Friday, 11 October 2019

October book: Boy Swallows Universe by Trent Dalton

Boy Swallows Universe

by Trent Dalton

Discussion to be led by CH



Some background links to get you started:


What we discussed about the book:
  • How the experience of this book may differ depending on whether it was 'read' as an audio book or a traditional written page book 
  • use of the word 'reef' or 'reefing', 'reefed' - who noticed this?
  • the idea that the only two things you need to provide for kids is love and a quiet place. How was this shown in the book?
  • the importance of mentors - Slim, Lyle. Do mentors need to be 'good' people?
  • The theme of questioning 'are you a good man'? Why was Eli fixed on this? is it possible to be good and bad?
  • The fine line between magic and madness - e.g. the red telephone
  • What does 'boy swallows universe' mean? Is it a metaphor for taking control of your life? 
  • The theme of escape - escapes from prison, escapes from gangs, the ibis escaping from capture, escaping through the underground tunnel, Papillon novel
  • the authenticity of the voices of each character

And then we were distracted onto:
  • What makes the difference for kids from traumatic and/or disadvantaged backgrounds? Love? Good mentors? Having at least one person in your corner? 
  • Writing a memoir as catharsis. Does the period of time passed influence this? How does the process of writing create that catharsis?
  • Does a traumatic story require an element of love and hope in order to be retold and worked through? What happens if it doesn't?
  • What were our own experiences of Australia in the 1980s - what elements were recognisable? 
  • Why has this book been so popular? What is it that captures the public's imagination? 

In other news:

Ratings
Range: 6.5 to 10
Average: 8.56


Monday, 9 September 2019

September book: The Arsonist by Chloe Hooper

The Arsonist 

by Chloe Hooper

Discussion to be led by KM






Some background links to get you started:


What we discussed about the book:
  • the style of writing - did we find it read like a thriller (i.e. fiction)? 
  • Did the book meet/exceed our expectations of what it would be about?
  • We wondered what happened with Brendan's family afterwards?
  • Which characters (keeping in mind this is a work of non-fiction) were portrayed in a very likeable fashion? And vice versa?
  • Was there ever a DSE ute in the area? 
  • The impact of the coal/electricity industries on the social demographics of towns in the area
And then we were distracted onto:
  • Memories of Black Saturday - where we each were when we heard about the fires
  • How do you determine whether something is done 'on purpose'?
  • How fascinating the description of the work of wildfire investigators was
  • What is the psychology of firestarting?
In other news:
  • We discussed the prevalence of sequins in the shops at the moment - and the theory that sequins = pessimism in the economy
  • We debriefed about various travels - Greece, Edinburgh Bookfest, Europe

Ratings
Range: 2 to 9
Average: 7.16

Wednesday, 17 July 2019

July book: The Nowhere Child by Christian White

The Nowhere Child

by Christian White

(discussion led by KE)

Some background links to get you started:


What we discussed about the book:
  • The 'prescription' for a mystery/thriller - how closely did this book follow that plan?
  • Who picked 'whodunnit' and at what point in the novel? What were the clues?
  • The concept of the Evangelic snake-handling - we discussed some of the background to this practice
  • The idea that a photo shows a moment not a story
  • The process of tracking Sammy down...how credible was that? (similar, but different to the real-life Lion process...so do-able)
  • What was the role of sibling guilt? 

And then we were distracted onto:
  • the decay theory of psychology - is it better to put things behind you, move on and forget about past trauma
  • how well this book would adapt to a screenplay
  • Is there really a town of Manson?
  • Stephen King's 'On Writing' - how did that influence the structure or execution of the novel? 

