Thursday, 31 July 2014

Minutes July book: Poorly Made in China

Poorly Made in China

by Paul Midler

(chosen by KM)

Theme: Made in China




KM chose this book because it, quite literally, matched this month's theme. It is subtitled, "An Insider's Account of the China Production Game". 

About the author:

Paul Midler has over twenty years of experience related to Asia, and in his manufacturing career, he has worked directly with hundreds of Chinese suppliers in a broad range of industries. He holds an MBA from the Wharton School of Business and a master's in international studies from the University of Pennsylvania's Lauder Institute. Poorly Made in China is his first book.

(general biographical detail from publisher's webpage)

What the publisher says about the book:
An insider reveals what can—and does—go wrong when companies shift production to China. 
In this entertaining behind-the-scenes account, Paul Midler tells us all that is wrong with our effort to shift manufacturing to China. Now updated and expanded, Poorly Made in China reveals industry secrets, including the dangerous practice of quality fade—the deliberate and secret habit of Chinese manufacturers to widen profit margins through the reduction of quality inputs. U.S. importers don’t stand a chance, Midler explains, against savvy Chinese suppliers who feel they have little to lose by placing consumer safety at risk for the sake of greater profit. This is a lively and impassioned personal account, a collection of true stories, told by an American who has worked in the country for close to two decades. 
Poorly Made in China touches on a number of issues that affect us all.

What we discussed about the book:
  • Did the cover adequately reflect the book's message?
  • As readers, how frustrated did we feel about what we were reading?
  • Is criticism that the author didn't suggest any solutions fair? Is that the role of a book like this?
  • To what extent did this book display a degree of naivety on the behalf of US importers?
  • What did the book say about cultural differences in the development of relationships - long-term vs quick advantage?
  • The concept of quality fade.
  • What exactly was Paul Midler's role - was he an operational go-between, or more of a translator (in a broad sense of the term)?
  • Is it inevitable that when a company makes a decision to take manufacturing off-shore, that there will be compromises in the way they do business?
  • Can we trust our own governments' food and product safety standards and testing to protect us from dodgy imports?
  • The concept of 'saving face' - what role does it play in doing business in China?
  • How did the scene with the broken toilet sum up the whole book?
  • Was the narrative a bit repetitive?
  • Do the issues highlighted in this book apply equally across all market sectors and price-points in Chinese manufacturing, or are they particular to the discount goods end of the spectrum? 
  • Has there been any improvement/changes since the book was last published in 2009?
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • Wondering whether he ended up marrying Maria?
  • Did this book change our purchasing behaviour - especially with regards to personal toiletries items?
  • What role does/should the US government (or our own) have in regulating the quality of China-produced imports?
  • The counterfeiting industry throughout parts of Asia. Whose responsibility is it to police this?
In other news, we discussed:
  • Auditing our toiletries, cleaning products, pantry items...all Asian manufactured goods viewed suspiciously
  • 3D printing in schools. How incredible it is that idea that were science-fiction within our lifetimes, are accessible by our kids in school
  • Shark steam-cleaners - how incredible they are.
Ratings:
Range: 6.5 to 8
Average: 7.44

Next book: The Secret History by Donna Tartt (chosen by JP)

Monday, 30 June 2014

Minutes June book: The Go-Between

The Go-Between

by L.P.Hartley

(chosen by Gypsy)

Theme: The past is a foreign country




Gypsy declared that her choice of this book was either very lazy, or demonstrated  uncharacteristically risky behaviour for her, as she chose it without pre-reading it. This month's theme does in fact come from the first line of this novel, which makes it an eminently suitable choice!

About the author:

Leslie Poles Hartley was born in  England in 1895. For more than thirty years from 1923 he was a a fiction reviewer for periodicals. He published his first book, a collection of short stories entitled Night Fears, in 1924 and his first full-length novel, The Shrimp and the Anemone, did not appear until 1944.

The Go-Between (1953) was awarded the Heinemann Foundation Prize of the Royal Society of Literature in 1954 and was later made into an internationally successful film. L. P. Hartley died in 1972.

