Friday, 13 November 2020

November book: Eggshell Skull by Bri Lee



Eggshell Skull


by Bri Lee

Discussion led by KM











Some background links to get you started: 
  • Article: 'Eggshell Skull: What happens when a sexual assault complainant is strong and angry?' by Hayley Gleeson at ABC News.
  • Article: 'Eggshell Skull has won another award – it would have been illegal to publish it if I lived in Tasmania' by Bri Lee at The Guardian

Monday, 12 October 2020

October book - Educated by Tara Westover




Educated


by Tara Westover

Discussion led by JC









Some background links to get you started: 

What we discussed about the book:
  • How JC chose it via a recommendation from a graduate at Northeastern University - see Tara Westover's commencement speech The Un-instagrammable Self - on YouTube
  • Is this a book about religion? 
  • The effect of mental illness in this family
  • Why is it called 'Educated' - what role does education play in the story? 
  • Can there be multiple, equally valid 'truths' within a family?
  • What have other members of the family said publicly about this book?
  • Did we feel a shift in character at various points in the book (e.g. when the mother apologised)?
  • What effect would doomsday thinking have on a family in the day to day?
  • Is being a younger sibling an advantage when it comes to homeschooling? (i.e. do they learn from older siblings)?
  • The advantage of being literate - how would this story have played out if there was limited literacy among the children?
  • What drove Tara? What provided her motivation to learn? 
  • The role of singing in Tara's journey.
  • How has Tara reconciled loving her family, but also leaving them?
  • How did no-one die or sustain very serious injury in some of the accidents described?

And then we were sidetracked into:
  • Homeschooling - what types of people homeschool in Australia? Why? What are the benefits? How do they organise their days and social interactions? 
  • KM's experiences in Idaho in 1986
  • Should authors read their own memoirs for the audiobook? Why or why not? 
  • Tara's mother's memoir - 'Educating'
  • Tara's writing process - 30 journals over 10 years to draw on, but invested a lot of time to learn 'al the tricks' to write a good narrative.
  • Why would you use pseudonyms for real people in a memoir? 
  • How can society better protect children from instances of neglect and/or domestic violence?
  • Is it possible to protect children but also keep them with their families?

In other news:
  • We discussed what we've been watching on TV - The Social Dilemma, the 7.30 Report on ABC regarding the US election, Jess, Emily in Paris, Staged, Grace & Frankie and Dirty John (Betty), and listening to Rabbithole (podcast from the New York Times). 
  • We shared our opinions and views about the latest imbroglio involving Gladys Berejiklian.
  • What news can we hope for on Sunday regarding the Victorian lockdown? 

