August 2007

September book: Suite Francaise by Irène Némirovsky



Suite Francaise by Irène Némirovsky
(chosen by Domestic Goddess)

Meeting date: September 18th
Venue: KE's house

Some links for background information to get you started...

  • Sydney Morning Herald review
  • Sydney Morning Herald bookclub blog
  • New York Times book review
  • bookbrowse.com's bookclub reading guide
  • Wikipedia's biography of Irène Némirovsky
  • M (whose Sydney bookclub has already done this book) highly recommends listening to a radio interview with Irene Nemirovsky's daughter Denise Epstein and Suite Francaise translater Sandra Smith. Denise tells the story of this book from her own point of view.
    The interview is conducted by US nationally syndicated radio host Diane Rehm and can be listened to by clicking the appropriate link on this site.

Minutes August 2007 Book: The Women's Room by Marilyn French

The Women's Room by Marilyn French (chosen by JM)



JM chose this book after reading an article about Marilyn French in the Good Weekend magazine in May. The article referred to it being the 30th anniversary of The Women's Room this year, and highlighted the importance of this novel. JM hadn't ever heard of, so decided to choose this novel to "drag herself out of the cultural wasteland" and to haul all the No.1 Melbourne Ladies' Bookclub members along with her!

French was born in New York to a family of Polish descent. She did a BA at Hofstra College in Long Island in 1951, and left the college to marry. She started to write seriously in 1957, but it was 1976 before her first book was published. She has two children and divorced their father in 1967. She gained an MA and a PhD, and has taught in universities/colleges.

French's first book was her thesis on James Joyce (1976). A year later it was followed by The Women's Room. Her sixth novel was released in 2006 and is called In the Name of Friendship.

21 million copies of The Women's Room have been sold. It has been translated into 20 languages and has been made into a TV movie (1980).

In 1992 at the age of 61, French was diagnosed with metastasized esophageal cancer, and was given no hope. She did, however, win her battle. (Biographical details from here)

The synopsis of The Women's Room from amazon.co.uk:

A landmark in feminist literature, THE WOMEN'S ROOM is a biting social commentary of a world gone silently haywire. Written in the 1970s but with profound resonance today, this is a modern allegory that offers piercing insight into the social norms accepted blindly and revered so completely.

'Today's desperate housewives eat your heart out! This is the original and still the best, a page-turner that makes you think. Essential reading' Kate Mosse

'They said this book would change lives - and it certainly changed mine' Jenni Murray

'Reading THE WOMEN'S ROOM was an intense and wonderful experience. It is in my DNA' Kirsty Wark

'THE WOMEN'S ROOM took the lid off a seething mass of women's frustrations, resentments and furies; it was about the need to change things from top to bottom; it was a declaration of independence' OBSERVER


What we discussed about the book:


  • To what extent is this book still relevant 30 years later?
  • Are men scared of women's sexuality? Is that at the heart of attempts to retain power over women?
  • Did Mira do the right thing in refusing to accompany Ben to Africa?
  • The rape of Chris highlighted injustices in the way the judicial system in the 1970s dealt with victims of sex crimes. Is this still the case?
  • The suburban party scenes of the first half of the book - where married couples flirted (and took it further) with other husbands and wives. What was the motivation for this behaviour? Did it spring from the fact many had married young and inexperienced, and later yearned for some adventure?
  • Was Mira's name intended to be a reference to her acting as a 'mirror' to all women? Was 'Norm' intended to represent the normal man?
  • Is this book a cautionary tale about the futility of searching for 'love' in a relationship?

Issues we were sidetracked into:

  • Why are (traditionally) predominantly male-occupied jobs (eg. engineering, law, accounting) paid more than predominantly female-occupied jobs (eg. nursing, teaching)?
  • Is it neccessary for both partners in a marriage to work? What risk does not working pose to the non-working partner?
  • How can you change long-held attitudes across a whole society? How have some of the Scandinavian countries managed it?
  • Does the 'knight in shining armour' mentality still exist among the young Australian women of today?
  • Is there an ideal age difference between partners in a marriage? Would an older man be better suited to a younger women, and an older woman, a younger man?
  • Does 'education' alone cause women to question the status quo...or does it depend on the type and content of the education?
  • Could communal living work better for women than nuclear-family living?

And in other news:

  • Kensington is doing well with her gorgeous baby boy!
  • TeamSAK is back on track with her chemo...having only missed a few days.
  • M will be down from Sydney for the Writers Festival next weekend and hopes to catch up with as many No.1 Melbourne Ladies as possible on Saturday night.
  • T-Rex had seen Ian McKellen in King Lear and was most impressed with his performance. Melbourne radio media has commented in past weeks about his nude scene at great length!

Ratings

Average: 5.875

Range: 4 to 6.75

Next book: Suite Francaise by Irene Nemirovsky

August book: The Women's Room by Marilyn French


Sorry ladies, I've been very tardy in loading up this post - slap your blogmistress's wrist. But, in the interests of completeness I'm putting it up now. You never know when you may like to wander back through the archives and do a bit of background research on past book choices!

The Women's Room by Marilyn French
(chosen by JM)
Meeting date: August 21st
Venue: T-Rex's house

Some links for background information to get you started...

Wednesday, 8 August 2007

8 random things about the No.1 Melbourne Ladies' Bookclub

You may recall, way back in June, we were tagged by M at Easternmax to complete the "8 random things about me" meme. So your tardy Blogmistress (doesn't that sound a scary title?)has finally got around to putting together the list.

  1. Our bookclub started in 1999 when five friends all invited a (non-mutual) friend each to form a bookclub where we would read a book each month, then meet and discuss it.
  2. Since then, through natural attrition, demands of work or family, interstate moves and/or lack of interest (surely not!) we've had a bit of changeover of membership. At last count, we've had 24 active members in total, with five of the original 11 still current members.
  3. Not finishing the book, even you chose it in the first place, has never stopped any of us from attending and joining in the discussion!
  4. The host member provides the evening's refreshments...and thus we have experienced such gourmet delights as Greek Easter biscuits (at Domestic Goddess's place), licorice bullets at Kensington's and the world's best cheeses at JM's.
  5. There's been a lot of babies born to members over the years. Our current active members have 17 children between us (including one very brand new addition).
  6. A book has never scored an 'across the board' 10 out of 10.
  7. Individuals have scored books with ratings right through from 0 to 10 (although anything below 5 tends to be pretty rare).
  8. We're not big on 'rules'.

So now, we tag the only other bookclub blog we know*...The Lady Austinites! How about it My Utopia?

* Other than Books n Gossip who were tagged at the same time as us.