Friday, 25 November 2011
Books read in 2011
The ratings recorded below reflect an average of the members' ratings (out of ten) of their personal experience of the reading of that book.
Lovesong by Alex Miller (8.0)
Dogboy by Eva Hornung (7.67)
The Portrait of a Lady by Henry James (9.0*)
The Secret Scripture by Sebastian Barry (7.9)
Franklin and Eleanor: An Extraordinary Marriage by Hazel Rowley (8.35)
Freedom by Jonathan Franzen (5.28)
Rocks in the Belly by Jon Bauer (7.06)
The Group by Mary McCarthy (7.25)
Let the Great World Spin by Colum McCann (8.67)
Bereft by Chris Wolmersley (8.0)
* Only two No.1 Melbourne Ladies finished the book, so rating based on two scores.
Minutes November book: Bereft
Bereft
by Chris Wolmersley
(chosen by JP)
JP initially chose Cloud Atlas by David Mitchell, but decided to read it first before confirming her choice. It is a series of independent short stories which are all interlinked, but JP found it very difficult to read, and fearing the other No.1 Melbourne Ladies would find the same she decided not to risk a low rating! In her last minute, frantic scramble to find an alternative, Bereft became her 'it'll do' book.
About the author:
Chris Womersley’s fiction and reviews have appeared in Granta, The Best Australian Stories 2006, 2010 and 2011, Griffith REVIEW, Meanjin and The Age. His debut novel, The Low Road, won the Ned Kelly Award for Best First Fiction. His second novel, Bereft, won the Australian Book Industry Award for Literary Fiction and the Indie Award for Fiction, and was shortlisted for the Miles Franklin Literary Award, The Age fiction prize and the Australian Literature Society Gold Medal.
(general biographical detail from publisher's website)
What the publisher says about the book:
What we discussed about the book:
And then we were sidetracked into:
In other news, we discussed:
Ratings:
Range: 7 to 9
Average: 8
Next book: Room by Emma Donoghue (chosen by CH)
by Chris Wolmersley
(chosen by JP)
JP initially chose Cloud Atlas by David Mitchell, but decided to read it first before confirming her choice. It is a series of independent short stories which are all interlinked, but JP found it very difficult to read, and fearing the other No.1 Melbourne Ladies would find the same she decided not to risk a low rating! In her last minute, frantic scramble to find an alternative, Bereft became her 'it'll do' book.
About the author:
Chris Womersley’s fiction and reviews have appeared in Granta, The Best Australian Stories 2006, 2010 and 2011, Griffith REVIEW, Meanjin and The Age. His debut novel, The Low Road, won the Ned Kelly Award for Best First Fiction. His second novel, Bereft, won the Australian Book Industry Award for Literary Fiction and the Indie Award for Fiction, and was shortlisted for the Miles Franklin Literary Award, The Age fiction prize and the Australian Literature Society Gold Medal.
(general biographical detail from publisher's website)
What the publisher says about the book:
It is 1919. The Great War has ended, but the Spanish flu epidemic is raging across Australia. Schools are closed, state borders are guarded by armed men, and train travel is severely restricted. There are rumours it is the end of the world.
In the NSW town of Flint, Quinn Walker returns to the home he fled ten years earlier when he was accused of an unspeakable crime. Aware that his father and uncle would surely hang him, Quinn hides in the hills surrounding Flint. There, he meets the orphan Sadie Fox — a mysterious young girl who seems to know more about the crime than she should.
A searing gothic novel of love, longing and justice, Bereft is about the suffering endured by those who go to war and those who are forever left behind.
What we discussed about the book:
- How would we describe this novel if asked to pinpoint its genre? Ghost story? Crime fiction? Literary fiction? Magic realism? Do such labels matter? Do they affect how likely we are to pick up a book in the first place?
- Did we think Sadie was real? What influenced our thoughts about this?
- Sadie was originally written as a boy - how would this have changed the story?
- What were our feelings towards the mother? Did we want her to find out the truth before she died?
- Could Quinn have done more at the time of Sadie's death? What motivated the actions he took?
- Did we have any doubts about Quinn's character throughout the story? Did we believe his version of events?
- How reliable is the third-person narrator?
- How multi-dimensional was Robert Dalton? Did we find aspects of him almost a caricature?
- What was the purpose of the sacrifical lamb scene?
- How the author used language to paint quite graphic images (e.g. the representation of war, rape scenes, the lamb scene)
- What was the point of the mystic imagery built up throughout the novel in relation to Sadie? Was it used to the best effect? Were we expecting it to go further and push into the realms of magic realism?
