Saturday, 1 September 2012

Minutes August book: Religion for Atheists

Religion for Atheists

by Alain de Botton

chosen by Domestic Goddess




(Thanks to JP for her notes for the minutes this month)

 Domestic Goddess chose this book as it had no characters and she wanted to escape the 'novel' genre.

About the author:

Alain de Botton was born in Zurich, Switzerland in 1969 and now lives in London. He is a writer of essayist books on love, travel, architecture and literature. Alain also started and helps to run a school in London called The School of Life, dedicated to a new vision of education. Religion for Atheists is his latest book. His first book, Essays in Love, was published when he was twenty-three.

(general biographical detail from the author's website)

What the publisher says about the book:

The boring debate between fundamentalist believers and non-believers is finally moved on by Alain de Botton's inspiring new book, which boldly argues that the supernatural claims of religion are of course entirely false - and yet that religions still have some very important things to teach the secular world. Religion for Atheists suggests that rather than mocking religions, agnostics and atheists should instead steal from them - because they're packed with good ideas on how we might live and arrange our societies. 
Blending deep respect with total impiety, de Botton (a non-believer himself) proposes that we should look to religions for insights into, among other concerns, how to: build a sense of community; make our relationships last; overcome feelings of envy and inadequacy; escape the twenty-four hour media; go travelling; get more out of art, architecture and music; and create new businesses designed to address our emotional needs. 
For too long non-believers have faced a stark choice between either swallowing lots of peculiar doctrines or doing away with a range of consoling and beautiful rituals and ideas. At last, in Religion for Atheists, Alain de Botton, the author of the bestselling The Consolations of Philosophy and How Proust Can Change Your Life, has fashioned a far more interesting and truly helpful alternative.

What we discussed about the book:
  • Why atheists should not mock or make fun of religion
  • What can we learn from what spirituality and faith have to offer?
  • How religion has ideas which we can learn from going forward and use these ideas to help shape our society
  • Were some of the examples far-fetched? Did this detract from the ideas?
  • How can some of the ideas protect and assist religion to progress into the future
  • Are we presently at a crossroads with the risk of losing our 'faith' altogether going forward for the younger generations?
  • If we control peoples faith, are we assisting them to taking away their right to decide?
  • Is the book a series of suggestions that can be adopted into a non-religious framework?
  • How have religions branded their icons for recognition across the centuries?
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • What do militant atheists make of de Botton?
  • Do we need a structure of community togetherness (e.g. a secular Sabbath) to help us join together?
  • Do we need guidance and reminding about how to feed and nurture our souls?

Ratings:
Range: 7 to 8
Average:  7.56

Next book: A Visit from the Goon Squad by Jennifer Egan (chosen by KM)

Wednesday, 8 August 2012

August book: Religion for Atheists by Alain de Botton

Religion for Atheists

by Alain de Botton

(chosen by Domestic Goddess)



Some background links to get you started:

Minutes July book: Runaway

Runaway 

by Alice Munro

(chosen by KE)





KE was struggling to make a book choice, so I offered some suggestions that had been passed on to me by my osteopath who is a voracious and discerning reader.  Runaway by Alice Munro was one of those titles. KE chose it on that recommendation, and also based on the fact the we had never done a collection of short stories before.

About the author:

Alice Munro won the Man Booker International Prize for 2009 for her lifetime body of work. She has written eleven collections of stories, and one novel, Lives of Girls and Women. She is much-awarded and was shortlisted for the Booker Prize for The Beggar Maid. Her stories have appeared in The New Yorker, Atlantic Monthly, The Paris Review, and other publications, and her collections have been translated into thirteen languages. She lives with her husband in Ontario, Canada.

(general biographical detail from the publisher's website)

What the publisher says about the book:

The bestselling collection by the greatest short story writer in the world. The matchless Munro makes art out of everyday lives in this dazzling new collection. At its centre are three stories connected into one marvellously rich narrative about Juliet - who escapes from teaching at a girls' school and throws herself into a wild and passionate love match. Here are men and women of wildly different times and circumstances, their lives made vividly palpable by the nuance and empathy of Munro's writing. Runaway is about the power and betrayals of love, about lost children, lost chances. There is pain and desolation beneath the surface, like a needle in the heart, which makes these stories more powerful and compelling than anything she has written.

What we discussed about the book:
  • Did we all realize it was a collection of short stories when we started reading? At what point did that become clear?
  • How did Munro create so much story in so few pages each time? What devices did she use to do that?
  • Likewise, characterisation...how did Munro create such depth and richness in the characters, with fewer words than a novel?
  • Was there a linking theme throughout all the stories? 
  • Did all the stories contain an element of lack of hope?
  • In what ways were these stories about women making choices and struggling to be free of conventional restraints?
  • Were the women in these stories generally dissatisfied with their lives and/or choices?
  • How did the idea of running away (i.e Runaway) feature in various stories?
  • What effect did huge gaps in chronology have in some of the stories? i.e allowing the story to move forward rapidly
  • The various styles of writing employed - e.g. 'Powers': written from several points of view, 'Tricks': reflecting Shakespearean tragedy, '
  • Did we agree or disagree with the idea that 'plot is secondary and little happens' in these stories?
  • Were all the female characters fatally flawed?
  • In what ways did these stories turn on the 'chance moments' in life?

