Showing posts with label KE's choices. Show all posts
Showing posts with label KE's choices. Show all posts

Tuesday, 31 March 2015

Minutes March book: A City Lost & Found: Whelan the Wrecker's Melbourne

A City Lost and Found: Whelan the Wrecker's Melbourne 

by Robyn Annear

(chosen by KE)

Theme: This is Melbourne




KE chose this book as it fulfilled the 'Melbourne' brief...but also because she thought it would be a good choice to dip in and out of, not having to necessarily read it from start to finish. Most Melbournians of our age remember the Whelan the Wrecker was here signs, so it feeds our nostalgia too. 

About the author:

Robyn Annear is an ex-typist who lives in country Victoria with somebody else's husband. She is the author of A City Lost and Found, Bearbrass, Nothing But Gold, The Man Who Lost Himself, and Fly a Rebel Flag. She has also written several pieces for The Monthly magazine.

(biographical detail from the the blurb on the book)

What the publisher says about the book:
The demolition firm of Whelan the Wrecker was a Melbourne institution for a hundred years (1892-1992). Its famous sign – 'Whelan the Wrecker is Here' on a pile of shifting rubble - was a laconic masterpiece and served as a vital sign of the city's progress. It's no stretch to say that over three generations, the Whelan family changed the face of Melbourne, demolishing hundreds of buildings in the central city alone.
In A City Lost and Found, Robyn Annear uses Whelan's demolition sites as portals to explore layers of the city laid bare by their pick-axes and iron balls. Peering beneath the rubble, she brings to light fantastic stories about Melbourne's building sites and their many incarnations. This is a book about the making – and remaking – of a city.
'Old landmarks fall in nearly every block . . . and the face of the city is changing so rapidly that the time is not too far distant when a search for a building 50 years old will be in vain.' Herald, 1925.

What we discussed about the book:
  • Who already knew about Whelan the Wrecker?
  • Was there enough focus on the Whelan family in the book to satisfy us as readers? Was the 'Whelan the Wrecker' focus a vehicle to tell a story about past Melbourne buildings?
  • Occupational health and safety considerations in the past - particularly with regards demolitions.
  • The structure of the book - was there a clear narrative?
  • What were the wider socio-political contexts of some of the demolitions/redevelopments? Was there sufficient about this in the book? 
  • How the 'Whelan the Wrecker was here' signage permeated popular culture...and the references were much wider. 
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • What is the 'lives with someone else's husband' comment in the author's biography about?
  • How did this compare with Bearbrass as far as telling a story of a past city go?
  • What makes a location 'significant'? 
  • Renovations on heritage homes - pros and cons for imitation heritage vs contemporary additions
  • How quickly do you forget previous buildings once they've been demolished and something else built? 
  • Is demolition and redevelopment a necessity? 
  • The tradition of six o'clock closing in the pubs. How that has influenced the development of Australia's drinking culture.  
In other news, we discussed:
  • Rowing - the pros, the cons, the commitment, the parental involvement..
  • Year 11 and 12 formals - all the lowdown on dresses etc 
Ratings:
Range: 6 to 7
Average: 6.5

Next book: Foe by J.M.Coetzee (chosen by Gypsy)

Monday, 23 March 2015

March book: A City Lost & Found: Whelan the Wrecker's Melbourne by Robyn Annear

A City Lost and Found: Whelan the Wrecker's Melbourne

by Robyn Annear

(Chosen by KE)


Some background links to get you started:




Thursday, 13 November 2014

November book: The Fictional Woman by Tara Moss

The Fictional Woman

by Tara Moss

(chosen by KE)

Theme: True life is stranger than fiction




Some background links to get you started:

What we discussed about the book:
- how does the photo of the author affect our percetons of the book? Did that change as we read it?
- what conditions out percpetions of appearance
- why do we notice women's clothing/hair/shoes etc but not men's?
- did we feel frustrated with the book?
- what are the dominant types of female characters in TV and film? Has that changed?
- does free speech need limits?
- does a woman do more housework the more paid work she does?
- what are the (good) effects of appearance on opportunity?
- have we read more female or male-authored books? Has anyone noticed?
- would we suggest this book for our daughters to read?
- what are the solutions/alternatives?


