Showing posts with label Fairlie's choices. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fairlie's choices. Show all posts

Saturday, 28 February 2015

Minutes February book: The Bolter

The Bolter

by Frances Osborne

(chosen by Fairlie)

Theme: Women behaving badly




I chose this book, as I have previously read it and really enjoyed it. With a family connection to that era in Kenyan history, I am fascinated by all the writings about members of the Happy Valley set.

About the author:

Frances Osborne is the author of three books. Her first biography, Lilla's Feast (2004), was about her great-grandmother who wrote a cookery book in a Japanese internment camp in China during the Second World War. The Bolter (2008) is her second biography and was a Sunday Times No. 1 bestseller  Her first novel, Park Lane, is set in a London Mansion in 1914 and will be published this year.

(general biographical detail from the author's own website)

What the publisher says about the book:
'This is a truly astonishing book. Frances Osborne has not just brought to life a dizzyingly rich and scandalous slice of social history, she has produced a tragic and deeply moving tale as well. It is far more gripping than any novel I have read for years' Antony Beevor 
On Friday 25th May, 1934, a forty-one-year-old woman walked into the lobby of Claridge's Hotel to meet the nineteen-year-old son whose face she did not know. Fifteen years earlier, as the First World War ended, Idina Sackville shocked high society by leaving his multimillionaire father to run off to Africa with a near penniless man. 
An inspiration for Nancy Mitford's character The Bolter, painted by William Orpen, and photographed by Cecil Beaton, Sackville went on to divorce a total of five times, yet died with a picture of her first love by her bed. Her struggle to reinvent her life with each new marriage left one husband murdered and branded her the 'high priestess' of White Mischief's bed-hopping Happy Valley in Kenya. 
Sackville's life was so scandalous that it was kept a secret from her great-granddaughter Frances Osborne. Now, Osborne tells the moving tale of betrayal and heartbreak behind Sackville's road to scandal and return, painting a dazzling portrait of high society in the early twentieth century.
What we discussed about the book:
  • Was Idina a bolter or a boltee? What role did her husband's behaviour play in her decision to leave?
  • Is there sufficient evidence that Sakville is Mitford's Bolter?
  • Was the Edwardian 'system' of fidelity in a marriage more workable that current concepts of monogamous marriages?
  • To what extent was the behaviour exhibited class driven?
  • What was Alice's role in the Jos Hay murder?
  • Why is Idina's story interesting to us?
  • What is the author's attitude toward her great-grandmother?
  • Did Idina have her own moral code? e.g. not stealing a husband?
  • What were Idina's most redeeming features?
  • What were the most shocking aspects of her behaviour?
  • How did Alice get away with (attempted) murder in Paris?
  • What would Idina have been like as an old woman? 
  • What was the influence of Idina's own mother's behaviour on her?
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • What is the definition of 'women behaving badly'? Does it change depending on a woman's age? 
  • What is a 'man behaving badly'? What behaviour is unforgivable in a man?
  • The tradition of sending small children to boarding school in England.
  • Sheila Milbank - Australian 'it' girl, and her role in bringing Idina and David together 
  • How would today's psychology label Idina? How would today's media represent her?
  • Is a 'bolter' a more derogatory term than a 'bounder'? What is the appropriate male label for a bolter?
In other news, we discussed:
  • Old telephone exchanges - how operators used to connect the calls
  • The Hep A from frozen berries debacle
  • Various forms of Asian gastros
  • The class system in Cambodia
Ratings:
Range: 7 to 8.5
Average: 7.69

Next book:  A City Lost and Found: Whelan the Wrecker's Melbourne by Robyn Annear

Tuesday, 10 February 2015

February book: The Bolter by Frances Osborne

The Bolter

by Frances Osborne

(chosen by Fairlie)

Theme: Women behaving badly







Some background links to get you started:

Tuesday, 30 September 2014

Minutes September book: The Ancestor Game

The Ancestor Game

by Alex Miller

(chosen by Fairlie)

Theme: Miles Franklin Award winner




In choosing this book, I looked at the full list of Miles Franklin Award winners. Many of my first choices were too long to fit our page length limit. As we had read and mostly all enjoyed Alex Miller's Lovesong, I thought I would choose another title by the same author.

About the author:

Alex Miller has won the Miles Franklin Literary Award twice, first in 1993 for The Ancestor Game and again in 2003 for Journey to the Stone Country. He is also an overall winner of the Commonwealth Writers' Prize, in 1993 for The Ancestor Game. In 2008 he was awarded the Manning Clark Medal for an outstanding contribution to Australian cultural life. His books are published internationally and widely in translation. In 2012 he was awarded the prestigious Melbourne Prize for Literature and he is a Fellow of the Australian Academy of the Humanities.

