The ratings recorded below reflect an average of the members' ratings (out of ten) of their personal experience of the reading of that book. The links take you to the post that contains the minutes for that book's discussion.
(Warning! Spoiler alert for the minutes of all titles.)
The Widow Clicquot by Tilar J Mazzeo
Rating: 7.77
(Theme: Biography)
The Sense of an Ending by Julian Barnes
Rating:7.55
(Theme: Booker Prize winner)
Lady Chatterley's Lover by D.H. Lawrence
Rating: 7.19
(Theme: Banned books)
The Happiest Refugee by Anh Do
Rating: 7.89
(Theme: Inspiring and uplifting)
Madame Bovary by Gustave Flaubert
Rating: 7.38
(Theme: A woman scorned)
The In-Between World of Vikram Lall
Rating: 8.79 by M.G. Vassanji
(Theme: "Power doesn't corrupt. Fear corrupts. Perhaps fear of the loss of power.")
The Transit of Venus by Shirley Hazzard
Rating: 8.63
(Theme: Antipodeans abroad)
An Unequal Music by Vikram Seth
Rating: 6.71
(Theme: "Without music, life would be a mistake.")
Orange is the New Black by Piper Kerman
Rating: 7.44
(Theme: Crime and punishment)
The Age of Miracles by Karen Thompson Walker
Rating: 7.05
(Theme: "The perfect place to make a film about the end of the world.")
Tuesday, 31 December 2013
Saturday, 30 November 2013
Minutes November book: The Age of Miracles
by Karen Thompson Walker
(chosen by KM)
Theme: The perfect place to make a film about the end of the world
KM was inspired by this theme to look at end-of-the-world novels and sought out a 'top ten' list of apocalyptic novels. Included on the list were a couple of books we have already read as a bookclub (Blindness and The Road). She looked at reviews of a few of the other books on the list and found that this one had good reviews, so she chose it.
About the author:
Karen Thompson Walker was born and raised in San Diego, California, where The Age of Miracles is set. She studied English and creative writing at UCLA, where she wrote for the UCLA Daily Bruin. After college, she worked as a newspaper reporter in the San Diego area before moving to New York City to attend the Columbia University MFA program. A former book editor at Simon and Schuster, she wrote The Age of Miracles in the mornings before work—sometimes while riding the subway. She is the recipient of the 2011 Sirenland Fellowship as well as a Bomb Magazine fiction prize. She lives in Brooklyn with her husband.
(general biographical detail from the author's website)
What the publisher says about the book:
Spellbinding, haunting, The Age of Miracles is a beautiful novel of catastrophe and survival, growth and change, the story of Julia and her family as they struggle to live in an extraordinary time. On an ordinary Saturday, Julia awakes to discover that something has happened to the rotation of the earth. The days and nights are growing longer and longer, gravity is affected, the birds, the tides, human behavior and cosmic rhythms are thrown into disarray. In a world of danger and loss, Julia faces surprising developments in herself, and her personal world—divisions widening between her parents, strange behavior by Hannah and other friends, the vulnerability of first love, a sense of isolation, and a rebellious new strength. With crystalline prose and the indelible magic of a born storyteller, Karen Thompson Walker gives us a breathtaking story of people finding ways to go on, in an ever-evolving world.What we discussed about the book:
- The inexplicable nature of some of the events that occurred as a result of the slowing - are we not privy to the whys of these occurrences, because our narrator was not?
- Why did the author use an 11 year old narrator's voice? What effect did that have on the novel?
- How well did that voice transition to the 23 year old narrator?
- Why was the mother's character so dramatic? What underlay that behaviour?
- Was the parents' an unhappy marriage?
- Was her father actually having an affair with Sylvia, or is that just how it appeared to Julia?
- Was it okay for her father to lie? is what circumstances was it/wasn't it? Is it okay to lie to protect someone's fragility?
- The friendship with Hannah. Is that typical tween behaviour?
- The plausibility of the slowing. Did the science make sense? Did it need to? Why or why not?
- Did we think that the problem would be 'solved'?
- Did Seth die?
- Is this a novel about climate change?
- Did we, as readers need to know whether the world 'ended' or not? What was the effect of not knowing? Is that the very definition of hope?
- Was it a satisfying end to the novel? What were we left thinking?
- How does growing up in an on-going atmosphere of fear (e.g. in California, the fear of the BIG earthquake) shape views of the world and the future?
- Will humans always work out solutions to all problems?
- Would we be real timers or clock timers in the same circumstances?
In other news, we discussed:
- Genome mapping - it is too much information? How much would we want to know?
- Issues of informed consent in medical procedures.
- 2014 will be the 15th anniversary of the No.1 Melbourne Ladies Bookclub
Range: 6 to 8.5
Average: 7.05
Next book: The Fight by Norman Mailer (chosen by JM)
Monday, 4 November 2013
November book; The Age of Miracles
The Age of Miracles
by Karen Thompson Walker
(chosen by KM)
Some background links to get you started:
by Karen Thompson Walker
(chosen by KM)
Some background links to get you started:
- The website for the book
- 'Normalcy Grinds to a Halt' review by Michiko Kakutani in the New York Times
- Review by Christopher Priest in The Guardian
Thursday, 31 October 2013
Minutes October book: Orange is the New Black
by Piper Kerman
(chosen by JM)
Theme: Crime and Punishment
JM thought about the themes and decided she definitely wouldn't chose THE novel it suggested. She initially chose Marching Powder by Rusty Young, a story about a young guy caught bringing cocaine back from Bolivia, but changed her mind, as she was not rapt in it. Her second choice was Girls Like You, by Paul Sheehan but thought it was maybe a bit too long. The trusty Avenue bookstore suggested Orange is the New Black.
About the author:
Piper Kerman is the author of the memoir Orange is the New Black: My Year in a Women’s Prison from Spiegel and Grau, which has been adapted into an original television series for Netflix. She is a frequent invited speaker to students of law, criminology, gender and women’s studies, sociology, and creative writing, and also to groups that include the American Correctional Association’s Disproportionate Minority Confinement Task Force, federal probation officers, public defenders, justice reform advocates and volunteers, book clubs, and formerly and currently incarcerated people. She serves on the board of the Women’s Prison Association. Piper works with Spitfire Strategies as a communications consultant with nonprofits, philanthropies, and other organizations working in the public interest. She works on a range of issues including criminal justice reform. Her clients include the Open Society Foundations, the Ford Foundation, the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, and many nonprofits.