Ratings
Range:6.5 to 8
Average: 7.42

Monday, 30 September 2013

Minutes September book: An Unequal Music

An Unequal Music

by Vikram Seth

(chosen by KE)

Theme: 'Without music, life would be a mistake'


KE examined a few options before choosing this one, including Rose Tremain's Music and Silence, however at 484 pages, it exceeded the page limit! She also thought about some music biographies.

About the author:

Vikram Seth has written acclaimed books in several genres: verse novel, The Golden Gate; travel book, From Heaven Lake; animal fables, Beastly Tales; epic fiction, A Suitable Boy. His most recent novel, An Equal Music, was published in 1999. He lives in England and India.

(general biographical detail from the Harper Collins website)

What the publisher says about the book:
The author of the international bestseller A Suitable Boy returns with a powerful and deeply romantic tale of two gifted musicians. Michael Holme is a violinist, a member of the successful Maggiore Quartet. He has long been haunted, though, by memories of the pianist he loved and left ten years earlier, Julia McNicholl. Now Julia, married and the mother of a small child, unexpectedly reenters his life and the romance flares up once more. 
Against the magical backdrop of Venice and Vienna, the two lovers confront the truth about themselves and their love, about the music that both unites and divides them, and about a devastating secret that Julia must finally reveal. With poetic, evocative writing and a brilliant portrait of the international music scene, An Equal Music confirms Vikram Seth as one of the world's finest and most enticing writers.
What we discussed about the book:
  • The twin themes of lost love and passion for music.
  • St Jerome and the white dog (cat/ferret) - what was the significance of this in the story? How did it represent Julia and Michael's story?
  • What caused Michael to leave Julia in the first place?
  • Did we want a 'happy' ending? Regarding Julia? Regarding the violin? What did we care more about and why?
  • The links between Beethoven's loss of hearing and Julia's.
  • Do musical and non-musical people read this book differently?
  • Was there a musical structure to the novel?
  • How did we find the dialogue? How was it used as a expository device?
  • Were the quartet members fully developed characters?
  • How did the tension of the Mrs Formby violin story contribute overall to the novel? Was this relationship one of the most satisfactory and resolved?
  • Did Michael feel he was a fraud? How did his background contribute to this?
  • Would Julia ever leave James? Why did she invite Michael to meet James for lunch?
  • Was Julia right to hide her deafness?
  • What effect did the first person, present tense writing style have?
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • The concept of the irrevocable nature of time
  • Can you or do you, get second chances?
  • Is being a classical musical stalker a niche activity?
  • Are musicians 'highly strung' by nature?
In other news, we discussed:
  • Synesthesia - a neurological phenomenon in which stimulation of one sensory or cognitive pathway leads to automatic, involuntary experiences in a second sensory or cognitive pathway.
  • Gatecrashing of funerals...widely spread practice? 
  • MONA gallery at Hobart
Ratings:
Range: 5 to 7.5
Average: 6.71

Next book: Orange is the New Black by Piper Kerman (chosen by JM)

Sunday, 8 September 2013

September book: An Equal Music by Vikram Seth

An Equal Music 

by Vikram Seth

(chosen by KE)




Some background links to get you started:





Wednesday, 8 August 2012

Minutes July book: Runaway

Runaway 

by Alice Munro

(chosen by KE)





KE was struggling to make a book choice, so I offered some suggestions that had been passed on to me by my osteopath who is a voracious and discerning reader.  Runaway by Alice Munro was one of those titles. KE chose it on that recommendation, and also based on the fact the we had never done a collection of short stories before.

