Monday, 14 September 2009

September Book: Jasper Jones by Craig Silvey



Jasper Jones

by Craig Silvey

(chosen by LC)











Some background links to get you started:

Minutes August Book: The Gargoyle

The Gargoyle


by Andrew Davidson


(Chosen by KM)


KM chose this book on the recommendation of 'the good doctor' - her GP with whom she often discusses bookclub choices. The GP has a great track record of suggestion books to read.

Andrew Davidson was born in Pinawa, Manitoba, Canada and graduated in 1995 from the University of British Columbia with a B.A. in English literature. He has worked as a teacher in Japan, where he has lived on and off, and as a writer of English lessons for Japanese websites. The Gargoyle, the product of seven years' worth of research and composition, is his first book. Davidson lives in Winnipeg, Manitoba.

(General biographical details from publisher's website.)

What the publisher says about the book:

The narrator of The Gargoyle is a very contemporary cynic, physically beautiful and sexually adept, who dwells in the moral vacuum that is modern life. As the book opens, he is driving along a dark road when he is distracted by what seems to be a flight of arrows. He crashes into a ravine and suffers horrible burns over much of his body. As he recovers in a burn ward, undergoing the tortures of the damned, he awaits the day when he can leave the hospital and commit carefully planned suicide—for he is now a monster in appearance as well as in soul.

A beautiful and compelling, but clearly unhinged, sculptress of gargoyles by the name of Marianne Engel appears at the foot of his bed and insists that they were once lovers in medieval Germany. In her telling, he was a badly injured mercenary and she was a nun and scribe in the famed monastery of Engelthal who nursed him back to health. As she spins their tale in Scheherazade fashion and relates equally mesmerizing stories of deathless love in Japan, Iceland, Italy, and England, he finds himself drawn back to life—and, finally, in love. He is released into Marianne's care and takes up residence in her huge stone house. But all is not well. For one thing, the pull of his past sins becomes ever more powerful as the morphine he is prescribed becomes ever more addictive. For another, Marianne receives word from God that she has only twenty-seven sculptures left to complete—and her time on earth will be finished.

Already an international literary sensation, The Gargoyle is an Inferno for our time. It will have you believing in the impossible.



What we discussed about the book:

  • The graphic description of the burn treatment process. To what extent did we feel his suffering and his sense of despair?
  • The number of events in the story that were linked to Good Friday. What was the significance of that?
  • What was the snake? Was it self-doubt? A conscience? Was it addiction?
  • Did Marianne have a mental illness? Was she bipolar? Or was she really 700 years old?
  • Was the entire story an hallucination while he was in a drug-induced coma following the accident?
  • In what ways were the 'parables' linked and how did they progress the plot.
  • Was the purpose of the parable-stories to bring to the main character an understanding of the nature of love?
  • What WAS the main character's name?
  • How effective was the journey through hell as a representation of withdrawal from drug addiction?
  • What was the role of the food feasts that Marianne would bring into the hospital?
  • Why did the main character have a background in the pornography industry? In what way did that create the character?
  • The purpose of the arrow imagery throughout the book.
Then we were sidetracked into:

  • Did anyone cry reading this book? What does it take in a book to make each of us cry?
  • How the first letter of each of the chapters spells out: 'All things in a single book bound by love' (Dante) and the last letter of each chapter spells out: 'Die Liebe is strak wie der Tod Marianne.' Is this just too clever and tricky an element? Or does it add to our understanding of the story?
  • How would you describe the genre of this book? Is it magic realism?
  • How each of the parables was balanced on a combination of elements: air/earth/water/fire. Each of the characters lived by one and died by one.
  • The links between the nuns' names who nursed the burn victim and the contemporary nurses' names: Mathildis/Maddie, Elisabeth/Beth, Constantia/Connie.
  • Was the last chapter a little too 'Hollywood' in tying up the ends? Would we have preferred a different ending point?

And in other news...