(general biographical detail from the author's website)
What the publisher says about the book:
With a career, a boyfriend, and a loving family, Piper Kerman barely resembles the reckless young woman who delivered a suitcase of drug money ten years before. But that past has caught up with her. Convicted and sentenced to fifteen months at the infamous federal correctional facility in Danbury, Connecticut, the well-heeled Smith College alumna is now inmate #11187–424—one of the millions of people who disappear “down the rabbit hole” of the American penal system. From her first strip search to her final release, Kerman learns to navigate this strange world with its strictly enforced codes of behavior and arbitrary rules. She meets women from all walks of life, who surprise her with small tokens of generosity, hard words of wisdom, and simple acts of acceptance. Heartbreaking, hilarious, and at times enraging, Kerman’s story offers a rare look into the lives of women in prison—why it is we lock so many away and what happens to them when they’re there.What we discussed about the book:
- Was this a rose-coloured glasses view of life in prison written in retrospect? Or did this accurately reflect the circumstances?
- How were Piper's circumstances different to others around her?
- The compassionate and kind nature of other prisoners - e.g. the goodwill on arrival
- Did we want 'more' from each character, rather than snippets about each of them?
- Did we want to know more about what happened to each character outside prison?
- What is the purpose of the paperwork and bureaucracy in the prison system? Is it just an inefficiency or is there a greater purpose?
- What is Piper Kerman's motivation in writing the book? Does she want to change our perceptions of women in prisons?
- To what extent does the length of a sentence psychologically affect the prisoner?
- We wondered about Kerman's writing process. Had she kept notes or a journal? Or is it all reconstructed from memory?
- The 1980s US drug legislation that led to a rapid increase in rates of incarceration
- The impact of one mistake in one's youth
- The effect illiteracy has on life skills and expectations
- The differences between the book and the TV series
- Can parallels in be drawn between African-American incarceration rates, and Australian indigenous rates?
In other news, we discussed:
- Cutting out sugar and alcohol...does it also cut all the joy out of life?
- Michael Mosley's 5:2 fast diet
- The last days of year 12, and schoolies week.
- Weird Melbourne weather...and powercuts
Range: 6.5 to 9
Average: 7.44
Next book: The Age of Miracles by Karen Thompson Walker (chosen by KM)
Monday, 14 October 2013
October book: Orange is the New Black
Orange is the New Black
by Piper Kerman
Chosen by JM
Some background links to get you started:
by Piper Kerman
Chosen by JM
Some background links to get you started:
- Reading guide at Random House website
- Review by J. Courtney Sullivan in The Chicago Tribune
- Interview with Piper Kerman on NPR.org
- Six main differences between the TV series and the book - at buzzfeed.com
- Jessica Grose's review in slate.com
Monday, 30 September 2013
Minutes September book: An Unequal Music
by Vikram Seth
(chosen by KE)
Theme: 'Without music, life would be a mistake'
KE examined a few options before choosing this one, including Rose Tremain's Music and Silence, however at 484 pages, it exceeded the page limit! She also thought about some music biographies.
About the author:
Vikram Seth has written acclaimed books in several genres: verse novel, The Golden Gate; travel book, From Heaven Lake; animal fables, Beastly Tales; epic fiction, A Suitable Boy. His most recent novel, An Equal Music, was published in 1999. He lives in England and India.
(general biographical detail from the Harper Collins website)
What the publisher says about the book:
The author of the international bestseller A Suitable Boy returns with a powerful and deeply romantic tale of two gifted musicians. Michael Holme is a violinist, a member of the successful Maggiore Quartet. He has long been haunted, though, by memories of the pianist he loved and left ten years earlier, Julia McNicholl. Now Julia, married and the mother of a small child, unexpectedly reenters his life and the romance flares up once more.
Against the magical backdrop of Venice and Vienna, the two lovers confront the truth about themselves and their love, about the music that both unites and divides them, and about a devastating secret that Julia must finally reveal. With poetic, evocative writing and a brilliant portrait of the international music scene, An Equal Music confirms Vikram Seth as one of the world's finest and most enticing writers.What we discussed about the book:
- The twin themes of lost love and passion for music.
- St Jerome and the white dog (cat/ferret) - what was the significance of this in the story? How did it represent Julia and Michael's story?
- What caused Michael to leave Julia in the first place?
- Did we want a 'happy' ending? Regarding Julia? Regarding the violin? What did we care more about and why?
- The links between Beethoven's loss of hearing and Julia's.
- Do musical and non-musical people read this book differently?
- Was there a musical structure to the novel?
- How did we find the dialogue? How was it used as a expository device?
- Were the quartet members fully developed characters?
- How did the tension of the Mrs Formby violin story contribute overall to the novel? Was this relationship one of the most satisfactory and resolved?
- Did Michael feel he was a fraud? How did his background contribute to this?
- Would Julia ever leave James? Why did she invite Michael to meet James for lunch?
- Was Julia right to hide her deafness?
- What effect did the first person, present tense writing style have?
- The concept of the irrevocable nature of time
- Can you or do you, get second chances?
- Is being a classical musical stalker a niche activity?
- Are musicians 'highly strung' by nature?
In other news, we discussed:
- Synesthesia - a neurological phenomenon in which stimulation of one sensory or cognitive pathway leads to automatic, involuntary experiences in a second sensory or cognitive pathway.
- Gatecrashing of funerals...widely spread practice?