In other news:
  • One of our original No.1 Ladies (M) graced us with her presence all the way from Perth and discovered she and our newgirl have matching dogs (Nova Scotian Ducktoller).
  • Game of Thrones - yay or nay? Yay-sayers tell the others to stick with it past the first few episodes
  • We discussed aged care facilities
  • Recommendation of the movie - Head Full of Honey
Ratings
Range: 6.5 to 8.5
Average: 7.37

Wednesday, 12 June 2019

June book; A Place for Us by Fatima Farheen Mirza

A Place for Us

by Fatima Farheen Mirza

Discussion led by JP






Some background links to get you started:

Monday, 13 May 2019

May book: The Price of Fortune by Damon Kitney

The Price of Fortune

by Damon Kitney

Discussion led by JC



Some background links to get you started:


Monday, 18 March 2019

March book: The Fragments by Toni Jordan

The Fragments 
by Toni Jordan

Discussion led by MHC









Some background links to get you started:


Monday, 12 November 2018

November book: The Book That Matters Most by Ann Hood

The Book That Matters Most

by Ann Hood


Discussion led by Fairlie



Some background links to get you started:

Monday, 1 January 2018

2018 book choices


Our 2018 book line-up, plus one not photographed: The Book That Matters Most by Ann Hood.

Sunday, 12 November 2017

November book: The Last Painting of Sara de Vos by Dominic Smith

The Last Painting of Sara de Vos

by Dominic Smith


Discussion led by Fairlie


Some background links to get you started:


Monday, 11 September 2017

September book: Commonwealth by Ann Patchett

Commonwealth
by Ann Patchett

(Discussion led by KM)








Some background links to get you started:


Wednesday, 16 August 2017

August book: Big Little Lies by Liane Moriarty

Big Little Lies
by Liane Moriarty

(discussion led by JC)






Some background links to get you started:


Thursday, 10 August 2017

Top rated books 2007 to date

A question came up after we read All the Light We Cannot See as to whether that was our highest rating book ever? So…I’ve gone back through our records to 2007 (when the blog began), and pulled out the top-rating books (see below). No, All the Light We Cannot See is not our highest…that honour goes to The Book Thief Interesting to reflect on whether there are any common genres/themes/styles/periods etc within this list?

The Book Thief by Marcus Zusak (9.06)

The Road by Cormac McCarthy (9.0)

The Secret History by Donna Tartt (9.0)


The Portrait of a Lady by Henry James
 (9.0*)
*only two ladies finished the book, so this is based on two scores…

The Go-Between by L.P.Hartley (8.83)

The In-Between World of Vikram Lall  by M.G. Vassanji (8.79)

All the Light We Cannot See by Anthony Doerr (8.7)

Let the Great World Spinby Colum McCann
 (8.67)


The Transit of Venus by Shirley Hazzard (8.63)

The Other Hand by Chris Cleave (8.6)


Monday, 7 August 2017

July book: The Sellout by Paul Beatty

The Sellout
by Paul Beatty

Discussion led by CH




Some background links to get you started:

Wednesday, 14 June 2017

June book: Faithful by Alice Hoffman

Faithful

by Alice Hoffman

(discussion led by TG)





Some background links to get you started:
What we discussed about the book:
  • The themes of redemption and making your own family
  • Did Shelby make choices or did life make them for her? 
  • The writing style and the devices used
  • The rawness and sparseness of the lanaguage - what was the effect of that? How did it move the story along? 
  • The interactions with Marvelle and the kids - what did that show about Shelby?
  • Was teh power of the postcards in the idea of them rather than the actuality? 
  • What role did Helene play? Was she a vehicle to outwardly reflect Sheby's inner guilt?
  • Was this a book about religion?
  • Who was 'faithful' to Shelby? Who was she faithful to? 
  • What was the role of the tattooed girl in the bookshop?
  • Which (if any) characters did we empathise with and why? 
  • What did Shelby look like?
Then we were distracted to discuss: 
  • Why are we so polarised in our experience of this book - lovers vs haters? (as reflected in ratings)
  • Do you need to have personal experience of dysfunction in order for a portrayal of it to resonate?
  • The idea of one moment where a life changes course permanently
And in other news we chatted about: 
  • OAMs, AMs, etc - what is the Australian award system all about? What do you need to do to get one? Do the right people get them?
  • The pleasures and perils of new puppies
  • The quote 'life just grows around your wound' - what does this mean? 