(general biographical detail from the publisher's website 

What the publisher says about the book:
Steven Muir, August Spiess and his daughter Gertrude, and Lang Tzu all acknowledge a restless sense of cultural displacement, an ambivalence in their relations with the culture of European Australia. Steven left England for Australia as a young man and his one attempt at returning is unsuccessful. August Spiess, although he speaks frequently of returning to his native Hamburg, fails to make the journey, as does his daughter Gertrude. Lang Tzu's very name defines his fate: 'two characters which in Mandarin signify the son who goes away.'
The 'game', however, does have winners. For despite their yearnings for the home of their ancestral dreams, a desire to belong somewhere that is truly their own, none of Miller's characters leaves Australia, and each in their own way comes to see that to be at home in exile may be a defining paradox of the European Australian condition: the paradox of belonging and estrangement that perhaps lies uneasily at the heart of all European cultures. 
The Ancestor Game, which Robert Dessaix described as 'one of the most engrossing books I've read in a long time', is an enthralling journey into the ancestral dreams and present dilemmas of a rich cast of characters.
What we discussed about the book:
  • The role of myth and storytelling in memory.
  • The relationships between history, fiction and truth.  What constitutes each? 
  • How do others' expectations inform our own memory of identity - e.g. Dorsett?
  • Does the history of intimate and small moments inform our reading of a novel far more than the the history of politics or economics?
  • What were the links between the various characters? How did  know Steven know Lang?
  • How we kept track (or didn't) of the family tree aspect of the Fengs (for instance...who was Feng 3?)
  • Was it immediately obvious that this was a novel, rather than a series of short stories? How did we make those links?
  • Who was Gertrude's mother?
  • Were we able to easily traverse the jumps in chronology?
  • What was the point of the fire on the deck of the boat?
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • Why did so many people who had written on-line reviews (e.g. on Goodreads) give up on this book?
  • Is there some kind of cosmic message that so many of the books we've read this year feature the concept of Janus (looking forwards and looking backwards)?
In other news, we discussed:
  • Concerns about non-stick frying pans and their health implications
  • On-line dating criteria...how specific should you be in your description of what you're looking for?
  • Leadership selection processes at schools...is there a perfect system?
Ratings:
Range: 6 to 8
Average: 6.75

Next book: The Dinner by Herman Koch (chosen by T-Rex)

Friday, 12 September 2014

September book: The Ancestor Game by Alex Miller

The Ancestor Game 

by Alex Miller 

(chosen by Fairlie)

Theme: Miles Franklin Award winner




Some background links to get you started:


Friday, 9 August 2013

Minutes August book: The Transit of Venus

The Transit of Venus

by Shirley Hazzard

(chosen by Fairlie)

Theme: Antipodeans abroad


I originally interpreted this theme as meaning I should chose a work by an 'Australian' writer who lives (or lived) overseas, which led me to the likes of Peter Carey, Kathy Lette, Germaine Greer, Nikki Gemmell, Geraldine Brooks. While I was pondering a choice of these authors' works, I came across a reference on the Meanjin blog to Shirley Hazzard as being one of Australia's most neglected women authors, possibly as a result of her living overseas for so long.  I initially thought I would choose her more recent work, The Great Fire, but opinion from others swayed me to The Transit of Venus. It was only after I had chosen it and ordered a copy that I found a pristine copy of the book on my own bookshelf. It had been on one of my university literature subject reading lists and I can only assume my 18 year old self saw the reading of it as an optional part of that course, as it obviously had never been opened. When I realised that not only was the author an 'antipodean aboard' but the novel was also about two Australian sisters who moved to England, it seemed like destiny that I should make it my choice.

About the author:

Shirley Hazzard was born in 1931 in Sydney, Australia. She left Australia as a child, due to her parents’ diplomatic postings and at 16, started to work for British Intelligence in Hong Kong, monitoring civil war in China. Since then she has lived in New Zealand, Europe, USA and Italy. In the USA she worked for the United Nations Secretariat in New York. She has been a full-time writer since leaving the UN, and has written a number non-fiction books including: Defeat of an Ideal: A Study of the Self-Destruction of the United Nations (1973), Countenance of Truth: the United Nations and the Waldheim Case (1990), Greene on Capri: A Memoir (2000) about her friend, Graham Greene. In 1985, Coming of Age in Australia was published, a collection of her Australian Broadcasting Corporation Boyer lectures. Her works of fiction include five novels: The Evening of the Holiday (1966); People in Glass Houses (1967); The Bay of Noon (1970); The Transit of Venus (1980); and most recently, The Great Fire (2003). Shirley Hazzard lives in New York.

(general biographical detail from the British Council website)

What the publisher says about the book:
Caro, gallant and adventurous, is one of two Australian sisters who have come to post-war England to seek their fortunes. Courted long and hopelessly by young scientist, Ted Tice, she is to find that love brings passion, sorrow, betrayal and finally hope. The milder Grace seeks fulfilment in an apparently happy marriage. But as the decades pass and the characters weave in and out of each other's lives, love, death and two slow-burning secrets wait in ambush for them.
What we discussed about the book:
  • The choice of 'The Transit of Venus' as the title. What was the significance, symbolism?
  • What did the novel says about Australia and being Australian? How was it shown as a 'place to escape from'?  In what ways did being Australian influence Caro and Grace's interactions with other characters?
  • Could this be described as an anti-war novel? What evidence was there of this viewpoint?
  • The coincidental and accidental nature of the human interactions vs the predictable nature of the astronomical transit of Venus.
  • How we would describe the style of the writing - dense, given to understatement, having gravity, no superfluous words?
  • The role of the omniscient narrator - foreshadowing details of plot essential to our later understanding.
  • The themes of disappearance and loss: the Benbow sinking, Adam Vail's death, Dora's Major
  • Is this a novel driven by plot or by character?
  • What degree of engagement is required by the reader. How does Hazzard instruct the reader in what is going to be required right on the first page?
  • The role of dialogue - minimal, but expressive.
  • Dora, as a character. In what ways does Hazzard create such a rounded and believable character with so few scenes?
  • Why do Caro and Grace treat Dora with no judgement and with a huge degree of loyalty.
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • What makes a writer 'Australian'? Is it just that they have an Australian birth certificate?  
  • The role of working women at that time, with particular reference to the tea-making and button/typewriter ribbon replacing scenes.
  • The social and political issues that form the background to the novel: post-war politics, nursing homes, women in the workforce, inequality of marraige, US political assassinations, English class system
In other news, we discussed:
  • VCE subject choices, getting through Year 12, work experience options
  • The nature of  Australian customs practices - checking parcels etc
  • The realities of nursing in 2013
  • The daggy to glamorous spectrum of parents at each school. How do we know where we fall on the continuum?
  • The etiquette of thank yous. One exchange is enough...you do not need to do a thank you for a thank you.
Ratings:
Range: 7 to 10
Average:  8.63