- MONA gallery at Hobart
Range: 5 to 7.5
Average: 6.71
Next book: Orange is the New Black by Piper Kerman (chosen by JM)
Sunday, 8 September 2013
September book: An Equal Music by Vikram Seth
An Equal Music
by Vikram Seth
(chosen by KE)
Some background links to get you started:
by Vikram Seth
(chosen by KE)
Some background links to get you started:
- Reading group guide
- 'An Equal Music' article by Akash Kapur in Salon.com
- List of the music from the novel
- Nicholas Christopher's review in The New York Times
- An interview with Vikram Seth
- The publisher's page for the novel
Friday, 9 August 2013
Minutes August book: The Transit of Venus
by Shirley Hazzard
(chosen by Fairlie)
Theme: Antipodeans abroad
I originally interpreted this theme as meaning I should chose a work by an 'Australian' writer who lives (or lived) overseas, which led me to the likes of Peter Carey, Kathy Lette, Germaine Greer, Nikki Gemmell, Geraldine Brooks. While I was pondering a choice of these authors' works, I came across a reference on the Meanjin blog to Shirley Hazzard as being one of Australia's most neglected women authors, possibly as a result of her living overseas for so long. I initially thought I would choose her more recent work, The Great Fire, but opinion from others swayed me to The Transit of Venus. It was only after I had chosen it and ordered a copy that I found a pristine copy of the book on my own bookshelf. It had been on one of my university literature subject reading lists and I can only assume my 18 year old self saw the reading of it as an optional part of that course, as it obviously had never been opened. When I realised that not only was the author an 'antipodean aboard' but the novel was also about two Australian sisters who moved to England, it seemed like destiny that I should make it my choice.
About the author:
Shirley Hazzard was born in 1931 in Sydney, Australia. She left Australia as a child, due to her parents’ diplomatic postings and at 16, started to work for British Intelligence in Hong Kong, monitoring civil war in China. Since then she has lived in New Zealand, Europe, USA and Italy. In the USA she worked for the United Nations Secretariat in New York. She has been a full-time writer since leaving the UN, and has written a number non-fiction books including: Defeat of an Ideal: A Study of the Self-Destruction of the United Nations (1973), Countenance of Truth: the United Nations and the Waldheim Case (1990), Greene on Capri: A Memoir (2000) about her friend, Graham Greene. In 1985, Coming of Age in Australia was published, a collection of her Australian Broadcasting Corporation Boyer lectures. Her works of fiction include five novels: The Evening of the Holiday (1966); People in Glass Houses (1967); The Bay of Noon (1970); The Transit of Venus (1980); and most recently, The Great Fire (2003). Shirley Hazzard lives in New York.
(general biographical detail from the British Council website)
What the publisher says about the book:
Caro, gallant and adventurous, is one of two Australian sisters who have come to post-war England to seek their fortunes. Courted long and hopelessly by young scientist, Ted Tice, she is to find that love brings passion, sorrow, betrayal and finally hope. The milder Grace seeks fulfilment in an apparently happy marriage. But as the decades pass and the characters weave in and out of each other's lives, love, death and two slow-burning secrets wait in ambush for them.What we discussed about the book:
- The choice of 'The Transit of Venus' as the title. What was the significance, symbolism?
- What did the novel says about Australia and being Australian? How was it shown as a 'place to escape from'? In what ways did being Australian influence Caro and Grace's interactions with other characters?
- Could this be described as an anti-war novel? What evidence was there of this viewpoint?
- The coincidental and accidental nature of the human interactions vs the predictable nature of the astronomical transit of Venus.
- How we would describe the style of the writing - dense, given to understatement, having gravity, no superfluous words?
- The role of the omniscient narrator - foreshadowing details of plot essential to our later understanding.
- The themes of disappearance and loss: the Benbow sinking, Adam Vail's death, Dora's Major
- Is this a novel driven by plot or by character?
- What degree of engagement is required by the reader. How does Hazzard instruct the reader in what is going to be required right on the first page?
- The role of dialogue - minimal, but expressive.
- Dora, as a character. In what ways does Hazzard create such a rounded and believable character with so few scenes?
- Why do Caro and Grace treat Dora with no judgement and with a huge degree of loyalty.
- What makes a writer 'Australian'? Is it just that they have an Australian birth certificate?
- The role of working women at that time, with particular reference to the tea-making and button/typewriter ribbon replacing scenes.
- The social and political issues that form the background to the novel: post-war politics, nursing homes, women in the workforce, inequality of marraige, US political assassinations, English class system
In other news, we discussed:
- VCE subject choices, getting through Year 12, work experience options
- The nature of Australian customs practices - checking parcels etc
- The realities of nursing in 2013
- The daggy to glamorous spectrum of parents at each school. How do we know where we fall on the continuum?
- The etiquette of thank yous. One exchange is enough...you do not need to do a thank you for a thank you.
Range: 7 to 10
Average: 8.63
Next book: An Equal Music by Vikram Seth (chosen by KE)
Tuesday, 23 July 2013
Augusg book: The Transit of Venus by Shirley Hazzard
The Transit of Venus
by Shirley Hazzard
(chosen by Fairlie)
Theme: Antipodeans abroad
Some background links to get you started:
by Shirley Hazzard
(chosen by Fairlie)
Theme: Antipodeans abroad
Some background links to get you started:
- Page for the book at ABC's The First Tuesday Bookclub
- Review by David Miller in The Independent
- "A Look Back at Shirley Hazzard's The Transit of Venus" by Michael Gorra
- An interview with Shirley Hazzard by JD McClatchy in The Paris Review
Minutes July book: The In-Between World of Vikram Lall
The In-Between World of Vikram Lall
by M.G. Vassanji
(chosen by JP)
Theme: "Power does not corrupt, fear corrupts. Perhaps fear of the loss of power."
JP researched the theme for her book choice, and realised that it was a John Steinbeck quote from the novel, The Short Reign of Pippin IV, a political satire. She decided that any book she chose should focus on the WHY of power and corruption. Some initial options she examined were: The Betrayal by YA Erskine, No Fear: A Whistlebowers Triumph over Corruption and Retaliation at the EPA by Marsha Coleman-Abedayo and The Story of My Assassins: a Novel by Tarun J Teijpal. In each of those cases, the story was told by a victim or an observer of corruption. JP wanted to choose one told through the eyes of the perpetrator - so eventually she found The In-Between World of Vikram Lall.
