Showing posts with label ch's choices. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ch's choices. Show all posts

Monday, 26 October 2015

November book: The Most Good You Can Do by Peter Singer

The Most Good You Can Do 

by Peter Singer

(chosen by CH)

Theme: The price of privilege is poverty

Some background links to get you started:


What we discussed about the book:

- is the book's core essentially a pessimistic one?
- How do you define 'the most good'?
- the difference between simple interest and compound interest - is what Singer is describing, a simple interest approach?
- generational differences in approaches to philanthropy and philosophies underpinning it
- is stopping extinction of the human race the 'ultimate good' you can do?
- the differences between donating time and donating money to organisations. Which would they prefer?

Ratings:
Range: 7 to 9 
Average: 7.83

Thursday, 15 May 2014

Minutes April book; Revolutionary Road

Revolutionary Road

by Richard Yates

(chosen by CH)

Theme: All that glitters is not gold


CH chose this after several friends agreed that it was a great fit for the theme. Initially she had read Jonestown as an option, but decided that it didn't fit the theme all that well.

About the author:

Richard Yates was born in 1926. The author of several acclaimed works of fiction, including Revolutionary Road, Eleven Kinds of Loneliness, Disturbing the Peace, and The Easter Parade, he was lauded during his lifetime as the foremost novelist of the post-war "age of anxiety". He died in 1992.

(general biographical detail from the publisher's website)

What the publisher says about the book:
From the moment of its publication in 1961, Revolutionary Road was hailed as a masterpiece of realistic fiction and as the most evocative portrayal of the opulent desolation of the American suburbs. It's the story of Frank and April Wheeler, a bright, beautiful, and talented couple who have lived on the assumption that greatness is only just around the corner. With heartbreaking compassion and remorseless clarity, Richard Yates shows how Frank and April mortgage their spiritual birthright, betraying not only each other, but their best selves.
What we discussed about the book:
  • Is this an anti-suburban book?
  • To what extent is it autobiographical?
  • Is Yates bitter about the suburban life? What does he show as being particularly nasty?
  • Why did the Wheelers only have one good set of friends? Were they really 'friends' when they were constantly criticising them?
  • Were the characters well-developed? Rounded?
  • Did Frank love his job? Why was he happy to have an easy life and coast?
  • What did this say about employment in that era? A
  • Was the Paris idea an escape plan for April from a domestic wasteland?
  • Did April suffer from a mental illness?
  • What role did her failed career play in her future life?
  • Did Frank have any self-reflection when he read the note?
  • How skilled the writing is that when Frank goes back to the house the reader can hear April's voice.
  • And then when Frank reads the note, he can no longer hear her voice.
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • Was Yates' talent not fully-recognized during his lifetime?
  • Why are so many books written about the suburban malaise? Who do they appeal to? And why?
  • Is this book a fair representation of suburban life?
  • Are people  different in the city from the suburbs? Do they same any/all of the same issues?
  • Are there still workplaces like Frank's? When did workplaces change?
  • Can women whose mothers reject them ever fully love anyone else?
  • The life for women in that era who were unhappy or unfulfilled by the stereotypical housewife role. What options were there for them?
In other news, we discussed:
  • Greek school. Why do kids go to it? What do they learn?
  • Juggling work/travel/kids/husbands...the modern day malaise!
  • New York shopping
  • Formal dresses...formal partners...formal hairdos...formal make-up...formals...
  • Lean In by Sheryl Sandberg
Ratings:
Range: 5 to 9
Average: 7.75

Next book: The Namesake by Jhumpa Lahiri (chosen by Elster)

April book: Revolutionary Road by Richard Yates

Revolutionary Road

by Richard Yates

(chosen by CH)



Some background links to get you started: 



Tuesday, 30 April 2013

Minutes April book: Lady Chatterley's Lover

Lady Chatterley's Lover

By D.H. Lawrence

(Chosen by CH)

Theme: Banned books

CH chose this book after perusing a Wiki list of banned books. She had first read it when she was 12 years old, again at 30 and now. She was interested in exploring the basis on which this book was banned, particularly as it was just recently (2009) banned from sale in Australia Post shops, as it was didn't fit in with the 'theme of their stores'. 