  • We discussed how various schools view the taking of holidays during school term.
  • The value of ordering books from http://www.bookdepository.co.uk/ (no postage fees)
  • Would we swap meals with a stranger?
  • The impact of Crackberries on family/worklife balance. Is it impolite to continue to check it at another person's house if they've asked you not to? Is it impolite to ask them in the first place?
  • And we wondered how many times EXACTLY we've heard the story about how RR was the only one to read Gypsy's book.
  • EDITED TO ADD: KM brought along some delicious Bougatsa (like the dog in the book) for us to try!

Ratings:

Ratings average: 7.85

Ratings range: 4 to 9

Next book: Jasper Jones by Craig Silvey (LC's choice)

Saturday, 15 August 2009

August book: The Gargoyle by Andrew Davidson



The Gargoyle

by Andrew Davidson

(chosen by KM)



Some background links to get you started:

Minutes July Book: The Book of Emmett by Deborah Forster


The Book of Emmett
by Deborah Forster
(Chosen by KE)
KE chose this book after seeing an article about it in The Age which highlighted "the inventiveness of the telling". She was particularly interested to see whether the book would examine the possibility of changing behaviours between generations, thus breaking ongoing inherited cycles of dysfunction.
Deborah Foster grew up in Footscray, Melbourne. She worked as a staff and freelance journalist for many years and was a This Life columnist on The Age and The Sunday Age. Deborah Foster is married to Alan Kohler and they have three children. The Book of Emmett is her first novel.
(general biographical detail from the publisher's website.)
What the publisher says about the book:
Emmett Brown is as dark as Heathcliff, and as unpredictable. Sometimes he's an inspiration, but not often. He's a man of booze and obsessions: one of them is his 'System', an attempt to bend the laws of probability. But when the lottery numbers and horses fail him, so do love and reason, and he becomes an ogre to his wife and children.

For the innocents - Louisa, Rob, Peter, Daniel and Jessie - the bonds formed hiding in hedges at the end of the street, waiting for the maelstroms to pass, are complex and unbreakable. Over the years, the consequences of Emmett's rages shape both their spirits and psyches, but as he lies dying they discover that love - however imperfect - is the best defence against pain. The Book of Emmett is a novel about hope and love and surviving.
What we discussed about the book:
  • Who was the real Emmett? How did he appear in the eyes of the children?
  • Did the occasional softness he showed (the encyclopedias, taking them to the ballet) make it difficult for the children to hate him?
  • To what extent did we feel this was a memoir as opposed to totally fiction? Did we think Louisa was representative of the author?
  • If an author denies that a novel is autobiographical, are we able to accept that is is totally fiction? Does it matter?
  • To what extent was this a novel "entirely about forgiveness and hope" (Quote from Deborah Forster)
  • How affected were we by the graphic nature of some of the scenes?
  • In what ways did the texture and beauty of the language Forster employed heighten our experience of the story?
  • What did we think about Ann (the mother). What were her options in that time and culture? Why don't we know more about her back story?
  • In what ways did Ann protect her children, or minimise the impact on them?
  • How did their upbringing impact differently on each of the children?
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • Is it possible to break cycles between generations? or is it inevitable that history repeats?
  • How resilient children are to rise above their domestic situations. Why do some children carry issues into adulthood and others don't?
  • Deborah Forster was 53 when this novel was published. She was inspired by Olga Masters whose first piece of fiction was published at 63, and Elizabeth Jolley who published her first novel at 53. Is there hope in this for all of us?!
  • How important it is to have at least one significant adult in your childhood to steer you on the right path (teachers, friends, grandparents, godparents)
  • The importance of mentors in achieving better outcomes...not just in times of adversity.
  • Will children always love their parents no matter how badly they behave?
  • Is it easier to resolve issues by remaining in an abusive environment than it is by leaving?
And in other news we discussed:
  • Breath tests for fructose intolerance, epiglottis malfunctions, reflux and vomiting....
  • Could we last 21 days without complaining?
  • Who would ask their partners to return two excess brackets to the hardware store for a refund of $4 and who wouldn't.
  • The differences in ethnic and cultural attitudes to looking after the older generation.
  • Skype. As one No.1 Lady stated, "It's better with a camera, but you need to get dressed."
  • Approaches to pocket money for children. Should they work for it? Is it a reward or a right? Can they spend it however they like?
  • The current focus in the media on violence in the city at night. Have youth become desensitised to violence through exposure to TV, films and computer games?
Ratings:
Ratings range: 7 to 9 (lowest score was a DNF)
Ratings average: 8.25
Next book: The Gargoyle by Andrew Davidson (chosen by KM)

