Showing posts with label Alice Hoffman. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Alice Hoffman. Show all posts

Wednesday, 14 June 2017

June book: Faithful by Alice Hoffman

Faithful

by Alice Hoffman

(discussion led by TG)





Some background links to get you started:
What we discussed about the book:
  • The themes of redemption and making your own family
  • Did Shelby make choices or did life make them for her? 
  • The writing style and the devices used
  • The rawness and sparseness of the lanaguage - what was the effect of that? How did it move the story along? 
  • The interactions with Marvelle and the kids - what did that show about Shelby?
  • Was teh power of the postcards in the idea of them rather than the actuality? 
  • What role did Helene play? Was she a vehicle to outwardly reflect Sheby's inner guilt?
  • Was this a book about religion?
  • Who was 'faithful' to Shelby? Who was she faithful to? 
  • What was the role of the tattooed girl in the bookshop?
  • Which (if any) characters did we empathise with and why? 
  • What did Shelby look like?
Then we were distracted to discuss: 
  • Why are we so polarised in our experience of this book - lovers vs haters? (as reflected in ratings)
  • Do you need to have personal experience of dysfunction in order for a portrayal of it to resonate?
  • The idea of one moment where a life changes course permanently
And in other news we chatted about: 
  • OAMs, AMs, etc - what is the Australian award system all about? What do you need to do to get one? Do the right people get them?
  • The pleasures and perils of new puppies
  • The quote 'life just grows around your wound' - what does this mean? 

Ratings
Range: 2 to 9
Average: 6.19

Tuesday, 18 August 2015

August Book: The Museum of Extraordinary Things by Alice Hoffman



The Museum of Extraordinay Things

by Alice Hoffman

(Chosen by Elster)

Theme: A fairytale ending









Some background links to get you started: 

What we discussed about the book:
- chosen because MC wanted something dark and gothic 
- device of magic realism
- themes of strong women and Judaism
- is there always historical fact underlying fairy tales?
- why did the fonts swap?
- hoe (practically) do you wear gloves when you have webbed fingers?
- was Maureen her mother?
- does every criminal see themselves as the hero of the story?
- what was the role of the hermit?
-was the ending too neat?

Ratings:
Range: 5 to 9
Average: 7.36