Sunday, 8 August 2010

August book: The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society by Mary Ann Shaffer and Annie Barrows

The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society

by Mary Ann Shaffer and Annie Barrows

(chosen by KM)




Some background links to get you started:

Minutes July book: The Beauty Myth

The Beauty Myth

by Naomi Wolf

(Chosen by Domestic Goddess)






Domestic Goddess chose this book as she had first read it almost 20 years ago, and wanted to revisit it to see how relevant the issues were today, and whether there had been any changes in that time.

Naomi Wolf is the author of seven books, including the New York Times bestsellers The Beauty Myth, The End of America and Give Me Liberty. She has toured the world speaking to audiences of all walks of life about gender equality, social justice, and, most recently, the defense of liberty in America and internationally. She is the co founder of the Woodhull Institute for Ethical Leadership, which teaches ethics and empowerment to young women leaders, and is also a co founder of the American Freedom Campaign, a grass roots democracy movement in the United States whose mission is the defense of the Constitution and the rule of law.

(general biographical details from the author's website)

What the publisher says about the book:

In the struggle for women's equality, there is one subject still shrouded in silence - women's compulsive pursuit of beauty. The myth of female beauty challenges every woman, every day of her life. The author exposes the tyranny of the beauty myth through the ages and its oppressive function today, in the home and at work, in literature and the media, in relationships between men and women, between women and women. With examples, she confronts the beauty industry and its advertising and uncovers the reasons why women are consumed by this destructive obsession.

What we discussed about the book:
  • Was this an easy book to read? Was it a little like wading through mud?
  • Did the need to provide academically acceptable evidence for every argument weigh down the 'narrative' of the book?
  • Is it hard to be a both a respected academic thesis, and a book with wide popular appeal?
  • What was the main argument of the chapter on religion? How many of us understood that chapter?
  • How did Wolf acknowledge the idea of individual free-will to make choices, as opposed to a dominant patriarchal society dictating choices? 
  • What is the archetypal ideal of feminine beauty in our society? How is that ideal propagated?
  • What are the solutions? Does Wolf offer any solutions? Is being aware of the issue a solution in itself?

Then we were sidetracked into discussing:
  • Was this a particularly courageous and ambitious book for a 28 year old to write?
  • What is the appeal of professional uniforms? Why are flight attendants, for example, considered 'sexy'?
  • The role of digital retouching of photos in creating unrealistic ideals of beauty. (See this video for an excellent summation)
  • The recent events at retailer, David Jones. Did the store management/board do enough, soon enough?
  • Does 'normalising' nakedness create greater awareness of the wide variety of body types - naked bike day...Turkish baths... How else do people realise there are more body shapes and types than that presented by the mass media?
  • Cosmetic surgery, waxing, hair colouring, make-up...who does what and why?
  • What can we, as women, do to show leadership on this issue? Is it enough to educate our own children?
And in other news:
  • We talked about the idea that 10,000 hours of practice (of any skill) is necessary to become an expert (from Malcolm Gladwell's Outliers book)
  • Gypsy confessed to watching 'The Footy Show'...argggghhhhh. (Just for the team line-ups, mind you.)
  • We all listened in shocked amusement as Domestic Goddess described her kids' lunchbox packing regime...half a mandarin, three strawberries, half a sandwich for the youngest....She has portion control down to a fine art.
Ratings:
Range: 7 to 9
Average: 7.6

Next book: The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Society  by Mary Ann Shaffer and Annie Barrows (chosen by KM)

Saturday, 10 July 2010

July book: The Beauty Myth by Naomi Wolf

The Beauty Myth
by Naomi Wolf

(Chosen by Domestic Goddess)




Some background links to get you started:

Wednesday, 9 June 2010

Minutes June book: Brooklyn by Colm Toibin


Brooklyn

by Colm Toibin

(chosen by LC)











LC was browsing in her local bookstore for a book to take away on holiday to Thailand - not too long, something enjoyable. The ever-helpful assistant recommended Brooklyn. A few pages into the book, already in Thailand, LC had a small panic as she realised she *loved* this book and it wasn't going to last the whole holiday. When she returned, she immediately emailed your No.1 Melbourne Ladies' Bookclub Administrator and nominated it as her book choice before anyone else could get in first.

Colm Tóibín was born in Enniscorthy, Co Wexford in 1955 and educated at University College Dublin. He is the author of five novels. The Blackwater Lightship (1999) was shortlisted for the Booker Prize and The Master was also shortlisted for the Man Booker Prize in 2004 and was the winner of the Los Angeles Times Novel of the Year and the Prix du Meilleur Livre Etranger in France. Tóibín’s books have been translated into twenty-five languages.

(biographical details from the reader's guide at  www.themanbookerprize.com )

What the publisher says about the book:

It is Ireland in the early 1950s and for Eilis Lacey, as for so many young Irish girls, opportunities are scarce. So when her sister arranges for her to emigrate to New York, Eilis knows she must go, leaving behind her family and her home for the first time.

Arriving in a crowded lodging house in Brooklyn, Eilis can only be reminded of what she has sacrificed. She is far from home - and homesick. And just as she takes tentative steps towards friendship, and perhaps something more, Eilis receives news which sends her back to Ireland. There she will be confronted by a terrible dilemma - a devastating choice between duty and one great love.