Monday, 20 July 2009

July book: The Book of Emmett



The Book of Emmett

by Deborah Forster

(chosen by KE)





Some background links to get you started:

Minutes June Book: The Slap by Christos Tsiolkas


The Slap
by Christos Tsiolkas
(Chosen by Domestic Goddess)










Domestic Goddess chose this book so that she could (in her own words) "maintain her record of picking sh*tty books." She introduced the discussion of the book with a disclaimer that she was in no way related to the author or the publishers. She had no personal links to the book, and therefore No.1 Ladies should not apologise for not liking the book, or for having critical views of it.

More seriously however, she explained that she had chosen the book after reading some rave reviews of it and hearing excellent word-of-mouth recommendations. Reading the blurb on the back cover, she was intrigued by the concept.


Christos Tsiolkas is the son of Greek migrants, and was born in Melbourne in 1965. He grew up in a predominantly Greek inner city suburb of Melbourne. He has an Arts degree from the University of Melbourne and has worked as a writer, artist and film maker.

His first novel Loaded was published in 1995. (It was later made into a film, Head On.) His next novel The Jesus Man was published in 1999, followed by the critically acclaimed novel Dead Europe in 2005. The Slap was published in 2008 and has reached bestseller status.

While writing The Slap, Tsiolkas began working as a veterinary nurse. He lives in Melbourne with his partner of 24 years.


(general biographical detail from First Tuesday Book Club.)


What the publisher says about the book:

At a suburban barbecue, a man slaps a child who is not his own. This event has a shocking ricochet effect on a group of people, mostly friends, who are directly or indirectly influenced by the event. In this remarkable novel, Christos Tsiolkas turns his unflinching and all-seeing eye onto that which connects us all: the modern family and domestic life in the twenty-first century. The Slap is told from the points of view of eight people who were present at the barbecue. The slap and its consequences force them all to question their own families and the way they live, their expectations, beliefs and desires.What unfolds is a powerful, haunting novel about love, sex and marriage, parenting and children, and the fury and intensity - all the passions and conflicting beliefs - that family can arouse. In its clear-eyed and forensic dissection of the ever-growing middle class and its aspirations and fears, The Slap is also a poignant, provocative novel about the nature of loyalty and happiness, compromise and truth.

What we discussed about the book:
  • What were the overriding themes of this book: parenting, love and sex, fury and violence, family values, suburbia, class, loyalty, drugs, fidelity, youth...?
  • Did any of the characters have warm aspects? Did we empathise with any of them?
  • Was it difficult to keep track of the characters as they moved through the plot?
  • The actual slap: was it a retaliation or protection of his own child?
  • The language used was very abrasive and 'in your face' - did this alienate us as readers? Were we offended?
  • Was the language one-noted? Did we find any diffentiation in the voices of the characters?
  • Was there any degree of intimacy in any of the sexual relationships? Was the behaviour credible for 40-something year olds or did it seem adolescent?
  • Was the sex in this book, "man-sex"? Blokey? Lacking in gentle intimacy? Was it erotic?
  • Were the characters (particularly Harry) in any way self-reflective? Was there any growth as a result of the events?
  • What did the No.1 Ladies of Greek heritage think about the portrayal of Greek-Australians in this book - particularly the men? Was Koula's behaviour acceptable? Was Aisha disrespectful of Manoli?
  • Was longterm breastfeeding used as a device to make Rosie unlikeable? Was this fair?
  • What were Gary and Rosie's responsibilities in the bbq/slap event? Did they meet their responsibilities?
  • Did we think any of the characters were a reflection of the author himself? Anouk? Nick?
  • Could we relate to any of the characters?