Next book: An Equal Music by Vikram Seth (chosen by KE)

Tuesday, 23 July 2013

Augusg book: The Transit of Venus by Shirley Hazzard

The Transit of Venus

by Shirley Hazzard

(chosen by Fairlie)

Theme: Antipodeans abroad





Some background links to get you started:





Sunday, 6 May 2012

Minutes April book: The Happiness Project

The Happiness Project


by Gretchen Rubin


(chosen by Fairlie)





I read Gretchen Rubin's Happiness Project blog before it became a book and often found aspects of her experience worthwhile in thinking about my own life.  So when the book was published, I pre-ordered a copy and read it straightaway when it arrived. I found it a really useful means to pull all the information from the blog together.  The structure of the book provided more focus to my thinking about the concept of happiness and how to add more of it to one's life.  I made it my bookclub choice for this year, as I knew we had never done a book in this genre before and thought there would be an interesting discussion surrounding the issues the book raises.


About the author:

Gretchen Rubin is a graduate of Yale and Yale Law School.  Rubin started her career in law, and she was clerking for Justice Sandra Day O’Connor when she realized she really wanted to be a writer. Her published works include:  Forty Ways to Look at Winston Churchill and Forty Ways to Look at JFK, Power Money Fame Sex: A User’s Guide and  Profane Waste, (a collaboration with artist Dana Hoey). She was raised in Kansas City, and now lives in New York City with her husband and two daughters.The Happiness Project is "an account of the year she spent test-driving the wisdom of the ages, the current scientific studies, and the lessons from popular culture about how to be happier". On her blog, The Happiness Project, she reports on her daily adventures in the pursuit of happiness.

(general biographical detail from the author's website)

What the publisher says about the book:

Award-winning author Gretchen Rubin is back with a bang, with The Happiness Project. The author of the bestselling 40 Ways to Look at Winston Churchill has produced a work that is “a cross between the Dalai Lama’s The Art of Happiness and Elizabeth Gilbert’s Eat, Pray, Love.” (Sonya Lyubomirsky, author of The How of Happiness: A Scientific Approach to Getting the Life You Want) In the vein of Julie and Julia, The Happiness Project describes one person’s year-long attempt to discover what leads to true contentment. Drawing at once on cutting-edge science, classical philosophy, and real-world applicability, Rubin has written an engaging, eminently relatable chronicle of transformation.  
Gretchen Rubin had an epiphany one rainy afternoon in the unlikeliest of places: a city bus. "The days are long, but the years are short," she realized. "Time is passing, and I'm not focusing enough on the things that really matter." In that moment, she decided to dedicate a year to her happiness project. In this lively and compelling account, Rubin chronicles her adventures during the twelve months she spent test-driving the wisdom of the ages, current scientific research, and lessons from popular culture about how to be happier. Among other things, she found that novelty and challenge are powerful sources of happiness; that money can help buy happiness, when spent wisely; that outer order contributes to inner calm; and that the very smallest of changes can make the biggest difference. 

What we discussed about the book:

  • Our own definitions of happiness: "A feeling of contentment", "Someone to love, something to look forward to, something to do",  "love+family", "A state of mind where positive thoughts outweigh negative thoughts", "A feeling of peace within one's soul", "Life's destination", "A state of contentment, ability to feel great".
  • Is the pursuit of happiness a selfish concept? Or a worthy goal?
  • The role of balance in a life to create happiness - can you be happy with a huge emphasis on one or other aspect of your life: work/health/family/spirit/friends/community/intellect?
  • St. Therese of Lisieux - why was she Rubin's spiritual master?  What is a spiritual master?
  • Who are our spiritual masters? 
  • Which quotations in the book resonated most strongly with us? "The days are long but the years are short", "It's easy to be heavy; it's hard to be light".
  • Rubin accepts she has 'snappy' tendencies - did we find her to be particularly so?
  • Did we want to do any of the resolutions?
  • Rubin observed that "Outer order contributes to inner calm". Is this a universal rule, or does it only apply to certain types of people/personalities?
  • The concept that charitable giving makes you wealthier, rather than the wealthier being more charitable.
  • Control/order/choices - in what ways do these concepts contribute to personal happiness?
  • What did we enjoy doing as 10 year olds? How do those activities feature in our lives today?
  • Was this a 'self-help' book? 

And then we were sidetracked into:

  • Could Oprah be a spiritual master?
  • The concept of happiness fog in relation to children
  • Writing life plans - the idea of starting with your own obituary and working backwards from that - what do you want to be said about you, and what are you doing to make that a reality?
  • Why was"the pursuit of happiness" included in the US Declaration of Independence?
  • The idea of automatically saying "yes" rather than "no" to children - and framing the rest of the sentence to actually communicate what you want to say: i.e "Yes, you can have a cupcake, just as soon as you finish all the vegetables" vs "No, you can't have a cupcake, you haven't finished your vegetables." Is this effective?
  • What would a 3rd world definition of happiness look like? 
  • Can you be happy in isolation, or does happiness require social bonds?  
  • Is it possible to consciously decide to be happy and make it happen?
  • Do low expectations (parental, one's own, society's) make it easier to be happy?