- Were the horrors at home shown to be worse than the horrors of war?
- How did we think Dalton had power over Gracie?
- How did the visits Quinn made to his mother create almost a Scherazade-style telling of the story?
- The impact of the idea that there isn no word to describe the mother who has lost a child. Is 'bereft' that word?
- What was the purpose of the seance? Was it a way to connect the living and the dead in a 'plausible' way?
- Was it credible that Dalton found Sadie in the dark and without a tracker - the two things that Sadie said he wouldn't be able to do?
- Did Part Four (The Angel of Death) work for us?
- Was it a satisfying or unsatisfying ending? What did we think had happened?
- Our favourite passage from the book:
His mother sighed. 'It is a strange bargain one makes with the gods - that in return for the purest love imaginable one must endure the constant fear that something dreadful will happen to your child, and that it will be your fault for bringing them into the world. The number of times I thought of you. Mothers never believe their children are dead. I have seen it in others, the ones with sons killed in the war. God, it's awful. Months after they have received those telegrams they still stand at their kitchen windows and watch the gate for a sign of them. I wake in the night. One's child,' she went on in a trembling voice, 'is always one's child, no matter what age they might be. You worry when your child makes a noise, when he doesn't. It's a terrible kind of love. Terrible.'
And then we were sidetracked into:
- The concept of love a mother has for a child - the responsibility that comes with that
- The impact of the Spanish flu on Australia/the world in the post -World War 1 period.
- Imported food - the testing requirements...are they stringent enough? Is Australian food subjected to equally stringent testing?
- How delicious Gypsy's desserts were - especially given her oven was broken, and she'd had to impose on her neighbours to actually cook them!
Range: 7 to 9
Average: 8
Next book: Room by Emma Donoghue (chosen by CH)
November book: Bereft by Chris Wolmersley
Bereft
by Chris Wolmersley
(chosen by JP)
Some background links to get you started:
by Chris Wolmersley
(chosen by JP)
Some background links to get you started:
- The author's website
- Review by Peter Pierce in The Age
- Radio National The Book Show - audio and transcript
- Angela Meyer's review at crikey.com.au
Minutes October book: Let the Great World Spin
Let the Great World Spin
by Colum McCann
(chosen by JM)
JM chose this book after having four book choices in mind, but no idea which one to choose. During a girls' weekend she received a strong recommendation to select Let the Great World Spin and she went with that.
About the author:
Colum McCann was born in Dublin in 1965 and began his career as a journalist in The Irish Press. In the early 1980's he took a bicycle across North America and then worked as a wilderness guide in a program for juvenile delinquents in Texas. After a year and a half in Japan, he and his wife moved to New York where they currently live with their three children.
He has won numerous international literary awards and his fiction has been published in over thirty languages.
(general autobiographical details from the author's website)
What the publisher says about the book:
What we discussed about the book:
And then we were sidetracked into:
In other news, we discussed:
Ratings:
Range: 8 to 9
Average: 8.67
Next book: Bereft by Chris Womersley (chosen by JP)
by Colum McCann
(chosen by JM)
JM chose this book after having four book choices in mind, but no idea which one to choose. During a girls' weekend she received a strong recommendation to select Let the Great World Spin and she went with that.
About the author:
Colum McCann was born in Dublin in 1965 and began his career as a journalist in The Irish Press. In the early 1980's he took a bicycle across North America and then worked as a wilderness guide in a program for juvenile delinquents in Texas. After a year and a half in Japan, he and his wife moved to New York where they currently live with their three children.
He has won numerous international literary awards and his fiction has been published in over thirty languages.
(general autobiographical details from the author's website)
What the publisher says about the book:
New York, August 1974: a man is walking in the sky. Between the newly built Twin Towers, the man twirls through the air. Far below, the lives of complete strangers spin towards each other: Corrigan, a radical Irish monk working in the Bronx; Claire, a delicate Upper East Side housewife reeling from the death of her son; Lara, a drug-addled young artist; Gloria, solid and proud despite decades of hardship; Tillie, a hooker who used to dream of a better life; and Jazzlyn, her beautiful daughter raised on promises that reach beyond the skyline of New York. In the shadow of one reckless and beautiful act, these disparate lives will collide, and be transformed for ever.
What we discussed about the book:
- What does this book say about America 'burning from the inside out"? (see Colum McCann interview).
- In what ways is this "a 9/11 book"? Is it a book of hope?