And then we were sidetracked into:
  • Is this book "a satanic version of Neighbours"?
  • In what ways was this a political comment on "Howard's middle class"?
  • What is the "middle class"? Is it easily defined in 21st century Australia?
  • Were we tricked by the set-up of the slap at the beginning of the book into expecting something different from what the book delivered?
  • How different would this book have been if Harry did not have a history of domestic violence and had been an otherwise reasonable man who on this one occasion had crossed the line?
  • What are the rights of children? Are children as adequately protected from emotional/verbal abuse as they are from physical abuse?
  • In what ways can children's rights and adults' responsibilities come into conflict?
  • What is it about Perth that disconnected characters in novels (e.g. Aisha, Rosie) often come from Perth? Is the distance used to create that sense of disconnection?
  • Why does this book win so many awards and critical acclaim?
  • Was this book just TOO MUCH?
And in other news we discussed:
  • How many of us read births and obituraries in the newspaper? We discussed the Greek-Australian tradition of reading the funeral notices regularly.
  • The Greek inability to say the word, "cancer". Instead it is called "kakia" - the bad one/ the bad disease.
  • There was much hilarity among the Greek No.1 Ladies when it was suggested that your brother-in-law's father-in-law is a distant relation...apparently that is not the case at all. That is a close relation.
  • CH announced that, after 17 years with the one employer she has resigned. Her employers were suitably disappointed. Initially, she will be taking time off to spend with the kids - from whom she has asked for some performance criteria to measure her progress against!
Ratings:

Pre-discussion ratings range: 0 to 8
Post-discussion ratings range: 0 to 6.5
Pre-discussion ratings average: 5.2
Post-discussion ratings average: 4.7


Next book: The Book of Emmett by Deborah Forster (chosen by KE)

Saturday, 13 June 2009

June book: The Slap by Christos Tsiolkas

The Slap

by Christos Tsiolkas

(chosen by Domestic Goddess)












Some background links to get you started:

Minutes May Book: The White Tiger





The White Tiger by Aravind Adiga

(Chosen by T-Rex)




T-Rex chose this book because it attracted her attention when it won the Man Booker Prize in 2008, and she then watched it sitting in the bestseller lists for weeks.

Aravind Adiga was born in Madras (now Chennai) in 1974 . He grew up in Mangalore and studied at Canara High School, then at St. Aloysius High School. After emigrating to Sydney, Australia, with his family, he studied at James Ruse Agricultural High School. He studied English literature at Columbia College, Columbia University in New York, and also studied at Magdalen College, Oxford

Adiga began his journalistic career as a financial journalist, interning at the Financial Times. He was subsequently hired by TIME, where he remained a South Asia correspondent for three years before going freelance. During his freelance period, he wrote The White Tiger. He currently lives in Mumbai, India.

The White Tiger is his debut novel and won the 2008 Booker Prize. He is the fourth Indian-born author to win the prize, after Salman Rushdie, Arundhati Roy and Kiran Desai.

(general biographical detail from Wikipedia)

What the publisher says about the book:

Introducing a major literary talent, The White Tiger offers a story of coruscating wit, blistering suspense, and questionable morality, told by the most volatile, captivating, and utterly inimitable narrator that this millennium has yet seen.

Balram Halwai is a complicated man. Servant. Philosopher. Entrepreneur. Murderer. Over the course of seven nights, by the scattered light of a preposterous chandelier, Balram tells us the terrible and transfixing story of how he came to be a success in life -- having nothing but his own wits to help him along.