What we discussed about the book:
  • Some of us attended the session with Colm Toibin at The Wheeler Centre (and one of us saw him again at the Sydney Writers Festival). How did hearing his voice influence how we read (heard) the narrator's voice?
  • What did the book reveal about the nature of being an "Irish" women - in light of how Toibin described firefighters at 9/11 as having Irish faces, and had to explain  that he meant: 'A man whose eyes are soft but his mouth is stubborn. A man who loves and hates with seriousness but doesn't talk about them. A man who's bad at working for himself but good at working for others. A man who's better with his daughters than with his sons.' (see SMH interview)
  • Is a character's inner life more interesting than an exterior life? How does an inner life get revealed? What devices are used to do so?
  • Was this a melancholic book?
  • How did we feel reading the swimsuit shopping scenes? What did this scene reveal about Eilis? Did we empathise with her vulnerability?
  • How were notions of racism, elitism and class explored within the plot. Were big issues illuminated through small stories?
  • The concept of migrants 'missing two countries' - the one they have left, and not fully experiencing the one they have arrived in.
  • Did we expect Father Flood's character to be disreputable? Why or why not? What was the effect of him being a benign character?
  • What is the role of a 2nd daughter? Did we think Rose already knew about her illness before sending Eilis to Brooklyn and saw it as a way of getting her away from the carer situation? 
  • Were we satisfied with the ending? Who wanted her to stay, who wanted her to return to Brooklyn? Why?
  • Did Brooklyn offer a 'better life'? What is the definition of better? How did the Italian ideal of a better life fit with the Irish?
  • Did we think Tony was 'one great love' as described in the blurb of the book? Was it truly a choice between duty and love?
  • How did we feel about the sex scene between Eilis and Tony?
  • What did we think of Eilis as a character? Did she exercise her own free will? Did she make something of herself? What motivated her?

And then we were sidetracked into:
  • In what ways does this book reflect elements of Pride and Prejudice?
  • The issues of caring for elderly family when families are geographically disparate.
  • All the paths in life are choices, and how we will never know the alternate reality - the 'Sliding Doors' view of life. How would it affect us to have a glimpse at the alternate reality?
  • The role of education in getting 'a better life'. 
  • Catholic concepts of divorce/annulment.
  • Can you ever go back once you have left your childhood home?
In other news:
  • We discussed Robert Drewe's article in Saturday's Age about brides from Belarus.
  • Why are people interested in the private goings on in public figures' lives (Tiger Woods, Ernie Dingo...)? Is it only of interest when the reality contradicts the constructed image which has been sold to the public?
  • Facebook - how are children using it? is it appropriate? what is the role of a school in policing 'under-age' use of Facebook?
Ratings
Ratings range:  5 to 10
Ratings average:  7.55

Next book: The Beauty Myth by Naomi Wolf (chosen by Domestic Goddess)

Wednesday, 12 May 2010

June Book: Brooklyn by Colm Toibin



Brooklyn

by Colm Toibin

(Chosen by LC)





Some background links to get you started:

Minutes May book: The Other Hand

***warning: these minutes may contain spoilers...read on at your own risk***




The Other Hand


by Chris Cleave



(chosen by Elster)



Elster chose this book on the recommendation of JM...who had bought it at Lorne over the summer, in a reaction against the reading of Twilight.


Chris Cleave is 36. He lives in London with his wife and three children.

His debut novel
Incendiary won a 2006 Somerset Maugham Award, was shortlisted for the 2006 Commonwealth Writers Prize, won the United States Book-of-the-Month Club’s First Fiction award 2005 and won the Prix Spécial du Jury at the French Prix des Lecteurs 2007.

The Other Hand is his second novel (and is titled Little Bee in Canada and the US). It was shortlisted for the Costa Book Awards.

Chris Cleave has been a barman, a long-distance sailor and teacher of marine navigation, an internet pioneer and a journalist
.

(general biographical details from the author's website)

What the publisher says about the book:



We don't want to tell you too much about this book. It is a truly special story and we don't want to spoil it.

Nevertheless, you need to know something, so we will just say this:

It is extremely funny, but the African beach scene is horrific.

The story starts there, but the book doesn't.

And it's what happens afterwards that is most important.

Once you have read it, you'll want to tell everyone about it. When you do, please don't tell them what happens either. The magic is in how it unfolds.


What we discussed about the book:


  • Why was the title of the book changed from The Other Hand to Little Bee for release in the US and Canada?
  • What was the other hand? How was this term used in the novel? e.g "When it hurt too much to prise open the box of washing powder, I used the other hand."
  • Although some thought the African beach scene unbelievable in some ways, why was it necessary to create the point at which the the developed world collided with chaos?
  • The power of imagining horror versus the actual telling of the story...why was it necessary for Sarah to hear the story of Nkiruka?
  • How did we think the story ended? What happened?
  • Was it a hopeful or a tragic ending? Or both?
  • What did Lawrence represent? Why do we remember the description of the carpet tiles in his office?
  • Was Little Bee's dialogue and insight beyond her years? What would cause that?
  • The idea of "the girls back home" acting as a Greek chorus - "a foil in whose imagined reaction the cultural dissonance experienced by Little Bee can be made explicit" (from the author's website)
  • Why did Little Bee seek the ways in which she could kill herself in every situation - what did this tell us about her and her experiences?
  • What does the quote at the beginning of the book say about the British experience?
  • Why did Sarah take action on the beach? Why didn't Andrew? What did each of their choices represent?
  • How did the novel explore the idea of weighing up options? Rationalism vs emotion? On the other hand...
  • Was this just Little Bee's story?
  • What was the role of the other three girls released at the same time as Little Bee?
  • What was the purpose of Charlie? Why did Batman see everyone in terms of goodies and baddies?