(general biographical detail from the publisher's website)

What the publisher says about the book:
When one long, hot summer, young Leo is staying with a school-friend at Brandham Hall, he beings to act as a messenger between Ted, the farmer, and Marian, the beautiful young woman up at the hall. He becomes drawn deeper and deeper into their dangerous game of deceit and desire, until his role brings him to a shocking and premature revelation. The haunting story of a young boy's awakening into the secrets of the adult world, The Go-Between is also an unforgettable evocation of the boundaries of Edwardian society.
What we discussed about the book:
  • How many elements of this novel were autobiographical?
  • How old was Marian? 18? 
  • How did Marian justify her behaviour? Could it be described as 'grooming'?
  • How did Marian wield power over Leo? 
  • What was the exact definition of 'spooning' as intended by Hartley?
  • What role does Marcus play in the novel? To what degree is he the 'honest' narrator, telling it like it is with no hidden agenda?
  • The stratified nature of the household.  
  • The characteristics of the plant, belladonna. How was it used metaphorically in the plot?
  • The symbolism of Janus with relation to Lord Trimingham.
  • Why does Leo deliver the final message at the end of the novel?
  • How had these events impacted on the rest of Leo's life? Did Marian in any way acknowledge her role?
  • What does Leo actually remember about events and what does he think he remembers?
  • Was the behaviour of the adults cruel?
  • Did we foresee Ted's fate?
  • The role of the climate in mirroring the plot.
  • Symbolism of the gods - Mercury, Janus etc
  • To what extent was this novel an allusion to an earlier style of writing rapidly becoming unfashionable in the 1950s?
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • How is the past a foreign country? Do they do things differently there?
  • How this novel portrays the British class system at that time. 
  • Parallels with Lady Chatterley's Lover
  • Did we imagine Downton Abbey when we read about Brandham Hall?
  • The role of written journals in  recreating the past/memory many years later.
  • The concept of memory. What can be trusted? What does our contemporary mind add to it?
  • Did the endnote references dotted throughout the text aid or interrupt our reading?
In other news, we discussed:
  • The mechanics of memory - how you only ever remember your last recollection of a memory, not the initial event itself. Hence, memories alter like Chinese whispers.
  • The current state of Australian newspapers...which one offers quality, balanced journalism?
  • The documentary about 11 year old boys sitting the Harrow entrance exam (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MWYaoWPdUOI)
  • The 'Eton Style' (Gangnam parody)...an oldie, but a goodie: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9FtZkVRkusQ
  • What we would change in life if we won lotto
  • Is life best lived at on mediocre middle line...does having extreme highs risk oncoming falls?? 
Ratings:
Range: 7.5 to 10
Average: 8.83

Next book: Poorly Made in China by Paul Midler (chosen by KM)

Friday, 13 June 2014

June book: The Go Between by L P Hartley

The Go-Between 

by L P Hartley 

(chosen by Gypsy)

Theme: The past is a foreign country




Some background links to get you started:

Saturday, 31 May 2014

Minutes May book: The Namesake

The Namesake

by Jhumpa Lahiri

(chosen by Elster)

Theme: Book with a bird on the cover




On the day of last year's No.1 Melbourne Ladies Bookclub end of year dinner, Elster heard Rafael Epstein talking on ABC Radio about this book, saying it was the best book he had read all year. (It was later featured as one of his bookclub choices). So Elster bought a copy to put into our traditional 'Great Book Swap for Indigenous Literacy' that night. When no-one had chosen it off the table by the time her turn came around, she took it herself, and decided to make it her book choice for 2014.

It doesn't have a bird on the cover. No.1 Melbourne Ladies never let 'rules' get in the way of a great book choice.

About the author:

Jhumpa Lahiri is the author of three books, most recently Unaccustomed Earth. Her debut collection, Interpreter of Maladies, won the 2000 Pulitzer Prize for fiction. She is the recipient of a Guggenheim fellowship and her work has been translated into twenty-nine languages.

(general biographical detail from the publisher's website)