- How did the 1970s parallel the late 20th C, early 21st C? (e.g. Vietnam vs Afghanistan/Iraq)
- Could this book have been set anywhere but New York? How is the city itself a character?
- Could we follow all the interlinking characters? (e.g. Who were the people who spoke on the public telephones? Was Tag the boy who answered the phone?)
- Was Tag's photograph intended as a foreshadowing of the 9/11 attack?
- Could we see the links between stories coming, or did they surprise us?
- In what ways were Corrigan and Jazzlyn the Twin Towers? What did the wire between them represent?
- Were we obsessed throughout the book about how the wire-walker would get the wire across between the two buildings?
- Did we find the book slow-paced or about right?
- Examples of the vivid language used - the genius of the author in painting visual pictures with words.
- Were we surprised by who Ciaran married?
- Who were our favourite characters? Why? In what ways did we empathise with Claire and Gloria particularly?
- If this is a book of hope - have the years since 2006 lived up to that expectation?
- Was the font in this book too small to read comfortably? Does our concern about this indicate we are getting old?
- The idea that people can brush each other's lives, barely connecting and yet the impact can send ripples
In other news, we discussed:
- The difficulty of trying to watch the AFL Grand Final live while on holiday in Italy
- Steve Jobs untimely passing.
- We declared that 2012 is to be "little book year" - all book choices are to be 300 pages or less. This is a challenge, not a restriction!
Ratings:
Range: 8 to 9
Average: 8.67
Next book: Bereft by Chris Womersley (chosen by JP)
October book: Let the Great World Spin by Colum McCann
Let the Great World Spin
by Colum McCann
Some background links to get you started:
by Colum McCann
Some background links to get you started:
- The author's website
- Tim Adams' review in The Observer
- Jonathan Mahler's review in The New York Times
- The book trailer on YouTube
Wednesday, 23 November 2011
Minutes September book: The Group
The Group
by Mary McCarthy
(Chosen by KM)
KM chose this book on the recommendation of her GP who has also recommended several of KM's other book choices (The Gargoyle, The Guernsey Potato Peel Pie Literary Society, Water for Elephants).
About the author:
Mary Therese McCarthy was born in 1912 in Seattle, Washington. Her parents became victims of the influenza epidemic of 1918 and the siblings were taken in by their great-aunt and her new husband, and subjected to a horrible life depicted in McCarthy's work, Memories of a Catholic Girlhood (1957). After six years, Mary was taken back to Seattle to live with her maternal grandparents, and her brothers were sent to boarding school. Mary moved to her grandparents' upper-class home and enjoyed a life of luxury. Her grandparents wanted Mary to have an excellent education and enrolled her good schools. From there she went on to Vassar College in Poughkeepsie, New York, and graduated, Phi Beta Kappa, with her bachelor's degree in 1933.
Following commencement McCarthy moved to New York City and married Harold Johnsrud, an aspiring playwright, the first of her four husbands.
Mary McCarthy was the author of twenty-eight books during her lifetime, both fiction and non-fiction. Her novels were partially autobiographical, and many times her characters were based on her acquaintances.
She died of cancer in 1989, aged 77.
(general biographical detail from here)
What the publisher says about the book:
The Group follows eight graduates from exclusive Vassar College as they find love and heartbreak, forge careers, gossip and party in 1930s Manhattan.
The Group can be seen as the original Sex and the City. It is the first novel to frankly portray women's real lives, exploring subjects such as sex, contraception, motherhood and marriage.
What we discussed about the book:
- We started the discussion by each confessing to how much of the book we had actually read - JM was the winner at three-quarters of the way through!
- Why did we find this a difficult book to get through?
- How does this novel contribute to our understanding of the status and roles of women in the 1930s in America?
- Was it difficult to keep track of the eight "group" members through the book? Was there continuity of their stories?
- The nature of women's friendship - how did these women support each other?
- What was the significance of starting with a wedding and ending with a funeral?
- In what ways do 'occasions' bring the Group together?
- How is this novel like Sex and the City?
- In what ways did the friendships between the women in the two books (or the SITC TV show) differ? How were they similar?
- How would this novel have been received when it was first published in 1963? Were any of the topics considered taboo at the time?
- We discussed shoe-sizing in Asia. Is it possible to get size 9 or 10 shoes there?
- We admired the photos from T-Rex's sojourn in Paris.
Range: 7-7.5
Average: 7.25
Next book: Let the Great World Spin by Colum McCann (chosen by JM)