About the author:

Alice Munro won the Man Booker International Prize for 2009 for her lifetime body of work. She has written eleven collections of stories, and one novel, Lives of Girls and Women. She is much-awarded and was shortlisted for the Booker Prize for The Beggar Maid. Her stories have appeared in The New Yorker, Atlantic Monthly, The Paris Review, and other publications, and her collections have been translated into thirteen languages. She lives with her husband in Ontario, Canada.

(general biographical detail from the publisher's website)

What the publisher says about the book:

The bestselling collection by the greatest short story writer in the world. The matchless Munro makes art out of everyday lives in this dazzling new collection. At its centre are three stories connected into one marvellously rich narrative about Juliet - who escapes from teaching at a girls' school and throws herself into a wild and passionate love match. Here are men and women of wildly different times and circumstances, their lives made vividly palpable by the nuance and empathy of Munro's writing. Runaway is about the power and betrayals of love, about lost children, lost chances. There is pain and desolation beneath the surface, like a needle in the heart, which makes these stories more powerful and compelling than anything she has written.

What we discussed about the book:
  • Did we all realize it was a collection of short stories when we started reading? At what point did that become clear?
  • How did Munro create so much story in so few pages each time? What devices did she use to do that?
  • Likewise, characterisation...how did Munro create such depth and richness in the characters, with fewer words than a novel?
  • Was there a linking theme throughout all the stories? 
  • Did all the stories contain an element of lack of hope?
  • In what ways were these stories about women making choices and struggling to be free of conventional restraints?
  • Were the women in these stories generally dissatisfied with their lives and/or choices?
  • How did the idea of running away (i.e Runaway) feature in various stories?
  • What effect did huge gaps in chronology have in some of the stories? i.e allowing the story to move forward rapidly
  • The various styles of writing employed - e.g. 'Powers': written from several points of view, 'Tricks': reflecting Shakespearean tragedy, '
  • Did we agree or disagree with the idea that 'plot is secondary and little happens' in these stories?
  • Were all the female characters fatally flawed?
  • In what ways did these stories turn on the 'chance moments' in life?

And then we were sidetracked into:
  • Why does an author chose to write short stories rather than novels? 
  • How popular are short stories? Who reads them? Why or why not?
  • What is 'Southern Ontario Gothic'?
  • What was the link with Jonathan Franzen? (i.e. introduction in revised edition)

In other news we discussed:
  • Bali, Singapore, Hong Kong, Penang, Langkawi...
  • The appearance on Offspring of the Life's Little Treasures logo
  • Sleep and/or lack of it. 
  • Books people are talking about at the moment: 50 Shades of Grey, Game of Thrones, Bringing up the Dead, The Bolter. 

Ratings:
Range: 6 to 9
Average:  7.57

Next book: Religion for Atheists by Alain de Botton (chosen by Domestic Goddess)

July book - Runaway by Alice Munro

Runaway

by Alice Munro

(chosen by KE)






Some background links to get you started:




Wednesday, 15 June 2011

Minutes June book: Franklin and Eleanor: An Extraordinary Marriage

Franklin and Eleanor: An Extraordinary Marriage

by Hazel Rowley

(chosen by KE)





KE chose this book after reading several articles in The Age about the book itself, and then around a month later, the author's sudden untimely death.  KE says that "people books" are her thing, and therefore biography is an appealing genre for her.

About the author:

Hazel Rowley was brought up in England and Australia, and was living in New York City at the time of her sudden, unexpected death in March of this year.

Previous books include Tête-à-Tête: The Tumultuous Lives and Loves of Simone de Beauvoir and Jean-Paul Sartre, Richard Wright: The Life and Times and Christina Stead: A Biography. The latter was published in Australia in 1993, where it won the 1993 National Book Award for Nonfiction.

A passionate speaker, she appeared at numerous book festivals and literary events in the United States, Canada, the UK, France, and Australia. She was on a US nationwide book tour for Franklin and Eleanor at the time of her death, and had planned to tour Australia later in the year.