What the publisher says about the book:
Jhumpa Lahiri's debut story collection, Interpreter of Maladies, took the literary world by storm when it won the Pulitzer Prize in 2000. Fans who flocked to her stories will be captivated by her best-selling first novel, now in paperback for the first time. 
The Namesake is a finely wrought, deeply moving family drama that illuminates this acclaimed author's signature themes: the immigrant experience, the clash of cultures, the tangled ties between generations. The Namesake takes the Ganguli family from their tradition-bound life in Calcutta through their fraught transformation into Americans. On the heels of an arranged wedding, Ashoke and Ashima Ganguli settle in Cambridge, Massachusetts, where Ashoke does his best to adapt while his wife pines for home. When their son, Gogol, is born, the task of naming him betrays their hope of respecting old ways in a new world. And we watch as Gogol stumbles along the first-generation path, strewn with conflicting loyalties, comic detours, and wrenching love affairs. 
With empathy and penetrating insight, Lahiri explores the expectations bestowed on us by our parents and the means by which we come to define who we are.
What we discussed about the book:
  • Is this autobiographical to any extent?
  • Did we realise that it was a female author (for those of us who didn't already know that)?  The strength of the male character voice.
  • The engaging writing style - what devices were used to achieve such well-rounded characters?
  • How did we feel when the father died? Did we see it coming?
  • How did the jumps in chronology move the narrative along?  Were there parts where we felt cheated by the jumps?
  • The importance of the concept of 'name'. Do certain names carry certain characteristics?  e.g. Nikhil could talk to girls, but Gogol couldn't
  • Why did it take Gogol so long to finally read the book?
  • Did Maxine fully understand the cultural implications of Gogol's upbringing and background?
  • Was he just another guy to her?
  • Was Gogol trying to erase or ignore his background up to the point of his father's death?
  • Was Moushumi a relationship of convenience? For him? For her?
  • Did she resent her cultural background?
  • How well did this book depict the immigrant experience, regardless of country of origin?
  • How did we feel towards Gogol? Did we like him as a character? Why or why not?
  • What was the point of Dimitri?
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • The clash between assimilation and the desire to hold onto traditions and culture. How is that best managed?
  • Instances where people choose different names to those they are given as a baby. e.g. international students 'Anglicizing' their names while they are in Australia, celebrities choosing stage names... 
  • Does a name you choose yourself hold greater significance than one you are given?
  • The impressions names convey- e.g. Kathy vs Kathleen or Candi vs Candice....Do people respond differently to the same person using different versions of the name? 
In other news, we discussed:
  • Is there an inherently racist undertone to asking someone 'Where are you from?'
  • The success of arranged marriages vs non arranged.
  • Whether it is appropriate for a doctor to comment on your shoes during/following any kind of gynae appointment?
  • The etiquette of texting. At what point should you just dial.the.friggin.number and speak?
Ratings:
Range: 7.5 to 8.5
Average: 7.92

Next book: The Go-Between by L P Hartley (chosen by Gypsy)

Thursday, 15 May 2014

May book: The Namesake by Jhumpa Lahiri

The Namesake 

by Jhumpa Lahiri 

(chosen by Elster)

Theme: A book with a bird on the cover




Some background links to get you started:

Minutes April book; Revolutionary Road

Revolutionary Road

by Richard Yates

(chosen by CH)

Theme: All that glitters is not gold


CH chose this after several friends agreed that it was a great fit for the theme. Initially she had read Jonestown as an option, but decided that it didn't fit the theme all that well.

About the author:

Richard Yates was born in 1926. The author of several acclaimed works of fiction, including Revolutionary Road, Eleven Kinds of Loneliness, Disturbing the Peace, and The Easter Parade, he was lauded during his lifetime as the foremost novelist of the post-war "age of anxiety". He died in 1992.

(general biographical detail from the publisher's website)

What the publisher says about the book:
From the moment of its publication in 1961, Revolutionary Road was hailed as a masterpiece of realistic fiction and as the most evocative portrayal of the opulent desolation of the American suburbs. It's the story of Frank and April Wheeler, a bright, beautiful, and talented couple who have lived on the assumption that greatness is only just around the corner. With heartbreaking compassion and remorseless clarity, Richard Yates shows how Frank and April mortgage their spiritual birthright, betraying not only each other, but their best selves.
What we discussed about the book:
  • Is this an anti-suburban book?
  • To what extent is it autobiographical?
  • Is Yates bitter about the suburban life? What does he show as being particularly nasty?
  • Why did the Wheelers only have one good set of friends? Were they really 'friends' when they were constantly criticising them?
  • Were the characters well-developed? Rounded?
  • Did Frank love his job? Why was he happy to have an easy life and coast?
  • What did this say about employment in that era? A
  • Was the Paris idea an escape plan for April from a domestic wasteland?
  • Did April suffer from a mental illness?
  • What role did her failed career play in her future life?
  • Did Frank have any self-reflection when he read the note?
  • How skilled the writing is that when Frank goes back to the house the reader can hear April's voice.
  • And then when Frank reads the note, he can no longer hear her voice.
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • Was Yates' talent not fully-recognized during his lifetime?
  • Why are so many books written about the suburban malaise? Who do they appeal to? And why?
  • Is this book a fair representation of suburban life?
  • Are people  different in the city from the suburbs? Do they same any/all of the same issues?
  • Are there still workplaces like Frank's? When did workplaces change?
  • Can women whose mothers reject them ever fully love anyone else?
  • The life for women in that era who were unhappy or unfulfilled by the stereotypical housewife role. What options were there for them?
In other news, we discussed:
  • Greek school. Why do kids go to it? What do they learn?
  • Juggling work/travel/kids/husbands...the modern day malaise!
  • New York shopping
  • Formal dresses...formal partners...formal hairdos...formal make-up...formals...
  • Lean In by Sheryl Sandberg
Ratings:
Range: 5 to 9
Average: 7.75

Next book: The Namesake by Jhumpa Lahiri (chosen by Elster)

April book: Revolutionary Road by Richard Yates

Revolutionary Road

by Richard Yates

(chosen by CH)



Some background links to get you started: 



Monday, 31 March 2014

Minutes March book: One Day

One Day

by David Nicholls

(chosen by Domestic Goddess)

Theme: From the page to the screen


Domestic Goddess chose this book as she had already seen the movie and enjoyed it, and wondered if the book would be as good. She was particularly interested in whether any aspects of the book would be different from that of the movie.