About the author:

David Herbert Lawrence was born in 1885. After attending Beauvale Board School he won a scholarship to Nottingham High School. He left school in 1901 and was employed for a short time as a clerk at a manufacturer of surgical appliances, then trained as a teacher and took up a teaching post. In 1912, after a period of serious illness, he returned to Nottinghamshire, and then eloped to Germany with Frieda Weekley, the wife of Professor Ernest Weekley. They returned to England in 1914 and were married at Kensington Register Office on 14 July. After the War, they left England once more, and travelled extensively within Europe and then further afield to Ceylon, Australia, Mexico and New Mexico. Lawrence's health continued to deteriorate and he returned to Europe with Frieda in 1925. During his last years he lived mostly in Italy, making only brief visits to England.  He died on 2 March 1930 in the south of France. Lawrence was a prolific writer - of poetry, novels, short stories, plays, essays, and criticism. His works are heavily autobiographical and profoundly influenced by  the experiences of his early years in Nottinghamshire.

(general biographical detail from The University of Nottingham Manuscripts and Special Collections webpage)

What a publisher says about the book:
Constance Chatterley feels trapped in her sexless marriage to the invalid Sir Clifford. Unable to fulfil his wife emotionally or physically, Clifford encourages her to have a liaison with a man of their own class. But Connie is attracted instead to her husband’s gamekeeper and embarks on a passionate affair that brings new life to her stifled existence. Can she find a true equality with Mellors, despite the vast gulf between their positions in society? One of the most controversial novels in English literature, Lady Chatterley’s Lover is an erotically charged and psychologically powerful depiction of adult relationships.
What we discussed about the book:
  • Why are books banned? 
  • On what basis can a book be banned? Immorality? Offensiveness? Perverting the course of justice? 
  • What subject matter (if any) would each of us think is unacceptable for publication?
  • Does the language (particularly the use of the C and F-words) shock readers nowadays? Is it the kind of book 'you'd wish your wife or your servants to read'?
  • Was 'coarse' language used to desensitise readers to the sexual aspects of the story?
  • The repetitious use of certain phrases or words in the novel - e.g. 'bitch goddess', 'stirring in the bowels'
  • How were plot and characters used to philosophise about social issues? Did this interrupt the flow of the narrative?
  • Was Connie a creature of her times? In what ways did her character display conflict of head vs body.
  • Was Connie's upbringing usual? In what ways did it influence her thoughts and actions?
  • The concept of being 'in the body' or 'in the mind' - what was Lawrence saying about each state?
  • Was the relationship between Connie and Mellors believable? How did it contrast with the beautifully drawn analysis of Connie and Clifford's relationship?
  • Was Clifford portrayed fairly?  Were readers manipulated into our views of him?
  • What was the catalyst for Connie moving from the realm of the intellectual to the physical?
  • Is Lawrence suggesting that falling in love can follow after connecting initially physically.
  • The representation of class issues. In what ways had Mellors been damaged by class structures?
  • Why did Mellors alternate between Darbyshire dialect and middle class English? What statement was being made about this?
  • How did Mellor's treatment of his child influence our opinion of him? Did we trust him?
  • How did power shift with the introduction of Mrs Bolton? How did she represent the rise of industrialisation?
  • Was it a happy ending? What did we think happened after the novel ended?
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • What is the etymology of the F-word? And the C-word?
  • What is a bath chair?
  • Was this the book we expected (for those who hadn't read it before)?
  • Would this book have been as 'famous' and popular if it hadn't been banned?
In other news, we discussed:
  • Various ailments affecting family members
  • The stresses and funny moments of nursing
Ratings:
Range: 6.5 to 8.5
Average:  7.19

Next book: The Happiest Refugee by Anh Do (chosen by Elster)

Monday, 1 April 2013

April book: Lady Chatterley's Lover

Lady Chatterley's Lover

by DH Lawrence

(chosen by CH)

Theme: Banned books


Some background links to get you started:

Wednesday, 7 March 2012

Minutes February book: Room

Room


by Emma Donoghue


(chosen by CH)






CH  chose this book in an attempt to redeem herself after the reception of her last choice (Imperial Bedrooms). She asked three women whose opinions she admires to suggest titles and this was one of them.