About the author:
M.G. Vassanji was born in Kenya, and raised in Tanzania. He took a doctorate in physics at M.I.T. and came to Canada in 1978. While working as a research associate and lecturer at the University of Toronto in the 1980s he began to dedicate himself seriously to a longstanding passion: writing. His first novel, The Gunny Sack, won a regional Commonwealth Writers Prize, and he was invited to be writer-in-residence at the University of Iowa. The novel’s success was a spur, Vassanji has commented: “It was translated into several languages. I was confident that this was what I could do, that writing was not just wishful thinking. In 1989 I quit my full-time job and began researching The Book of Secrets.” That celebrated, bestselling novel won the inaugural Giller Prize, in 1994. Vassanji’s other books include the acclaimed novels No New Land (1991) and Amriika (1999), and Uhuru Street (1991), a collection of stories. His unique place in Canadian literature comes from his elegant, classical style, his narrative reach, and his interest in characters trying to reconcile different worlds within themselves. The subtle relations of the past and present are also constants in his writing: “When someone asks you where you are from or who you are, there is a whole resume of who you are. I know very few people who do not have a past to explain. That awareness is part of my work.” M.G. Vassanji was awarded the Harbourfront Festival Prize in 1994 in recognition of his achievement in and contribution to the world of letters, and was in the same year chosen as one of twelve Canadians on Maclean’s Honour Roll. He lives in Toronto with his wife and two sons.
(general biographical detail from the publisher's website)
What the publisher says about the book:
into:
Ratings:
Range: 7.5 to 9.5
Average: 8.79
Next book: The Transit of Venus by Shirley Hazzard (chosen by Fairlie)
by M.G. Vassanji
(chosen by JP)
Theme: "Power does not corrupt, fear corrupts. Perhaps fear of the loss of power."
JP researched the theme for her book choice, and realised that it was a John Steinbeck quote from the novel, The Short Reign of Pippin IV, a political satire. She decided that any book she chose should focus on the WHY of power and corruption. Some initial options she examined were: The Betrayal by YA Erskine, No Fear: A Whistlebowers Triumph over Corruption and Retaliation at the EPA by Marsha Coleman-Abedayo and The Story of My Assassins: a Novel by Tarun J Teijpal. In each of those cases, the story was told by a victim or an observer of corruption. JP wanted to choose one told through the eyes of the perpetrator - so eventually she found The In-Between World of Vikram Lall.
About the author:
M.G. Vassanji was born in Kenya, and raised in Tanzania. He took a doctorate in physics at M.I.T. and came to Canada in 1978. While working as a research associate and lecturer at the University of Toronto in the 1980s he began to dedicate himself seriously to a longstanding passion: writing. His first novel, The Gunny Sack, won a regional Commonwealth Writers Prize, and he was invited to be writer-in-residence at the University of Iowa. The novel’s success was a spur, Vassanji has commented: “It was translated into several languages. I was confident that this was what I could do, that writing was not just wishful thinking. In 1989 I quit my full-time job and began researching The Book of Secrets.” That celebrated, bestselling novel won the inaugural Giller Prize, in 1994. Vassanji’s other books include the acclaimed novels No New Land (1991) and Amriika (1999), and Uhuru Street (1991), a collection of stories. His unique place in Canadian literature comes from his elegant, classical style, his narrative reach, and his interest in characters trying to reconcile different worlds within themselves. The subtle relations of the past and present are also constants in his writing: “When someone asks you where you are from or who you are, there is a whole resume of who you are. I know very few people who do not have a past to explain. That awareness is part of my work.” M.G. Vassanji was awarded the Harbourfront Festival Prize in 1994 in recognition of his achievement in and contribution to the world of letters, and was in the same year chosen as one of twelve Canadians on Maclean’s Honour Roll. He lives in Toronto with his wife and two sons.
(general biographical detail from the publisher's website)
What the publisher says about the book:
Double Giller Prize winner M.G. Vassanji’s The In-Between World of Vikram Lall is a haunting novel of corruption and regret that brings to life the complexity and turbulence of Kenyan society in the last five decades. Rich in sensuous detail and historical insight, this is a powerful story of passionate betrayals and political violence, racial tension and the strictures of tradition, told in elegant, assured prose. The novel begins in 1953, with eight-year-old Vikram Lall a witness to the celebrations around the coronation of Queen Elizabeth II, just as the Mau Mau guerilla war for independence from Britain begins to gain strength. In a land torn apart by idealism, doubt, political upheaval and terrible acts of violence, Vic and his sister Deepa must find their place among a new generation. Neither colonists nor African, neither white nor black, the Indian brother and sister find themselves somewhere in between in their band of playmates: Bill and Annie, British children, and Njoroge, an African boy. These are the relationships that will shape the rest of their lives. We follow Vikram through the changes in East African society, the immense promise of the fifties and sixties. But when that hope is betrayed by the corruption and violence of the following decades, Vic is drawn into the Kenyatta government’s orbit of graft and power-broking. Njoroge, his childhood friend, can abandon neither the idealism of his youth nor his love for Vic’s sister Deepa. But neither the idealism of the one nor the passive cynicism of the other can avert the tragedies that await them.What we discussed about the book:
- The idea of incremental corruption: "Total corruption occurs in inches and travels through many veils of ambiguity."
- The role of colonial Kenya to this story - how the British society remained a background rather than a key feature.
- The loose ends that remain unresolved in the reader's mind - e.g. what role did Kenyatta play in Njoroge's death?
- The idea of identity. Is it possible to be 'African' when your ethnicity is Indian (or British?) How has that issue played out in out societies around the world?
- How ideas of racism are portrayed in the book - between and within various groups.
- The roles of the land and the love of the land. How does that affect choices various characters make?
- What changed within Vic's parents relationship? Where these changes caused by external events?
- What were the different responses to Deepa's relationship with Njorge? What influenced each response? Particularly, why was her mother so against it?
- What did we learn of the history of Kenya through the telling of this story?
- What was the true nature of the Kenyatta character, particularly with relation to the dichotomy between 'my father'/'your excellency' forms of address?
- Was Kenyatta motivated by a a fear of a loss of power?
- What motivated Vic? Was it money, personal safety, opportunism?
- The different life choices and pathways Njorge, Deepa and Vikram followed.
- What is the 'in-between' of Vic's world?
- What was the point of Joseph's character?
- Our favorite quotes: e.g. " It was the night that curdled the blood..."(p.46), "Mother left behind a broken and disoriented Papa..." (p.401)
- What happened in the ending? Is it left to interpretation?
into:
- How does the process of corruption progress - inch by inch, or by grand plan?
- Is it okay to accept a small amount of corruption to create a large amount of good difference?
- In what ways can people effect change in a generally corrupt society?
- The history of Kenya from 1AD to date.
- Did colonial governments provide a better day-to-day life for the people (i.e. more ordered, predictable)? This this ever a preferable option to self-rule?