And then we were sidetracked into:
  • Why does an author chose to write short stories rather than novels? 
  • How popular are short stories? Who reads them? Why or why not?
  • What is 'Southern Ontario Gothic'?
  • What was the link with Jonathan Franzen? (i.e. introduction in revised edition)

In other news we discussed:
  • Bali, Singapore, Hong Kong, Penang, Langkawi...
  • The appearance on Offspring of the Life's Little Treasures logo
  • Sleep and/or lack of it. 
  • Books people are talking about at the moment: 50 Shades of Grey, Game of Thrones, Bringing up the Dead, The Bolter. 

Ratings:
Range: 6 to 9
Average:  7.57

Next book: Religion for Atheists by Alain de Botton (chosen by Domestic Goddess)

July book - Runaway by Alice Munro

Runaway

by Alice Munro

(chosen by KE)






Some background links to get you started:




Minutes June book: The Picture of Dorian Gray

The Picture of Dorian Gray

by Oscar Wilde

(chosen by LC)





Last year, while in Paris, LC visited the Père Lachaise Cemetery and saw Oscar Wilde's grave. For years fans have visited the grave, and left lipsticked kisses on the cream-coloured gravestone (the stone has recently been cleaned off and protected by a glass screen - which is now also covered in lipstick kisses.) LC saw a message written on the glass which said, 'You changed my life'. She was intrigued by this and then decided to make The Picture of Dorian Gray her book choice.

About the author:

Oscar Fingal O'Flahertie Wills Wilde was born in Dublin in 1854, the son of an eye-surgeon and a nationalist poetess. He went to Trinity College, Dublin and then to Magdalen College, Oxford. He married Constance Lloyd in 1884, and then tried to establish himself as a writer. Success was slow, however his three volumes of short fiction, The Happy Prince (1888), Lord Arthur Savile's Crime (1891) and A House of Pomegranates (1891), together with his only novel, The Picture of Dorian Gray (1891), gradually won him a solid reputation as a modern writer. His Society Comedies – Lady Windermere's Fan, A Woman of No Importance, An Ideal Husband and The Importance of Being Earnest, were all performed on the West End stage between 1892 and 1895 and were very popular.

In 1891, Wilde had met and fallen in love with Lord Alfred Douglas. In 1895, Wilde brought an unsuccessful libel action against Douglas's father, the Marquess of Queensberry. Wilde lost the case and after a further two trials was sentenced to two years' imprisonment for acts of gross indecency. He was released from prison in 1897 and exiled himself to a life on the Continent. He died in Paris in 1900.

(general biographical detail from the publisher's website)

What the publisher says about the book:

Enthralled by his own exquisite portrait, Dorian Gray exchanges his soul for eternal youth and beauty. Influenced by his friend Lord Henry Wotton, he is drawn into a corrupt double life, indulging his desires in secret while remaining a gentleman in the eyes of polite society. Only his portrait bears the traces of his decadence. The Picture of Dorian Gray was a succes de scandale. Early readers were shocked by its hints at unspeakable sins, and the book was later used as evidence against Wilde at the Old Bailey in 1895.

What we discussed about the book:

  • In what ways did the portrait represent a conscience?
  • Was the character of Basil a conscience?
  • Were Lord Henry's shocking words, worse than / better than / the same as shocking deeds?
  • What was it about Dorian that fascinated Lord Henry?
  • What did Dorian have over Alan Campbell?
  • How could we explain Henry's attitude towards Sybil - 'The girl never really lived, and so she has never really died...'. What did he mean by that?
  • Was Lord Henry a more insidious character than Dorian?  How/when would he pay for his sins?
  • The symbolism of colours in the novel. What was the 'yellow book'?
  • Could this be called a fable? A morality tale? Were there elements of fairy tale?
  • Was there ever an actual pact with the devil/evil? 
  • Were the underclasses portrayed as having an ugliness?
  • Did we agree with the quotes, 'There is no such thing as a good influence, Mr Gray. All influence is immoral - immoral from the scientific point of view.'...'Because to influence a person is to give him one's own soul.'?

And then we were sidetracked into:
  • In what ways was the Victorian social code suffocating to individuals? How did this play out in their lives?
  • The concept of opium houses and brothels in that time.
  • Is this considered an immoral book today?  What would the definition of immoral literature look like today? Does it depend on the reader, rather than a societal view?
  • The concept of 'keeping up appearances' in the upper classes. After the beater was shot, the shoot was cancelled because it would not look good to go on.
  • How does the book stand up now, over a century later?
  • How did censorship/editing of this novel change the original intended meaning?