And then we were sidetracked into:

  • Would we have taken Charlie to Nigeria?
  • The role of journalism in exposing injustice, horror, corruption. How does the collection of a number of stories strengthen the story of an individual?
  • Did this novel change our perception of how UK policy on refugees and detention compares with Australia's?
  • What global forces create the corruption which causes situations from which people need to flee?
  • Do we take our freedom of movement for travel for granted? How easy is it for others to obtain visas to visit Australia as tourists (e.g Indonesians?)
  • How stories are framed differently by their telling.
  • In what ways should/can multinational companies contribute to the local communities and make a difference?
  • How many refugees are admitted to Australia each year?
  • Why is a political hard-line on illegal immigration a vote-grabber?

In other news:

  • We discussed the burqa issue in the media at the moment. What are our views?
  • Why do some people wear sunglasses almost always?
  • Gypsy recommended the movie, Welcome

Ratings:

Ratings range: 6 to 10

Ratings average: 8.6



Next book: Brooklyn by Colm Toibin (Chosen by LC)





Friday, 7 May 2010

May book: The Other Hand by Chris Cleave




The Other Hand

by Chris Cleave

(chosen by Elster)




Some background links to get you started:

Minutes April Book: The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo

** Warning...these minutes contain spoilers...read on at your own risk**





The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo

by Steig Larsson

(Chosen by JM)




Unfortunately, JM was ill the day of our April meeting and was not able to attend to discuss her book choice, but in true No.1 Melbourne Ladies' style, we were able to wing the discussion, and cover a lot of different aspects of the book.

Stieg Larsson, who lived in Sweden, was the editor in chief of the magazine Expo and a leading expert on antidemocratic right-wing extremist and Nazi organizations. He died in 2004, shortly after delivering the manuscripts for The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, The Girl Who Played with Fire, and The Girl Who Kicked the Hornet's Nest.

(General biographical details from the official website for the books)

What the publisher says about the book:



An international publishing sensation, Stieg Larsson's The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo combines murder mystery, family saga, love story, and financial intrigue into one satisfyingly complex and entertainingly atmospheric novel.

Harriet Vanger, a scion of one of Sweden's wealthiest families disappeared over forty years ago. All these years later, her aged uncle continues to seek the truth. He hires Mikael Blomkvist, a crusading journalist recently trapped by a libel conviction, to investigate. He is aided by the pierced and tattooed punk prodigy Lisbeth Salander. Together they tap into a vein of unfathomable iniquity and astonishing corruption.

What we discussed about the book:


  • Was Mikael an aspirational character for Steig Larrson?
  • Did the translation make sense? At what points did we feel the English words chosen possibly did not accurately reflect the author's intention?
  • Who is the main character? Mikael or Lisbeth?
  • If it was Lisbeth, what was Mikael's role?
  • Is Mikael a bad man? Did we lack empathy for him? Why?
  • Would the relationship between Erika and Mikael read differently to Swedish readers?
  • Were we frustrated by them not going to the police? Why was this the path chosen?
  • Were there parts of the plot that didn't seem credible, and therefore affected our engagement with the plot? (i.e. the idea of compensation the families of all the girls, Harriet being able to live as Anita, the scene with Lisbeth and the two hotels/disguises)
  • Is this a feminist novel?
  • Is Lisbeth an anarchist? Do we like her or not? Does she show signs of Aspergers?

And then we were sidetracked into:
  • Who wants to see the movie? Does it matter if the movie is in Swedish with English subtitles?
  • How responsible is a criminal for his crimes? For example, Martin's abuse as a child continues in his abuse of others. How responsible should he be for making that choice?
  • Photographic evidence. Does the sheer volume of digital photography of any given moment ensure that there will be way more evidence for investigators to examine for crimes?
  • Do what extent are we able to read graphically violent scenes?

In other news:

  • In case you missed it previously, the online bookstore some of us use is http://www.bookdepository.co.uk/
  • We agreed to take part in The Great Book Swap for Indigenous Literacy Day this year in memory of our much missed member, S.
  • We chatted about Burma as a holiday destination, and the age range of the No.1 Melbourne Ladies (10 years between the oldest and youngest)
  • And we discussed what to do with all those digital photos stored on computers (e.g producing Photobooks), wondered at the ability of Picasa to recognise faces in photos and mused about why it is that setting photos to a music soundtrack is guaranteed to produce tears in the viewer?

Ratings

Range: 6.5 to 9.5

Average: 8.05

Next book: The Other hand by Chris Cleave (Chosen by Elster)

Sunday, 11 April 2010

April book: The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo by Steig Larsson



The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo

by Steig Larsson

(Chosen by JM)





Some background links to get you started:

Minutes March Book: I'm Not Scared


I'm Not Scared

by Niccolo Ammantiti (translated by Jonathon Hunt)

(Chosen by The New Girl, JP)



JP chose the book because her father is from the North of Italy, from a small town of just 200 people. Aqua Traversa struck a chord with her as being like the town her father grew up in, and she wanted to explore the sense of innocence of children growing up in such small towns. She told us the story of her father and his two friends, who found a live grenade in old trenches in the mountains behind their town, and the tragic outcome of their find.

Niccolo Ammantiti was born in Rome in 1966. He has written three novels and a collection of short stories. He won the Italian Viareggio-Repaci Prize for Fiction with I'm Not Scared, which has become a best-seller and has been translated into forty languages and made into a film.

(General biographical details from the inside back cover of the book)

What the publisher says about the book:

When Michele Amitrano stumbles onto a boy held prisoner in a hole deep in the Italian countryside, he begins a journey that will lead him to a series of startling discoveries.