About the author:


Born in Dublin, Ireland, in 1969, Donoghue is the youngest of eight children. She attended Catholic convent schools in Dublin, apart from one eye-opening year in New York at the age of ten. She has a  first-class honours BA in English and French from University College Dublin. She moved to England, and received a PhD (on the concept of friendship between men and women in eighteenth-century English fiction) from the University of Cambridge. She has  earned a living as a writer, since she was 23. After years of commuting between England, Ireland, and Canada, she settled in London, Ontario, in 1998, where she lives with her partner and two children.


(General biographical details from the author's website)


What the publisher says about the book:

The story of a mother, her son, a locked room and the outside world Jack is five and, like any little boy, excited at the prospect of presents and cake. He's looking forward to telling his friends it's his birthday, too. But although Jack is a normal child in many ways – loving, funny, bright, full of energy and questions – his upbringing is far from ordinary: Jack's entire life has been spent in a single room that measures just 12 feet by 12 feet; as far as he's concerned, Room is the entire world.


He shares this world with his mother, with Plant, and tiny Mouse (though Ma isn't a fan and throws a book at Mouse when she sees him). There's TV too, of course – and the cartoon characters he thinks of as his friends – but Jack knows that nothing else he sees on the screen is real. Old Nick, on the other hand, is all too real, but only visits at night – like a bat – when Jack is meant to be asleep and hidden safely in Wardrobe. And only Old Nick has the code to Door, which is otherwise locked...Told in Jack's voice, Room is the story of a mother's love for her son, and of a young boy's innocence.
What we discussed about the book:

  • In what ways is the concept of 'motherhood' the inspiration for this book?
  • How did Ma interpret the role of mother - storytelling, health, exercise, education, manners? 
  • What Ma a good mother? If the author was aiming to create the 'best mother' did she succeed?
  • Was there any hint of Ma seeing a reflection of Old Nick in Jack?
  • Who's story was this? Ma's? Jack's? 
  • How did the author ensure it was NOT Old Nick's story?
  • How did the captivity affect Jack's development? Did he have any notion of himself as a separate entity to Ma? 
  • How did we feel reading the escape scene? What devices did the author use to heighten that tension?
  • How was our experience of the sense of claustrophobia in Room created?
  • Ma's mental state post-escape. What triggered her depression and suicide attempt?
  • In what ways was Ma brave?
  • What role did routine play as a coping mechanism for Ma? What happened post-escape?
  • Were all the items in Room named (Door, Wardrobe etc) to create a sense of community for Jack?
  • Did Ma maintain a sense of hope? How?
  • How did we experience Jack's 5 year-old voice? Was it authentic? How is oral language development influenced?
  • Was it plausible that Old Nick would not have checked that Jack was dead?
  • How old did we think Old Nick was?
  • The ripples caused in the outside world by Ma's abduction - e.g. parents' separation
  • Was this a positive book? Was there a sense of hope at the end?
And then we were sidetracked into:

  • In what ways did this book remind us of the film 'Life is Beautiful'? How were they similar?
  • Why do victims in these types of crime often not hate the perpetrators? Is it a form of Stockholm Syndrome?
  • The benefits of child-raising in an environment which is not over-stimulated, and in which you can devote large amounts of one-on-one time to the child.
  • What motivates people to carry out crimes such as this one?
In other news, we discussed:

  • Cold case homicides. What developments of technology allow 30 year old cases to be solved?
  • Updates on various medical issues affecting those close to various No.1 Ladies. Our love, best wishes and support to everyone involved.
Ratings:
Range: 7 to 9.5
Average: 8.25