In other news we discussed:

  • Our delight at the newest addition to the No.1 Melbourne Ladies' Bookclub family - congratulations KE!


Ratings:
Range: 5 to 9.5
Average: 7.42

Next book: Fly Away Peter by David Malouf (chosen by Gypsy)

Monday, 16 April 2012

April book: The Happiness Project by Gretchen Rubin




The Happiness Project 


By Gretchen Rubin


(Chosen by Fairlie)





Some background links to get you started:






Wednesday, 4 May 2011

Minutes April book: The Portrait of a Lady by Henry James

The Portrait of a Lady

by Henry James

(chosen by Fairlie)





I chose this book because it is one of those books I've always meant to get around to, and I knew that by choosing it for Bookclub, I would ensure I finally read it!  I read James' Washington Square a few years ago, and really enjoyed it. It was however, a much smaller book than this one, and I apologised to the Ladies for unknowingly selecting such a weighty book.

One of the reasons I wanted to read it, is that several times over the past few years I've heard other authors refer to it as inspiring their own work, and I liked the idea of following through the genealogy of ideas within novels.

About the author:

Henry James was born in 1843 in New York City. He was the grandchild of one of the three richest men in New York and was raised in "an atmosphere of affluence". Shortly after his birth, James's father took the family on a trip to Europe. By the time he was fourteen, James and his family had traveled across the ocean twice.

James began studies in law, but withdrew from Harvard in 1863 and started writing. At the age of twenty-two, his first short story was published in Atlantic Monthly. By 1872,  he was able to live off the proceed of his writing, (fiction, travel essays and reviews) while living in Rome, Florence, and Paris.

From the mid-1870s until the end of his life, James lived abroad.

Henry James was thirty-eight when The Portrait of a Lady was published.

Possibly one of the greatest writers in the English language, James wrote twenty-two novels and one hundred and twelve stories. He died in 1916.
 
(General biographical details from here)
 
What the publisher says about the book:  
Henry James's magnificent heroine, a "young woman affronting her destiny"


When Isabel Archer, a beautiful, spirited American, is brought to Europe by her wealthy Aunt Touchett, it is expected that she will soon marry. But Isabel, resolved to determine her own fate, does not hesitate to turn down two eligible suitors. She then finds herself irresistibly drawn to Gilbert Osmond, who, beneath his veneer of charm and cultivation, is cruelty itself. A story of intense poignancy, Isabel's tale of love and betrayal still resonates with modern audiences.

What we discussed about the book:
  • Only two of us finished the book. Why did we find this such a difficult book to get through? The size? The nature of the writing? The themes? Relevance to current audiences?
  • Is there any value in reading classics? Are the themes universal? eg: oppression vs freedom, free will vs destiny, the role of women in society, the clash of American and European cultures.
  • Is this a feminist text? What does it tell us about the role of women in that society?
  • How did the writing style differ from what we are used to in contemporary novels?
  • Was Isabel a metaphor for "modern" (ie in 1870s) America.
  • In what ways did James define freedom and maturity as the acceptance of one's destiny.
  • Is this an elitist book? Does that matter?
  • How did each of the men view Isabel? What did each of them want from her?
  • What was the effect of the ellipses in the novel? (eg the jump in time through Isabel's marriage to Osmond.)
  • Was Madame Merle pure evil or a figure of sympathy? What did she have to offer hosts in return for their hospitality (eg. wit, charm, good company)?
  • Did Isabel meet Lord Warburton too early?
  • Was Isabel afraid of passion?
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • The differences (generalising!) between Australian and American women.
  • The language used in this book - leading to the classic KE quote: "I  did enjoy it. The dictionary and I."
In other news:
  • We discussed the demise of bricks and mortar bookshops. What can they offer to compensate for cheaper on-line options?
  • We discussed and compared the laptops and schoolbags required by various high schools.
  • We were envious listening to T-Rex's plans for a month in Paris.
Ratings:
Range of those finished: 9
Range of DNF: 6 to 8.5
Average (only finished): 9

Next book: The Secret Scripture by Sebastian Barry (chosen by Gypsy)

Sunday, 3 April 2011

April book: The Portrait of a Lady by Henry James

The Portrait of a Lady

by Henry James

(chosen by Fairlie)





Some background links to get you started:

Wednesday, 13 October 2010

Minutes October book: At Home: A Short History of Private Life

At Home: A Short History of Private Life

by Bill Bryson

(chosen by Fairlie)








I chose this book because I am fascinated by the history of domesticity, and thought this would be an interesting survey of how we have come to conduct our lives inside our homes. Whether that hope was met will be explored further in the minutes.  I have read some of Bill Bryson's books before and knew that it would offer an engaging, humorous read.

Bill Bryson was born in Des Moines, Iowa, in 1951. He moved to and settled in England in 1977, working in journalism until becoming a full time author. He lived with his English wife and their four young children in North Yorkshire, before moving the family to New Hampshire in America for a spell in the late 1990s. Now they have all returned to live in the UK.

Bill Bryson is the UK’s biggest selling non-fiction author since official records began. Some of his previous books include: In The Lost Continent, Neither Here Nor There, Notes From a Small Island, A Walk in the Woods, Notes From a Big Country, Down Under, Mother Tongue,  A Short History of Nearly Everything and his memoir of growing up in 1950s America, The Life and Times of the Thunderbolt Kid.
Bill Bryson has been the Chancellor of Durham University since 2005, and in 2006, was awarded an honorary OBE for services to literature. He loves the English countryside and became the President of the Campaign to Protect Rural England in 2007.