I’m Not Scared explores the playful and volatile world of childhood through the eyes of nine-year-old Michele, who is forced, again and again, to make the hard choices that will define his character. As the book opens, he must choose between helping his younger sister or winning a race. Later, he must choose between letting his friend Barbara be humiliated or taking the punishment himself. And as the novel approaches its stunning climax, he must choose between obeying his father and fulfilling the oath he swore to him, or following his conscience and keeping his promise to Filippo, the boy who has been kidnapped. But the choices he makes bring him into serious danger, not from the monsters of his childish imagination but from the adults around him who are capable of violence and monstrosities that are all too real.

Written with an immediacy and poignancy which is itself evocative of childhood, I’m Not Scared is a powerful tale of how one boy finds the courage to overcome his fear, risk his life, and make wrenchingly difficult moral choices.

What we discussed about the book:
  • The progression of Michele's discovery - the jigsaw pieces that gradually fell into place and his slow realisation of the actual nature of what he had uncovered.
  • Why did Michele chose helping others over the easier path (his little sister, Barbara, Filippo)? Is this innate character, or is it taught?
  • The idea that Michele kept the discovery a secret so that it would be his only - once he told someone, he would no longer own it.
  • Was the mother a 'good' character? He lioness qualities, her concern for the children...was she responsible for shaping Michele's character?
  • At what point did we think the mother knew about the kidnap?
  • In what ways was Papa the 'boogie man'? How did he reconcile the dichotomy of his personality?
  • Are children innately good? Why did Skull and Salvatore act the way they did?
  • Was Filippo hallucinating or were the wash bears and the Lord of the Worms a madness linked to reality? Did he think he'd already died?
  • Why was Filippo too sacred to get out of the hole?
  • What was Michele scared of and what wasn't he scared of? Is the point of the book that the only thing he wasn't scared of was doing the right thing?
  • Was Michele more scared of imaginary monsters than real ones? "It's men you should be scared of."
  • In what way did his father's drawing of the short match motivate Michele to find Filippo in the gravina?
  • Did we think Michele died at the end? Does it matter to our reading of the novel whether he died or survived?
  • Were we satisfied with the ending? Who needed closure and why? Was the scene in the gravina credible in context of the rest of the book?

And then we were sidetracked into:

  • Comparing the three different cover versions we had around the table - and the different author photos in each.
  • How Italy was in the 1970s, "the years of lead" when kidnapping for ransom was relatively common. In 1978, 600 children were kidnapped. In what ways did the author being a child himself at that time influence the writing of this book?
  • Did this book examine the psychology of terrorism? How do people separate their actions towards 'the other' from their actions towards their friends and families?
  • How do adults who perpetrate such crimes disconnect from the child? What is the process of rationalising their actions?
  • Is this a book about bravery and courage?
  • Is this a horror book?
In other news:
  • We commiserated with JP about the damage done to her beautiful house by Melbourne's freak storm.
  • We mocked the way fashion models walk the catwalk with hips pushed forward and pouty expressions.
  • We admired Gypsy's new renovation.
  • We discussed the necessity or otherwise of telemovies about murders, tragedies etc - i.e Wales-King murders. Why do people seem fascinated by these re-enactments?

Ratings:
Ratings average: 7.17
Ratings range: 5 to 9

Next book: The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo by Steig Larsson (chosen by JM)

Sunday, 14 March 2010

Friday, 12 March 2010

Minutes February Book: Twilight



Minutes February Book: Twilight

by Stephenie Meyer

(chosen by Gypsy)



Gypsy chose this book with a degree of encouragement from those of us who had already read it. The alternative choice she had in mind was The Secret Scripture by Sebastian Barry. There was some debate as to whether some of us forced her into the Twilight choice!

She highlighted, however, a highest selling book list for 2009 which showed that Twilight was the 5th highest selling book last year (and Stephenie Meyer books also held spots 1, 2, 3, 6, 7, 8 and 9 on that same list. What is it about these books that makes them so popular?

Stephenie Meyer (born December 24, 1973), is an American author best known for her vampire romance series Twilight. The Twilight novels have sold over 85 million copies worldwide with translations into 37 different languages. Meyer is also the author of the adult science-fiction novel The Host.

Meyer was the biggest selling author of 2008, having sold over 29 million books in that year alone, with Twilight being the best-selling book of the year. She was ranked #49 on Time magazine's list of the "100 Most Influential People in 2008", and was also included at #26 in the Forbes Celebrity 100 list of the world's most powerful celebrities in 2009, with annual earnings exceeding $50 million.

Meyer was born in Hartford, Connecticut, and grew up in Phoenix, Arizona. She received a B.A. in English in 1997 from Brigham Young University in Utah. She met her husband Christian, growing up in Arizona and married him in 1994 when they both were 21. They have three sons.

Meyer is a member of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints and does not drink alcohol or smoke.


(General biographical details from here)

What the publisher says about this book:


When 17 year old Isabella Swan moves to Forks, Washington to live with her father she expects that her new life will be as dull as the town.

But in spite of her awkward manner and low expectations, she finds that her new classmates are drawn to this pale, dark-haired new girl in town. But not, it seems, the Cullen family. These five adopted brothers and sisters obviously prefer their own company and will make no exception for Bella.

Bella is convinced that Edward Cullen in particular hates her, but she feels a strange attraction to him, although his hostility makes her feel almost physically ill. He seems determined to push her away - until, that is, he saves her life from an out of control car.