Next book: Letter to D by Andre Gorz (chosen by T-Rex)

Saturday, 11 February 2012

February book: Room by Emma Donoghue

Room


by Emma Donoghue


(chosen by CH)






Some background links to get you started:


Friday, 12 November 2010

Minutes November Book: Imperial Bedrooms by Bret Easton Ellis

Imperial Bedrooms

by Bret Easton Ellis

(chosen by CH)






In 1991, as a young graduate driving in an old blue car across the Nullabor with her boyfriend (now husband) for a new adventure in The Eastern States, CH read Less than Zero.  (She was the passenger, T did most of the driving.) She was mesmerised by a book which she felt, 'defined a generation', and saw it as an interesting depiction of that time.  So, when she heard that Imperial Bedrooms had been written as a sequel of sorts, she was keen to read it too.

In a departure from our usual procedures, CH asked all No.1 Ladies to write a pre-discussion rating and a comment about the book (in ten words or less) on a post-it note before we started.

About the author:

Bret Easton Ellis is the author of Less Than Zero, The Rules of Attraction, American Psycho, The Informers (a collection of short stories), Glamorama, and Lunar Park. His work has been translated into twenty-seven languages. His highly anticipated novel, Imperial Bedrooms was published June, 2010. Less Than Zero, The Rules of Attraction, American Psycho and The Informers have all been made into movies. Bret Easton Ellis lives in Los Angeles.

(general biographical detail from the author's website)

What the publisher says about the book:
Bret Easton Ellis’s debut, Less Than Zero, is one of the signal novels of the last thirty years, and he now follows those infamous teenagers into an even more desperate middle age.

Clay, a successful screenwriter, has returned from New York to Los Angeles to help cast his new movie, and he’s soon drifting through a long-familiar circle. Blair, his former girlfriend, is married to Trent, an influential manager who’s still a bisexual philanderer, and their Beverly Hills parties attract various levels of fame, fortune and power. Then there’s Clay’s childhood friend Julian, a recovering addict, and their old dealer, Rip, face-lifted beyond recognition and seemingly even more sinister than in his notorious past.

But Clay’s own demons emerge once he meets a gorgeous young actress determined to win a role in his movie. And when his life careens completely out of control, he has no choice but to plumb the darkest recesses of his character and come to terms with his proclivity for betrayal.

A genuine literary event.

What we discussed about the book:
  • Does this book 'define a generation'? What generation is that?
  • Where and how did each of these characters develop their moral compasses?
  • Is this book autobiographical?
  • In what ways does this book display a general disdain for the conventional?
  • Is the book deliberately emotionless? What is the effect of this?
  • Is "he", the narrator, a perpetrator?
  • What kind of character development does this book display between the 19 year-olds of Less than Zero (for those who had read it) and the 40-somethings of this novel?
  • Did we keep reading waiting for something to happen? What did we think may have happened?
  • Does this book fit into a literary genre equivalent of film noir?
  • Did we feel the tension of the book, or a lack of tension?
  • Was there a need to increase the violence within the book, as the reader became desensitised by what had occurred earlier?
  • What was the point of this book? Does it test (and push through) our thresholds?
  • The last line: "I have never liked anyone and I'm afraid of people." What did Clay mean by that?

And we were sidetracked into:
  • The power of a book to affect the mood of the reader. Some described feeling 'narky' reading this book.
  • The size of the author's name vs the title of the book on the cover.
  • Do we always expect change for the better within a novel's plot? Why or why not?
  • Who are the reviewers who love this book? Does your experience of a book depend upon your own life experiences?