In other news, we discussed:
- How JP's dog literally ate her homework, but that didn't stop her doing a stellar job at research for this month's bookclub.
- Sex education for teenagers
- The ethics of charities accepting donations from gambling-related companies
- Dan Brown's Inferno and its theme of world over-population, plus the idea that doing nothing when witnessing a transgression is the worst possible crime.
Range: 7.5 to 9.5
Average: 8.79
Next book: The Transit of Venus by Shirley Hazzard (chosen by Fairlie)
Monday, 1 July 2013
July book: The In-Between World of Vikram Lall
The In-Between World of Vikram Lall
by M.G. Vassanji
(chosen by JP)
Theme: "Power doesn't corrupt. Fear corrupts. Perhaps fear of the loss of power."
Some background links to get you started:
by M.G. Vassanji
(chosen by JP)
Theme: "Power doesn't corrupt. Fear corrupts. Perhaps fear of the loss of power."
Some background links to get you started:
- Review by Helon Habila In The Guardian
- Publisher's page for the book
- Review by James Bradley in The Age
- Review by Tara Sahgal in India Today
- Book club guide at Bookclubbuddy.com
Sunday, 30 June 2013
Minutes June book: Madame Bovary
by Gustave Flaubert
(chosen by Gypsy)
Theme: A woman scorned
Gypsy experienced much angst over her book choice for the theme, 'a woman scorned' and after soliciting advice both on-line and from her local bookstore, decided on Madame Bovary. For the first time ever, she had not pre-read the book before choosing it.
About the author:
Gustave Flaubert was born in Rouen in 1821, the son of a prominent physician. A solitary child, he was attracted to literature at an early age, and after his recovery from a nervous breakdown suffered while a law student, he turned his total energies to writing. Aside from journeys to the Near East, Greece, Italy, and North Africa, and a stormy liaison with the poetess Louise Colet, his life was dedicated to the practice of his art. The form of his work was marked by intense aesthetic scrupulousness and passionate pursuit of le mot juste; its content alternately reflected scorn for French bourgeois society and a romantic taste for exotic historical subject matter. The success of Madame Bovary (1857) was ensured by government prosecution for “immorality”; Salammbô (1862) and The Sentimental Education (1869) received a cool public reception; not until the publication of Three Tales (1877) was his genius popularly acknowledged. Among fellow writers, however, his reputation was supreme. His circle of friends included Turgenev and the Goncourt brothers, while the young Guy de Maupassant underwent an arduous literary apprenticeship under his direction. Increasing personal isolation and financial insecurity troubled his last years. His final bitterness and disillusion were vividly evidenced in the savagely satiric Bouvard and Pécuchet, left unfinished at his death in 1880.
(general biographical detail from the *publisher's website)
What the publisher* says about the book:
Emma Bovary is the original desperate housewife. Beautiful but bored, she spends lavishly on clothes and on her home and embarks on two disappointing affairs in an effort to make her life everything she believes it should be. Soon heartbroken and crippled by debts, she takes drastic action, with tragic consequences for her husband and daughter. In this landmark new translation of Gustave Flaubert's masterwork, award-winning writer and translator Lydia Davis honors the nuances and particulars of Flaubert's legendary prose style, giving new life in English to the book that redefined the novel as an art form.* Note: 'publisher' in this instance refers to the publisher of the Madame Bovary Penguin Classics edition, translated by Lydia Davis (there being many translations/editions of this work)
What we discussed about the book:
- The many different translations of the book. As we had read five different translations between us, did that effect our experience of the novel?
- Was Emma essentially a sophisticated aristocrat born into a bourgeois life, or a middle class girl obsessed with a more elite way of life? Did she set out with these intentions, or was it something that slowly built?
- Who were Emma's female role models?
- Did Emma have a sense of entitlement? If so, what motivated that?
- Do we get a sense of her as a fully rounded character?
- Did we empathize with Emma or were we repulsed by her?
- Did any of the characters have any redeeming features?
- Was Charles blinded to what was going on, or what it selective vision?
- Were we able to keep up with the maths of Emma's financial issues? Does the reader's confusion mirror the spiraling nature of her problems?
- Why did Rodolphe spurn Emma?
- Was Emma a romantic soul, ruled by her heart? Was her concept of love a fantasy?
- Use of symbolism in the novel: being trapped, phallic images, reins being broken, balls and spires in Rouen, flowers being thrown into the fire
- Was Emma's death inevitable? Why or why not?
- The sense of impending doom that pervaded the book - at what point did we realize it was all going to end very badly?
- Did Emma's physical isolation from family and female friends contribute to her fate?
- How did Homais, the chemist represent the growing bourgeois class? What were Flaubert's comments on this group?
- "We must not touch our idols, the gilt sticks to our fingers." What does this quote mean?
- How was irony used in the novel?
- Did Emma suffer from a psychological condition?
- The parallels between the novel and Gustave Flaubert's own life. Was he writing 'what he knew'?
- Is Emma in fact a woman scorned? What is our definition of a woman scorned?
- The role of wet nurses.
- Would we recommend this book, and if so, which translation?
In other news, we discussed:
- Prancercise as an exercise form - who is up for it?!
- The links between mathematical and musical ability.
- Burials, mausoleums, maggots and leeches.
Range: 6 to 9.5
Average: 7.38
Next book: The In-Between World of Vikram Lall by M.G.Vassanji (chosen by JP)
Wednesday, 29 May 2013
June book: Madame Bovary
by Gustave Flaubert
(chosen by Gypsy)
Theme: A woman scorned
Some background links to get you started:
- Spark notes for the book
- Article by AS Byatt in The Guardian
- Review by Kathryn Harrison in The New York Times
- Review by Russell Kane in The Independent
- Julian Barnes reviews a translation of Madame Bovary in London Review of Books
Minutes May book: The Happiest Refugee
By Anh Do
(Chosen by Elster)
Theme: Inspiring and uplifting
Elster read at least four possible titles before making her choice. Some were based on bookshop or library recommendations. One, at least, was not at all inspiring and uplifting. She settled on this choice because it had a very 'happy' title and fitted the theme.