Ratings:
Range - 8 to 9
Average - 8.5

Next book:
Eggshell Skull by Bri Lee

Friday, 11 September 2020

September book: The Wall by John Lanchester


The Wall


by John Lanchester

Discussion led by AD







Some background links to get you started: 
What we discussed about the book: 
  • The opening sentence is “It’s cold on the Wall.” The final sentence is also ‘It’s cold on the Wall.”What is the significance of this? Is it a form of concrete poetry?
  • Does ‘everything have to be all right’ for a story to make sense? Why does Kavanagh think that telling the story of the Wall fits that bill?
  • How do we feel as readers when we think it is not all going to be alright? 
  • Are you left with a feeling of hope or possibility at the end of the novel?  Or despair? 
  • Trump’s use of ‘the beautiful wall’ in talking about the border fence was a form of storytelling – to what extent is this an oppositional story that shows what happens to a society if you do build walls?  
  • Does this book's dramatisation of the threat of climate change hit the mark?
  • Did the events seems realistic or too far-fetched to be seem a possible future? Does this matter in dystopian fiction? 
  • Are the young right to hate the old? What does the novel say about the ways that generations interact? In what other situations do you see this type of generational discord? (e.g politics, Covid, refugee issues, marriage equality) 
  • Who is to blame for the Change?
  • Is this an allegory about global warming, populism, isolationism, or Brexit — or is it literally just a story about a guy standing on a wall? In the opening page Kavanagh says ‘You look for the metaphors...’ 
  • If it is an allegory – which parts are easy to decode vs what is not? 
  • So many of the names are capitalised – the Others, Breeders, Elite, the Wall, Defenders, the Help - what is the effect of this?
  • What is an Other? How did you imagine what an Other was, how it felt to be an Other? We never really get to see those Others, how does the author create empathy for the Others? 
  • Is this a novel about powerlessness? How is that explored as a Defender vs as an Other? 
  • Who was the Captain? What do we as readers know about him? What was his motivation? 
  • As a narrator, is Kavanagh reliable? Do his views align with our own? Does his first person voice restrict us from seeing or knowing as much about the world and the circumstances as we want to?
  • Boredom is a feature of life on the Wall – how was that portrayed?
  • What we wanted to know about the Change and its effects but didn't...e.g. how it happened, what parts of culture are retained and what is not, how was that achieved? 
  • Are the characters, particularly the women, under developed? What is the effect of that? Initially, some of the Defenders appear gender ambiguous, what is the effect of that? 
And we were sidetracked into...
  • Second readings of books - how knowing an ending affects subsequent readings...to what extent is each reading a 'different book'.
  • What is the purpose of walls? Keeping people out or keeping people in? (i.e. fortress or prison) Keeping the sea out? Demarkation of ‘property’? What are the features of a good wall? 
  • The Wall seems to draw on or reflect a lot of contemporary events. What real-life images came to your mind with the symbolism of The Wall? (Mexico wall, Brexit, Berlin wall, Great Wall of China, city walls, sea walls, prison walls, refugee crises) 
  • What is the symbolism of walls?

In other news, we discussed:
  • navigating the medical system in Covid-times
  • home-schooling - dress standards
  • the experience of hotel quarantine
  • perceptions of WA life by those on the outside of the border and vice versa
  • The Social Dilemma - Netflix documentary-drama hybrid exploring the dangerous human impact of social networking
  • The Great Hack - Netflix - documentary about Cambridge Analytica's dark role in the use of social media in the 2016 US presidential election.
  • The Bureau - SBS on Demand - drama based on real accounts from French spies, 

Ratings
Range: 5 to 8.5
Average: 7.09

Next up:
Educated by Tara Westover

Monday, 17 August 2020

August book: A Man Called Ove by Fredrik Backman


A Man Called Ove

by Fredrik Backman

Discussion to be led by MH





Some background links to get you started: 


What we discussed about the book:
  • Why it was a replacement for our previous choice of book for this month 
  • Was it an accurate characterization of cat behaviour?
  • The narrative style of the book, which led to the very amusing quote, "It was a really easy read. Oh, actually, I listened to it..." :) 
  • Who has an Ove in their life? Do you need one to fully appreciate the character?
  • Was it shocking to us that Ove was only 59? 
  • The use of colour symbolism/language throughout the book
  • The use of humour of varying kinds, including black humour
  • What was at the heart of Ove's reaction to Rune swapping from Volvo to BMW?
  • In what ways is Ove a good person?
  • What do the 'white shirts' represent?
  • What does this novel say about the value of connection in communities?
  • Did Parvaneh know what Ove was up to? Were all her 'emergencies' part of her wanting to drag him into connection with others and save him from himself? What was her motivation?
  • Did Ove change as a character, or did our attitudes towards him change as readers? 
  • What were the saddest moments of the book and why? 
  • How did Ove have his father's brown suit ("He was his father’s slightly too tight-fitting brown suit across his broad, sad shoulders.") if he had lost everything in the fire? 
And we were sidetracked into...
  • Do any of the characters cross-over into any of his other books?
  • Similarities in style to some of our other favourite authors - such as Alexander McCall Smith, Gail Honeyman
  • How much it reminded some of Ricky Gervais's Afterlife
  • A discussion of the movie of the novel (which is in Swedish)
  • Would the men we know like this book?
  • Why do some readers criticize books for not being 'believable' - what does that mean? If the emotional heart of a novel is believable, does the actual plot need to be realistic or meet some kind of credibility test?
  • Sonja and Ove had similar upbringings in many ways - and yet had very different personalities. What influences this?
  • Would Ove be considered to be on the spectrum? 
  • Would absent member who places great importance on the endings of novels be satisfied with this one? (We thought, yes) 
  • How retirement can lead to a loss of purpose, alienation. Have attitudes to workplace security changed over the past 30 or so years/ (i.e. the former 'company men' with 35+ years service) 
  • How 'connectedness' and strong relationships are a huge part of coping in times of crisis