(General biographical details from the author's website)



What the publisher says about the book:

From one of the most beloved authors of our time—more than six million copies of his books have been sold in this country alone—a fascinating excursion into the history behind the place we call home.

"Houses aren't refuges from history. They are where history ends up."

Bill Bryson and his family live in a Victorian parsonage in a part of England where nothing of any great significance has happened since the Romans decamped. Yet one day, he began to consider how very little he knew about the ordinary things of life as he found it in that comfortable home. To remedy this, he formed the idea of journeying about his house from room to room to "write a history of the world without leaving home." The bathroom provides the occasion for a history of hygiene; the bedroom, sex, death, and sleep; the kitchen, nutrition and the spice trade; and so on, as Bryson shows how each has figured in the evolution of private life. Whatever happens in the world, he demonstrates, ends up in our house, in the paint and the pipes and the pillows and every item of furniture.

Bill Bryson has one of the liveliest, most inquisitive minds on the planet, and he is a master at turning the seemingly isolated or mundane fact into an occasion for the most diverting exposition imaginable. His wit and sheer prose fluency make At Home one of the most entertaining books ever written about private life.
 
What we discussed about the book:
  • Is this really a history of private life? What other descriptions could we suggest (eg social history, history of the development of comfort, collection of fascinating information that Bill Bryson came across in his research?)
  • What were we looking for in a history of private life? Does the title fit the book?
  • How was the device of moving through the rooms of the Rectory used to organise the material? Was this effective? How relevant was the information to each room?
  • How easily were we able to keep chronological details in order in our heads, given the meandering nature of the narrative?
  • Which parts of the book did we find most fascinating? (eg the role of the clergy, the 'rat stats', the ice industry...)
  • Why did we think the book started with the Great Exhibition and the Crystal Palace? What was the purpose of this information?
  • How were notions of 'private' and 'privacy' explored? Is this a history of the rise of privacy - from sharing halls with family, servants and animals to having individual bedrooms and personal space in 21st century nuclear families?
  • What happened to private life in the world outside the UK (and the side-trips into the US)?
  • At what points did we want more information than was presented? Were there points where our interest was piqued only for the story to move on without satisfying our curiosity?
  • How was the historical information related to the present? Did Bill Bryson have a 'message'? Was it left to the readers to draw our own conclusions?
  • Why were we so fascinated by the burial stories?
  • Can we as a society sustain the level of comfort reached thus far? How will we need to compromise our 'comfort' as the populations of countries such as India and China also develop their 'comfort'?
  • Words we would use to describe Bryson's writing style: witty, engaging, casual, funny, meandering.

And then we were sidetracked into:
  • How else the history of private life could have been structured - eg. following the progress of various functions through from pre-history to 21st Century: dwellings, plumbing, electricity, refrigeration, food preparation/eating, clothing... OR creating a fictitious genealogy and following a family or families through the ages, tracking their rise/fall/fortunes against the times? 
  • What were the spices we had never heard of?
  • Is it a miracle any of our ancestors survived at all? Arsenic, accidents, poisons, scurvy...
  • To what extent is the progress of humanity a happy accident of trial and error?
  • How do we see private life progressing into the future - what changes do we think will be necessary to create a sustainable lifestyle?
  • Is open-plan living necessarily a good thing?
  • Why don't we share more resources within neighbourhoods? (eg swimming pools, tennis courts)
  • What is the value of history? Does it need to teach a lesson for the present?
In other news, we discussed:
  • Who has friendly neighbours? How do you create a friendly neighbourhood?
  • Why do staff in stores hardly ever wear uniforms anymore. How do we know who is staff, and who is just another customer?
  • The globalisation of brands...how the same stores are now seen the world over. Is this a good thing for the brand? Is it good for local culture? Why travel if everything comes to you?
  • Are iPads any good for reading eBooks?
  • Why do some people pick up accents after living overseas, and some don't?
  • The Commonwealth Games. What do we think? Is its time up? Should the male cyclists have been given a better outfit than their all-in-one suits to stand on the medal podium? Where are all the spectators?
Ratings:
Range: 5 to 8
Average: 6.85

Next book: Imperial Bedrooms by Bret Easton Ellis (chosen by CH)

Wednesday, 18 February 2009

Minutes February Book: Diary of a Bad Year by J.M Coetzee



Minutes February Book: Diary of a Bad Year by J.M Coetzee


(chosen by Fairlie)








I have to confess to choosing this book somewhat hastily. A colleague recommended it. After flicking through a few pages and with no further research, I signed it up as my choice for this year. What appealed to me was the challenge of reading a book with an obvious degree of difficulty – the split stories running across the pages would, I thought, challenge our assumptions about how to read a book.

J. M. Coetzee was the first author to win the Booker Prize twice and was awarded the Nobel Prize for Literature in 2003. His work includes Waiting for the Barbarians, Life and Times of Michael K, The Master of Petersburg, Disgrace and Inner Workings. He lives in Adelaide.
(biographical details sourced from Text Publishing’s website)

What the publisher says about the book:


A famous writer is commissioned to contribute to a book of essays called Strong opinions when he meets a young woman who lives in his apartment tower. He asks
her to become his...
... ... ... ... ...
In the laundry room of her apartment block a young woman makes the acquaintance of an ageing writer. She agrees to type up his opinions, although she is aware that what he really desires...
... ... ... ... ...
The young woman's boyfriend starts to spy on his neighbour and hatches a jealous plot to...