About the author:
Anh Do is one of Australia's leading comedians. He has also acted in television series and films, written screenplays and is a sought-after keynote speaker. His unique and inspirational experience leaving Vietnam as a toddler and growing up in Australia is the subject of his bestselling and award-winning memoir, The Happiest Refugee.
(general biographical detail from the publisher's website)
What the publisher says about the book:
Anh Do nearly didn't make it to Australia. His entire family came close to losing their lives on the sea as they escaped from war-torn Vietnam in an overcrowded boat. But nothing - not murderous pirates, nor the imminent threat of death by hunger, disease or dehydration as they drifted for days - could quench their desire to make a better life in a country where freedom existed. Life in Australia was hard, an endless succession of back-breaking work, crowded rooms, ruthless landlords and make-do everything. But there was a loving extended family, and always friends and play and something to laugh about for Anh, his brother Khoa and their sister Tram. Things got harder when their father left home when Anh was thirteen - they felt his loss very deeply and their mother struggled to support the family on her own. His mother's sacrifice was an inspiration to Anh and he worked hard during his teenage years to help her make ends meet, also managing to graduate high school and then university. Another inspiration was the comedian Anh met when he was about to sign on for a 60-hour a week corporate job. Anh asked how many hours he worked. 'Four,' the answer came back, and that was it. He was going to be a comedian! The Happiest Refugee tells the incredible, uplifting and inspiring life story of one of our favourite personalities. Tragedy, humour, heartache and unswerving determination - a big life with big dreams. Anh's story will move and amuse all who read it.What we discussed about the book:
- What were the most profound themes of this book? (e.g. 'There's only two times in life. Now and too late')
- Given Anh's background as a comedian, how was humour used to tell the story? What was its tone? Was it underdone, overdone or just right?
- Whose story is this? Is it Anh's alone, or does he speak on behalf of others? Would their stories of the same events be different?
- Did this meet the 'uplifting and inspiring' brief? In what ways?
- What we thought about Do's forgiveness of his father? What does that say about him as a person?
- How did we describe his father? What factors from his past contributed to his alcoholism?
- What was the tipping point for his father's behaviour?
- Is Anh's mother the hero of this story?
- The role of cooking and eating in family life.
- Why did some characters seem to appear and then disappear from the story? (e.g. Uncle Six)
- The scenes from the book that we loved; e.g. bringing the pig to the engagement party, the engagement party speech, the 50c fur coat.
- The Little Refugee - Anh Do's book for kids based on his experience. A great picture book for children.
- Working out exactly how big the boat was in comparison to the room we were sitting in.
- The chronology of Vietnamese immigration post-1975
- Does the notion of 'family' loom larger for immigrants than for others?
- Is the use of the word 'refugee' in the title political? Are political points sometimes communicated best in a softly,softly or humorous manner?
- The recent story about the plight of Tamil refugees living in the suburbs of Melbourne.
- What does this book teach us about the refugee experience, and what does it make us think about the issue moving forward?
- The term 'economic refugee'. What are the connotations of it?
- The role of self-deprecating humour. Are Australians losing the ability to laugh at ourselves?
In other news, we discussed:
- The types of voluntary community work being done by our kids.
- Greek banking fees
- The serving (or not) of pork products on Qantas/Emirates code-share flights
- The wearing of pants (trousers) vs skirts to church (or to court). At what point did the 'rules' change?
Range: 6.5 to 8.5
Average: 7.89
Next book: Madame Bovary by Gustave Flaubert (chosen by Gypsy)
Sunday, 5 May 2013
May book: The Happiest Refugee by Anh Do
The Happiest Refugee
by Anh Do
(chosen by Elster)
Theme: inspiring and uplifting
Some background links to get you started:
by Anh Do
(chosen by Elster)
Theme: inspiring and uplifting
Some background links to get you started:
- The publisher's page for the book
- Anh Do's website
- Sydney Morning Herald review by Cameron Woodhead of the live performance
- Article by Sacha Molitorisz in Sydney Morning Herald
- Article by Rosemary Neill in The Australia
Tuesday, 30 April 2013
Minutes April book: Lady Chatterley's Lover
By D.H. Lawrence
(Chosen by CH)
Theme: Banned books
CH chose this book after perusing a Wiki list of banned books. She had first read it when she was 12 years old, again at 30 and now. She was interested in exploring the basis on which this book was banned, particularly as it was just recently (2009) banned from sale in Australia Post shops, as it was didn't fit in with the 'theme of their stores'.
About the author:
David Herbert Lawrence was born in 1885. After attending Beauvale Board School he won a scholarship to Nottingham High School. He left school in 1901 and was employed for a short time as a clerk at a manufacturer of surgical appliances, then trained as a teacher and took up a teaching post. In 1912, after a period of serious illness, he returned to Nottinghamshire, and then eloped to Germany with Frieda Weekley, the wife of Professor Ernest Weekley. They returned to England in 1914 and were married at Kensington Register Office on 14 July. After the War, they left England once more, and travelled extensively within Europe and then further afield to Ceylon, Australia, Mexico and New Mexico. Lawrence's health continued to deteriorate and he returned to Europe with Frieda in 1925. During his last years he lived mostly in Italy, making only brief visits to England. He died on 2 March 1930 in the south of France. Lawrence was a prolific writer - of poetry, novels, short stories, plays, essays, and criticism. His works are heavily autobiographical and profoundly influenced by the experiences of his early years in Nottinghamshire.
(general biographical detail from The University of Nottingham Manuscripts and Special Collections webpage)
What a publisher says about the book:
Constance Chatterley feels trapped in her sexless marriage to the invalid Sir Clifford. Unable to fulfil his wife emotionally or physically, Clifford encourages her to have a liaison with a man of their own class. But Connie is attracted instead to her husband’s gamekeeper and embarks on a passionate affair that brings new life to her stifled existence. Can she find a true equality with Mellors, despite the vast gulf between their positions in society? One of the most controversial novels in English literature, Lady Chatterley’s Lover is an erotically charged and psychologically powerful depiction of adult relationships.What we discussed about the book:
- Why are books banned?
- On what basis can a book be banned? Immorality? Offensiveness? Perverting the course of justice?
- What subject matter (if any) would each of us think is unacceptable for publication?
- Does the language (particularly the use of the C and F-words) shock readers nowadays? Is it the kind of book 'you'd wish your wife or your servants to read'?