(general biographical details from the author's website)

What the publisher says about the book:

Franklin Delano and Eleanor Roosevelt’s marriage is one of the most celebrated and scrutinized partnerships in presidential history. It raised eyebrows in their lifetimes and has only become more controversial since their deaths. From FDR’s lifelong romance with Lucy Mercer to Eleanor’s purported lesbianism—and many scandals in between—the American public has never tired of speculating about the ties that bound these two headstrong individuals. Some claim that Eleanor sacrificed her personal happiness to accommodate FDR’s needs; others claim that the marriage was nothing more than a gracious facade for political convenience. No one has told the full story until now.

In this groundbreaking new account of the marriage, Hazel Rowley describes the remarkable courage and lack of convention—private and public—that kept FDR and Eleanor together. She reveals a partnership that was both supportive and daring. Franklin, especially, knew what he owed to Eleanor, who was not so much behind the scenes as heavily engaged in them. Their relationship was the product of FDR and Eleanor’s conscious efforts—a partnership that they created according to their own ambitions and needs.

In this dramatic and vivid narrative, set against the great upheavals of the Depression and World War II, Rowley paints a portrait of a tender lifelong companionship, born of mutual admiration and compassion. Most of all, she depicts an extraordinary evolution—from conventional Victorian marriage to the bold and radical partnership that has made Franklin and Eleanor Roosevelt go down in history as one of the most inspiring and fascinating couples of all time
What we discussed about the book:
  • The domestic life of FDR and Eleanor seemed to be based around a model of communal living with many family outsiders. Why? How did this work for them?
  • What were the differences in the way the media and the political process interacted then compared with now? Would it be possible now to keep a secret such as not being able to walk from the public? Why does/doesn't this fact matter?
  • Would FDR (or anyone else with severe physical disability) be voted President of the US today?
  • What was the nature of Eleanor's relationships with Louis Howe and Earl Miller?  What influence did they have on her?
  • What was the nature of FDR's relationships with various women? What evidence does Rowley show as to the nature of the relationships?
  • In what way was his relationship with Lucy different? Why was Eleanor upset that she had been there when he died?
  • How did FDR's mother manipulate the marriage and the course of the family's lives? Was it purely a financial power over them, or was there more to it?
  • Why was FDR able to achieve so much in his first 100 days of office? How has that "100 days" mythology now permeated all politicians plans of action when first elected?
  • What kind of mother was Eleanor? What evidence did Rowley illuminate on this question?
  • Did Eleanor always seek reassurance in her interactions with others? Was she a people-pleaser? Did we think she was charismatic?
  • How did this book add flesh to the story of Churchill, Stalin and Roosevelt's interactions? Did we feel we understood the machinations of the Second World War better reading it from a personal perspective?
  • Was the continued employment of Henrietta Nesbit and her horrendously bad cooking a passive-aggressive ploy on the part of Eleanor? Did FDR have to put up with it in order not to upset the balance of power in their relationship?
  • Was Eleanor a feminist role-model?
  • Was there too much, too little or just right amount of politics in this book?
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • From the background reading we had done, what were the themes that united the biographies that Rowley wrote? (courage, risk taking, interest in outsiders, relationships that enlarged people’s lives, politically left leaning)
  • What parallels did we see between Eleanor's story and that of Hilary Clinton?
  • How complex the Roosevelt family tree was - did any of us understand exactly how FDR and Eleanor were related?
  • Why girls will often adore dysfunctional fathers regardless of their behaviour.
  • The 'harem' model of domestic arrangement - multiple women co-habiting - can this work? Why/how does it work?
In other news, we discussed:
  • How Domestic Goddess listened to this book on her iPhone. She feel asleep at one stage and woke up with Missy in a wheelchair.
  • KE's youthful Cadillac drive from Detroit to Boston, with a washing line strung across the back seat drying off their smalls.
  • Agnostics vs atheists: what is the difference?
  • Fairlie's badly-behaved Bengals one of whom took a shine to Gypsy's furry coat and plonked himself on her lap, while the other stood commandingly at a window asking to be let in. Effing cats.
  • We congratulated the new Doctor in the house.