J. M. Coetzee's Diary of a Bad Year is about loneliness, friendship and the possibility of love. It takes the reader from Australian democracy to Guantanamo Bay, from the meaning of dishonour to the creative truth of dreams. Enthralling, unexpected and deeply moving, this may be the most original work of fiction to appear this year.**


What we discussed about the book:
  • How did we read the book? Some read each story until the dot, then read the next story until the same dot etc. Others read down each page. Some read each story in its entirety before starting the next one. Some needed three bookmarks to keep up with where they were up to.
  • Is this book fact? Is it fiction? To what degree are the opinions expressed in the essays the opinions of JM Coeztee? How much can we trust these opinions? Does it matter?
  • Was there a hierarchy to the stories on each page?
  • In what ways was it a ‘bad year’?
  • Could we hear the voice of the character ‘Senor C’ in the academic writing?
  • What was the point of the second diary?
  • To what degree does the writer mock his own opinions?
  • Is this a book about dying? Is it the book of a man saying goodbye?
  • To what degree was the JS Bach essay intended to make us reflect on this writing being like a piece of music – each of the storylines the part of a different instrument.
  • Could the book only be completely appreciated once all the parts had intertwined and played out to their end?

And then we were sidetracked into:
  • The political situation in South Africa. To what degree has that history influenced JM Coetzee’s writing?
  • Do we enjoy books that challenge to look at writing in a new way? Were we able to accept the non-linear narrative style of this book?

And in other news:

  • We reflected on the tragic events of recent days in Victoria with the bushfires.
  • We acknowledged that this meeting marked the 10 year anniversary of the No.1 Melbourne Ladies’ Bookclub and we agreed to plan some events to celebrate this during the year.
  • We discussed the Twilight series of books...and how addictive they are for mothers of tweenage girls...

Ratings:

Ratings range: 6 to 9
Ratings average: 7.55
(one DNF was a midrange score)

Next book: The People of the Book by Geraldine Brooks

Wednesday, 12 November 2008

Minutes October Book: In Defence of Food by Michael Pollan



Minutes October Book: In Defence of Food by Michael Pollan

(chosen by Fairlie)


In memory of our friend, S



Fairlie chose this book because she heard Michael Pollan speak at the Sydney Writers Festival and he was very impressive. He has a science/journalism background and as a result has done a lot of research into nutrition. Fairlie saw and heard him speak another time (also at the Writers Festival) and this clinched it for her - it was a book for her bookclub!

Michael Pollan is the author, most recently, of In Defense of Food: An Eater's Manifesto. His previous book, The Omnivore's Dilemma: A Natural History of Four Meals (2006), was named one of the ten best books of 2006 by the New York Times and the Washington Post. He is also the author of The Botany of Desire: A Plant's-Eye View of the World (2001); A Place of My Own (1997); and Second Nature (1991). A contributing writer to the New York Times Magazine, Pollan is the recipient of numerous journalistic awards. Pollan served for many years as executive editor of Harper's Magazine and is now the Knight Professor of Science and Environmental Journalism at UC Berkeley. His articles have been anthologized in Best American Science Writing (2004); Best American Essays (1990 and 2003) and the Norton Book of Nature Writing. He lives in the Bay Area with his wife, the painter Judith Belzer, and their son, Isaac.
(biographical details sourced from the author's website.)

What the publisher says about the book:

"Eat food. Not too much. Mostly plants." These simple words go to the heart of Michael Pollan's In Defence of Food. Humans used to know how to eat well, Pollan argues. But the balanced dietary lessons that were once passed down through generations have been confused, complicated, and distorted by food industry marketers, nutritional scientists, and journalists – all of whom have much to gain from our dietary confusion. Indeed, real food is fast disappearing from the marketplace, to be replaced by "nutrients," and plain old eating by an obsession with nutrition that is, paradoxically, ruining our health, not to mention our meals. Michael Pollan's bracing and eloquent manifesto shows us how we might start making thoughtful food choices that will enrich our lives and our palates and enlarge our sense of what it means to be healthy.


What we discussed about the book:
  • The message of the book was simple and it was not rocket science - we knew or suspected the message but having it in black and white really brought it home.
  • When you take out all of the fat in foods what do you put back in?
  • Is what manufacturers put back in "good" for human consumption?
  • Food lobbying - is it as strong in Australia as in USA and other countries?
  • Is corn syrup in everything?
  • Why has the meat industry changed so dramatically in Australia in last 5 yrs - with increased use of antibiotics and hormones?
  • National Heart Foundation health tick - what do companies have to do (or not do) to get the tick?
  • Upsizing of meals - is this tied to commodity prices? Are supermarkets downsizing their packaging whilst increasing price of manufactured food items?
  • Lengthy discussion regarding full fat (yogurt, cheese etc) versus skim or low fat products and number of eggs that are now considered healthy in daily diet.
  • Chemical processes to produce powdered egg or a substitute product (eg fruit flavours) - is it as healthy as using fresh egg or fruits in manufactured products? Does this apply to whole host of other products - eg milk, yogurt?
  • Are we losing our sense of community due to shopping in supermarkets - no longer knowing local butcher, baker etc?
  • Are the range of products available in Australia declining? Is this a positive development? Is it squeezing smaller (perhaps organic focused) manufacturers out of the market?
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • Are the burgers really bigger and tastier at Hungry Jacks'?
  • What sort of food colouring and "make up" for the food do advertisers (via professional food stylists) use in those gorgeous photos of succulent food?