About the author:

David Nicholls is an English novelist and screenwriter. He trained as an actor before becoming a write and has written for TV and film as well as three best-selling novels. He has twice been nominated for BAFTA awards for his screen-writing.
He has written the screenplays for film versions of both Starter for Ten (his first novel) and The Understudy (his second novel).
His third novel, One Day, was published in hardback in 2009, and stayed in the Sunday Times top ten bestseller list for ten weeks on publication. It has sold over five million copies and has been translated into forty languages. David wrote the screenplay for Lone Scherfig's film adaptation starring Jim Sturgess and Anne Hathaway, which was released in 2010. He is currently writing his fourth novel, as well as working on a feature-film version of Dickens' Great Expectations.

(general biographical detail from the author's website)

What the publisher says about the book:
ONE DAY is the multi-million copy bestselling novel that brilliantly captures the experiences of a generation. 
'I can imagine you at forty,' she said, a hint of malice in her voice. 'I can picture it right now.' He smiled without opening his eyes. 'Go on then.' 
15th July 1988. Emma and Dexter meet for the first time on the night of their graduation. 
Tomorrow they must go their separate ways. So where will they be on this one day next year? And the year after that? And every year that follows? 
Twenty years, two people, ONE DAY. From the author of the massive bestseller STARTER FOR TEN.
What we discussed about the book:
  • How does the pace of the book compare with the pace of the movie?
  • Were we (and if so, why were we) shocked by the ending?
  • How many of us consciously thought about it being a male author? 
  • How well the female characters were captured.
  • Were there similarities between this story and the movie of When Harry met Sally? What were they?
  • How did we fell about the character of Ian?  Why didn't he get that Em didn't find him funny?  Did she ever try to love him? Was she his one true love?
  • Was it 20 wasted years? Why or why not?  Was it frustrating to the reader?
  • In the Tex-Mex - in what ways did the author use both humour and pathos to create those scenes.
  • In what ways did the affair with the principal display a life spinning out of control?
  • Was Em's life a product of low self-esteem and confidence?
  • What was teh turning point? Was it the day she took off to see the publisher, her book being accepted for publications?
  • Was Em actually frumpy, or was that only her self-perception?
  • How would things have been different if she had received Dex's letter from India?
  • Why couldn't Dex say what he wanted to if he wasn't drunk? Why was his attention constantly drawn to other women?
  • Why did he (or did he?) fall in love with Sylvie?
  • Is Dex a good father?
  • Would we have checked up on Dex when he was alone with Jasmine? Why didn't Sylvie?
  • How clever the structure of this book is - the 'one day' snippets move the plot forward and build character and detail.
  • How is the tension developed throughout the 20 years?
  • Was this a funny book?
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • How often would we read a book after seeing a movie vs the opposite way around?
  • The concept of living day to day, 'this will do'
  • Did we empathise more with these characters because their ages made them our contemporaries?
In other news, we discussed:
  • The mystery of MH 370. What really happened? Will we ever know?
  • The pain scale of 1-10...whoever thought that up? And how effective is it in practice?
  • Deteriorating eyesight...who needs glasses for menus in restaurants?
  • We revisited Turkish hamans with updated information
Ratings:
Range: 6.5 to 9
Average:  7.66

Next book: Revolutionary Road by Richard Yate (chosen by CH)

Thursday, 13 March 2014

March book: One Day by David Nicholls

One Day

by David Nicholls

(chosen by Domestic Goddess)







Some background links to get you started:

Friday, 28 February 2014

Minutes February book: The Fight

The Fight

by Norman Mailer

(chosen by JM)

Theme: Winning isn't everything, but wanting to win is.


JM is (we discovered) obsessed with Muhammad Ali and boxing.  She loves this book, and was waiting for an opportunity to choose it for bookclub - which her allocated theme gave her. In the past, she's shied away from selecting it, as she thought we'd "all hate it".  One of her favourite movies is When we Were Kings, which is a documentary about the 'Rumble in the Jungle' fight, and she can vaguely remember seeing parts of the fight back in the 1970s.

About the author:

Norman Mailer was born in 1923 and went to Harvard when he was sixteen. While studying engineering at university he became interested in writing; he published his first story when he was eighteen. He wrote a number of books and also directed four films. In 1955 Norman Mailer co-founded the Village Voice, and he was the editor of Dissent from 1952 until 1963. For his part in demonstrations against the war in Vietnam he was gaoled in 1967. He was President of PEN (US chapter) from 1984 to 1986 and was winner of the National Book Award for Arts and Letters in 1969 and of the Pulitzer Prize twice, once in 1969 and again in 1980. He was married six times and had nine children. He died in November 2007.

