Thursday, 17 April 2008

Minutes April 2008 Book: The Secret River by Kate Grenville

The Secret River

by Kate Grenville

(chosen by Elster)



Elster chose this book on the recommendation of her neighbour. She read it last year and enjoyed it, so decided to choose it for bookclub.

Kate Grenville was born and currently lives in Sydney. She has an Arts degree from Sydney University and worked in the film industry before living in the UK and Europe for several years and starting to write.

She completed an MA in Creative Writing at the University of Colorado in 1980 and when she returned to Australia in 1983 she worked at the Subtitling Unit for SBS Television. Her first book, a collection of stories - Bearded Ladies - was published in 1984, and since then she's published six novels and four books about the writing process (one co-written with Sue Woolfe).

The Secret River has won many prizes, including the Commonwealth Prize for Literature and the Christina Stead Prize. Her other works of fiction have also won state and national awards. The Idea of Perfection won the Orange Prize. Her most recent book Searching for the Secret River is a memoir about the writing of The Secret River. It tells the story of the research behind the novel.

Kate Grenville's novels have been published in a number of countries, including in translation, and her books about the writing process are used in many creative writing courses.

(general biographical details from Kate Grenville's own website.)

What the publisher says about The Secret River:

In the early nineteenth century William Thornhill is transported from the slums of London to New South Wales for the term of his natural life. He arrives with his wife Sal and their children in a harsh land he cannot understand.

Eight years later, Thornhill sails up the Hawkesbury as a free man to claim a hundred acres. Aboriginal people already live on that river and Thornhill will soon have to make the most difficult decision of his life.

Inspired by research into her own family history, Kate Grenville's The Secret River is a tour de force, a powerful and groundbreaking story about life on the frontier.


What we discussed about the book:

  • To what extent did we empathise with the main characters?
  • How harshly did we judge their actions, particularly the indigenous relations. Were we able to experience the story without viewing it from a 21st century perspective?
  • How would we have behaved faced with the same situations as the characters? Could we have coped with frontier life in the way that Sal did?
  • In relation to the various examples of mistreatment of the Aboriginal people, what alternative courses of action may have been available to the settlers? Could William have informed authorities about the woman chained up? What would the implications of that course of action have been?
  • Did the flaws in William's character make it easier or harder for us to empathise with him?
  • The symbolism of the fish carved into the rock above the Thornhill's land. Was the placement of his large permanent house over the fish an attempt to wipe out the memory, or a reminder that no matter what was put on top of it, the land had always been someone else's first?
  • Why didn't the settlers learn from the Aborigines with regard to hunting and gathering food? What was the cultural mindset at the time that caused them to dismiss such obvious survival mechanisms as 'savage'?
  • The difficulties of communication between two societies that didn't share a language or cultural references. Were there differences in understanding of body language too? What examples were there of attempts to communicate being misinterpreted?
  • To what extent the convicts were victims of a rigid British class structure. Did we judge them less harshly than the authorities?
  • Was Sal representative of most settler women? Her stoic endurance of fearful and hard conditions made her an admirable character. How did we view the relationship between her and William?
  • How did the evocative, descriptive writing style heighten our experience of this book?

Then we were sidetracked into:

  • What role does historical fiction play in the representation of history? What responsibility does an historical fiction writer have to get the facts right?
  • Is it possible to empathise with a character whose actions you find abhorrent?
  • If hypothetical aliens arrived in our world, and we shared no language, cultural references or perhaps even body language, how would we communicate with them? Would our immediate response be one of repelling the invader? Or how would we communicate our welcome? How would we know whether they came in peace?
And in other news, we discussed:

  • Mobile phones. Is it possible to get one which just makes and receives calls and has no extra features we don't need?
  • Acceptance of cultural and religious rules passed down through generations. Which ones do we follow blindly because we've always done it, which ones do we question?
Ratings:
Initial rating average: 8.4
Initial rating range: 7.5 to 9.5
End of discussion ratings: no change

* Next month, the initial rating will be a silent rating.

Next book: Notes from an Exhibition by Patrick Gale

Wednesday, 9 April 2008

April book: The Secret River by Kate Grenville

The Secret River by Kate Grenville
(chosen by Elster)

Meeting date: Tuesday 15th April
Venue: Fairlie's house




Some links for background information to get you started:

Minutes March 2008 Book: What is the What by Dave Eggers



What is the What

by Dave Eggers

(chosen by CH)

CH chose this book on a recommendation from another bookclub which had given it a really high rating. She was told it was an "important book" with a really significant story which needs to be told. This appealed to CH, as she felt that the issue of the Sudan is difficult to understand and engage with, and the personal story provides a bridge into it.

Dave Eggers was born in 1970 in Boston, Massachusetts and attended the University of Illinois. He is married to writer, Vendela Vida and they live in San Francisco with their daughter, born in 2005.

Eggers began writing as a Salon.com editor. His first book was a memoir, A Heartbreaking Work of Staggering Genius (2000). It is about the author's struggle to raise his younger brother following the sudden deaths of their parents.

In 2002, Eggers published his first novel, You Shall Know Our Velocity. What Is the What: The Autobiography of Valentino Achak Deng is his second novel and it was a finalist for the 2006 National Book Critics Circle Award for Fiction.

Eggers is a founder of McSweeney's, an independent publishing house and currently teaches writing in San Francisco at a nonprofit tutoring centre and writing school for children that he co-founded with Vendela Vida in 2002. They have expanded the program by using volunteers to operate similar centres in Los Angeles, New York City, Seattle, Chicago, and Ann Arbor, Michigan.

(General biographical details from here)

The publisher's comments:

Separated from his family, Valentino Achak Deng becomes a refugee in war-ravaged southern Sudan. His travels bring him in contact with enemy soldiers, with liberation rebels, with hyenas and lions, with disease and starvation, and with deadly murahaleen (militias on horseback)—the same sort who currently terrorize Darfur. Based closely on actual experiences, What Is the What is heartrending and astonishing, filled with adventure, suspense, tragedy, and, finally, triumph.

What we discussed about the book:

  • How does this book portray hope as the primary driver of the human condition?
  • In what ways was Deng a charismatic character?
  • Is telling the story a healing process for Deng?
  • The Sudanese story of evolution - the cow or the what? What is the what? What is the cow? Does our society value the what over the cow?
  • The level of violence shown in the refugee camps, particularly towards women.
  • The flow of the narrative. In what ways did the jumping between past and present effect the telling of the story?
  • Was the book too long?
  • Was the font too small?

Then we were sidetracked into:

  • When a society experiences a total disregard for human life, how does it begin to rebuild? In what ways is 'civilisation' nurtured?
  • The idea that many children in the world today still grow up not knowing much about the world beyond their village. How does a lack of outside influences affect a society?

And in other news, we discussed:

  • Branded foods for kids in supermarkets. Is it right that food choices may be made on the basis of which superhero is on the packet rather than on its nutritional, economic and environmental impact. Should we just vote with our feet?
  • The politics of food choices. Do we consume way more than we really need to? And is too much of it over-packaged and over-refined? Fascinating photos of the weekly groceries for families around the world can be found here.
  • Packaging in school lunches. How can we minimise the plastic wrapping going to school each day?
  • The Uplift Fiji bra donation program. Which, of course, led us to...water-filled bras vs chicken fillets. Which is more natural looking?

Ratings

Initial rating average: 7.08

Initial rating range: 5 to 9

End of discussion rating average: 7.25

End of discussion rating range: 6 to 9

Next book: The Secret River by Kate Grenville (Elster's choice)