In other news:
  • We discussed the desensitising nature of combat video games. Does the graphic reality of these games blur the distinction between fantasy and reality for teens?
  • The merits of each variety of Kit Kat. Is the Kit Kat chunky a man's Kit Kat?
  • Nasal delivery technology advertising. What is it going to take to stop these ads on the radio and on billboards where children are exposed to them?
  • We discussed our ratings system. Why and how do we rate? Is it possible for a book to have a negative impact on us, therefore justifying a negative score? Is it a rating on how 'good' we think the book is, or how much we enjoyed it? We concluded that we each rate based on our own personal experience of the reading of the book - and if we felt it justified a zero score, that was okay, as is a 10 score.
Ratings:
Range: 0 to 6 (no change from pre-discussion ratings)
Average: 2.55

Next book: Lovesong by Alex Miller (chosen by T-Rex)

Wednesday, 13 October 2010

November book: Imperial Bedrooms by Bret Easton Ellis

Imperial Bedrooms

by
Bret Easton Ellis

(chosen by CH)



Some background links to get you started:

Sunday, 15 November 2009

Minutes October Book: Breath by Tim Winton

Breath

by Tim Winton

(chosen by CH)




CH chose this book because she couldn't believe that over a ten year period, we hadn't read any books by Tim Winton before.


Tim Winton began his first novel, An Open Swimmer (1982), at the age of 19, while on a Creative Writing course at Curtin University, Perth. It won the Australian/Vogel National Literary Award, and he has since made his living as a full-time writer. He was born in Perth in 1960, and is the author of several novels for adults. Many of his books are set in his familiar landscapes of Western Australia. He has also written books for children and collections of short stories.

Breath is his most recent novel and was winner of the 2009 Miles Franklin Award.

Tim Winton been named a Living Treasure by the National Trust, and awarded the Centenary Medal for service to literature and the community. He has lived in Greece, France and Ireland, but has now settled in Western Australia with his family.

(General biographical details from here.)

What the publisher says about the book:

More than once since then I've wondered whether the life-threatening high jinks that Loonie and I and Sando and Eva got up to in the years of my adolescence were anything more than a rebellion against the monotony of drawing breath.

Breath is a story about the wildness of youth - the lust for excitement and terror, the determination to be extraordinary, the wounds that heal and those that don't - and about learning to live with its passing.

In his first novel for seven years, Tim Winton has achieved a new level of mastery. Breath confirms him as one of the world's finest storytellers, a writer of novels that are at the same time simple and profound, relentlessly gripping and deeply moving.


What we discussed about the book:

  • The sense of place in Tim Winton’s writing. Is the location immediately recognisable? What makes it so distinctive?
  • Was Eva a believable character?
  • The impact of events in adolescence on the rest of your life.
  • What was Pikelet looking for in the relationship with Sando and Loonie? Did he get it?
  • Was the relationship between Eva and Pikelet abusive?
  • Did Eva’s risk-taking replace the thrill of the risks of her extreme sport?
  • In how many ways was ‘breath’ represented in this book: drowning, dreaming, hyperventilation, held-breath diving, sleep apnoea, asthma, didgeridoo playing, asphyxia, resuscitations, extracting oxygen from surf foam...
  • Were some of these means of fighting the natural monotony of unconscious breathing? Was it a metaphor for pushing against the monotony of life?
  • How did the non-use of quotation marks affect our reading of the book?
  • In what ways did Pikelet’s surfing exploits make his feel ‘special’?
  • Was the end of the book satisfactory?
  • Were we at times holding our breath reading some of the surfing scenes?
  • Is this a book which is more about mood than plot? The evocation of the senses? The notion of place?
  • Did we feel we were on a wave in reading the book? How had Winton created that sensation?
  • What was the purpose of the paramedic scenes? How did they enrich the plot?


And then we were sidetracked into:

  • Is surfing the only thing that men do that is both elegant and pointless?
  • How fabulous is the Panadol ad with the 70yo surfer man?
    How had the culture of surfing changed between the 1960s and the 1980s. And what about now?
  • Why was there little mention of the mechanics of Eva and Pikelet’s relationship in any of the reviews of the book we read?
  • What did we think of other endings to Tim Winton novels?
  • Why are Tim Winton books so highly acclaimed? What makes a ‘great’ book in an award sense?


In other news:

  • We sympathised with Elster over her foot injury and wished her a speedy recovery.
  • We discussed the finer details of fructose malabsorbtion.