(general biographical detail from the publisher's website)

What the publisher says about the book:
In 1975, at the World Heavyweight Boxing Championship in Kinshasa, Zaire, Muhammad Ali met George Foreman in the ring. Foreman's genius employed silence, serenity and cunning. He had never been defeated. His hands were his instrument, and 'he kept them in his pockets the way a hunter lays his rifle back into its velvet case'. Together the two men made boxing history in an explosive meeting of two great minds, two iron wills and monumental egos.
What we discussed about the book:
  • Is this a book about Ali and Foreman, or a book about Mailer? How did he insert himself into the narrative?
  • Why did Mailer chose an illeistic style to write this book? (referring to himself in the third person)
  • In what ways are each of the characters presented?
  • Why does Ali hold such popular appeal - what is it about his character that creates this? 
  • How much would the fight fees of $5,000,0000 in 1974 be worth in today's money?
  • What were each of them going to do with the money?
  • Was Mailer privy to the actual training Ali was doing, or was it a strategic facade to seem to be doing less than Foreman? Was he training during the night?
  • Was loosening the rope, and tightening the canvas within the rules?
  • How did the written descriptions of the actual fight compare with the video footage on YouTube?
  • How would we describe the writing style of this book? Did it help or hinder our reading experience?
  • Did we understand the black political agenda underpinning the book? What were Mailer's views?  
  • How did Mailer present the political situation in the Zaire? 
  • Is this a book that appeals equally to men and women? Why or why not?
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • What is the appeal of boxing as a spectator sport?
  • How do you become a 'heavyweight champion'? Is there just one?
  • What is cage fighting? Why is it popular?
  • How a full-length book tells a story differently to newspaper and magazine articles. Does the longer deadline alter the views of the writer by offering time for reflection?
  • Are there racist connotations to the term 'Rumble in the Jungle'?
In other news, we discussed:
  • Numerous upcoming travel plans
  • The experience of a Turkish hamam. Is communal semi-nude bathing in our comfort zone?
Ratings:
Range: 4 to 8.5
Average:  6.61

Next book: One Day by David Nicholls (chosen by Domestic Goddess)

Tuesday, 4 February 2014

February book: The Fight by Norman Mailer


The Fight

by Norman Mailer

(chosen by JM)






Some background links to get you started:

Tuesday, 31 December 2013

Books read in 2013

The ratings recorded below reflect an average of the members' ratings (out of ten) of their personal experience of the reading of that book. The links take you to the post that contains the minutes for that book's discussion.

(Warning! Spoiler alert for the minutes of all titles.)

The Widow Clicquot by Tilar J Mazzeo 
Rating: 7.77
(Theme: Biography)

The Sense of an Ending by Julian Barnes
Rating:7.55
(Theme: Booker Prize winner)

Lady Chatterley's Lover by D.H. Lawrence
Rating: 7.19
(Theme: Banned books)

The Happiest Refugee by Anh Do
Rating: 7.89
(Theme: Inspiring and uplifting)

Madame Bovary by Gustave Flaubert
Rating: 7.38
(Theme: A woman scorned)

The In-Between World of Vikram Lall 
Rating: 8.79 by M.G. Vassanji
(Theme: "Power doesn't corrupt. Fear corrupts. Perhaps fear of the loss of power.")

The Transit of Venus by Shirley Hazzard
Rating: 8.63
(Theme: Antipodeans abroad)

An Unequal Music by Vikram Seth
Rating: 6.71
(Theme: "Without music, life would be a mistake.")

Orange is the New Black by Piper Kerman
Rating: 7.44
(Theme: Crime and punishment)

The Age of Miracles by Karen Thompson Walker
Rating: 7.05
(Theme: "The perfect place to make a film about the end of the world.")

Saturday, 30 November 2013

Minutes November book: The Age of Miracles

The Age of Miracles

by Karen Thompson Walker

(chosen by KM)

Theme: The perfect place to make a film about the end of the world


KM was inspired by this theme to look at end-of-the-world novels and sought out a 'top ten' list of apocalyptic novels. Included on the list were a couple of books we have already read as a bookclub (Blindness and The Road). She looked at reviews of a few of the other books on the list and found that this one had good reviews, so she chose it.

About the author:

Karen Thompson Walker was born and raised in San Diego, California, where The Age of Miracles is set. She studied English and creative writing at UCLA, where she wrote for the UCLA Daily Bruin. After college, she worked as a newspaper reporter in the San Diego area before moving to New York City to attend the Columbia University MFA program. A former book editor at Simon and Schuster, she wrote The Age of Miracles in the mornings before work—sometimes while riding the subway. She is the recipient of the 2011 Sirenland Fellowship as well as a Bomb Magazine fiction prize. She lives in Brooklyn with her husband.