Ratings
Range: 2 to 9
Average: 6.19

Friday, 12 May 2017

May book: Judas by Amos Oz

Judas 
by Amos Oz

(Discussion led by BC)




Some background links to get you started:

What we discussed about the book:

  • The themes of treachery and loyalty - how were they explored?
  • Are traitors always bad?
  • What do we know about Judas? 
  • The juxtaposition of Atalia's story with that of Judas
  • The language devices used - e.g. repetition of phrases
  • How the book interweaves the personal and the political
  • What did the stray cats and dogs represent?
Then we were distracted to discuss: 

  • A potted history of Israel/Palestine
  • The current politics of the Middle East 
  • The mechanics of the two-state solution
  • Are there any conflicts in the world that don't have an element of religion as a factor?
  • How appropriate are the 10 commandments today? Are they all applicable to our lives?
And in other news we chatted about: 

  • The hierachy of Victorian skifields - where does Mt Buller sit in that heirachy?
  • The similarities and differences between Greek biscuits and Scottish ones. 
  • Issues the ACCC should be investigating


Ratings
Range: 5 to 7.5
Average: 6.63

Saturday, 22 April 2017

April book: The Dry by Jane Harper

The Dry
by Jane Harper
(discussion led by MH-C)





Some background links to get you started: 



What we discussed about the book:

  • Where did we think this was set? Was it the Mallee?
  • What were the clues revealed throughout the book? Who spotted them? Did anyone pick the killer before the reveal?
  • How could we explain the note with 'Falk' written on it? How would that have been motivated?
  • Did we think this book vilify country town life? Did it reflect our own experiences of country life?
  • Were we happy with the resolution? 
  • Could there be a sequel to this book...or would that be a mistake? If so, what direction should it take? 
  • Structurally, the italic sections initially were memory or explanation as viewed by a character...then part way through they swapped to omniscient narrator - did this make sense?
  • Is shooting rabbits a regular past-time during a drought?
  • Why was it suggested the Luke may have been cruel to a rabbit in the past? 
  • Was Luke the father of Gretchen's baby? 
  • Appreciation of the writing style - a descriptive, but pacy narrative. 

Then we were distracted to discuss: 

  • Who do we think Hollywood will cast to play each of the characters in the film version of this book? But who would we actually LIKE to play each?
  • Crime-writing as a genre. What are the 'rules'? And how closely did this book, stick to the rules?
  • If you liked this book - The Broken Shore by Peter Temple is recommended
  • How long a grave has to be left to 'settle' before a gravestone can be erected.


And in other news: 

  • We were educated about 'Netflix and chill'
  • We discussed profiling of psycho-killers. In real life, can anyone pick a killer in their midst?


Ratings
Range: 7 to 9
Average: 7.85

Monday, 13 March 2017

March book: The Riviera Set by Mary S. Lovell

The Riviera Set

by Mary S. Lovell

Discussion led by JP




Some background links to get you started:



What we discussed about the book:

  • Is this the story of a house? Or a biography?
  • Aly Khan - how fascinating he was?
  • Did this story bring 'interesting bits to life'?
  • How could we see the author being influenced by her sources as to how to shape the book?
  • What is the point of the book? What did we take away from it?
  • How was the backdrop of historical events portrayed? (WW2, Great Depression etc)
  • What did we think the author's opinion of Churchill was? Which characters did we as readers like/dislike? 
  • Why do readers continue to be fascinated by this set of people and this era? What is it that captures imaginations?
  • How did this book reflect social structures in England?
  • Why did we think the post-scripts were included? 
Then we were distracted to discuss:
  • Class mobility in the early part of the 20th Century - what did it take to breach boundaries?
  • Differences between English reviews and non-English reviews of the book - what influences these differences?
  • How difficult is it to construct a continuity of narrative when writing non-fiction?
  • How quickly huge 'celebrities' are forgotten - e.g. Sheila Milbanke etc. Will the Khardasians ever suffer the same fate? 
And in other news:
  • We mused about DNA and genetics
Ratings
Range: 3 to 6
Average: 4.61