Bella will soon discover that there is a very good reason for Edward’s coldness. He, and his family, are vampires - and he knows how dangerous it is for others to get too close.


What we discussed about the book:
  • Were Edward and Bella plausible as characters?
  • Why was it important that Bella was an 'outsider' to the town?
  • Is Bella ever in control?
  • Did the organisiation of the vampire world ressemble a religion or cult?
  • The reality of the setting. The places mentioned do all exist. LaPush has been home to the Quileute Nation forever.
  • Is this a book about temptation? Canit be read metaphorically to apply to many tempting scenarios?

Then we were sidetracked into:

  • Why does this book appeal to both tween and young-teen girls AND their middle-aged mothers?
  • Does this book in any way incorporate or reflect Meyer's Mormon beliefs?
  • Is this an appropriate book for girls? What 'messages' is it sending them? Is it possible to read a book for pure escapism and enjoyment without taking a 'message' from it?
  • What makes a bestseller? Is it instantly recognisable? If it is, why have many bestsellers been rejected by multiple publishers before finally finding one who is prepared to take it on?

And in other news, we discussed:

  • Back to school progress, stories and dramas
  • The length of t-shirts - what is right for each of us, and can we find them that length?

Ratings:

Ratings average: 5.6

Ratings range: 2 to 8.5

Next book: I'm Not Scared by Niccolo Ammaniti (chosen by JP)

(Ed note - sorry for the brevity of the minutes, the discussion must have been so good, I hardly took any notes! I've reconstructed what I can from memory...but feel free to add bits in the comments...)

Thursday, 7 January 2010

February book: Twilight by Stephenie Meyer



Twilight by Stephenie Meyer

chosen by Gypsy






No need for many background links for this one! But just to get you started:

Books Read in 2009

The Great Gatsby by F.Scott Fitzgerald


Breath by Tim Winton


Jasper Jones by Craig Silvey


The Gargoyle by Andrew Davidson


The Book of Emmett by Deborah Forster


The Slap by Christos Tsiolkas


The White Tiger by Aravind Adiga


Speeches That Changed the World with intro by Simon Sebag Montefiore


People of the Book by Geraldine Brooks


Diary of a Bad Year by J.M. Coetzee

MInutes November Book: The Great Gatsby



Minutes November Book: The Great Gatsby

by F.Scott Fitzgerald

(chosen by Elster)



Elster chose this book because she hadn't read it, but knew it was an American classic. Over the course of the year, she had heard lots of people talking about it and then saw that the ABC Book Show did it one month.

F. Scott Fitzgerald was born in 1896, in St. Paul, Minnesota and attended St. Paul Academy, Newman School (1911-1913), and Princeton. His first work of fiction was a detective story published in the school newspaper. He died of a heart attack in 1940 after his health had declined with severe alcoholism.

F. Scott Fitzgerald fell in love with Zelda Sayre, the youngest daughter of an Alabama Supreme Court judge, in June 1918 and they married in New York a week after the publication of his novel, This Side of Paradise (1920). They had one child, Frances Scott (Scottie) Fitzgerald, who was born in October 1921.

(General biographical details from here.)

What the publisher says about the book:

In The Great Gatsby, Fitzgerald brilliantly captures both the disillusion of post-war America and the moral failure of a society obsessed with wealth and status. But he does more than render the essence of a particular time and place, for in chronicling Gatsby's tragic pursuit of his dream, Fitzgerald recreates the universal conflict between illusion and reality.

What we discussed about the book:

  • Is there a cross-over between reality and fiction? Are there elements of Fitzgerald's life represented in the book?
  • How was the 'American Dream' defined? Had it changed from discover, individualism and the pursuit of happiness to easy money and relaxed social values?
  • Was Gatsby portrayed positively or negatively?
  • What was the turning point in our empathy for Gatsby?
  • Was Gatsby obsessive? Manic depressive? What drove him?
  • Why did Gatsby intrigue us?
  • How did we react to Tom's violence towards Myrtle?
  • Did Nick love Jordan?
  • What did 'The Ashes' represent? Was it a moral emptiness?
  • The beauty of the language employed. To what extent did it enhance the plot?
And then we were sidetracked into:

  • Who had an introduction to the version of their book? Did reading it enhance or detract from our reading of the novel?
  • Is it true that Fitzgerald's grandfather wrote the Star-Spangled Banner? (ed: it was actually a distant cousin...Francis Scott Key... who wrote it in 1814)
  • What makes a classic book?
  • Was this book worth $80 in babysitting to read it?

  • In other news:
    • We talked about the worldwide genealogical source that the Mormons have created: http://www.familysearch.org/
    • We were updated on the progress of Elster's broken foot.
    • We discussed the marketing of water and fruit juices.
    • We analysed the imaginary stories some us used to make up about our soft toys as children.

    Ratings:
    Ratings average
    : 7.25
    Ratings range:6 to 9

    Next book: Twilight by Stephenie Meyer (chosen by Gypsy)

      Sunday, 15 November 2009

      November Book: The Great Gatsby by F.Scott Fitzgerald

      The Great Gatsby

      by

      F.Scott Fitzgerald
      (chosen by Elster)

      Some background links to get you started:

      Minutes October Book: Breath by Tim Winton

      Breath

      by Tim Winton

      (chosen by CH)




      CH chose this book because she couldn't believe that over a ten year period, we hadn't read any books by Tim Winton before.


      Tim Winton began his first novel, An Open Swimmer (1982), at the age of 19, while on a Creative Writing course at Curtin University, Perth. It won the Australian/Vogel National Literary Award, and he has since made his living as a full-time writer. He was born in Perth in 1960, and is the author of several novels for adults. Many of his books are set in his familiar landscapes of Western Australia. He has also written books for children and collections of short stories.