(general biographical detail from the author's website)

What the publisher says about the book:
Spellbinding, haunting, The Age of Miracles is a beautiful novel of catastrophe and survival, growth and change, the story of Julia and her family as they struggle to live in an extraordinary time. On an ordinary Saturday, Julia awakes to discover that something has happened to the rotation of the earth. The days and nights are growing longer and longer, gravity is affected, the birds, the tides, human behavior and cosmic rhythms are thrown into disarray. In a world of danger and loss, Julia faces surprising developments in herself, and her personal world—divisions widening between her parents, strange behavior by Hannah and other friends, the vulnerability of first love, a sense of isolation, and a rebellious new strength. With crystalline prose and the indelible magic of a born storyteller, Karen Thompson Walker gives us a breathtaking story of people finding ways to go on, in an ever-evolving world.
What we discussed about the book:
  • The inexplicable nature of some of the events that occurred as a result of the slowing - are we not privy to the whys  of these occurrences, because our narrator was not?
  • Why did the author use an 11 year old narrator's voice? What effect did that have on the novel?
  • How well did that voice transition to the 23 year old narrator? 
  • Why was the mother's character so dramatic? What underlay that behaviour?
  • Was the parents' an unhappy marriage?
  • Was her father actually having an affair with Sylvia, or is that just how it appeared to Julia?
  • Was it okay for her father to lie? is what circumstances was it/wasn't it? Is it okay to lie to protect someone's fragility?
  • The friendship with Hannah. Is that typical tween behaviour? 
  • The plausibility of the slowing. Did the science make sense? Did it need to? Why or why not?
  • Did we think that the problem would be 'solved'?
  • Did Seth die?
  • Is this a novel about climate change?
  • Did we, as readers need to know whether the world 'ended' or not? What was the effect of not knowing? Is that the very definition of hope?
  • Was it a satisfying end to the novel? What were we left thinking?
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • How does growing up in an on-going atmosphere of fear (e.g. in California, the fear of the BIG earthquake) shape views of the world and the future?
  • Will humans always work out solutions to all problems?  
  • Would we be real timers or clock timers in the same circumstances?
In other news, we discussed:
  • Genome mapping -  it is too much information? How much would we want to know?
  • Issues of informed consent in medical procedures. 
  • 2014 will be the 15th anniversary of the No.1 Melbourne Ladies Bookclub
Ratings:
Range: 6 to 8.5
Average:  7.05

Next book: The Fight by Norman Mailer (chosen by JM)

Monday, 4 November 2013

November book; The Age of Miracles

The Age of Miracles

by Karen Thompson Walker

(chosen by KM)






Some background links to get you started:


Thursday, 31 October 2013

Minutes October book: Orange is the New Black

Orange is the New Black

by Piper Kerman

(chosen by JM)

Theme: Crime and Punishment


JM thought about the themes and decided she definitely wouldn't chose THE novel it suggested. She initially chose Marching Powder by Rusty Young, a story about a young guy caught bringing cocaine back from Bolivia, but changed her mind, as she was not rapt in it. Her second choice was Girls Like You, by Paul Sheehan but thought it was maybe a bit too long. The trusty Avenue bookstore suggested Orange is the New Black.

About the author:

Piper Kerman is the author of the memoir Orange is the New Black: My Year in a Women’s Prison from Spiegel and Grau, which has been adapted into an original television series for Netflix. She is a frequent invited speaker to students of law, criminology, gender and women’s studies, sociology, and creative writing, and also to groups that include the American Correctional Association’s Disproportionate Minority Confinement Task Force, federal probation officers, public defenders, justice reform advocates and volunteers, book clubs, and formerly and currently incarcerated people. She serves on the board of the Women’s Prison Association. Piper works with Spitfire Strategies as a communications consultant with nonprofits, philanthropies, and other organizations working in the public interest. She works on a range of issues including criminal justice reform. Her clients include the Open Society Foundations, the Ford Foundation, the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, and many nonprofits.