In other news we discussed:
  • The Age article about the dark Internet - a webworld beyond law enforcement.
  • Botox and the 'Dorian Gray Effect' - a medical condition in which rapid aging occurs when the botox wears off. 
  • Various approaches to religion - which churches swing the incense.

Ratings:
Range: 7 to 8
Average: 7.66

Next book: Runaway by Alice Munro (chosen by KE)

Friday, 8 June 2012

June book: The Picture of Dorian Gray by Oscar Wilde

The Picture of Dorian Gray 


by Oscar Wilde


(chosen by LC)














Some background links to get you started:

Minutes May book: Fly Away Peter

Fly Away Peter

by David Malouf

(chosen by Gypsy)





Gypsy was still carrying the scars from her previous choice of Twilight, and was determined to find the 'perfect' book this year. She read many, many options over several months. She thought long and hard about it. And she still couldn't make a decision. Then, while perusing the reviews on Kimbofo's Reading Matters blog, she came across a review of Fly Away Peter. It was 144 pages long (which met our small books challenge) and had been rated 5 stars. She decided to take a chance on it.

About the author:

David Malouf is an internationally acclaimed author of many prize-wining and short-listed novels including The Great World,  Remembering Babylon , An Imaginary Life, Conversations at Curlow Creek, Dream Stuff , Every Move You Make, and his autobiographical work12 Edmondstone Street. Fly Away Peter was published in 1982 and is often studied in Australian schools. Malouf was born in 1934 and was brought up in Brisbane.

(general biographical detail from the publisher's website)

What the publisher says about the book:

For three very different people brought together by their love for birds, life on the Queensland coast in 1914 is the timeless and idyllic world of sandpipers, ibises and kingfishers. In another hemisphere civilization rushes headlong into a brutal conflict. Life there is lived from moment to moment. Inevitably, the two young men -sanctuary owner and employee - are drawn to the war, and into the mud and horror of the trenches of Armentieres. Alone on the beach, their friend Imogen, the middle-aged wildlife photographer, must acknowledge for all three of them that the past cannot be held.

What we discussed about the book:

  • Is this a novel which explores big ideas rather than a simple story? Life and death, war and peace, poverty and wealth, bravery and cowardice, innocence and evil.
  • The birds. What was their purpose in the story? How did the migratory patterns of birds relate to the story of the characters. How did the birds represent other concepts - e.g. freedom. What role did the birds play while the action was set in France?
  • What did it foreshadow when a bird turned up in the wrong place?
  • How was so much story told in so few words/pages? What devices did Malouf use to achieve that?
  • "An old girl, he guessed, of more than fifty." How has life changed, that 'more than fifty' is no longer considered 'an old girl.'?
  • The concept of Ashley Crowther being a 'serious person'. Do such people still exist? What role did they play in society in that time?
  • In what ways is the essence of the Australian landscape communicated? Is it through subtle clues? Would the reading of it differ if we were not Australian?
  • The use of earth/sky imagery - the first half of the book focusing upwards, and the second part underground.  
  • The scenes with Eric, the orphan. Why were we so moved by them?
  • Why did Clancy's death affect us so strongly?
  • In what ways was the machinery of war conveyed? Were the soldiers expendable cogs in a giant mechanism?
  • The balance of the war scenes - horror and humour, loneliness and mateship, sanctuary and violence. How did Malouf create this sense of yin/yang?
  • What role does humour play in creating a release for the horror?
  • Was the death scene all a hallucination? What parts were real? Does it matter to be able to distinguish?
  • What is the meaning of the title?
  • What role does Imogen play? How does she reconcile the past, present and future?
  • Why surfing? Is it that it represents that balance point between air and earth?
  • Were we satisfied with the ending?

And then we were sidetracked into:

  • The Northern Wheatear - a fascinating tiny migratory bird!
  • Why do we connect so strongly with some books, but not with others? What determines each experience?
  • Is the world fundamentally bad?
  • How did people survive mentally after seeing what they did during wars?
  • Do we look after returned soldiers nowadays?
  • The G.K Chesterton quote at the beginning of the book. Refer back to our favourite quotes from The Happiness Project and one of them was a Chesterton quote as well. Coincidence?
  • Would we have liked to study this as a school text? Would deconstructing it and analysing it, and having to write essays have dampened our enthusiasm for this novel?
  • In what ways did this book remind us of Tim Winton's writing?

In other news we discussed:

  • How you have to watch out for the size of books when ordering on-line - some of the cheaper options for a title turn up and they're like mini-pocket book versions with tiny font!
  • Hair washing, dry shampoos, frequency of washing, length of time a blow dry can last. Oh, we're high brow, people.
  • Should only the Mum in a household have a say in whether or not a family gets a dog, as they are the ones who end up doing everything for it?

Ratings:
Range: 7.25 to 9.75
Average: 8.66

Next book: The Picture of Dorian Grey by Oscar Wilde (chosen by LC)

Sunday, 6 May 2012

May book: Fly Away Peter by David Malouf

Fly Away Peter


by David Malouf


(chosen by Gypsy)




Some background links to get you started:


Minutes April book: The Happiness Project

The Happiness Project


by Gretchen Rubin


(chosen by Fairlie)





I read Gretchen Rubin's Happiness Project blog before it became a book and often found aspects of her experience worthwhile in thinking about my own life.  So when the book was published, I pre-ordered a copy and read it straightaway when it arrived. I found it a really useful means to pull all the information from the blog together.  The structure of the book provided more focus to my thinking about the concept of happiness and how to add more of it to one's life.  I made it my bookclub choice for this year, as I knew we had never done a book in this genre before and thought there would be an interesting discussion surrounding the issues the book raises.


About the author:

Gretchen Rubin is a graduate of Yale and Yale Law School.  Rubin started her career in law, and she was clerking for Justice Sandra Day O’Connor when she realized she really wanted to be a writer. Her published works include:  Forty Ways to Look at Winston Churchill and Forty Ways to Look at JFK, Power Money Fame Sex: A User’s Guide and  Profane Waste, (a collaboration with artist Dana Hoey). She was raised in Kansas City, and now lives in New York City with her husband and two daughters.The Happiness Project is "an account of the year she spent test-driving the wisdom of the ages, the current scientific studies, and the lessons from popular culture about how to be happier". On her blog, The Happiness Project, she reports on her daily adventures in the pursuit of happiness.

(general biographical detail from the author's website)

What the publisher says about the book:

Award-winning author Gretchen Rubin is back with a bang, with The Happiness Project. The author of the bestselling 40 Ways to Look at Winston Churchill has produced a work that is “a cross between the Dalai Lama’s The Art of Happiness and Elizabeth Gilbert’s Eat, Pray, Love.” (Sonya Lyubomirsky, author of The How of Happiness: A Scientific Approach to Getting the Life You Want) In the vein of Julie and Julia, The Happiness Project describes one person’s year-long attempt to discover what leads to true contentment. Drawing at once on cutting-edge science, classical philosophy, and real-world applicability, Rubin has written an engaging, eminently relatable chronicle of transformation.  
Gretchen Rubin had an epiphany one rainy afternoon in the unlikeliest of places: a city bus. "The days are long, but the years are short," she realized. "Time is passing, and I'm not focusing enough on the things that really matter." In that moment, she decided to dedicate a year to her happiness project. In this lively and compelling account, Rubin chronicles her adventures during the twelve months she spent test-driving the wisdom of the ages, current scientific research, and lessons from popular culture about how to be happier. Among other things, she found that novelty and challenge are powerful sources of happiness; that money can help buy happiness, when spent wisely; that outer order contributes to inner calm; and that the very smallest of changes can make the biggest difference. 

What we discussed about the book:

  • Our own definitions of happiness: "A feeling of contentment", "Someone to love, something to look forward to, something to do",  "love+family", "A state of mind where positive thoughts outweigh negative thoughts", "A feeling of peace within one's soul", "Life's destination", "A state of contentment, ability to feel great".
  • Is the pursuit of happiness a selfish concept? Or a worthy goal?
  • The role of balance in a life to create happiness - can you be happy with a huge emphasis on one or other aspect of your life: work/health/family/spirit/friends/community/intellect?
  • St. Therese of Lisieux - why was she Rubin's spiritual master?  What is a spiritual master?
  • Who are our spiritual masters? 
  • Which quotations in the book resonated most strongly with us? "The days are long but the years are short", "It's easy to be heavy; it's hard to be light".
  • Rubin accepts she has 'snappy' tendencies - did we find her to be particularly so?
  • Did we want to do any of the resolutions?
  • Rubin observed that "Outer order contributes to inner calm". Is this a universal rule, or does it only apply to certain types of people/personalities?
  • The concept that charitable giving makes you wealthier, rather than the wealthier being more charitable.
  • Control/order/choices - in what ways do these concepts contribute to personal happiness?
  • What did we enjoy doing as 10 year olds? How do those activities feature in our lives today?
  • Was this a 'self-help' book? 

And then we were sidetracked into:

  • Could Oprah be a spiritual master?
  • The concept of happiness fog in relation to children
  • Writing life plans - the idea of starting with your own obituary and working backwards from that - what do you want to be said about you, and what are you doing to make that a reality?
  • Why was"the pursuit of happiness" included in the US Declaration of Independence?
  • The idea of automatically saying "yes" rather than "no" to children - and framing the rest of the sentence to actually communicate what you want to say: i.e "Yes, you can have a cupcake, just as soon as you finish all the vegetables" vs "No, you can't have a cupcake, you haven't finished your vegetables." Is this effective?
  • What would a 3rd world definition of happiness look like? 
  • Can you be happy in isolation, or does happiness require social bonds?  
  • Is it possible to consciously decide to be happy and make it happen?
  • Do low expectations (parental, one's own, society's) make it easier to be happy?

In other news we discussed:

  • Our delight at the newest addition to the No.1 Melbourne Ladies' Bookclub family - congratulations KE!


Ratings:
Range: 5 to 9.5
Average: 7.42

Next book: Fly Away Peter by David Malouf (chosen by Gypsy)

Monday, 16 April 2012

April book: The Happiness Project by Gretchen Rubin




The Happiness Project 


By Gretchen Rubin


(Chosen by Fairlie)





Some background links to get you started:






Friday, 30 March 2012

Minutes March book: Letter to D

Letter to D: A Love Story


by Andre Gorz
(translated by Julie Rose)


chosen by T-Rex




T-Rex did not just choose this book because it was under the 300 page limit we've set this year! She read it when it was first published and loved it then. She's read it twice since.  She wonders if perhaps she's just a hopeless romantic?


About the author: 
Andre Gorz was a French writer and philosopher. He was born Gerhard Hirsh in Vienna, and spent the war years in Switzerland, moving to Paris in 1949. After working for the pacifist group Citizens of the World, Gorz entered journalism.  He was a supporter of Jean-Paul Sartre's existentialist version of Marxism after World War Two,  and in the aftermath of the May 1968 student riots, he became more concerned with political ecology. In the 1960s and 1970s, he was a main theorist in the New Left movement. His central theme was wage labour issues such as liberation from work, the just distribution of work, social alienation, and a guaranteed basic income. His final book was “Lettre à D,”  an homage to his gravely ill wife of over fifty years, Dorine. On September 22, 2007, they committed suicide together.

(General biographical details from Wikipedia and marxists.org) 


What the publisher says about the book: 
The heartbreakingly romantic testament to true love that became a beloved bestseller in France makes its worldwide English language debut in Australia. It is impossible not to be moved by this exquisitely touching story, the ultimate love letter from a man to the woman he loves more than life itself, written after he discovers she is dying. ′I have to appreciate the story of our love piece by piece to appreciate its full meaning. It′s allowed us to become who we are now, living side by side, and only for each other ... Lately I′ve fallen in love with you all over again ...′ A year after Letter to D was published, a single sheet of paper pinned to the door for the cleaning lady marked the final chapter in a love affair that remained to the end as intense and passionate as their first encounter, love at first sight, almost 60 years before. In the bedroom lying peacefully side by side were the bodies of author André Gorz and his terminally ill wife Dorine. They simply could not have lived without each other. But this book is not about death - it′s about life and love, and what a love. Of all the millions of words André Gorz wrote as one of the 20th century′s leading social philosophers, pioneering ecologist and associate of Jean-Paul Sartre and Simone de Beauvoir, none will be remembered as long as this beautiful and moving tribute to his lover and wife, Dorine.
What we discussed about the book: 

  • Was this book written for publication, or was it intended as a private letter?
  • What did we know about Andre Gorz and his other works? Why is he not as well known as say, Sartre?
  • In what ways did his philosophy differ from others at the time?
  • Was he a happy, contended man? How did he lack comfort in his life?
  • Had he taken Dorine for granted? Was he self-absorbed? Is what ways was she understanding?
  • What did the following quote mean? 
"On paper, I could cite Hero and Leandre, Tristan and Isolda, Romeo and Juliette and show how love is the mutual fascination of two individuals based precisely on what is least definable about them, least socialisable, most resistant to the roles and images of themselves that society imposes on them. We could share almost everything because we had almost nothing to start with.


  • Is this a book of regret? An apology? An attempt to set the record straight?
  • Was Gorz the person Dorine deserved?
  • Could the love they shared have had room for children?
  • Was the statement at the end, "I don't want to be there for your cremation; I don't want to be given an urn with your ashes in it," more about Gorz or Dorine? Is there any other way it could have been written?
  • What happened during the 30 years she was ill?
  • Did we find the language used poetic?
  • Did the translator meet her aim to "nail that distinctive voice - the voice of truth, rare and particular, full of love yet free of any sentimentality."? 



And then we were sidetracked into: 

  • How is philosophy taught in Australian schools?
  • Would an Australian write a book like this? If so, who? 
  • Would a book that is a glowing story of love be as popular as one dishing the dirt?
  • Is it easier to share criticisms of our loved ones with our friends than singing their praises?
  • How true is the belief that, "a good relationship is more about tolerating their faults than appreciating/celebrating their assets"?
  • What is the nature of an artist's ego? 



In other news, we discussed: 

  • Do you choose who you fall in love with?
  • Leeches. Gross.



Ratings: 
Range: 6.5 to 9.5
Average: 7.56


Next book: The Happiness Project by Gretchen Rubin (chosen by Fairlie)

Wednesday, 7 March 2012

March book: Letter to D by Andre Gorz

March book: Letter to D


by Andre Gorz


(chosen by T-Rex)








Some background links to get you started:

Minutes February book: Room

Room


by Emma Donoghue


(chosen by CH)






CH  chose this book in an attempt to redeem herself after the reception of her last choice (Imperial Bedrooms). She asked three women whose opinions she admires to suggest titles and this was one of them.


About the author:


Born in Dublin, Ireland, in 1969, Donoghue is the youngest of eight children. She attended Catholic convent schools in Dublin, apart from one eye-opening year in New York at the age of ten. She has a  first-class honours BA in English and French from University College Dublin. She moved to England, and received a PhD (on the concept of friendship between men and women in eighteenth-century English fiction) from the University of Cambridge. She has  earned a living as a writer, since she was 23. After years of commuting between England, Ireland, and Canada, she settled in London, Ontario, in 1998, where she lives with her partner and two children.


(General biographical details from the author's website)


What the publisher says about the book:

The story of a mother, her son, a locked room and the outside world Jack is five and, like any little boy, excited at the prospect of presents and cake. He's looking forward to telling his friends it's his birthday, too. But although Jack is a normal child in many ways – loving, funny, bright, full of energy and questions – his upbringing is far from ordinary: Jack's entire life has been spent in a single room that measures just 12 feet by 12 feet; as far as he's concerned, Room is the entire world.


He shares this world with his mother, with Plant, and tiny Mouse (though Ma isn't a fan and throws a book at Mouse when she sees him). There's TV too, of course – and the cartoon characters he thinks of as his friends – but Jack knows that nothing else he sees on the screen is real. Old Nick, on the other hand, is all too real, but only visits at night – like a bat – when Jack is meant to be asleep and hidden safely in Wardrobe. And only Old Nick has the code to Door, which is otherwise locked...Told in Jack's voice, Room is the story of a mother's love for her son, and of a young boy's innocence.
What we discussed about the book:

  • In what ways is the concept of 'motherhood' the inspiration for this book?
  • How did Ma interpret the role of mother - storytelling, health, exercise, education, manners? 
  • What Ma a good mother? If the author was aiming to create the 'best mother' did she succeed?
  • Was there any hint of Ma seeing a reflection of Old Nick in Jack?
  • Who's story was this? Ma's? Jack's? 
  • How did the author ensure it was NOT Old Nick's story?
  • How did the captivity affect Jack's development? Did he have any notion of himself as a separate entity to Ma? 
  • How did we feel reading the escape scene? What devices did the author use to heighten that tension?
  • How was our experience of the sense of claustrophobia in Room created?
  • Ma's mental state post-escape. What triggered her depression and suicide attempt?
  • In what ways was Ma brave?
  • What role did routine play as a coping mechanism for Ma? What happened post-escape?
  • Were all the items in Room named (Door, Wardrobe etc) to create a sense of community for Jack?
  • Did Ma maintain a sense of hope? How?
  • How did we experience Jack's 5 year-old voice? Was it authentic? How is oral language development influenced?
  • Was it plausible that Old Nick would not have checked that Jack was dead?
  • How old did we think Old Nick was?
  • The ripples caused in the outside world by Ma's abduction - e.g. parents' separation
  • Was this a positive book? Was there a sense of hope at the end?
And then we were sidetracked into:

  • In what ways did this book remind us of the film 'Life is Beautiful'? How were they similar?
  • Why do victims in these types of crime often not hate the perpetrators? Is it a form of Stockholm Syndrome?
  • The benefits of child-raising in an environment which is not over-stimulated, and in which you can devote large amounts of one-on-one time to the child.
  • What motivates people to carry out crimes such as this one?
In other news, we discussed:

  • Cold case homicides. What developments of technology allow 30 year old cases to be solved?
  • Updates on various medical issues affecting those close to various No.1 Ladies. Our love, best wishes and support to everyone involved.
Ratings:
Range: 7 to 9.5
Average: 8.25


Next book: Letter to D by Andre Gorz (chosen by T-Rex)

Saturday, 11 February 2012

February book: Room by Emma Donoghue

Room


by Emma Donoghue


(chosen by CH)






Some background links to get you started:


Friday, 25 November 2011

Books read in 2011


The ratings recorded below reflect an average of the members' ratings (out of ten) of their personal experience of the reading of that book.

Lovesong by Alex Miller (8.0)

Dogboy  by Eva Hornung (7.67)

The Portrait of a Lady by Henry James (9.0*)

The Secret Scripture by Sebastian Barry (7.9)

Franklin and Eleanor: An Extraordinary Marriage by Hazel Rowley (8.35)

Freedom  by Jonathan Franzen (5.28)

Rocks in the Belly  by Jon Bauer (7.06)

The Group  by Mary McCarthy (7.25)

Let the Great World Spin by Colum McCann (8.67)

Bereft by Chris Wolmersley (8.0)


* Only two No.1 Melbourne Ladies finished the book, so rating based on two scores.

Minutes November book: Bereft

Bereft

by Chris Wolmersley

(chosen by JP)



JP initially chose Cloud Atlas by David Mitchell, but decided to read it first before confirming her choice.  It is a series of independent short stories which are all interlinked, but JP found it very difficult to read, and fearing the other No.1 Melbourne Ladies would find the same she decided not to risk a low rating! In her last minute, frantic scramble to find an alternative, Bereft became her 'it'll do' book.

About the author:

Chris Womersley’s fiction and reviews have appeared in Granta, The Best Australian Stories 2006, 2010 and 2011, Griffith REVIEW, Meanjin and The Age. His debut novel, The Low Road, won the Ned Kelly Award for Best First Fiction. His second novel, Bereft, won the Australian Book Industry Award for Literary Fiction and the Indie Award for Fiction, and was shortlisted for the Miles Franklin Literary Award, The Age fiction prize and the Australian Literature Society Gold Medal.

(general biographical detail from publisher's website)

What the publisher says about the book:
It is 1919. The Great War has ended, but the Spanish flu epidemic is raging across Australia. Schools are closed, state borders are guarded by armed men, and train travel is severely restricted. There are rumours it is the end of the world.
In the NSW town of Flint, Quinn Walker returns to the home he fled ten years earlier when he was accused of an unspeakable crime. Aware that his father and uncle would surely hang him, Quinn hides in the hills surrounding Flint. There, he meets the orphan Sadie Fox — a mysterious young girl who seems to know more about the crime than she should.
A searing gothic novel of love, longing and justice, Bereft is about the suffering endured by those who go to war and those who are forever left behind.

What we discussed about the book:
  • How would we describe this novel if asked to pinpoint its genre? Ghost story? Crime fiction? Literary fiction?  Magic realism? Do such labels matter? Do they affect how likely we are to pick up a book in the first place?
  • Did we think Sadie was real? What influenced our thoughts about this?
  • Sadie was originally written as a boy - how would this have changed the story?
  • What were our feelings towards the mother? Did we want her to find out the truth before she died?
  • Could Quinn have done more at the time of Sadie's death? What motivated the actions he took?
  • Did we have any doubts about Quinn's character throughout the story?  Did we believe his version of events?
  • How reliable is the third-person narrator?
  • How multi-dimensional was Robert Dalton? Did we find aspects of him almost a caricature?
  • What was the purpose of the sacrifical lamb scene?
  • How the author used language to paint quite graphic images (e.g. the representation of war, rape scenes, the lamb scene)
  • What was the point of the mystic imagery built up throughout the novel in relation to Sadie? Was it used to the best effect? Were we expecting it to go further and push into the realms of magic realism?
  • Were the horrors at home shown to be worse than the horrors of war?
  • How did we think Dalton had power over Gracie?
  • How did the visits Quinn made to his mother create almost a Scherazade-style telling of the story?
  • The impact of the idea that there isn no word to describe the mother who has lost a child. Is 'bereft' that word?
  • What was the purpose of the seance? Was it a way to connect the living and the dead in a 'plausible' way?
  • Was it credible that Dalton found Sadie in the dark and without a tracker - the two things that Sadie said he wouldn't be able to do?
  • Did Part Four (The Angel of Death) work for us?
  • Was it a satisfying or unsatisfying ending? What did we think had happened?
  • Our favourite passage from the book:
His mother sighed. 'It is a strange bargain one makes with the gods - that in return for the purest love imaginable one must endure the constant fear that something dreadful will happen to your child, and that it will be your fault for bringing them into the world. The number of times I thought of you. Mothers never believe their children are dead. I have seen it in others, the ones with sons killed in the war. God, it's awful. Months after they have received those telegrams they still stand at their kitchen windows and watch the gate for a sign of them. I wake in the night. One's child,' she went on in a trembling voice, 'is always one's child, no matter what age they might be. You worry when your child makes a noise, when he doesn't. It's a terrible kind of love. Terrible.'

And then we were sidetracked into:
  • The concept of love a mother has for a child - the responsibility that comes with that
  • The impact of the Spanish flu on Australia/the world in the post -World War 1 period.
In other news, we discussed:
  • Imported food - the testing requirements...are they stringent enough? Is Australian food subjected to equally stringent testing?
  • How delicious Gypsy's desserts were - especially given her oven was broken, and she'd had to impose on her neighbours to actually cook them!
Ratings:
Range: 7 to 9
Average: 8

Next book: Room by Emma Donoghue (chosen by CH)

November book: Bereft by Chris Wolmersley

Bereft

by Chris Wolmersley

(chosen by JP)




Some background links to get you started:

Minutes October book: Let the Great World Spin

Let the Great World Spin

by Colum McCann

(chosen by JM)






JM chose this book after having four book choices in mind, but no idea which one to choose.  During a girls' weekend she received a strong recommendation to select Let the Great World Spin and she went with that.

About the author:

Colum McCann was born in Dublin in 1965 and began his career as a journalist in The Irish Press. In the early 1980's he took a bicycle across North America and then worked as a wilderness guide in a program for juvenile delinquents in Texas. After a year and a half in Japan, he and his wife moved to New York where they currently live with their three children.

He has won numerous international literary awards and his fiction has been published in over thirty languages.

(general autobiographical details from the author's website)

What the publisher says about the book:


New York, August 1974: a man is walking in the sky. Between the newly built Twin Towers, the man twirls through the air. Far below, the lives of complete strangers spin towards each other: Corrigan, a radical Irish monk working in the Bronx; Claire, a delicate Upper East Side housewife reeling from the death of her son; Lara, a drug-addled young artist; Gloria, solid and proud despite decades of hardship; Tillie, a hooker who used to dream of a better life; and Jazzlyn, her beautiful daughter raised on promises that reach beyond the skyline of New York. In the shadow of one reckless and beautiful act, these disparate lives will collide, and be transformed for ever.

What we discussed about the book:
  • What does this book say about America 'burning from the inside out"? (see Colum McCann interview).
  • In what ways is this "a 9/11 book"?  Is it a book of hope?
  • How did the 1970s parallel the late 20th C, early 21st C? (e.g. Vietnam vs Afghanistan/Iraq)
  • Could this book have been set anywhere but New York? How is the city itself a character?
  • Could we follow all the interlinking characters? (e.g. Who were the people who spoke on the public telephones? Was Tag the boy who answered the phone?)
  • Was Tag's photograph intended as a foreshadowing of the 9/11 attack?
  • Could we see the links between stories coming, or did they surprise us?
  • In what ways were Corrigan and Jazzlyn the Twin Towers? What did the wire between them represent?
  • Were we obsessed throughout the book about how the wire-walker would get the wire across between the two buildings?
  • Did we find the book slow-paced or about right?
  • Examples of the vivid language used - the genius of the author in painting visual pictures with words.
  • Were we surprised by who Ciaran married?
  • Who were our favourite characters? Why? In what ways did we empathise with Claire and Gloria particularly?
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • If this is a book of hope - have the years since 2006 lived up to that expectation?
  • Was the font in this book too small to read comfortably? Does our concern about this indicate we are getting old?
  • The idea that people can brush each other's lives, barely connecting and yet the impact can send ripples

In other news, we discussed:
  • The difficulty of trying to watch the AFL Grand Final live while on holiday in Italy
  • Steve Jobs untimely passing.
  • We declared that 2012 is to be "little book year" - all book choices are to be 300 pages or less. This is a challenge, not a restriction!

Ratings:
Range: 8 to 9
Average: 8.67

Next book: Bereft by Chris Womersley (chosen by JP)

October book: Let the Great World Spin by Colum McCann

Let the Great World Spin

by Colum McCann







Some background links to get you started:

Wednesday, 23 November 2011

Minutes September book: The Group


The Group

by Mary McCarthy

(Chosen by KM)


KM chose this book on the recommendation of her GP who has also recommended several of KM's other book choices (The Gargoyle, The Guernsey Potato Peel Pie Literary Society, Water for Elephants).

About the author:

Mary Therese McCarthy was born in 1912 in Seattle, Washington. Her parents became victims of the influenza epidemic of 1918 and the siblings were taken in by their great-aunt and her new husband,  and subjected to a horrible life depicted in McCarthy's work, Memories of a Catholic Girlhood (1957). After six years, Mary was taken back to Seattle to live with her maternal grandparents,  and her brothers were sent to boarding school. Mary moved to her grandparents' upper-class home and enjoyed a life of luxury. Her grandparents wanted Mary to have an excellent education and enrolled her good schools.  From there she went on to Vassar College in Poughkeepsie, New York, and graduated, Phi Beta Kappa, with her bachelor's degree in 1933.

Following commencement McCarthy moved to New York City and married Harold Johnsrud, an aspiring playwright, the first of her four husbands.

Mary McCarthy was the author of twenty-eight books during her lifetime, both fiction and non-fiction. Her novels were partially autobiographical, and many times her characters were based on her acquaintances.

She died of cancer in 1989, aged 77.

(general biographical detail from here)

What the publisher says about the book:
The Group follows eight graduates from exclusive Vassar College as they find love and heartbreak, forge careers, gossip and party in 1930s Manhattan.
The Group can be seen as the original Sex and the City. It is the first novel to frankly portray women's real lives, exploring subjects such as sex, contraception, motherhood and marriage.

What we discussed about the book:
  • We started the discussion by each confessing to how much of the book we had actually read - JM was the winner at three-quarters of the way through!
  • Why did we find this a difficult book to get through?
  • How does this novel contribute to our understanding of the status and roles of women in the 1930s in America?
  • Was it difficult to keep track of the eight "group" members through the book? Was there continuity of their stories?
  • The nature of women's friendship - how did these women support each other?
  • What was the significance of starting with a wedding and ending with a funeral?
  • In what ways do 'occasions' bring the Group together?
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • How is this novel like Sex and the City?
  • In what ways did the friendships between the women in the two books (or the SITC TV show) differ? How were they similar?
  • How would this novel have been received when it was first published in 1963? Were any of the topics considered taboo at the time?
In other news:
  • We discussed shoe-sizing in Asia. Is it possible to get size 9 or 10 shoes there? 
  • We admired the photos from T-Rex's sojourn in Paris.

Ratings:
Range: 7-7.5
Average: 7.25

Next book: Let the Great World Spin by Colum McCann (chosen by JM)