- Was 'coarse' language used to desensitise readers to the sexual aspects of the story?
- The repetitious use of certain phrases or words in the novel - e.g. 'bitch goddess', 'stirring in the bowels'
- How were plot and characters used to philosophise about social issues? Did this interrupt the flow of the narrative?
- Was Connie a creature of her times? In what ways did her character display conflict of head vs body.
- Was Connie's upbringing usual? In what ways did it influence her thoughts and actions?
- The concept of being 'in the body' or 'in the mind' - what was Lawrence saying about each state?
- Was the relationship between Connie and Mellors believable? How did it contrast with the beautifully drawn analysis of Connie and Clifford's relationship?
- Was Clifford portrayed fairly? Were readers manipulated into our views of him?
- What was the catalyst for Connie moving from the realm of the intellectual to the physical?
- Is Lawrence suggesting that falling in love can follow after connecting initially physically.
- The representation of class issues. In what ways had Mellors been damaged by class structures?
- Why did Mellors alternate between Darbyshire dialect and middle class English? What statement was being made about this?
- How did Mellor's treatment of his child influence our opinion of him? Did we trust him?
- How did power shift with the introduction of Mrs Bolton? How did she represent the rise of industrialisation?
- Was it a happy ending? What did we think happened after the novel ended?
- What is the etymology of the F-word? And the C-word?
- What is a bath chair?
- Was this the book we expected (for those who hadn't read it before)?
- Would this book have been as 'famous' and popular if it hadn't been banned?
In other news, we discussed:
- Various ailments affecting family members
- The stresses and funny moments of nursing
Range: 6.5 to 8.5
Average: 7.19
Next book: The Happiest Refugee by Anh Do (chosen by Elster)
Monday, 1 April 2013
April book: Lady Chatterley's Lover
by DH Lawrence
(chosen by CH)
Theme: Banned books
Some background links to get you started:
- Stories from the Banned Books in Australia exhibition at University of Melbourne
- Spark notes for the book
- Article by Geoffrey Robertson in The Guardian about the trial
- Article by Steve Hare in The Telegraph
Sunday, 31 March 2013
Minutes March book: The Sense of an Ending
By Julian Barnes
(Chosen by Domestic Goddess)
Theme: Booker Prize winner
(editors note: thanks to Domestic Goddess for taking the notes for the minutes this month!)
Domestic Goddess chose this book because it sounded quirky and interesting and also because it was within our page length parameters.
About the author:
Julian Barnes was born in England and educated at the City of London School and at Magdalen College, Oxford, from which he graduated in modern languages (with honors). After graduation, he worked as: a lexicographer for the Oxford English Dictionary supplement, a reviewer and literary editor for the New Statesmen and the New Review; and a television critic. Barnes has received several awards and honors for his writing, including the 2011 Man Booker Prize for The Sense of an Ending. He has written numerous novels, short stories, and essays. His writing deals with the themes of history, reality, truth and love. he currently lives in London.
(general biographical detail from the author's website)
What the publisher says about the book:
Tony Webster and his clique first met Adrian Finn at school. Sex-hungry and book-hungry, they would navigate the girl-less sixth form together, trading in affectations, in-jokes, rumour and wit. Maybe Adrian was a little more serious than the others, certainly more intelligent, but they all swore to stay friends for life.Now Tony is in middle age. He's had a career and a single marriage, a calm divorce. He's certainly never tried to hurt anybody. Memory, though, is imperfect. It can always throw up surprises, as a lawyer's letter is about to prove.The Sense of an Ending is the story of one man coming to terms with the mutable past. Laced with trademark precision, dexterity and insight, it is the work of one of the world's most distinguished writers.What we discussed about the book:
- The Booker Prize – we discussed this at length – awarded each year since 1969 to the best original full length novel written in English by a citizen of the Commonwealth or Republic of Ireland.
- Booker is presented by the “Man Group” – an investment company – we spoke about why a company that was not clearly a book publisher would sponsor such a prize.
- Booker winners – we looked at the books that had been selected in previous years, who was their publishers, who were the judges, what country the author who won came from etc.
- The characters – even though book was so short there was enough information provided by the author that you had a real sense of each character.
- We explored the theme of memory and how it interacts with our actions now.
- That the book is split into two parts – the earlier being the acute observations of history and memory by teenagers – this was a very good tool to pave the way for the second part of the book.
- We asked is Tony a manipulative narrator? Is he hiding information from himself and others – again the issue of memory and how it can be distorted.
- Is the ending the real truth? Veronica kept saying that Tony does not get it so is there more to the ending and are we all missing the real truth so that we only have “a sense of an ending”?
- Was Adrian’s suicide an intellectual/philosophical decision or just like Robson’s suicide a person who was troubled by life and circumstances?
- Who should take responsibility for another person’s suicide? Is this even appropriate – here Tony takes responsibility but others were also involved – Veronica and Mrs Ford.
- We spent a lot of time on Veronica’s obstructive behaviour and the reasons that would underpin such behaviour.
- Also spent a lot of time dwelling on the question is Tony the father of Adrian 2 (disabled son) or is he the son of Adrian and Mrs Ford?
- We asked if Tony omits Veronica from his life when speaking to Margaret could he omit a sexual relationship with Mrs Ford as well?
- We discussed the “incest vibe” – was this a red herring or a real issue? Comments about Veronica being damaged – but as Tony may be an unreliable narrator can we place any faith in his comments? Very tricky feeling not being able to believe the narrator.
- That many parts of the book are open to different interpretation – more so than most books – this factor gave the book a very quirky twist.
- It is a book that inspires speculation!!
- We asked “ultimately does it matter in what sequence events occur in the retelling”? Lots of people say NO because memory is unreliable but society constantly strives for reliability/the truth/correct memory – in the media, the law, business, medical etc .
- Touched on the blog posts by Andrew Blackman about this book.
In other news, we discussed:
- Arthroscopy on knees. Does anaesthetic recalibrate your brain (and sometimes not in a good way)?Amazing what they can do now via keyhole surgery.
- The catastrophe scale: How one No.1 Lady's phrase "build a bridge and get over it – it is not a catastrophe" was explained at length in a daughter's school English essay.
- Another daughter of a No.1 Lady presented a speech at State Parliament on International Women’s Day on the topic of domestic violence and homelessness.