(general biographical detail from the author's website)

What the publisher says about the book:
With a career, a boyfriend, and a loving family, Piper Kerman barely resembles the reckless young woman who delivered a suitcase of drug money ten years before. But that past has caught up with her. Convicted and sentenced to fifteen months at the infamous federal correctional facility in Danbury, Connecticut, the well-heeled Smith College alumna is now inmate #11187–424—one of the millions of people who disappear “down the rabbit hole” of the American penal system. From her first strip search to her final release, Kerman learns to navigate this strange world with its strictly enforced codes of behavior and arbitrary rules. She meets women from all walks of life, who surprise her with small tokens of generosity, hard words of wisdom, and simple acts of acceptance. Heartbreaking, hilarious, and at times enraging, Kerman’s story offers a rare look into the lives of women in prison—why it is we lock so many away and what happens to them when they’re there.
What we discussed about the book:
  • Was this a rose-coloured glasses view of life in prison written in retrospect? Or did this accurately reflect the circumstances?
  • How were Piper's circumstances different to others around her?
  • The compassionate and kind nature of other prisoners - e.g. the goodwill on arrival
  • Did we want 'more' from each character, rather than snippets about each of them?
  • Did we want to know more about what happened to each character outside prison?
  • What is the purpose of the paperwork and bureaucracy in the prison system? Is it just an inefficiency or is there a greater purpose?
  • What is Piper Kerman's motivation in writing the book? Does she want to change our perceptions of women in prisons?
  • To what extent does the length of a sentence psychologically affect the prisoner?
  • We wondered about Kerman's writing process. Had she kept notes or a journal? Or is it all reconstructed from memory?
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • The 1980s US drug legislation that led to a rapid increase in rates of incarceration
  • The impact of one mistake in one's youth
  • The effect illiteracy has on life skills and expectations
  • The differences between the book and the TV series
  • Can parallels in be drawn between African-American incarceration rates, and Australian indigenous rates?
In other news, we discussed:
  • Cutting out sugar and alcohol...does it also cut all the joy out of life?
  • Michael Mosley's 5:2 fast diet
  • The last days of year 12, and schoolies week.
  • Weird Melbourne weather...and powercuts
Ratings:
Range: 6.5 to 9
Average:  7.44

Next book: The Age of Miracles by Karen Thompson Walker (chosen by KM)

Monday, 14 October 2013

October book: Orange is the New Black

Orange is the New Black

by Piper Kerman

Chosen by JM






Some background links to get you started:


Monday, 30 September 2013

Minutes September book: An Unequal Music

An Unequal Music

by Vikram Seth

(chosen by KE)

Theme: 'Without music, life would be a mistake'


KE examined a few options before choosing this one, including Rose Tremain's Music and Silence, however at 484 pages, it exceeded the page limit! She also thought about some music biographies.

About the author:

Vikram Seth has written acclaimed books in several genres: verse novel, The Golden Gate; travel book, From Heaven Lake; animal fables, Beastly Tales; epic fiction, A Suitable Boy. His most recent novel, An Equal Music, was published in 1999. He lives in England and India.

(general biographical detail from the Harper Collins website)

What the publisher says about the book:
The author of the international bestseller A Suitable Boy returns with a powerful and deeply romantic tale of two gifted musicians. Michael Holme is a violinist, a member of the successful Maggiore Quartet. He has long been haunted, though, by memories of the pianist he loved and left ten years earlier, Julia McNicholl. Now Julia, married and the mother of a small child, unexpectedly reenters his life and the romance flares up once more. 
Against the magical backdrop of Venice and Vienna, the two lovers confront the truth about themselves and their love, about the music that both unites and divides them, and about a devastating secret that Julia must finally reveal. With poetic, evocative writing and a brilliant portrait of the international music scene, An Equal Music confirms Vikram Seth as one of the world's finest and most enticing writers.
What we discussed about the book:
  • The twin themes of lost love and passion for music.
  • St Jerome and the white dog (cat/ferret) - what was the significance of this in the story? How did it represent Julia and Michael's story?
  • What caused Michael to leave Julia in the first place?
  • Did we want a 'happy' ending? Regarding Julia? Regarding the violin? What did we care more about and why?
  • The links between Beethoven's loss of hearing and Julia's.
  • Do musical and non-musical people read this book differently?
  • Was there a musical structure to the novel?
  • How did we find the dialogue? How was it used as a expository device?
  • Were the quartet members fully developed characters?
  • How did the tension of the Mrs Formby violin story contribute overall to the novel? Was this relationship one of the most satisfactory and resolved?
  • Did Michael feel he was a fraud? How did his background contribute to this?
  • Would Julia ever leave James? Why did she invite Michael to meet James for lunch?
  • Was Julia right to hide her deafness?
  • What effect did the first person, present tense writing style have?
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • The concept of the irrevocable nature of time
  • Can you or do you, get second chances?
  • Is being a classical musical stalker a niche activity?
  • Are musicians 'highly strung' by nature?
In other news, we discussed:
  • Synesthesia - a neurological phenomenon in which stimulation of one sensory or cognitive pathway leads to automatic, involuntary experiences in a second sensory or cognitive pathway.
  • Gatecrashing of funerals...widely spread practice? 
  • MONA gallery at Hobart
Ratings:
Range: 5 to 7.5
Average: 6.71