In other news, we discussed:
  • Gaming, gamers and teenagers in general - particularly in the current lockdown environment. Suggested reading: Dr Pete Etchells Lost in a Good Game, also The Winter of Our Disconnect by Susan Maushart.
  • The announcement that Qantas is unlikely to be flying internationally until July 2021
  • The witnessing of neighbourhood lemon theft. The brazenness of some people...
  • TV series: Little Fires Everywhere
  • What the word incandescent means.
  • NPR podcast: Codeswitch
  • Ageism and the value of older people. 
  • Covid and civil disobedience - what is the thinking of those who choose to break rules? 


Ratings
Range: 6 to 9
Average: 8.0

Next up:
The Wall by John Lanchester

Wednesday, 15 July 2020

July post: The Wife and the Widow by Christian White

The Wife and the Widow

by Christian White

Discussion led by KE





Some background links to get you started: 


What we discussed about the book:
  • Is this a 'thriller'? What is the definition of a thriller? Does it require the main character to face jeopardy in real time? 
  • Theme: how well do we know those we love? Which relationships is this theme explored through and how?
  • Theme: monsters under the bed. What were the monsters for each character? 
  • The setting - did it give us a real sense of place? Could we identify it and/or identify with it? Examples of internationalization of the setting - e.g traffic lights, the local store. How would we describe the local island community?
  • How could this book be turned into a TV series or movie? What would be the difficulties in adapting it to a visual medium? 
  • Did we see the twist coming? How did it impact us? 
  • What was the role of the moth imagery? 
  • What was going on in the Prologue? Different interpretations of it.
  • Was Abby's character credible? How did we feel about her at various points in the novel? 
  • What was 'spiritual distress'? How did it manifest? What was its cause?
  • Was John's career specialty a conscious choice? If so, for what reason/motivation? 
  • Did the last line of the novel meet JP's exacting standards? 
  • How was sexuality dealt with in the novel? 
  • Was justice served in the end? 
  • Were any of the characters evil? Or just caught in circumstances? 
  • Are there any good parents in this novel? 

We were sidetracked into discussing:
  • To what ends would you go to protect your children?
  • The characteristics of genre fiction vs literary fiction
  • Can crime fiction be literary?
  • Does the reader need to suspend disbelief at points in crime fiction in order for the plot to progress?  
  • The importance of reading generally - and how different books resonate at different times of your life, or states of mind
  • How do you 'rate' a book? By its performance within its genre, or by your own experience/enjoyment of it? 
  • Is there such a thing as a 'bookclub book'?  Is it chicken/egg? i.e. which comes first - 'this is written as a bookclub book' or 'this book will appeal to bookclubs, so we'll market it to them'?
  • What is a 'bookclub' - is there a stereotype? 

In other news:
  • We marveled at how we've maintained our regular bookclub meetings for over 21 years, even mastering Zoom to do so!
  • However, one downside of lockdown is how those of us working from home are feeling 'a bit Zoomed-out' at the end of each day.
  • We caught up on KM's new job news.
  • We discussed the impact of Covid-19 on hospital environments with our members who are medical workers.
  • We pondered why KFC features in several lockdown restriction fines? 
  • Masks? Pros and cons about wearing them, making them.
  • KE enlightened us about rbdigital (https://www.rbdigital.com/thelibrarynetworkmi/service/magazines/landing) and how it may be available through our library cards to borrow magazines online (including The New Yorker and Hello!)
  • We noted the brilliance of sports commentator, Andrew Cotter who commentates his dogs Olive and Mabel during iso (https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCjBbISPrZy7SWtiy8Ta8lnA)

Ratings:
Range - 5 to 8
Average - 7.0

Next month's Book: A man called Ove by Fredrick Backman

Monday, 15 June 2020

June book: The Beekeeper of Aleppo by Christy Lefteri

The Beekeeper of Aleppo

by Christy Lefteri

Discussion led by JM





Some background links to get you started: 