And in other news:

  • Muck up days - why was a whole Yr 12 Grade suspended at a prominent boys school in Melbourne?
  • Boarding school in Perth - one member reminisced about a headmistress who had a really strict view of life and really enforced the rules but deep down had a soft spot in her heart.
  • We discussed the rumour that there may be a document dating back to the late 90s regarding the "rules" of our bookclub. Some members will search their archives and report back - this drew great peels of laughter....and led us into a discussion that there may also be a "briefing document" that was provided to one new member with a run down of the personalities of other members!
  • Type 2 diabetes - explanation of the difference between this and Type 1. Symptoms - thirsty, loss of concentration, tiredness. We had a look at an insulin kit and explanation of what a person with Type 2 diabetes has to do each day to maintain their insulin level.
  • And then we decided that we really should stop chatting at 11.00 pm so the host can get us out of their home...

On a very sad note:
We discussed the funeral arrangements for our dear friend and previous administrator and minute secretary - S. She was loved by many and will be so greatly missed. Our love and thoughts go to her husband, her daughter and their families.

Ratings:

Ratings range: 6.5 to 8.5

Ratings average: 7.43

Next book: The Time Traveller's Wife by Audrey Niffenegger

Thank you to Domestic Goddess for compiling these minutes!

Tuesday, 14 October 2008

October book: In Defence of Food by Michael Pollan



October book: In Defence of Food by Michael Pollan

(chosen by Fairlie)


Some background links to get you started:

Wednesday, 16 July 2008

Minutes July book: Love in the Time of Cholera by Gabriel Garcia Marquez

Love in the Time of Cholera

By Gabriel Garcia Marquez

(chosen by Fairlie)



As most of the No.1 Melbourne Bookclub Ladies know (because I tell them often enough) One Hundred Years of Solitude which is also by Gabriel Garcia Marquez still stands as my all-time favourite book. I hadn’t however, read anything else written by him, and had always meant to get around to reading Love in the Time of Cholera. My husband gave me a copy of it for Christmas so, motivated by the desire to read it and the fact it was sitting on my bedside table, I made it my bookclub choice.

Gabriel García Márquez was born in March of 1927 in the tiny Colombian banana town of Aracataca. The following year, the banana economy took a downturn and created a rift in the town. As a result, his parents struggled financially and García Márquez was raised by his maternal grandparents.

At the age of 19, he enrolled in the law program at the Universidad Nacional in Bogotá, but also had a passion for writing.

García Márquez met the then 13-year-old Mercedes Barcha Pardo in his hometown when he was 18 and proposed to her soon after. They married fourteen years later, and their love has lasted a lifetime. While he traveled after dropping out of law school, she waited for him in Colombia until he returned for her when she was 27-years-old.

García Márquez became a journalist after leaving law school and in 1954 he was sent to Rome on an assignment for his newspaper, and since then he has mostly lived abroad - in Paris, New York, Barcelona and Mexico – more or less in exile.

One Hundred Years of Solitude was published in 1967, and within a week all 8000 copies of the original printing had been sold. It was translated into many languages and won the Chianchiano Prize in Italy, the Best Foreign Book in France, the Rómulo Gallegos Prize and the Nobel Prize for Literature.

Love in the Time of Cholera was first published in 1982.

(general biographical details from here)

What the publisher says about the book:

In their youth, Florentino Ariza and Fermina Daza fall passionately in love. When Fermina eventually chooses to marry a wealthy, well-born doctor, Florentino is devastated, but he is a romantic. As he rises in his business career he whiles away the years in 622 affairs--yet he reserves his heart for Fermina. Her husband dies at last, and Florentino purposefully attends the funeral. Fifty years, nine months, and four days after he first declared his love for Fermina, he will do so again.


What we discussed about the book:

  • Why was cholera used as a device to reflect the properties of love?
  • What was the purpose of the emphasis on bodily functions, particularly in relation to Florentino?
  • In what way had Florentino “remained a virgin” for Fermina?
  • What was the nature of the relationship between Dr Urbino and Fermina – could it be described as love?
  • To what extent was Dr Urbino a modern man?
  • How many different types of love are portrayed in this book?
  • Is there a risk when reading a translation of a book written in another language that some significant subtlety may be lost? How does the fact that the Spanish words for cholera (el colera) and choler/anger (la colera) are so similar affect our understanding of the title of the book?
  • How did Garcia Marquez appeal to the senses in his descriptions. What effect did that have?
  • What would have happened after the last page? Would they have continued on the boat “forever”?
  • Why did we find Florentino such an unappealing character? In what ways does the steadfast pursuit of unrequited romantic love differ from obsessive stalking?
  • How did the decline and decay of the physical environment (e.g. the river) mirror the emotional content of the book?
  • How was magic realism employed in this novel?
Then we were sidetracked into:

  • What are the possibilities of love developing within an arranged relationship?
  • In cases where Ladies were reading this book for the second time several years after the first reading - why were their impressions of it so different?
  • Is there a case for a book being ‘the right book at the right time’? Is this book interpreted differently by 20-something readers than it is by 40-somethings?
  • The different approaches various cultures have towards death, funerals, inheritances.

And in other news, we discussed:

  • How gorgeous KM’s little boy is, when they paid us a surprise visit!
  • Why it is responsible to wear a helmet while skiing.
  • How various sayings in other languages do not translate directly into English – does for instance, “money open all tongues”? and do we “close the light”?
  • Is Apple the Chanel of the computer world?
  • Were record players (turntables) that stacked 5-6 vinyl LPs which dropped down as the one before finished, just as good as CD stackers in your carboot?