Next book: Orange is the New Black by Piper Kerman (chosen by JM)

Sunday, 8 September 2013

September book: An Equal Music by Vikram Seth

An Equal Music 

by Vikram Seth

(chosen by KE)




Some background links to get you started:





Friday, 9 August 2013

Minutes August book: The Transit of Venus

The Transit of Venus

by Shirley Hazzard

(chosen by Fairlie)

Theme: Antipodeans abroad


I originally interpreted this theme as meaning I should chose a work by an 'Australian' writer who lives (or lived) overseas, which led me to the likes of Peter Carey, Kathy Lette, Germaine Greer, Nikki Gemmell, Geraldine Brooks. While I was pondering a choice of these authors' works, I came across a reference on the Meanjin blog to Shirley Hazzard as being one of Australia's most neglected women authors, possibly as a result of her living overseas for so long.  I initially thought I would choose her more recent work, The Great Fire, but opinion from others swayed me to The Transit of Venus. It was only after I had chosen it and ordered a copy that I found a pristine copy of the book on my own bookshelf. It had been on one of my university literature subject reading lists and I can only assume my 18 year old self saw the reading of it as an optional part of that course, as it obviously had never been opened. When I realised that not only was the author an 'antipodean aboard' but the novel was also about two Australian sisters who moved to England, it seemed like destiny that I should make it my choice.

About the author:

Shirley Hazzard was born in 1931 in Sydney, Australia. She left Australia as a child, due to her parents’ diplomatic postings and at 16, started to work for British Intelligence in Hong Kong, monitoring civil war in China. Since then she has lived in New Zealand, Europe, USA and Italy. In the USA she worked for the United Nations Secretariat in New York. She has been a full-time writer since leaving the UN, and has written a number non-fiction books including: Defeat of an Ideal: A Study of the Self-Destruction of the United Nations (1973), Countenance of Truth: the United Nations and the Waldheim Case (1990), Greene on Capri: A Memoir (2000) about her friend, Graham Greene. In 1985, Coming of Age in Australia was published, a collection of her Australian Broadcasting Corporation Boyer lectures. Her works of fiction include five novels: The Evening of the Holiday (1966); People in Glass Houses (1967); The Bay of Noon (1970); The Transit of Venus (1980); and most recently, The Great Fire (2003). Shirley Hazzard lives in New York.

(general biographical detail from the British Council website)

What the publisher says about the book:
Caro, gallant and adventurous, is one of two Australian sisters who have come to post-war England to seek their fortunes. Courted long and hopelessly by young scientist, Ted Tice, she is to find that love brings passion, sorrow, betrayal and finally hope. The milder Grace seeks fulfilment in an apparently happy marriage. But as the decades pass and the characters weave in and out of each other's lives, love, death and two slow-burning secrets wait in ambush for them.
What we discussed about the book:
  • The choice of 'The Transit of Venus' as the title. What was the significance, symbolism?
  • What did the novel says about Australia and being Australian? How was it shown as a 'place to escape from'?  In what ways did being Australian influence Caro and Grace's interactions with other characters?
  • Could this be described as an anti-war novel? What evidence was there of this viewpoint?
  • The coincidental and accidental nature of the human interactions vs the predictable nature of the astronomical transit of Venus.
  • How we would describe the style of the writing - dense, given to understatement, having gravity, no superfluous words?
  • The role of the omniscient narrator - foreshadowing details of plot essential to our later understanding.
  • The themes of disappearance and loss: the Benbow sinking, Adam Vail's death, Dora's Major
  • Is this a novel driven by plot or by character?
  • What degree of engagement is required by the reader. How does Hazzard instruct the reader in what is going to be required right on the first page?
  • The role of dialogue - minimal, but expressive.
  • Dora, as a character. In what ways does Hazzard create such a rounded and believable character with so few scenes?
  • Why do Caro and Grace treat Dora with no judgement and with a huge degree of loyalty.
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • What makes a writer 'Australian'? Is it just that they have an Australian birth certificate?  
  • The role of working women at that time, with particular reference to the tea-making and button/typewriter ribbon replacing scenes.
  • The social and political issues that form the background to the novel: post-war politics, nursing homes, women in the workforce, inequality of marraige, US political assassinations, English class system
In other news, we discussed:
  • VCE subject choices, getting through Year 12, work experience options
  • The nature of  Australian customs practices - checking parcels etc
  • The realities of nursing in 2013
  • The daggy to glamorous spectrum of parents at each school. How do we know where we fall on the continuum?
  • The etiquette of thank yous. One exchange is enough...you do not need to do a thank you for a thank you.
Ratings:
Range: 7 to 10
Average:  8.63

Next book: An Equal Music by Vikram Seth (chosen by KE)