      Breath is his most recent novel and was winner of the 2009 Miles Franklin Award.

      Tim Winton been named a Living Treasure by the National Trust, and awarded the Centenary Medal for service to literature and the community. He has lived in Greece, France and Ireland, but has now settled in Western Australia with his family.

      (General biographical details from here.)

      What the publisher says about the book:

      More than once since then I've wondered whether the life-threatening high jinks that Loonie and I and Sando and Eva got up to in the years of my adolescence were anything more than a rebellion against the monotony of drawing breath.

      Breath is a story about the wildness of youth - the lust for excitement and terror, the determination to be extraordinary, the wounds that heal and those that don't - and about learning to live with its passing.

      In his first novel for seven years, Tim Winton has achieved a new level of mastery. Breath confirms him as one of the world's finest storytellers, a writer of novels that are at the same time simple and profound, relentlessly gripping and deeply moving.


      What we discussed about the book:

      • The sense of place in Tim Winton’s writing. Is the location immediately recognisable? What makes it so distinctive?
      • Was Eva a believable character?
      • The impact of events in adolescence on the rest of your life.
      • What was Pikelet looking for in the relationship with Sando and Loonie? Did he get it?
      • Was the relationship between Eva and Pikelet abusive?
      • Did Eva’s risk-taking replace the thrill of the risks of her extreme sport?
      • In how many ways was ‘breath’ represented in this book: drowning, dreaming, hyperventilation, held-breath diving, sleep apnoea, asthma, didgeridoo playing, asphyxia, resuscitations, extracting oxygen from surf foam...
      • Were some of these means of fighting the natural monotony of unconscious breathing? Was it a metaphor for pushing against the monotony of life?
      • How did the non-use of quotation marks affect our reading of the book?
      • In what ways did Pikelet’s surfing exploits make his feel ‘special’?
      • Was the end of the book satisfactory?
      • Were we at times holding our breath reading some of the surfing scenes?
      • Is this a book which is more about mood than plot? The evocation of the senses? The notion of place?
      • Did we feel we were on a wave in reading the book? How had Winton created that sensation?
      • What was the purpose of the paramedic scenes? How did they enrich the plot?


      And then we were sidetracked into:

      • Is surfing the only thing that men do that is both elegant and pointless?
      • How fabulous is the Panadol ad with the 70yo surfer man?
        How had the culture of surfing changed between the 1960s and the 1980s. And what about now?
      • Why was there little mention of the mechanics of Eva and Pikelet’s relationship in any of the reviews of the book we read?
      • What did we think of other endings to Tim Winton novels?
      • Why are Tim Winton books so highly acclaimed? What makes a ‘great’ book in an award sense?


      In other news:

      • We sympathised with Elster over her foot injury and wished her a speedy recovery.
      • We discussed the finer details of fructose malabsorbtion.


      Ratings:
      Ratings average: 7.45
      Ratings range:6.5 to 8

      Next book: The Great Gatsby by F.Scott Fitzgerald (chosen by Elster)



        Wednesday, 14 October 2009

        October book: Breath by Tim Winton



        Breath

        by Tim Winton

        (chosen by CH)


        Some background links to get you started:


        Minutes September Book - Jasper Jones by Craig Silvey




        Jasper Jones

        by Craig Silvey

        chosen by LC





        This was LC's inaugural bookclub book choice. She admitted she chose the book before she read it (we assured her that is quite normal...heck, some Ladies have even been known to make the choice and then not read it before the meeting...).She selected it as she wanted to find something modern/contemporary. The sales assistant in Readings recommended this and said it would 'have lots to talk about'.

        Craig Silvey grew up on an orchard in Dwellingup in Western Australia. He now lives in Fremantle where at the age of 19, he wrote his first novel, Rhubarb. It was published in 2004. In 2005, Silvey won a Sydney Morning Herald Best Young Novelist Award. In 2007, Silvey released The World According To Warren, a picture book starring the guide-dog from Rhubarb. In early 2008, he completed his second novel, Jasper Jones. Silvey is also the singer/songwriter for the band The Nancy Sikes!



        (General biographical details from publisher's website)



        What the publisher says about the book:

        Late on a hot summer night in the tail end of 1965, Charlie Bucktin, a precocious and bookish boy of thirteen, is startled by an urgent knock on the window of his sleep-out. His visitor is Jasper Jones, an outcast in the regional mining town of Corrigan. Rebellious, mixed-race and solitary, Jasper is a distant figure of danger and intrigue for Charlie. So when Jasper begs for his help, Charlie eagerly steals into the night by his side, terribly afraid but desperate to impress.Jasper takes him through town and to his secret glade in the bush, and it's here that Charlie bears witness to Jasper's horrible discovery. With his secret like a brick in his belly, Charlie is pushed and pulled by a town closing in on itself in fear and suspicion as he locks horns with his tempestuous mother; falls nervously in love and battles to keep a lid on his zealous best friend, Jeffrey Lu. And in vainly attempting to restore the parts that have been shaken loose, Charlie learns to discern the truth from the myth, and why white lies creep like a curse. In the simmering summer where everything changes, Charlie learns why the truth of things is so hard to know, and even harder to hold in his heart.