Ratings:

Initial rating range: we forgot to do initial ratings!
Initial rating average: n/a
Post-discussion range: 5.5 to 8.0
Post-discussion average: 6.57


Next book: The Mitford Girls by Mary S. Lovell (T-Rex’s choice)

Saturday, 12 July 2008

July book: Love in the Time of Cholera by Gabriel Garcia Marquez



July book: Love in the Time of Cholera


by Gabriel Garcia Marquez



(chosen by Fairlie)


Some background links to get you started:

Wednesday, 31 October 2007

Minutes October 2007 Book: Theft by Peter Carey



Theft: A Love Story
by Peter Carey
(chosen by Fairlie)







At one of the bookclubs I went to during my year in Perth, one of the ladies bemoaned the fact that most of the books we had read that year were a little depressing in their content. "I'd just like to do a love story," she said.

The very next day, I saw a review for the newly released Theft, a book which is sub-titled "A Love Story". That caught my eye, and when I realised that the plot of the book was centred around a case of art fraud, and was written by Peter Carey (who also wrote Oscar & Lucinda which I really enjoyed), I was sold.

Like the main character in Theft, Peter Carey was born in 1943, in Bacchus Marsh, Victoria, Australia. His parents had a General Motors dealership. He attended Geelong Grammar School, and studied briefly at Monash University, but left after failing his first year science exams. He then worked as a copywriter in advertising agencies in Melbourne and London. He started writing in 1964. He moved to Sydney in 1974 where he continued copyrighting. His first collection of surreal short stories, War Crimes, was published in 1979.

In 1990/1991 he moved to New York, with his wife, Alison Summers, a theatre director, and his sons, to teach creative writing at University of New York. He still lives in New York, and still teaches Creative Writing at New York University. He is now divorced and his ex-wife has accused him of using this book to attack her and distort the story of their marriage breakdown. Carey does, however, refute this claim strongly.

(general biographical details from here)

Description of Theft from Random House website:

'I don't know if my story is grand enough to be a tragedy, although a lot of shitty stuff did happen. It is certainly a love story but that did not begin until midway through the shitty stuff, by which time I had not only lost my 8-year-old son, but also my house and studio in Sydney where I had once been as famous as a painter could expect in his own backyard.'

So begins Peter Carey's highly charged, recklessly funny new novel. Narrated by artist Butcher Bones and his 'damaged 220 lb brother' Hugh, it recounts their adventures and troubles after Butcher's plummeting prices and spiralling drink problem force them to retreat from Sydney to northern New South Wales. Here the formerly famous artist is reduced to acting as caretaker for his patron and nurse to his idiot-savant brother. Then mysterious American beauty Marlene turns up one stormy night, clad in a pair of Manolo Blahniks. Claiming that the brothers' neighbour owns an original Jacques Liebovitz, she sets in motion a chain of events that could be the making or ruin of them all.A truly brilliant novel - an act of fantastic writing bravura from Peter Carey, in which he once again displays his extraordinary flair for language - THEFT is a love poem of a completely unexpected kind. Ranging from the rural wilds of Australia to Manhattan via Sydney and Tokyo and exploring the ideas of art, fraud, responsibility and redemption, this is a dark, thought-provoking and stirring story that will also make you laugh out loud.


What we discussed about the book:
  • What is the purpose of the dual-narrative format of the book? Which narrator is more credible? Why do both narrators address the reader directly?
  • The use of capitalisation in Hugh's narrative. How did that add to the voice of the character? How did the quote at the beginning of the book about the use of capital letters contribute to our understanding?
  • What form of disability did Hugh have? Do we need to know that information for our reading of the book?
  • Does the dust-jacket consist of a photo of the Twin Towers? If so, what is the reason for this choice?
  • The final line of the book, "How do you know how much to pay if you don't know what it's worth?" How many different parts of the story could this have applied to?
  • The concept of manipulating an artist's 'worth' by creating an artificial market - i.e. the sell-out show in Japan. How does that affect an artist's sense of self-worth?
  • What was the "love story"? Was it brotherly love? Romantic love? Lustful love? Love of the art?
  • How do the concepts of dishonesty, fakery and forgery apply to more in this story than just the art fraud?
  • Why is there a note about the typsetting at the back of the book?
  • Does this book push the language to somewhere new?

Then we were sidetracked into:

  • How does the concept of "droit moral" work? See Wikipedia entry for quick overview.
  • Do you need to have a knowledge of the art world to be able to get the most from this book?
  • Would the main character, Butcher, really have gone to prison in Australia for stealing his paintings back from his ex-wife?

And in other news, we discussed:

  • How much is reasonable in a divorce settlement?
  • Are A-line dresses and baby-doll dresses EVER flattering on anyone other than tall, willowy, young models?
  • The curse of insomnia.
  • The expectation of being "busy" - i.e when someone asks you how you are, you are almost expected to reply, "I'm busy." The clever ladies over at Do You Speak-a My Language have a post on exactly this subject.

Ratings
Average: 7.0
Range: 5 to 9.5


Next book: The Gospel of Gods and Crocodiles by Elizabeth Stead.

Wednesday, 10 October 2007

October book: Theft: A Love Story by Peter Carey



Theft: A Love Story by Peter Carey (chosen by Fairlie)

Meeting date: October 16th
Venue: JM's house

Some links for background information to get you started...