Ratings:
Range: 7.5 to 9
Average: 8.35

Next book: Freedom by Jonathon Franzen (chosen by Dr LC)

Sunday, 12 June 2011

June book: Franklin and Eleanor. An Extraordinary Marriage by Hazel Rowley

Franklin and Eleanor. An Extraordinary Marriage

by Hazel Rowley

(chosen by KE)








Some background links to get you started:

Sunday, 12 September 2010

Minutes September Book: The 19th Wife by David Eberschoff

The 19th Wife

by David Ebershoff

(chosen by KE)







Editors note: I did not attend this bookclub meeting, so have constructed the minutes based on notes kindly made by Gypsy. Thank you, Gypsy.

 
The book was chosen on recommendation by another nurse working with KE and the group made comment that KE has a great propensity to (unconsciously) select books by young gay authors.

About the author:

David Ebershoff is the author of four books of fiction, including The Danish Girl, The Rose City, and Pasadena. His most recent novel is the international bestseller, The 19th Wife. He has won a number of awards, including the Rosenthal Foundation Award from the American Academy of Arts and Letters, the Lambda Literary Award, the Ferro-Grumley Award for excellence in gay and lesbian literature. His books have been translated into eighteen languages to critical acclaim. Two of his novels are being adapted for film and television. Ebershoff has taught creative writing at New York University and Princeton and currently teaches in the graduate writing program at Columbia University. He is an editor-at-large at Random House and lives in New York City.

(general biographical detail from the author's website)


What the publisher says about the book:

Jordan returns from California to Utah to visit his mother in jail. As a teenager he was expelled from his family and religious community, a secretive Mormon offshoot sect. Now his father has been found shot dead in front of his computer, and one of his many wives - Jordan's mother - is accused of the crime.


Over a century earlier, Ann Eliza Young, the nineteenth wife of Brigham Young, Prophet and Leader of the Mormon Church, tells the sensational story of how her own parents were drawn into plural marriage, and how she herself battled for her freedom and escaped her powerful husband, to lead a crusade to end polygamy in the United States.

Bold, shocking and gripping, The 19th Wife expertly weaves together these two narratives: a pageturning literary mystery and an enthralling epic of love and faith.

What we discussed about the book:
  • Is it ambitious to structure a novel telling two parallel polygamous stories: one set in the nineteenth century and the other contemporary? How successful is this structure?
  • In what ways were creative and interesting techniques used to reproduce old newspaper articles and writings?
  • How many wives did Brigham Young have in reality? (the total number is unknown but possibly upwards of 65)
  • Did women exercise their permission to veto the choice of a new wife? Did they, in practice, really have that option? 
  • Why did new followers come from Europe? What role did propoganda play in convincing newcomers that they were the chosen ones?
  • Did we engage equally with the 19th century story and the contemporary one? Were we less convinced of the credibility of the contemporary parallel? Why?
  • In what ways was the 19th century story enlightening and informative?
  • Was it 'convenient' that God had spoken to Brigham Young (as opposed to the women) and mentioned that he (God) thought it was a fine idea that men could and should take many wives?
  • Why would the women accept plural marriages? Is the promise of heaven and eternal salvation sufficient enticement?
  • What can an inspiration speaker encourage people to do?

And then we were sidetracked into:
  • The role of religion in today's society.
  • Is the gender imbalance created by plural marriages the reason young male Mormons were  required to go forth and spread the word to others?
  • Interesting facts about the Mormons: there are 13 million Jesus Christ of the Latter Day Saints worldwide, but only 14% live in Utah where the book is essentially set.
  • Are the Latter Day Saints nowadays interested in progressive thoughts and inclusion of minorities?
     