        What we discussed about the book:
        • Who is the central character - Charlie or Jasper?
        • Why did Charlie help Jasper? What motivated him?
        • Why did Jasper choose Charlie?
        • The idea of the 'outsider' - how many of the characters were outsiders? What does it take to become an 'insider'?
        • Was Jeffrey Lu an outsider? What was different about his approach to life?
        • Was Charlie's voice that of a 13 year old, or an adult reflecting back on 13?
        • Is the author Charlie? Is this the town he grew up in? Or is it an extrapolation/ exaggeration of his own experiences?
        • How did the townsfolk reconcile their differences in attitude towards Jasper on and off the football field?
        • Why was it set in 1965? What was it about that era that impacts on the story (e.g. race relations during the 1960s, the Vietnam War, women's roles in society)
        • Who are the good guys and who are the bad guys in this town? Is it possible to divide on such lines?
        • Was it believable that Charlie could keep the secret? Did he realise that growing up was about keeping secrets?
        • Did Eliza intend for her father to be in the house when it burnt down?
        • The combination of comic elements and intense drama...is this a reflection of human resilience - humour in the face of tragedy?

        And then we were side-tracked into:

        • The role of sport in the social structure of a country town.
        • The role of other institutions such as schools/churches in a country town.
        • What would Jasper's life have been like if he had stayed in that town?
        • What causes outsiders to bond together - shared experiences? shared secrets?
        • Do insider/outsider groups exist in large cities? How are they identified?
        • Did the slow and leisurely pace of the book reflect the pace of life in a country town?

        In other news:

        • We discussed the resurgence of old skills and hobbies. Some people are starting mother/daughter groups to do some of these activities.
        • How you know when you have possums and rats in your roof.
        • Misinterpretation of hand symbols between cultures - the raised thumb as a sign of greeting, the Greek outstretched hand...
        • Polygamist marriages...who saw the Oprah show about them?
        • We discussed appropriate book choices to suggest to our blog friend Dee from Fort Wayne, Indiana and thought maybe The Secret River by Kate Grenville (an Australian author, but the book can be obtained through amazon.com or bookdepository.co.uk)
        • Domestic Goddess held our incredulous attention as she described her cataloguing procedure for pairs of pantyhose (into zip lock labelled plastic bags): excellent, medium, ones for skirts or boots, unusuals, only to be worn under jeans....
        • ...which led to a discussion about the 101 uses for an old pair of pantyhose: packaging jigsaw puzzles, cleaning wood panelling, cleaning flyscreens, tying up tomato plants...

        Ratings:

        Ratings range: 4 to 9

        Ratings average: 7.66

        Next Book: Breath by Tim Winton (Chosen by CH)

        Monday, 14 September 2009

        September Book: Jasper Jones by Craig Silvey



        Jasper Jones

        by Craig Silvey

        (chosen by LC)











        Some background links to get you started:

        Minutes August Book: The Gargoyle

        The Gargoyle


        by Andrew Davidson


        (Chosen by KM)


        KM chose this book on the recommendation of 'the good doctor' - her GP with whom she often discusses bookclub choices. The GP has a great track record of suggestion books to read.

        Andrew Davidson was born in Pinawa, Manitoba, Canada and graduated in 1995 from the University of British Columbia with a B.A. in English literature. He has worked as a teacher in Japan, where he has lived on and off, and as a writer of English lessons for Japanese websites. The Gargoyle, the product of seven years' worth of research and composition, is his first book. Davidson lives in Winnipeg, Manitoba.

        (General biographical details from publisher's website.)

        What the publisher says about the book:

        The narrator of The Gargoyle is a very contemporary cynic, physically beautiful and sexually adept, who dwells in the moral vacuum that is modern life. As the book opens, he is driving along a dark road when he is distracted by what seems to be a flight of arrows. He crashes into a ravine and suffers horrible burns over much of his body. As he recovers in a burn ward, undergoing the tortures of the damned, he awaits the day when he can leave the hospital and commit carefully planned suicide—for he is now a monster in appearance as well as in soul.

        A beautiful and compelling, but clearly unhinged, sculptress of gargoyles by the name of Marianne Engel appears at the foot of his bed and insists that they were once lovers in medieval Germany. In her telling, he was a badly injured mercenary and she was a nun and scribe in the famed monastery of Engelthal who nursed him back to health. As she spins their tale in Scheherazade fashion and relates equally mesmerizing stories of deathless love in Japan, Iceland, Italy, and England, he finds himself drawn back to life—and, finally, in love. He is released into Marianne's care and takes up residence in her huge stone house. But all is not well. For one thing, the pull of his past sins becomes ever more powerful as the morphine he is prescribed becomes ever more addictive. For another, Marianne receives word from God that she has only twenty-seven sculptures left to complete—and her time on earth will be finished.

        Already an international literary sensation, The Gargoyle is an Inferno for our time. It will have you believing in the impossible.



        What we discussed about the book:

        • The graphic description of the burn treatment process. To what extent did we feel his suffering and his sense of despair?
        • The number of events in the story that were linked to Good Friday. What was the significance of that?
        • What was the snake? Was it self-doubt? A conscience? Was it addiction?
        • Did Marianne have a mental illness? Was she bipolar? Or was she really 700 years old?
        • Was the entire story an hallucination while he was in a drug-induced coma following the accident?
        • In what ways were the 'parables' linked and how did they progress the plot.
        • Was the purpose of the parable-stories to bring to the main character an understanding of the nature of love?
        • What WAS the main character's name?
        • How effective was the journey through hell as a representation of withdrawal from drug addiction?
        • What was the role of the food feasts that Marianne would bring into the hospital?
        • Why did the main character have a background in the pornography industry? In what way did that create the character?
        • The purpose of the arrow imagery throughout the book.
        Then we were sidetracked into:

        • Did anyone cry reading this book? What does it take in a book to make each of us cry?
        • How the first letter of each of the chapters spells out: 'All things in a single book bound by love' (Dante) and the last letter of each chapter spells out: 'Die Liebe is strak wie der Tod Marianne.' Is this just too clever and tricky an element? Or does it add to our understanding of the story?
        • How would you describe the genre of this book? Is it magic realism?
        • How each of the parables was balanced on a combination of elements: air/earth/water/fire. Each of the characters lived by one and died by one.
        • The links between the nuns' names who nursed the burn victim and the contemporary nurses' names: Mathildis/Maddie, Elisabeth/Beth, Constantia/Connie.
        • Was the last chapter a little too 'Hollywood' in tying up the ends? Would we have preferred a different ending point?