- Is it appropriate for a professional writer to visit a school and ask, “What have your parents done that is embarrassing?” - to then have kids disclosing personal information in front of all their class members. Is this a bit weird and inappropriate for a number of reasons? Are we being PC or is it just inappropriate?
- Elster's first day at work as a qualified Div 2 nurse after 18 months of study. Congratulations!
Range: 6 to 9
Average: 7.55
Next book: Lady Chatterley's Lover by DH Lawrence (chosen by CH)
Saturday, 9 March 2013
March book: The Sense of an Ending
The Sense of an Ending
by Julian Barnes
(chosen by Domestic Goddess)
Theme: Booker Prize Winner
Some background links to get you started:
by Julian Barnes
(chosen by Domestic Goddess)
Theme: Booker Prize Winner
Some background links to get you started:
- The author's website
- Review by Michiko Kakutani in The New York Times
- Review by Geordie Williamson in The Australian
- The publisher's page for the book
- Reading guide questions at Book Browse
Minutes February book: The Widow Clicquot
By Tilar J Mazzeo
(Chosen by T-Rex)
Theme: Biography
T-Rex chose this book on the recommendation of a friend who is in another bookclub. She needed no encouragement at all to read about champagne, especially when the reading came in the form of her favourite book genre - biography! Having toured the area of Champagne recently, she was especially keen to learn more about the history. The book also fitted within this year's page limit
About the author:
Tilar J. Mazzeo is the New York Times best-selling author of books on wine, travel, French culture, and the history of luxury, including The Widow Clicquot: The Story of a Champagne Empire and the Woman Who Ruled It, The Secret of Chanel No. 5: The Intimate History of the World’s Most Famous Perfume, The Back-Lane Wineries of Sonoma, The Back-Lane Wineries of Napa, and the forthcoming The Ritz at War: Luxury in Occupied Paris. She divides her time between the California wine country, New York City, and Maine, where she is a Professor and the co-chair of the English department at Colby College.
(general biographical detail from the author's website)
What the publisher says about the book:
The Widow Clicquot is the New York Times bestselling business biography of the visionary young widow who built a champagne empire, became a legend in her tumultuous times, and showed the world how to live with style. Tilar J. Mazzeo brings to life the woman behind the label, Barbe-Nicole Clicquot Ponsardin, in this utterly intoxicating book that is as much a fascinating journey through the process of making this temperamental wine as a biography of a uniquely tempered and fascinating woman.What we discussed about the book:
- Is this the only example of an 'oeno-biography'? ('Oeno' coming from the Ancient Greek for wine) Could we think of any others?
- In what ways did lack of written evidence of The Widow's life shape the form of the book, especially in the first half?
- How much of the story was 'made-up' to join the dots where evidence was missing?
- Was this an academic work or a best-selling biography? Does it walk a fine line between the two?
- How painstaking the research of this book was - as evidenced by the extensive notes.
- The 'invention' of champagne - how much is myth? how much is fact? What was Dom Perignon's role? How has modern marketing used these stories?
- Is Marie-Antoinette's breast and the coupe glass another myth?
- The role of politics and international relations in the story.
- What drove the Widow's persistence in the face of many setbacks?
- Did we warm to the Widow as a 'character'?
- What did we think the nature of her relationship with Edouard was?
- How unlikely it was for women at that time to travel. The Widow visited Paris once in her lifetime, and yet without travelling beyond her region, she was able to strategise on an international scale.
- How we loved the descriptions of the wine-making process - the 'ropey' and 'stringy' wine etc.
- What motivated the Widow to encourage an aristocratic marriage for her daughter?
- Was the Widow generous in a philanthropic sense?
- The role of the climate in creating great wines/champagnes.
- The invisibility of women in historical evidence. What types of women did leave strong traces, and what types didn't?
- How have women been involved in the wine industry over history? In what roles, and under what circumstances?
- The Champagne A.O.C. regulations. When did they come into force? What do they regulate?
- Traditions of wine making in various ethnic groups in Australia.
- Why Catholicism was literally driven underground in France.
- The role of monks in wine making.
In other news, we discussed:
- Les Miserables. A great movie? Or just plain miserable?
- Who is/was the most handsome of the British Royals?
- The purchase of macaroons at Laduree in Paris - how many are required to 'get the bag'?
- What is a 'billion'? (a UK billion was once 1,000,000,000,000 but is now the same as the US: 1,000,000,000)
Ratings:
Range: 7 to 8.5
Average: 7.77
Next book: The Sense of an Ending by Julian Barnes (chosen by Domestic Goddess)
Saturday, 2 February 2013
February book: The Widow Clicquot
The Widow Clicquot
by Tilar J Mazzeo
(Chosen by T-Rex)
Theme: biography
Some background links to get you started:
by Tilar J Mazzeo
(Chosen by T-Rex)
Theme: biography
Some background links to get you started:
- The publisher's page for the book
- The author's website
- Review by Jane and Michael Stern in The New York Times
- Review by Laura Griffin at My French Life
- Interview with Tilar Mazzeo at My French Life, Part 1
- Interview with Tilar Mazzeo at My French Life, Part 2
Plans for 2013
The No.1 Melbourne Ladies Bookclub is looking forward to another exciting and rewarding year of reading!
This year we plan to:
This year we plan to:
- keep book lengths to less than 350 pages, unless agreed on a case-by-case basis.
- start at 8pm as usual, but have a strict 11pm out-the-door rule!
- chose books according to a theme that has been allocated to each month. These can be interpreted as broadly or narrowly as the member wishes.
The themes are:
February: Biography
March: Booker Prize winner (any year)
April: Banned books
May: Uplifting and inspirational
June: A woman scorned
July: “The perfect place to make a film about the end of the world.”
August: “Power does not corrupt. Fear corrupts... perhaps the fear of a loss of power.”
September: Antipodeans abroad
October: “Without music, life would be a mistake.”
November: Crime and punishment
March: Booker Prize winner (any year)
April: Banned books
May: Uplifting and inspirational
June: A woman scorned
July: “The perfect place to make a film about the end of the world.”
August: “Power does not corrupt. Fear corrupts... perhaps the fear of a loss of power.”
September: Antipodeans abroad
October: “Without music, life would be a mistake.”
November: Crime and punishment