Ratings:
Range:  6 to 8.5



Next book: At Home: A Short History of Private Life by Bill Bryson (chosen by Fairlie)

Wednesday, 8 September 2010

September book: The 19th Wife by David Ebershoff

The 19th Wife

by David Ebershoff

(chosen by KE)







Some background links to get you started:

Saturday, 15 August 2009

Minutes July Book: The Book of Emmett by Deborah Forster


The Book of Emmett
by Deborah Forster
(Chosen by KE)
KE chose this book after seeing an article about it in The Age which highlighted "the inventiveness of the telling". She was particularly interested to see whether the book would examine the possibility of changing behaviours between generations, thus breaking ongoing inherited cycles of dysfunction.
Deborah Foster grew up in Footscray, Melbourne. She worked as a staff and freelance journalist for many years and was a This Life columnist on The Age and The Sunday Age. Deborah Foster is married to Alan Kohler and they have three children. The Book of Emmett is her first novel.
(general biographical detail from the publisher's website.)
What the publisher says about the book:
Emmett Brown is as dark as Heathcliff, and as unpredictable. Sometimes he's an inspiration, but not often. He's a man of booze and obsessions: one of them is his 'System', an attempt to bend the laws of probability. But when the lottery numbers and horses fail him, so do love and reason, and he becomes an ogre to his wife and children.

For the innocents - Louisa, Rob, Peter, Daniel and Jessie - the bonds formed hiding in hedges at the end of the street, waiting for the maelstroms to pass, are complex and unbreakable. Over the years, the consequences of Emmett's rages shape both their spirits and psyches, but as he lies dying they discover that love - however imperfect - is the best defence against pain. The Book of Emmett is a novel about hope and love and surviving.
What we discussed about the book:
  • Who was the real Emmett? How did he appear in the eyes of the children?
  • Did the occasional softness he showed (the encyclopedias, taking them to the ballet) make it difficult for the children to hate him?
  • To what extent did we feel this was a memoir as opposed to totally fiction? Did we think Louisa was representative of the author?
  • If an author denies that a novel is autobiographical, are we able to accept that is is totally fiction? Does it matter?
  • To what extent was this a novel "entirely about forgiveness and hope" (Quote from Deborah Forster)
  • How affected were we by the graphic nature of some of the scenes?
  • In what ways did the texture and beauty of the language Forster employed heighten our experience of the story?
  • What did we think about Ann (the mother). What were her options in that time and culture? Why don't we know more about her back story?
  • In what ways did Ann protect her children, or minimise the impact on them?
  • How did their upbringing impact differently on each of the children?
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • Is it possible to break cycles between generations? or is it inevitable that history repeats?
  • How resilient children are to rise above their domestic situations. Why do some children carry issues into adulthood and others don't?
  • Deborah Forster was 53 when this novel was published. She was inspired by Olga Masters whose first piece of fiction was published at 63, and Elizabeth Jolley who published her first novel at 53. Is there hope in this for all of us?!
  • How important it is to have at least one significant adult in your childhood to steer you on the right path (teachers, friends, grandparents, godparents)
  • The importance of mentors in achieving better outcomes...not just in times of adversity.
  • Will children always love their parents no matter how badly they behave?
  • Is it easier to resolve issues by remaining in an abusive environment than it is by leaving?
And in other news we discussed:
  • Breath tests for fructose intolerance, epiglottis malfunctions, reflux and vomiting....
  • Could we last 21 days without complaining?
  • Who would ask their partners to return two excess brackets to the hardware store for a refund of $4 and who wouldn't.
  • The differences in ethnic and cultural attitudes to looking after the older generation.
  • Skype. As one No.1 Lady stated, "It's better with a camera, but you need to get dressed."
  • Approaches to pocket money for children. Should they work for it? Is it a reward or a right? Can they spend it however they like?
  • The current focus in the media on violence in the city at night. Have youth become desensitised to violence through exposure to TV, films and computer games?
Ratings:
Ratings range: 7 to 9 (lowest score was a DNF)
Ratings average: 8.25
Next book: The Gargoyle by Andrew Davidson (chosen by KM)

Friday, 6 June 2008

Minutes May 2008 Book: Notes from an Exhibition by Patrick Gale



Notes from an Exhibition


by Patrick Gale


(chosen by KE)





KE chose this book because with her nursing background, she was fascinated by the idea of a book about the effect of bipolar disorder on a family.