        And in other news...

        • We discussed how various schools view the taking of holidays during school term.
        • The value of ordering books from http://www.bookdepository.co.uk/ (no postage fees)
        • Would we swap meals with a stranger?
        • The impact of Crackberries on family/worklife balance. Is it impolite to continue to check it at another person's house if they've asked you not to? Is it impolite to ask them in the first place?
        • And we wondered how many times EXACTLY we've heard the story about how RR was the only one to read Gypsy's book.
        • EDITED TO ADD: KM brought along some delicious Bougatsa (like the dog in the book) for us to try!

        Ratings:

        Ratings average: 7.85

        Ratings range: 4 to 9

        Next book: Jasper Jones by Craig Silvey (LC's choice)

        Saturday, 15 August 2009

        August book: The Gargoyle by Andrew Davidson



        The Gargoyle

        by Andrew Davidson

        (chosen by KM)



        Some background links to get you started:

        Minutes July Book: The Book of Emmett by Deborah Forster


        The Book of Emmett
        by Deborah Forster
        (Chosen by KE)
        KE chose this book after seeing an article about it in The Age which highlighted "the inventiveness of the telling". She was particularly interested to see whether the book would examine the possibility of changing behaviours between generations, thus breaking ongoing inherited cycles of dysfunction.
        Deborah Foster grew up in Footscray, Melbourne. She worked as a staff and freelance journalist for many years and was a This Life columnist on The Age and The Sunday Age. Deborah Foster is married to Alan Kohler and they have three children. The Book of Emmett is her first novel.
        (general biographical detail from the publisher's website.)
        What the publisher says about the book:
        Emmett Brown is as dark as Heathcliff, and as unpredictable. Sometimes he's an inspiration, but not often. He's a man of booze and obsessions: one of them is his 'System', an attempt to bend the laws of probability. But when the lottery numbers and horses fail him, so do love and reason, and he becomes an ogre to his wife and children.

        For the innocents - Louisa, Rob, Peter, Daniel and Jessie - the bonds formed hiding in hedges at the end of the street, waiting for the maelstroms to pass, are complex and unbreakable. Over the years, the consequences of Emmett's rages shape both their spirits and psyches, but as he lies dying they discover that love - however imperfect - is the best defence against pain. The Book of Emmett is a novel about hope and love and surviving.
        What we discussed about the book:
        • Who was the real Emmett? How did he appear in the eyes of the children?
        • Did the occasional softness he showed (the encyclopedias, taking them to the ballet) make it difficult for the children to hate him?
        • To what extent did we feel this was a memoir as opposed to totally fiction? Did we think Louisa was representative of the author?
        • If an author denies that a novel is autobiographical, are we able to accept that is is totally fiction? Does it matter?
        • To what extent was this a novel "entirely about forgiveness and hope" (Quote from Deborah Forster)
        • How affected were we by the graphic nature of some of the scenes?
        • In what ways did the texture and beauty of the language Forster employed heighten our experience of the story?
        • What did we think about Ann (the mother). What were her options in that time and culture? Why don't we know more about her back story?
        • In what ways did Ann protect her children, or minimise the impact on them?
        • How did their upbringing impact differently on each of the children?
        And then we were sidetracked into:
        • Is it possible to break cycles between generations? or is it inevitable that history repeats?
        • How resilient children are to rise above their domestic situations. Why do some children carry issues into adulthood and others don't?
        • Deborah Forster was 53 when this novel was published. She was inspired by Olga Masters whose first piece of fiction was published at 63, and Elizabeth Jolley who published her first novel at 53. Is there hope in this for all of us?!
        • How important it is to have at least one significant adult in your childhood to steer you on the right path (teachers, friends, grandparents, godparents)
        • The importance of mentors in achieving better outcomes...not just in times of adversity.
        • Will children always love their parents no matter how badly they behave?
        • Is it easier to resolve issues by remaining in an abusive environment than it is by leaving?
        And in other news we discussed:
        • Breath tests for fructose intolerance, epiglottis malfunctions, reflux and vomiting....
        • Could we last 21 days without complaining?
        • Who would ask their partners to return two excess brackets to the hardware store for a refund of $4 and who wouldn't.
        • The differences in ethnic and cultural attitudes to looking after the older generation.
        • Skype. As one No.1 Lady stated, "It's better with a camera, but you need to get dressed."
        • Approaches to pocket money for children. Should they work for it? Is it a reward or a right? Can they spend it however they like?
        • The current focus in the media on violence in the city at night. Have youth become desensitised to violence through exposure to TV, films and computer games?
        Ratings:
        Ratings range: 7 to 9 (lowest score was a DNF)
        Ratings average: 8.25
        Next book: The Gargoyle by Andrew Davidson (chosen by KM)