Ratings:
Ratings average: 7.45
Ratings range:6.5 to 8

Next book: The Great Gatsby by F.Scott Fitzgerald (chosen by Elster)



    Wednesday, 9 April 2008

    Minutes March 2008 Book: What is the What by Dave Eggers



    What is the What

    by Dave Eggers

    (chosen by CH)

    CH chose this book on a recommendation from another bookclub which had given it a really high rating. She was told it was an "important book" with a really significant story which needs to be told. This appealed to CH, as she felt that the issue of the Sudan is difficult to understand and engage with, and the personal story provides a bridge into it.

    Dave Eggers was born in 1970 in Boston, Massachusetts and attended the University of Illinois. He is married to writer, Vendela Vida and they live in San Francisco with their daughter, born in 2005.

    Eggers began writing as a Salon.com editor. His first book was a memoir, A Heartbreaking Work of Staggering Genius (2000). It is about the author's struggle to raise his younger brother following the sudden deaths of their parents.

    In 2002, Eggers published his first novel, You Shall Know Our Velocity. What Is the What: The Autobiography of Valentino Achak Deng is his second novel and it was a finalist for the 2006 National Book Critics Circle Award for Fiction.

    Eggers is a founder of McSweeney's, an independent publishing house and currently teaches writing in San Francisco at a nonprofit tutoring centre and writing school for children that he co-founded with Vendela Vida in 2002. They have expanded the program by using volunteers to operate similar centres in Los Angeles, New York City, Seattle, Chicago, and Ann Arbor, Michigan.

    (General biographical details from here)

    The publisher's comments:

    Separated from his family, Valentino Achak Deng becomes a refugee in war-ravaged southern Sudan. His travels bring him in contact with enemy soldiers, with liberation rebels, with hyenas and lions, with disease and starvation, and with deadly murahaleen (militias on horseback)—the same sort who currently terrorize Darfur. Based closely on actual experiences, What Is the What is heartrending and astonishing, filled with adventure, suspense, tragedy, and, finally, triumph.

    What we discussed about the book:

    • How does this book portray hope as the primary driver of the human condition?
    • In what ways was Deng a charismatic character?
    • Is telling the story a healing process for Deng?
    • The Sudanese story of evolution - the cow or the what? What is the what? What is the cow? Does our society value the what over the cow?
    • The level of violence shown in the refugee camps, particularly towards women.
    • The flow of the narrative. In what ways did the jumping between past and present effect the telling of the story?
    • Was the book too long?
    • Was the font too small?

    Then we were sidetracked into:

    • When a society experiences a total disregard for human life, how does it begin to rebuild? In what ways is 'civilisation' nurtured?
    • The idea that many children in the world today still grow up not knowing much about the world beyond their village. How does a lack of outside influences affect a society?

    And in other news, we discussed:

    • Branded foods for kids in supermarkets. Is it right that food choices may be made on the basis of which superhero is on the packet rather than on its nutritional, economic and environmental impact. Should we just vote with our feet?
    • The politics of food choices. Do we consume way more than we really need to? And is too much of it over-packaged and over-refined? Fascinating photos of the weekly groceries for families around the world can be found here.
    • Packaging in school lunches. How can we minimise the plastic wrapping going to school each day?
    • The Uplift Fiji bra donation program. Which, of course, led us to...water-filled bras vs chicken fillets. Which is more natural looking?

    Ratings

    Initial rating average: 7.08

    Initial rating range: 5 to 9

    End of discussion rating average: 7.25

    End of discussion rating range: 6 to 9

    Next book: The Secret River by Kate Grenville (Elster's choice)

    Friday, 29 February 2008

    March book: What is the What by Dave Eggers



    What is the What by Dave Eggers (chosen by CH)
    Meeting date: March 18th
    Venue: Gypsy's house






    Some links for background information to get you started:

    Review of book on ABC Radio National

    New York Magazine book review

    Dave Eggers entry in Wikipedia

    Dave Eggers reading from What is the What on Youtube