What we discussed about the book:
  • why did we think the author chose to tell the story from the point of view of a male character?
  • how this story takes a 'mass' issue and personalises it, creating greater empathy
  • what is this book about? (refugees, human spirit, hope, resilience)
  • when did we realise the truth about Mohammad? 
  • What was the true nature of Afra's blindness?
  • Who was the stronger character - Nuri or Afra? How did they differ? 
  • the 'key symbolism' - what did keys represent?
  • the use of the bee symbolism (particularly in relation to media language such as 'swarms')
  • what did the wingless bee represent?
  • what was the role of Mustafa?
  • the linking words between sections which acted as a device to time-shift. How was this done in the audio book? 
  • was there significance in the words themselves? (bronze Aleppo night Istanbul thw sea fire the waves sunrise the song morning hope a key away)
  • the importance of tea as a ritual, and the role of rituals as anchors in turbulent lives
  • what did we think about Nuri's role in the Nadim incident?
  • what did the above tell us about 'the line' that individuals will or will not cross? 
  • how old did Nuri's voice sound? 
And then we were sidetracked onto:
  • the value of bees to the environment (e.g. 1/3 of the world's pollination is done by bees) 
  • the value of literature and story telling in understanding big issues
  • discussing statistics - 'statistics are humans with the tears dried out'
  • child-trafficking in times of crisis
  • was there a queen bee in a box? 
  • who read, who listened? Is it the same thing? (i.e. did we experience the 'same' book? what are the differences?
  • the global refugee issue - what are the solutions? whose responsibility is it? what can individuals do? 
In other news:
  • while social distancing in JM's living room, we caught up on lots of stories from our isolation
  • whose hands are suffering from overuse of hand sanitiser?
  • we admired JM's outdoor firepit, as she set the scene for refugees sitting around a fire in a camp
  • JM outdid herself with a themed array of refreshments
  • we discussed the Jeffrey Epstein mini-series on Netflix

Ratings:
Range -  7 to 9.5
Average - 8.1

Next book: 
The Wife and the Widow by Christian White

Wednesday, 25 March 2020

March book: Too Much Lip by Melissa Lucashenko

Too Much Lip 
by Melissa Lucashenko

Discussion led by CH
(our first on-line meeting!) 





Some background links to get you started: 

Friday, 14 February 2020

February Book - A New Earth by Eckhart Tolle

A New Earth

by Eckhart Tolle
Discussion led by MK




Some background links to get you started:

What we discussed about the book:
  • Why MK chose it, and how life-changing it was for her
  • How different roads can lead to awakening
  • Why is/isn't this book life-changing for each individual - how do current circumstances impact on that?
  • The style of writing - dense, at times convoluted...how easy was it to read?
  • What are the signposts to ego behaviour in ourselves and others? e.g. having to be right, worrying about what others think
  • How much we liked the duck skirmish, the monk carrying the maiden, and the wrongly accused father-of-illegitimate-baby tales. How well did they illustrate Tolle's points?
  • Why needing an appropriate apology is ego-driven
  • Do collectives (e.g. schools, sporting clubs, workplaces, political parties etc) always create a negative collective mentality? Does this run counter to the belief that a sense of belonging is important to happiness?
  • How much the voices in our heads control our lives
  • Did we agree that babies come into the world carrying a pain-body?
  • How do you show empathy for a person carrying a large pain-body without feeding it?
  • How can you listen to others problems without becoming involved, offering opinions or trying to problem-solve? Is it more valuable to both parties to just listen impartially?
  • If yes to above, where is the space in the new earth for debate and argument? If ideas are not tested and challenged, how do they ever progress?
  • What did we think about the story of the pain-body following Tolle to the Indian restaurant?
  • Was there a lack of women and the feminine spirit in this book?
  • The value of the phrases 'Is that so?' and 'This will pass'
  • The concept of  'making friends with the day' - particularly in Melbourne's current changeable weather!
And we were sidetracked into:
  • The 'Oprah Bookclub Effect' - how does it affect sales of the chosen books, and other books?
  • The St Kevin's situation.  And how important it is to put the safety and well-being of students at the centre of any decision making in any educational environment.
Ratings
Range: 7 to 10
Average: 8.5