Patrick Gale was born in 1962 on the Isle of Wight, where his father was a prison governor. He was the youngest of four children. The family moved to London, where his father ran Wandsworth Prison, then to Winchester.

Patrick began boarding as a Winchester College Quirister at the cathedral choir school, Pilgrim’s, then went on to Winchester College. He has an English degree from New College, Oxford.

He says he "has never had a grown-up job". His first two novels, The Aerodynamics of Pork and Ease were published in 1986. The following year he moved to Camelford near the north coast of Cornwall and now lives in the far west, on a farm near Land’s End.


(general biographical details from here)


What the publisher says about the book:

When troubled artist Rachel Kelly dies painting obsessively in her attic studio in Penzance, her saintly husband and adult children have more than the usual mess to clear up. She leaves behind an extraordinary and acclaimed body of work – but she also leaves a legacy of secrets and emotional damage it will take months to unravel.

A wondrous, monstrous creature, she exerts a power that outlives her. To her children she is both curse and blessing, though they all in one way or another reap her whirlwind, inheriting her waywardness, her power of loving – and her demons… Only their father's Quaker gifts of stillness and resilience give them any chance of withstanding her destructive influence and the suspicion that they came a poor second to the creation of her art.

The reader becomes a detective, piecing together the clues of a life – as artist, lover, mother, wife and patient – which takes them from contemporary Penzance to 1960s Toronto to St Ives in the 1970s. What emerges is a story of enduring love, and of a family which weathers tragedy, mental illness and the intolerable strain of living with genius.

Patrick Gale's latest novel shines with intelligence, humour and tenderness.


What we discussed about the book:

  • Does Gale write 'like a woman'? Is that even a valid question to ask? How does a woman write? Is there such a thing as a 'woman's voice' in writing?
  • What was Antony's role in the family dynamic?
  • What we thought about the 'notes from an exhibition' which opened each chapter. What did they add to our understanding of the story? What was their purpose? Did they offer us clues to unravel the story?
  • Is mental illness a symptom of genius or a cause?
  • How did Rachel manage her obsession for art and her relationships family? Is it possible to have a passion for something and maintain a family life?
  • What was the significance of Petroc's death both to Rachel and to the rest of the family after her death?
  • Did Rachel try to control or to mentor Morwenna's artistic talent?
  • Was Rachel actually pregnant at the institution? Or was that a figment of her imagination?
  • The role of the Quaker religion in the book. Did its quiet and reflective nature act as a counter-point to the manic and hysterical nature of Rachel's life?
  • What frightened Rachel so much?

Then we were sidetracked into:
  • The nature of bipolar disorder. Does it seem more prevalent nowadays? Or is it just that more people speak openly about it?
  • Were we attracted by the idea of the Quaker religion by its portrayal in this book?
  • Can a male author write female characters convincingly, and vice versa?
  • Do creative people see things a little differently to others? Is this a symptom of a mental illness, or just a different perspective?
  • Is it acceptable for people with bipolar disorder to choose not to take their meds in order to maintain a creative edge?
  • Are children more resilient than we give them credit for?

And in other news, we discussed:

  • The health risks of a shared communion cup at church. And which churches use incense?
  • What influence do books have on your life? Are there any books that you have read and have changed your life? Are they fiction or non-fiction?


Ratings:


Initial rating range: 6.0 to 8.5
Initial rating average: 7.1
Post-discussion range: 6.0 to 8.5
Post-discussion average: 6.9


Next book: The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas by John Boyne

Thursday, 15 May 2008

May book: Notes from an Exhibition by Patrick Gale


Notes from an Exhibition by Patrick Gale (chosen by KE)

Meeting date: Tuesday 20th May
Venue: Domestic Goddess's house









Some links for background information to get you started: