Friday, 21 November 2008

Minutes November Book: The Time Traveler’s Wife by Audrey Niffenegger


Minutes November Book: The Time Traveler’s Wife by Audrey Niffenegger

(chosen by Domestic Goddess)


Domestic Goddess chose this book because she wanted something uplifting. She liked the science-fiction aspect to it, combined with a love story.

Audrey Niffenegger is an artist and a professor at the Columbia College Chicago Center for Book and paper Arts, where she teaches writing, letterpress printing, and fine edition book production. She is in her thirties. The Time Traveler's Wife is her first novel.

(biographical details sourced from readinggroupguides.com)

What the publisher says about the book:

This extraordinary, magical novel is the story of Clare and Henry who have known each other since Clare was six and Henry was thirty-six, and were married when Clare was twenty-two and Henry thirty. Impossible but true, because Henry is one of the first people diagnosed with Chrono-Displacement Disorder: periodically his genetic clock resets and he finds himself pulled suddenly into his past or future. His disappearances are spontaneous and his experiences are alternately harrowing and amusing. The Time Traveler's Wife depicts the effects of time travel on Henry and Clare's passionate love for each other with grace and humour. Their struggle to lead normal lives in the face of a force they can neither prevent nor control is intensely moving and entirely unforgettable.
What we discussed about the book:

  • The non-linear nature of the book. How did we read it? Were we able to rationalise the interlocking time-frames?
  • Was Henry’s violence a survival mechanism? Did his lack of clothing highlight his vulnerability?
  • Did the book “transport and transfix “us?
  • Why did stress seem to trigger the time travel?
  • In what ways did the time-travel explore different perspectives on Clare and Henry’s relationship?
  • Is this science-fiction? What constitutes science-fiction?
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • How would the ability to time-travel alter your perspective on events?
  • Would the ability to time travel be a curse? Knowing things but being powerless to change them.
And in other news:
  • Is the Thermomix the eight wonder of the world?
  • How many of us admit to having watched Bold and the Beautiful, Days of our Lives and/or The Young and the Restless at some point in our lives? And how easy is it to pick the storyline right up again after 10 years break?
Ratings:

Ratings range: 5 to 10
Ratings average: 7.44
(three DNFs were the lowest three marks)

Next book: Diary of a Bad Year by J.M Coetzee

Saturday, 15 November 2008

November book: The Time Traveler's Wife by Audrey Niffenegger



The Time Traveler's Wife
by Audrey Niffenegger

(Chosen by Domestic Goddess)



Some background links to get you started:

Wednesday, 12 November 2008

Minutes October Book: In Defence of Food by Michael Pollan



Minutes October Book: In Defence of Food by Michael Pollan

(chosen by Fairlie)


In memory of our friend, S



Fairlie chose this book because she heard Michael Pollan speak at the Sydney Writers Festival and he was very impressive. He has a science/journalism background and as a result has done a lot of research into nutrition. Fairlie saw and heard him speak another time (also at the Writers Festival) and this clinched it for her - it was a book for her bookclub!

Michael Pollan is the author, most recently, of In Defense of Food: An Eater's Manifesto. His previous book, The Omnivore's Dilemma: A Natural History of Four Meals (2006), was named one of the ten best books of 2006 by the New York Times and the Washington Post. He is also the author of The Botany of Desire: A Plant's-Eye View of the World (2001); A Place of My Own (1997); and Second Nature (1991). A contributing writer to the New York Times Magazine, Pollan is the recipient of numerous journalistic awards. Pollan served for many years as executive editor of Harper's Magazine and is now the Knight Professor of Science and Environmental Journalism at UC Berkeley. His articles have been anthologized in Best American Science Writing (2004); Best American Essays (1990 and 2003) and the Norton Book of Nature Writing. He lives in the Bay Area with his wife, the painter Judith Belzer, and their son, Isaac.
(biographical details sourced from the author's website.)

What the publisher says about the book:

"Eat food. Not too much. Mostly plants." These simple words go to the heart of Michael Pollan's In Defence of Food. Humans used to know how to eat well, Pollan argues. But the balanced dietary lessons that were once passed down through generations have been confused, complicated, and distorted by food industry marketers, nutritional scientists, and journalists – all of whom have much to gain from our dietary confusion. Indeed, real food is fast disappearing from the marketplace, to be replaced by "nutrients," and plain old eating by an obsession with nutrition that is, paradoxically, ruining our health, not to mention our meals. Michael Pollan's bracing and eloquent manifesto shows us how we might start making thoughtful food choices that will enrich our lives and our palates and enlarge our sense of what it means to be healthy.


What we discussed about the book:
  • The message of the book was simple and it was not rocket science - we knew or suspected the message but having it in black and white really brought it home.
  • When you take out all of the fat in foods what do you put back in?
  • Is what manufacturers put back in "good" for human consumption?
  • Food lobbying - is it as strong in Australia as in USA and other countries?
  • Is corn syrup in everything?
  • Why has the meat industry changed so dramatically in Australia in last 5 yrs - with increased use of antibiotics and hormones?
  • National Heart Foundation health tick - what do companies have to do (or not do) to get the tick?
  • Upsizing of meals - is this tied to commodity prices? Are supermarkets downsizing their packaging whilst increasing price of manufactured food items?
  • Lengthy discussion regarding full fat (yogurt, cheese etc) versus skim or low fat products and number of eggs that are now considered healthy in daily diet.
  • Chemical processes to produce powdered egg or a substitute product (eg fruit flavours) - is it as healthy as using fresh egg or fruits in manufactured products? Does this apply to whole host of other products - eg milk, yogurt?
  • Are we losing our sense of community due to shopping in supermarkets - no longer knowing local butcher, baker etc?
  • Are the range of products available in Australia declining? Is this a positive development? Is it squeezing smaller (perhaps organic focused) manufacturers out of the market?
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • Are the burgers really bigger and tastier at Hungry Jacks'?
  • What sort of food colouring and "make up" for the food do advertisers (via professional food stylists) use in those gorgeous photos of succulent food?

And in other news:

  • Muck up days - why was a whole Yr 12 Grade suspended at a prominent boys school in Melbourne?
  • Boarding school in Perth - one member reminisced about a headmistress who had a really strict view of life and really enforced the rules but deep down had a soft spot in her heart.
  • We discussed the rumour that there may be a document dating back to the late 90s regarding the "rules" of our bookclub. Some members will search their archives and report back - this drew great peels of laughter....and led us into a discussion that there may also be a "briefing document" that was provided to one new member with a run down of the personalities of other members!
  • Type 2 diabetes - explanation of the difference between this and Type 1. Symptoms - thirsty, loss of concentration, tiredness. We had a look at an insulin kit and explanation of what a person with Type 2 diabetes has to do each day to maintain their insulin level.
  • And then we decided that we really should stop chatting at 11.00 pm so the host can get us out of their home...

On a very sad note:
We discussed the funeral arrangements for our dear friend and previous administrator and minute secretary - S. She was loved by many and will be so greatly missed. Our love and thoughts go to her husband, her daughter and their families.

Ratings:

Ratings range: 6.5 to 8.5

Ratings average: 7.43

Next book: The Time Traveller's Wife by Audrey Niffenegger

Thank you to Domestic Goddess for compiling these minutes!

Tuesday, 14 October 2008

October book: In Defence of Food by Michael Pollan



October book: In Defence of Food by Michael Pollan

(chosen by Fairlie)


Some background links to get you started:

Tuesday, 30 September 2008

Minutes September Book: Water for Elephants

Minutes September Book: Water for Elephants


by Sara Gruen


(chosen by KM)


KM chose this book on the recommendation of her GP who is also in a bookclub and often shares advice and feedback about book choices. She said that she had flown through this book and that it was a great read.


Sara is a Canadian-born dual citizen (Canadian and American) who moved to the United States in 1999 for a technical writing job. When she was laid off two years later, instead of looking for another job, she started writing fiction full-time. She’s currently working on Ape House, her fourth novel.

Sara lives with her husband, three children, two dogs, two cats, three goats, and horse in an environmentalist community.


(biographical details sourced from the author's own website)


What the publisher says about the book:


A great, glorious, big-hearted novel set in a travelling circus touring the back blocks of America during the great depression of the early 1930s. It's a story of love and hate, trains and circuses, dwarves and fat ladies, horses and elephants - or, to be specific, one elephant, Rosie, star of the Benzini Bros Most Spectacular Show on Earth . . .

What we discussed about the book:
  • The extent to which the detailed research of the depression era and circuses enhanced the atmosphere and experience of this book
  • The manner in which Sara Gruen wrote this book - she started with a very detailed outline
  • The inclusion of mini-plots and themes within the story -e.g prohibition, elderly care
  • Did Jacob have dementia?
  • What was the nature of August's mental state? How did we feel about his treatment of animals?
  • Was Walter the archetypal clown - happy smile, but so sad?
  • The careful observation of the dialogue between the working men. In what ways was this created by Gruen?
  • Were there parallels between this story and that of Jacob in the Bible?
  • The use of symbolism in the story - eg the crossover between Rosie/Rosemary...rosemary is the symbol for remembrance.
  • What did water represent throughout the book?
  • Was the ending credible? Could it only happen in a circus?
Then we were sidetracked into:
  • The issue of homelessness during the Great Depression. What type of people became hobos? What were the circumstances that caused this?
  • Elderly care. Why are there not enough places? Is the standard of care offered adequate? How do we wish to be cared for when we are elderly?
  • Can elephants physically smile?
  • Do circuses still have animal performances?
  • Our own memories of childhood circuses: popcorn, sawdust, circus trucks, animals.
  • Why do clowns scare children?
And in other news:
  • We discussed the paucity of good part-time jobs for mums returning to the workforce
  • We talked about night-nannies and sleep schools to train babies and toddlers to sleep through the night
Ratings:

Ratings range: 7 to 9.5
Ratings average: 7.94

Next book: In Defence of Food by Michael Pollan

Thursday, 11 September 2008

September book: Water for Elephants by Sara Gruen



September book: Water for Elephants
by Sara Gruen

(chosen by KM)



Some background links to get you started:

Tuesday, 26 August 2008

Minutes August book: The Mitford Girls by Mary S. Lovell

August book: The Mitford Girls

by Mary S. Lovell

(chosen by T-Rex)



T-Rex read The Mitford Girls when it was first published in 2003 and has recommended it to several friends. This time she wanted to choose a book that she had read and enjoyed rather than basing her choice on an unread recommendation.

Mary S.Lovell was formerly an accountant and company director. She broke her back in a riding accident when she was 40 years old (1981) and wrote her first book while recovering. She continued to write in her spare time once she returned to work.

Her biography of aviatrix Beryl Markham, Straight on Till Morning, was researched and written in under a year and became an immediate international bestseller. At this point, Lovell decided to retire from accountancy to write full time.

The Mitford Girls (titled The Sisters in the USA) a biography of the celebrated Mitford sisters, was first published in September 2001 (paperback August 2002) and has been another international best-seller.

Lovell is recognised for her intensive research methods and all her non-fiction books are extensively annotated.

She regards herself as "a storyteller, rather than a literary writer. Everybody enjoys a good fast-paced story and that is what I try to write, only my stories are fact, not fiction. For me there is always an added frisson of enjoyment when I know that what I'm reading about actually occurred, and is not simply a figment of someone's imagination."

She lives in the New Forest in Hampshire, England and is currently writing a family biography of the Churchills.

(Biographical details sourced from the
author's website)

What the publisher says about the book:

THE MITFORD GIRLS tells the true story behind the gaiety and frivolity of the six Mitford daughters - and the facts are as sensational as any novel: Nancy, whose right social existence masked an obsessional doomed love which soured her success; Pam, a countrywoman married to one of the best brains in Europe; Diana, an iconic beauty, who was already married when at 22 she fell in love with Oswald Moseley, the leader of the British fascists; Unity, who romantically in love with Hitler, became a member of his inner circle before shooting herself in the temple when WWII was declared; Jessica, the family rebel, who declared herself a communist in the schoolroom and the youngest sister, Debo, who became the Duchess of Devonshire.This is an extraordinary story of an extraordinary family, containing much new material, based on exclusive access to Mitford archives.

What we discussed about the book:

(apologies for brief nature of the minutes, your bookclub webmistress was absent from this meeting - thanks to Elster for forwarding through a few notes!)

  • How different each of the girls was
  • How political each of the girls was
  • The extent to which each of the girls was endowed with literary talent (one of the No.1 Ladies had read Love in a Cold Climate, but was disappointed with it)
  • The influence their mother had on the girls
  • Why would MI5 records indicate that they condidered Diana more 'dangerous' than Moseley?
  • The non-judgemental style in which the book is written - does the author offer any judgement, or are the facts laid out for the reader to make those decisions?

Then we were sidetracked into:

  • Max Moseley's latest activities and the press coverage they have created
  • Examining some photos of Chatsworth - home of the only surviving sister (Debo, Duchess of Devonshire)

Ratings:

Initial ratings range: 7.5 to 8.5

Initial ratings average: 8.0

Post-discussion ratings: no change

Next book: Water for Elephants by Sara Gruen

Friday, 15 August 2008

August book: The Mitford Girls by Mary S. Lovell


August book: The Mitford Girls

by Mary S. Lovell

(chosen by T-Rex)


Some background links to get you started:

Wednesday, 16 July 2008

Minutes July book: Love in the Time of Cholera by Gabriel Garcia Marquez

Love in the Time of Cholera

By Gabriel Garcia Marquez

(chosen by Fairlie)



As most of the No.1 Melbourne Bookclub Ladies know (because I tell them often enough) One Hundred Years of Solitude which is also by Gabriel Garcia Marquez still stands as my all-time favourite book. I hadn’t however, read anything else written by him, and had always meant to get around to reading Love in the Time of Cholera. My husband gave me a copy of it for Christmas so, motivated by the desire to read it and the fact it was sitting on my bedside table, I made it my bookclub choice.

Gabriel García Márquez was born in March of 1927 in the tiny Colombian banana town of Aracataca. The following year, the banana economy took a downturn and created a rift in the town. As a result, his parents struggled financially and García Márquez was raised by his maternal grandparents.

At the age of 19, he enrolled in the law program at the Universidad Nacional in Bogotá, but also had a passion for writing.

García Márquez met the then 13-year-old Mercedes Barcha Pardo in his hometown when he was 18 and proposed to her soon after. They married fourteen years later, and their love has lasted a lifetime. While he traveled after dropping out of law school, she waited for him in Colombia until he returned for her when she was 27-years-old.

García Márquez became a journalist after leaving law school and in 1954 he was sent to Rome on an assignment for his newspaper, and since then he has mostly lived abroad - in Paris, New York, Barcelona and Mexico – more or less in exile.

One Hundred Years of Solitude was published in 1967, and within a week all 8000 copies of the original printing had been sold. It was translated into many languages and won the Chianchiano Prize in Italy, the Best Foreign Book in France, the Rómulo Gallegos Prize and the Nobel Prize for Literature.

Love in the Time of Cholera was first published in 1982.

(general biographical details from here)

What the publisher says about the book:

In their youth, Florentino Ariza and Fermina Daza fall passionately in love. When Fermina eventually chooses to marry a wealthy, well-born doctor, Florentino is devastated, but he is a romantic. As he rises in his business career he whiles away the years in 622 affairs--yet he reserves his heart for Fermina. Her husband dies at last, and Florentino purposefully attends the funeral. Fifty years, nine months, and four days after he first declared his love for Fermina, he will do so again.


What we discussed about the book:

  • Why was cholera used as a device to reflect the properties of love?
  • What was the purpose of the emphasis on bodily functions, particularly in relation to Florentino?
  • In what way had Florentino “remained a virgin” for Fermina?
  • What was the nature of the relationship between Dr Urbino and Fermina – could it be described as love?
  • To what extent was Dr Urbino a modern man?
  • How many different types of love are portrayed in this book?
  • Is there a risk when reading a translation of a book written in another language that some significant subtlety may be lost? How does the fact that the Spanish words for cholera (el colera) and choler/anger (la colera) are so similar affect our understanding of the title of the book?
  • How did Garcia Marquez appeal to the senses in his descriptions. What effect did that have?
  • What would have happened after the last page? Would they have continued on the boat “forever”?
  • Why did we find Florentino such an unappealing character? In what ways does the steadfast pursuit of unrequited romantic love differ from obsessive stalking?
  • How did the decline and decay of the physical environment (e.g. the river) mirror the emotional content of the book?
  • How was magic realism employed in this novel?
Then we were sidetracked into:

  • What are the possibilities of love developing within an arranged relationship?
  • In cases where Ladies were reading this book for the second time several years after the first reading - why were their impressions of it so different?
  • Is there a case for a book being ‘the right book at the right time’? Is this book interpreted differently by 20-something readers than it is by 40-somethings?
  • The different approaches various cultures have towards death, funerals, inheritances.

And in other news, we discussed:

  • How gorgeous KM’s little boy is, when they paid us a surprise visit!
  • Why it is responsible to wear a helmet while skiing.
  • How various sayings in other languages do not translate directly into English – does for instance, “money open all tongues”? and do we “close the light”?
  • Is Apple the Chanel of the computer world?
  • Were record players (turntables) that stacked 5-6 vinyl LPs which dropped down as the one before finished, just as good as CD stackers in your carboot?

Ratings:

Initial rating range: we forgot to do initial ratings!
Initial rating average: n/a
Post-discussion range: 5.5 to 8.0
Post-discussion average: 6.57


Next book: The Mitford Girls by Mary S. Lovell (T-Rex’s choice)

Saturday, 12 July 2008

July book: Love in the Time of Cholera by Gabriel Garcia Marquez



July book: Love in the Time of Cholera


by Gabriel Garcia Marquez



(chosen by Fairlie)


Some background links to get you started:

Friday, 11 July 2008

Minutes June 2008 Book: The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas by John Boyne

The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas

by John Boyne

(chosen by JM)



JM was given this book as a birthday present, so figured she had to read it at some point and bookclub was as good a motivation as any. She had heard good feedback from other people that had read it and liked the size of the print!


John Boyne is an Irish writer, born in Dublin in 1971. He studied at Trinity College Dublin and the University of East Anglia, Norwich and has published six novels, a short novella for charity, some short stories, book reviews, articles and interviews with other writers. He’s two Irish Book Awards, and the Bisto Book of the Year Award as well as being shortlisted for the British Book Award, and the Hennessy Award

The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas spent 66 weeks at no.1 in Ireland and has been a bestseller in many countries. It’s sold more than 2.5 million copies worldwide, and has been made into a film.

(general biographical details from John Boyne’s own website)

What the publisher says about the book:

A story of innocence existing within the most terrible evil, this is the fictional tale of two young boys caught up in events entirely beyond their control.

Berlin 1942
When Bruno returns home from school one day, he discovers that his belongings are being packed in crates. His father has received a promotion and the family must move from their home to a new house far far away, where there is no one to play with and nothing to do. A tall fence running alongside stretches as far as the eye can see and cuts him off from the strange people he can see in the distance.

But Bruno longs to be an explorer and decides that there must be more to this desolate new place than meets the eye. While exploring his new environment, he meets another boy whose life and circumstances are very different to his own, and their meeting results in a friendship that has devastating consequences.

What we discussed about the book:
  • How would children interpret the book? How would their understanding of it be different from adult readers?
  • What is a young adult? What age of child would this book be suitable for?
  • Was the naivety of Bruno credible?
  • Does this novel require a suspension of disbelief in order to fully appreciate the core of the story?
  • Is the book depressing or is it a celebration of friendship?
  • How was the friendship portrayed from each of the boy’s perspectives? What was the ‘value’ of the friendship to each of the boys? Was it a meeting of each other’s needs?
  • How did the father reconcile his work with his personal character? Was he a good father?
  • Did the mother have an affair with the Lieutenant? Is that idea too much a reflection of adult reading between the lines?
  • What did the ending mean? “Not in this day and age.” How does that apply to current world events?
Then we were sidetracked into:
  • How exactly is pyjamas/pajamas spelled? Why did we have different versions on the books we had?
  • What makes a book a “young adult” book as opposed to an adult book?
  • How amazing it was that everyone present had actually finished the book. Was this a No.1 Melbourne Bookclub Ladies’ first?
  • What degree of violence is acceptable for children in various forms of media – e.g literature, DVDs, games? Is fantasy horror or violence more acceptable than portrayals of ‘real’ violence?
  • Did we see some similarities thematically between this book and The Kiterunner?
And in other news, we discussed:
  • How many eggs could a chicken be expected to lay in a day? (Ed note: I googled it, and I believe those of us who said one or less a day are right!)
  • The value of getting your personal colours and style evaluated.
  • Babysitting clubs. How do they work?

Ratings:

Initial rating range: 5.5 to 10.0
Initial rating average: 8.06
Post-discussion range: 5.5 to 10.0
Post-discussion average: 7.93


Next book: Love in the Time of Cholera by Gabriel Garcia Marquez

Tuesday, 10 June 2008

June book: The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas by John Boyne

The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas

by John Boyne


(chosen by JM)

A few background links to get you started:

Friday, 6 June 2008

Minutes May 2008 Book: Notes from an Exhibition by Patrick Gale



Notes from an Exhibition


by Patrick Gale


(chosen by KE)





KE chose this book because with her nursing background, she was fascinated by the idea of a book about the effect of bipolar disorder on a family.


Patrick Gale was born in 1962 on the Isle of Wight, where his father was a prison governor. He was the youngest of four children. The family moved to London, where his father ran Wandsworth Prison, then to Winchester.

Patrick began boarding as a Winchester College Quirister at the cathedral choir school, Pilgrim’s, then went on to Winchester College. He has an English degree from New College, Oxford.

He says he "has never had a grown-up job". His first two novels, The Aerodynamics of Pork and Ease were published in 1986. The following year he moved to Camelford near the north coast of Cornwall and now lives in the far west, on a farm near Land’s End.


(general biographical details from here)


What the publisher says about the book:

When troubled artist Rachel Kelly dies painting obsessively in her attic studio in Penzance, her saintly husband and adult children have more than the usual mess to clear up. She leaves behind an extraordinary and acclaimed body of work – but she also leaves a legacy of secrets and emotional damage it will take months to unravel.

A wondrous, monstrous creature, she exerts a power that outlives her. To her children she is both curse and blessing, though they all in one way or another reap her whirlwind, inheriting her waywardness, her power of loving – and her demons… Only their father's Quaker gifts of stillness and resilience give them any chance of withstanding her destructive influence and the suspicion that they came a poor second to the creation of her art.

The reader becomes a detective, piecing together the clues of a life – as artist, lover, mother, wife and patient – which takes them from contemporary Penzance to 1960s Toronto to St Ives in the 1970s. What emerges is a story of enduring love, and of a family which weathers tragedy, mental illness and the intolerable strain of living with genius.

Patrick Gale's latest novel shines with intelligence, humour and tenderness.


What we discussed about the book:

  • Does Gale write 'like a woman'? Is that even a valid question to ask? How does a woman write? Is there such a thing as a 'woman's voice' in writing?
  • What was Antony's role in the family dynamic?
  • What we thought about the 'notes from an exhibition' which opened each chapter. What did they add to our understanding of the story? What was their purpose? Did they offer us clues to unravel the story?
  • Is mental illness a symptom of genius or a cause?
  • How did Rachel manage her obsession for art and her relationships family? Is it possible to have a passion for something and maintain a family life?
  • What was the significance of Petroc's death both to Rachel and to the rest of the family after her death?
  • Did Rachel try to control or to mentor Morwenna's artistic talent?
  • Was Rachel actually pregnant at the institution? Or was that a figment of her imagination?
  • The role of the Quaker religion in the book. Did its quiet and reflective nature act as a counter-point to the manic and hysterical nature of Rachel's life?
  • What frightened Rachel so much?

Then we were sidetracked into:
  • The nature of bipolar disorder. Does it seem more prevalent nowadays? Or is it just that more people speak openly about it?
  • Were we attracted by the idea of the Quaker religion by its portrayal in this book?
  • Can a male author write female characters convincingly, and vice versa?
  • Do creative people see things a little differently to others? Is this a symptom of a mental illness, or just a different perspective?
  • Is it acceptable for people with bipolar disorder to choose not to take their meds in order to maintain a creative edge?
  • Are children more resilient than we give them credit for?

And in other news, we discussed:

  • The health risks of a shared communion cup at church. And which churches use incense?
  • What influence do books have on your life? Are there any books that you have read and have changed your life? Are they fiction or non-fiction?


Ratings:


Initial rating range: 6.0 to 8.5
Initial rating average: 7.1
Post-discussion range: 6.0 to 8.5
Post-discussion average: 6.9


Next book: The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas by John Boyne

Thursday, 15 May 2008

May book: Notes from an Exhibition by Patrick Gale


Notes from an Exhibition by Patrick Gale (chosen by KE)

Meeting date: Tuesday 20th May
Venue: Domestic Goddess's house









Some links for background information to get you started:

Thursday, 17 April 2008

Minutes April 2008 Book: The Secret River by Kate Grenville

The Secret River

by Kate Grenville

(chosen by Elster)



Elster chose this book on the recommendation of her neighbour. She read it last year and enjoyed it, so decided to choose it for bookclub.

Kate Grenville was born and currently lives in Sydney. She has an Arts degree from Sydney University and worked in the film industry before living in the UK and Europe for several years and starting to write.

She completed an MA in Creative Writing at the University of Colorado in 1980 and when she returned to Australia in 1983 she worked at the Subtitling Unit for SBS Television. Her first book, a collection of stories - Bearded Ladies - was published in 1984, and since then she's published six novels and four books about the writing process (one co-written with Sue Woolfe).

The Secret River has won many prizes, including the Commonwealth Prize for Literature and the Christina Stead Prize. Her other works of fiction have also won state and national awards. The Idea of Perfection won the Orange Prize. Her most recent book Searching for the Secret River is a memoir about the writing of The Secret River. It tells the story of the research behind the novel.

Kate Grenville's novels have been published in a number of countries, including in translation, and her books about the writing process are used in many creative writing courses.

(general biographical details from Kate Grenville's own website.)

What the publisher says about The Secret River:

In the early nineteenth century William Thornhill is transported from the slums of London to New South Wales for the term of his natural life. He arrives with his wife Sal and their children in a harsh land he cannot understand.

Eight years later, Thornhill sails up the Hawkesbury as a free man to claim a hundred acres. Aboriginal people already live on that river and Thornhill will soon have to make the most difficult decision of his life.

Inspired by research into her own family history, Kate Grenville's The Secret River is a tour de force, a powerful and groundbreaking story about life on the frontier.


What we discussed about the book:

  • To what extent did we empathise with the main characters?
  • How harshly did we judge their actions, particularly the indigenous relations. Were we able to experience the story without viewing it from a 21st century perspective?
  • How would we have behaved faced with the same situations as the characters? Could we have coped with frontier life in the way that Sal did?
  • In relation to the various examples of mistreatment of the Aboriginal people, what alternative courses of action may have been available to the settlers? Could William have informed authorities about the woman chained up? What would the implications of that course of action have been?
  • Did the flaws in William's character make it easier or harder for us to empathise with him?
  • The symbolism of the fish carved into the rock above the Thornhill's land. Was the placement of his large permanent house over the fish an attempt to wipe out the memory, or a reminder that no matter what was put on top of it, the land had always been someone else's first?
  • Why didn't the settlers learn from the Aborigines with regard to hunting and gathering food? What was the cultural mindset at the time that caused them to dismiss such obvious survival mechanisms as 'savage'?
  • The difficulties of communication between two societies that didn't share a language or cultural references. Were there differences in understanding of body language too? What examples were there of attempts to communicate being misinterpreted?
  • To what extent the convicts were victims of a rigid British class structure. Did we judge them less harshly than the authorities?
  • Was Sal representative of most settler women? Her stoic endurance of fearful and hard conditions made her an admirable character. How did we view the relationship between her and William?
  • How did the evocative, descriptive writing style heighten our experience of this book?

Then we were sidetracked into:

  • What role does historical fiction play in the representation of history? What responsibility does an historical fiction writer have to get the facts right?
  • Is it possible to empathise with a character whose actions you find abhorrent?
  • If hypothetical aliens arrived in our world, and we shared no language, cultural references or perhaps even body language, how would we communicate with them? Would our immediate response be one of repelling the invader? Or how would we communicate our welcome? How would we know whether they came in peace?
And in other news, we discussed:

  • Mobile phones. Is it possible to get one which just makes and receives calls and has no extra features we don't need?
  • Acceptance of cultural and religious rules passed down through generations. Which ones do we follow blindly because we've always done it, which ones do we question?
Ratings:
Initial rating average: 8.4
Initial rating range: 7.5 to 9.5
End of discussion ratings: no change

* Next month, the initial rating will be a silent rating.

Next book: Notes from an Exhibition by Patrick Gale

Wednesday, 9 April 2008

April book: The Secret River by Kate Grenville

The Secret River by Kate Grenville
(chosen by Elster)

Meeting date: Tuesday 15th April
Venue: Fairlie's house




Some links for background information to get you started:

Minutes March 2008 Book: What is the What by Dave Eggers



What is the What

by Dave Eggers

(chosen by CH)

CH chose this book on a recommendation from another bookclub which had given it a really high rating. She was told it was an "important book" with a really significant story which needs to be told. This appealed to CH, as she felt that the issue of the Sudan is difficult to understand and engage with, and the personal story provides a bridge into it.

Dave Eggers was born in 1970 in Boston, Massachusetts and attended the University of Illinois. He is married to writer, Vendela Vida and they live in San Francisco with their daughter, born in 2005.

Eggers began writing as a Salon.com editor. His first book was a memoir, A Heartbreaking Work of Staggering Genius (2000). It is about the author's struggle to raise his younger brother following the sudden deaths of their parents.

In 2002, Eggers published his first novel, You Shall Know Our Velocity. What Is the What: The Autobiography of Valentino Achak Deng is his second novel and it was a finalist for the 2006 National Book Critics Circle Award for Fiction.

Eggers is a founder of McSweeney's, an independent publishing house and currently teaches writing in San Francisco at a nonprofit tutoring centre and writing school for children that he co-founded with Vendela Vida in 2002. They have expanded the program by using volunteers to operate similar centres in Los Angeles, New York City, Seattle, Chicago, and Ann Arbor, Michigan.

(General biographical details from here)

The publisher's comments:

Separated from his family, Valentino Achak Deng becomes a refugee in war-ravaged southern Sudan. His travels bring him in contact with enemy soldiers, with liberation rebels, with hyenas and lions, with disease and starvation, and with deadly murahaleen (militias on horseback)—the same sort who currently terrorize Darfur. Based closely on actual experiences, What Is the What is heartrending and astonishing, filled with adventure, suspense, tragedy, and, finally, triumph.

What we discussed about the book:

  • How does this book portray hope as the primary driver of the human condition?
  • In what ways was Deng a charismatic character?
  • Is telling the story a healing process for Deng?
  • The Sudanese story of evolution - the cow or the what? What is the what? What is the cow? Does our society value the what over the cow?
  • The level of violence shown in the refugee camps, particularly towards women.
  • The flow of the narrative. In what ways did the jumping between past and present effect the telling of the story?
  • Was the book too long?
  • Was the font too small?

Then we were sidetracked into:

  • When a society experiences a total disregard for human life, how does it begin to rebuild? In what ways is 'civilisation' nurtured?
  • The idea that many children in the world today still grow up not knowing much about the world beyond their village. How does a lack of outside influences affect a society?

And in other news, we discussed:

  • Branded foods for kids in supermarkets. Is it right that food choices may be made on the basis of which superhero is on the packet rather than on its nutritional, economic and environmental impact. Should we just vote with our feet?
  • The politics of food choices. Do we consume way more than we really need to? And is too much of it over-packaged and over-refined? Fascinating photos of the weekly groceries for families around the world can be found here.
  • Packaging in school lunches. How can we minimise the plastic wrapping going to school each day?
  • The Uplift Fiji bra donation program. Which, of course, led us to...water-filled bras vs chicken fillets. Which is more natural looking?

Ratings

Initial rating average: 7.08

Initial rating range: 5 to 9

End of discussion rating average: 7.25

End of discussion rating range: 6 to 9

Next book: The Secret River by Kate Grenville (Elster's choice)

Friday, 29 February 2008

March book: What is the What by Dave Eggers



What is the What by Dave Eggers (chosen by CH)
Meeting date: March 18th
Venue: Gypsy's house






Some links for background information to get you started:

Review of book on ABC Radio National

New York Magazine book review

Dave Eggers entry in Wikipedia

Dave Eggers reading from What is the What on Youtube

Minutes Febuary 2008 Book: The Road by Cormac McCarthy



The Road
by Cormac McCarthy
(chosen by Gypsy)









Gypsy first read The Road last year and although she found it a good read, thought it was dark, dismal and depressing. When it came time to chose her bookclub book for this year, she read about two dozen books in a period of three weeks to pick just the perfect one. But to her dismay, none of them seemed ‘quite right’. In desperation, she remembered The Road and thought it would offer interesting fodder for discussion. Hence her choice.

Cormac McCarthy was born in 1933 in Providence, Rhode Island, and moved with his family to Knoxville, Tennessee, in 1937. He entered the University of Tennessee in 1951-1952 and was a liberal arts major.

In 1953, he joined the United States Air Force for four years and in 1957, he returned to the University of Tennessee. In 1961, he married fellow university student Lee Holleman and their son Cullen was born. He left university without getting a degree and moved to Chicago where he wrote his first novel. His marriage to Lee Holleman ended.

McCarthy's first novel, The Orchard Keeper, was published by Random House in 1965.
While on the ship traveling to Ireland in 1965, he met Anne DeLisle, who was a singer on the ship. He married her in England in 1966, and separated from her in 1976.

McCarthy now lives in the Tesuque, New Mexico, area, north of Santa Fe, with his third wife, Jennifer Winkley, and their son, John. He is a very private person and rarely grants interviews.

He has now had ten novels published.

Oprah Winfrey chose The Road as the April 2007 selection for her Book Club. McCarthy agreed to do his first ever television interview with her on The Oprah Winfrey Show. During the interview he told of the outright poverty he experienced at times during his career as a writer. He also spoke about raising a child at an advanced age, and how his eight-year-old son was the inspiration for The Road.

(general biographical details from here)

Description of The Road from Random House website:


A searing, postapocalyptic novel destined to become Cormac McCarthy’s masterpiece.

A father and his son walk alone through burned America. Nothing moves in the ravaged landscape save the ash on the wind. It is cold enough to crack stones, and when the snow falls it is gray. The sky is dark. Their destination is the coast, although they don’t know what, if anything, awaits them there. They have nothing; just a pistol to defend themselves against the lawless bands that stalk the road, the clothes they are wearing, a cart of scavenged food—and each other.

The Road is the profoundly moving story of a journey. It boldly imagines a future in which no hope remains, but in which the father and his son, “each the other’s world entire,” are sustained by love. Awesome in the totality of its vision, it is an unflinching meditation on the worst and the best that we are capable of: ultimate destructiveness, desperate tenacity, and the tenderness that keeps two people alive in the face of total devastation.


What we discussed about the book:

  • What was the cataclysmic event that had happened? Was it a nuclear war, global warming, mass-terrorism, meteor impact…? Does it matter to our reading of the novel? As readers, were we able to dull our curiosity for prior events to focus on the current story of the road?
  • To what extent is hope a motivator of the characters?
  • The ‘fire’ that the man refers to – what was it? Humanity? Hope? Continuity of the human race?
  • The extent to which the language used in dialogue was sparse and minimal.
  • The sense of colour (or lack of) throughout the book. In what ways did McCarthy create the greyness of the landscape? Do humans lose perception of colour when traumatized?
  • Was the mother’s choice selfish or selfless?
  • Were there parallels between the boy and Jesus?
  • To what extent will faith and hope endure in the face of desolation and destruction?
  • Is the greatest fear of a parent that of not being able to care for and protect their child until they are grown up?
  • To what extent did the man die with the guilt of abandoning the boy?
  • Were the characters left nameless (The man and the boy) in order to create an everyman experience for the reader?
  • To what extent did we empathise with the characters?


Then we were sidetracked into:

  • How visual images of horror lock into your brain/memory. Is this process different between men and women?
  • What is the core of humanity? Is it love, ceremony and survival?


And in other news, we discussed:

  • RR’s upcoming trip to Egypt. The rest of us were VERY jealous.
  • How well S went with her craniotomy and we all pass on our best wishes, prayers, happy thoughts (tick as appropriate) for the next stage of her treatment.
  • Sleep schools and sleep Nazis. We decided we were the perfect group to advice new mothers on babies sleeping as we had all failed Sleep 101 the first (and in some cases second) time around.
  • KE’s scary experience of discovering a burglar in her home and chasing him out of the house.
  • How Domestic Goddess discovered that a gift voucher for ‘XXXX waxing’ was not one which offered her four lots of half-leg waxing!

Ratings

We introduced a new system where books are rated straight up at the start of the discussion and then again at the end.

Initial rating
Average: 9.0
Range: 7.5 to 10

End of discussion rating
Average: 9.0
Range: 7.5 to 10


Next book: What is the What by Dave Eggers (CH’s choice)