Born in the dark heart of India, Balram gets a break when he is hired as a driver for his village's wealthiest man, two house Pomeranians (Puddles and Cuddles), and the rich man's (very unlucky) son. From behind the wheel of their Honda City car, Balram's new world is a revelation. While his peers flip through the pages of Murder Weekly ("Love -- Rape -- Revenge!"), barter for girls, drink liquor (Thunderbolt), and perpetuate the Great Rooster Coop of Indian society, Balram watches his employers bribe foreign ministers for tax breaks, barter for girls, drink liquor (single-malt whiskey), and play their own role in the Rooster Coop. Balram learns how to siphon gas, deal with corrupt mechanics, and refill and resell Johnnie Walker Black Label bottles (all but one). He also finds a way out of the Coop that no one else inside it can perceive.

Balram's eyes penetrate India as few outsiders can: the cockroaches and the call centers; the prostitutes and the worshippers; the ancient and Internet cultures; the water buffalo and, trapped in so many kinds of cages that escape is (almost) impossible, the white tiger. And with a charisma as undeniable as it is unexpected, Balram teaches us that religion doesn't create virtue, and money doesn't solve every problem -- but decency can still be found in a corrupt world, and you can get what you want out of life if you eavesdrop on the right conversations.

Sold in sixteen countries around the world, The White Tiger recalls The Death of Vishnu and Bangkok 8 in ambition, scope, and narrative genius, with a mischief and personality all its own. Amoral, irreverent, deeply endearing, and utterly contemporary, this novel is an international publishing sensation -- and a startling, provocative debut.


What we discussed about the book:


  • Is this a political book? Can a book which deals with issues of class and society be anything but political?
  • Is this a particularly insightful book for a writer of such a young age (he is in his 30s)
  • The impact of the writing about the water of the Ganges. The way in which the writing evoked response on a number of levels.
  • The use of the rooster analogy throughout the book. What was the purpose and effect?
  • The issue of the disrespect Balram showed his family - is this credible? Was it that he needed to show this disrespect and lack of tradition in order for his story to work? Was he the only one who would have done so?
  • What we thought has happened to his family in the end.
  • Did Balram have a conscience?
  • Did the language within the book change as he challenged the status quo...in what ways did the language create a sense of chaos and disruption?
  • In what ways did the device of using the letters to the Chairman to tell the story influence the language used?
  • Comparing the method of dealing with Miss Pinky's driving accident and that of Balram's employee later in the book - what did that tell us about each group's values and behaviour?
  • Did the end justify the means? If Balram had just stolen the money but not killed, would that have been acceptable? Where do we draw the lines on behaviour?
  • Did Ashok get corrupted by his environment?
  • What did Balram mean when he said the power of the world would be in the browns and the yellows? Do what extent is this true?

And then we were sidetracked into:

  • Does a power imbalance corrupt even the best of intentions?
  • Are the Indian domestic classes "invisible"? (i.e. mentions in the book of them standing against the wall, almost unseen etc)
  • Democracy vs communism...is there ever a possibility of a perfect society? In what ways do human foibles undermine any attempts?
  • Would we prefer to be poor in India, or poor in China?
  • CH's experience of reading this book while on holiday in India and her experience of seeing a country consisting of of two worlds.
  • Did Slumdog Millionaire glamorise India?
  • How is it possible within any society for 1 percent of the population to force the remaining 99 per cent to live in servitude?
  • Tensions in developing nations between a rapidly rising middle class and the working class supporting them.
  • Is the vitilago that is mentioned often in the book the same condition Michael Jackson claims to have?

And in other news we discussed:

  • Whether judges and lawyers found guilty of criminal charges should face a greater sentence than the average man/woman.
  • The blinging flash from the bling across the room, as we celebrated T-Rex's impending marriage.
  • Should you be charged extra for a blow dry when you get your hair cut?
  • Clothing manufacturing sweatshops. How do you know whether retailers are using suppliers who have sweatshops or not?
  • The price of jeans. Are comfort and price inversely proportional?
  • How amazing it was to have an ABSOLUTE FULL HOUSE at bookclub - possibly for the first time in around nine years. And not only that, everyone had read AND finished the book. Gold stars all round!

Ratings:

Ratings range: 8 to 9

Ratings average: 8.45

Next book: The Slap by Christos Tsoilkas (chosen by Domestic Goddess)

Saturday, 16 May 2009

May book: The White Tiger by Aravind Adiga

May book: The White Tiger
by Aravind Adiga


(chosen by T-Rex)






Some background links to get you started:

Minutes April book: Speeches that Changed the World


Minutes April book: Speeches that Changed the World with intro by Simon Sebag Montefiore

(chosen by JM)




JM chose this book on the suggestion of a former No.1 Melbourne Ladies Bookclub member now residing in the wild West (JL). JL had said that it looked fantastic. She hadn't actually read it herself - but this is from a bookclub member who once chose the month's book (Dingo: The Story of Our Mob by Ernie Dingo) and then turned up to the discussion meeting having not actually read it herself...so we completely understood!

JM was intrigued by the idea of placing some of those famous lines from speeches into their original context by reading the full text of the speeches.

Simon Sebag Montefiore wrote the introduction to this book. He was born in 1965, educated at Harrow School and read history at Gonville & Caius College, Cambridge University.

He is the award-winning author of the bestselling books Young Stalin, Stalin: The Court of the Red Tsar and Catherine the Great & Potemkin.His new novel, Sashenka, published under the name 'Simon Montefiore', has been sold in 14 languages including Russian.

His next history book is Jerusalem: the Biography, a fresh history of the Middle East. He has recently selected his heroes from history, published as 'Heroes: History's Greatest Men and Women' and his anti-heroes published as Monsters: History's Most Evil Men and Women.

Montefiore is a Fellow of the Royal Society of Literature, and lives in London with his wife, the novelist Santa Montefiore, and their two children.


(General biographical detail from
Simon Sebag Montefiore's own website)

What the publisher says about this book:

Over 50 of the world's greatest speeches, the stories behind them and biographies of each speaker, including: Elizabeth I; Charles I; Oliver Cromwell; George Washington; Napolean; Emmeline Pankhurst; Marie Curie; Mahatma Gandhi; Stalin; Winston Churchill; Charles de Gaulle; John F Kennedy; Martin Luther King; Mother Teresa; Nelson Mandela; and many others from throughout history whose words have motivated, given hope to and sometimes terrified those who heard them.

Inspiring and thought-provoking, Speeches that Changed the World provides a unique perspective on the major turning points in history.

What we discussed about the book:
  • What was Simon Sebag Montefiore's role in the book? Was it purely the writing of the introduction? (Earlier editions do not contain his intro.) Was it just a marketing ploy to use his name to promote the anonymously compiled and edited book?
  • Why were some of the speeches chosen?
  • Did ever speech 'change the world'?
  • What constitutes a 'great speech' - is it the content, or the delivery?
  • How different is it to read words on paper that are intended to be received aurally?
  • Did we listen to the CD provided with the book? In what ways did that enhance our understanding of the speeches?
  • Was there too much or too little introductory information for each speech?
  • Would we have liked more analysis of the aftermath of the delivery of each speech?
  • Why were so many of the speeches by lawyers?
  • Did we think there were omissions of content - eg the Labour Movement/8 hour day movement?
  • Was this a book targeted at high school students?
  • What is the role of speechwriters? Should they be acknowledged, or does the giver of the speech ultimately 'own' the words?
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • Do speeches need to be heard in context to have the effect intended?
  • With hindsight, how differently do we interpret words spoken years earlier?
  • If Simon Sebag Montefiore didn't have anything to do with the editing of the book what benefit is there in writing an introduction and having your name associated with it? Is it purely a commercial transaction? Does it add to your 'brand' as an author?
  • Has modern media and the age of the soundbite changed the way speeches are written?
  • Do modern audiences have less tolerance for long-winded orations?
  • Can you teach the skill of good oration or is it something people are born with?
  • What would we include in a volume entitled, "Speeches that Changed Australia?" (e.g Rudd's Sorry day speech, Whitlam's dismissal speech, Menzies announcing war, Keating's victory speech.) What ones by non-politicians would we include?
  • How do you use silence in a speech for effect?
In other news:
  • We discussed GPS systems and whether the voices could be any more annoying.
  • Does Australia need a new standardised system of clothing sizing - how does 'Country Road' sizing compare with department store sizing?
  • Who remembered the community service announcements that ran on Channel Nine TV in Perth in the 1970s/80s? Vitamins and Minerals, Mum Knows , Dingalings do Stupid Things, and Dirt & Germs. (Click on the links to watch them on YouTube - ahhhhh for the days when mums were so revered!)
Ratings:
Ratings range: 6 to 8
Ratings average: 6.81


Next book: The White Tiger by Aravind Adiga (chosen by T-Rex)

Sunday, 19 April 2009

April Book: Speeches that Changed the World with intro by Simon Sebag Montefiore


April Book: Speeches that Changed the World
with intro by Simon Sebag Montefiore


(chosen by JM)




Some background links to get you started:

Minutes March Book: People of the Book by Geraldine Brooks



Minutes March Book: People of the Book
by Geraldine Brooks

(chosen by Gypsy)






Gypsy chose this book as she had already read it and thought it a worthy bookclub read. In a completely transparent grab for popularity, she confessed she thought it was ‘worthy of some 10s’!

We worked out that this is the third of Geraldine Brooks’ books that we have read in the 10 years of the No.1 Melbourne Ladies’ Bookclub.

Geraldine Brooks is an Australian-born author and journalist who grew up in the Western suburbs of Sydney. She worked as a reporter for The Sydney Morning Herald for three years as a feature writer with a special interest in environmental issues.

In 1982 she won a scholarship to the journalism masters program at Columbia University in New York City and later worked for The Wall Street Journal.

She was awarded the Pulitzer Prize in fiction in 2006 for her novel March. Her first novel, Year of Wonders, is an international bestseller. People of the Book is translated into 20 languages. She, her husband and their two sons divide their time between homes in Martha’s Vineyard, Massachusetts, and Sydney, Australia.

(biographical details sourced from the Author’s official website)

What the publisher says about the book:



When Hanna Heath gets a call in the middle of the night in her Sydney home about a precious medieval manuscript that has been recovered from the smouldering ruins of war−torn Sarajevo‚ she knows she is on the brink of the experience of a lifetime.

A renowned book conservator‚ she must now make her way to Bosnia to start work on restoring the Sarajevo Haggadah −− a Jewish prayer book −− to discover its secrets and piece together the story of its miraculous survival. But the trip will also set in motion a series of events that threaten to rock Hanna′s orderly life‚ including her encounter with Ozren Karamen‚ the young librarian who risked his life to save the book.

As meticulously researched as all of Brooks′ previous work‚ People of the Book is a gripping and moving novel about war‚ art‚ love and survival.

What we discussed about the book:


  • Did the structure of the novel work for us? What was the effect of unfolding the historical narrative in reverse chronological order, while the contemporary story moved forward?
  • To what extent did the novel explore the concept of human frailty?
  • Was there a theme of destructive and dysfunctional fathering within all the female characters in the book?
  • How plausible did we find Hannah Heath as a character? What was the intent of her seemingly out-of-character ‘ockerisms’ of speech at times?
  • How compelling did we find the contemporary story in comparison with the historical stories?
  • Was the contemporary story the human drama of The Book in today’s world – could it conceivably takes its place as one of the stories of The Book if the novel was set 100 years into the future?
  • Were there too many conveniences and coincidences in the plot?
  • The skill it take to start with an item such as the image of the Moorish woman at the table and then create an entire story from that spanning hundreds of years and many cultures and countries.
  • What were the links within the novel to true stories?
  • What did the novel have to say about cultures and religions co-existing peacefully?
And then we were sidetracked into:


  • What is a codex?
  • Do books such as these need a glossary for us to fully enjoy them? Is that our own responsibility to look things up?
And in other news:

  • We discussed JMs recent 40th party – and she handed out huge blocks of parmesan as party bags!
  • We analysed the appeal of the TV show Ladette to Lady. Why is it so strangely compelling?
  • We admired KE’s photobook from her trip over Christmas.
Ratings:

Ratings range: 7.5 to 9
Ratings average: 8.14
(three DNFs, one chose not to score)

Next book: Speeches that Changed the World edited by Simon Sebag Montefiore

Monday, 16 March 2009

March book: The People of the Book



People of the Book

by Geraldine Brooks







Some background information links to get you started:

Wednesday, 18 February 2009

Minutes February Book: Diary of a Bad Year by J.M Coetzee



Minutes February Book: Diary of a Bad Year by J.M Coetzee


(chosen by Fairlie)








I have to confess to choosing this book somewhat hastily. A colleague recommended it. After flicking through a few pages and with no further research, I signed it up as my choice for this year. What appealed to me was the challenge of reading a book with an obvious degree of difficulty – the split stories running across the pages would, I thought, challenge our assumptions about how to read a book.

J. M. Coetzee was the first author to win the Booker Prize twice and was awarded the Nobel Prize for Literature in 2003. His work includes Waiting for the Barbarians, Life and Times of Michael K, The Master of Petersburg, Disgrace and Inner Workings. He lives in Adelaide.
(biographical details sourced from Text Publishing’s website)

What the publisher says about the book:


A famous writer is commissioned to contribute to a book of essays called Strong opinions when he meets a young woman who lives in his apartment tower. He asks
her to become his...
... ... ... ... ...
In the laundry room of her apartment block a young woman makes the acquaintance of an ageing writer. She agrees to type up his opinions, although she is aware that what he really desires...
... ... ... ... ...
The young woman's boyfriend starts to spy on his neighbour and hatches a jealous plot to...

J. M. Coetzee's Diary of a Bad Year is about loneliness, friendship and the possibility of love. It takes the reader from Australian democracy to Guantanamo Bay, from the meaning of dishonour to the creative truth of dreams. Enthralling, unexpected and deeply moving, this may be the most original work of fiction to appear this year.**


What we discussed about the book:
  • How did we read the book? Some read each story until the dot, then read the next story until the same dot etc. Others read down each page. Some read each story in its entirety before starting the next one. Some needed three bookmarks to keep up with where they were up to.
  • Is this book fact? Is it fiction? To what degree are the opinions expressed in the essays the opinions of JM Coeztee? How much can we trust these opinions? Does it matter?
  • Was there a hierarchy to the stories on each page?
  • In what ways was it a ‘bad year’?
  • Could we hear the voice of the character ‘Senor C’ in the academic writing?
  • What was the point of the second diary?
  • To what degree does the writer mock his own opinions?
  • Is this a book about dying? Is it the book of a man saying goodbye?
  • To what degree was the JS Bach essay intended to make us reflect on this writing being like a piece of music – each of the storylines the part of a different instrument.
  • Could the book only be completely appreciated once all the parts had intertwined and played out to their end?

And then we were sidetracked into:
  • The political situation in South Africa. To what degree has that history influenced JM Coetzee’s writing?
  • Do we enjoy books that challenge to look at writing in a new way? Were we able to accept the non-linear narrative style of this book?

And in other news:

  • We reflected on the tragic events of recent days in Victoria with the bushfires.
  • We acknowledged that this meeting marked the 10 year anniversary of the No.1 Melbourne Ladies’ Bookclub and we agreed to plan some events to celebrate this during the year.
  • We discussed the Twilight series of books...and how addictive they are for mothers of tweenage girls...

Ratings:

Ratings range: 6 to 9
Ratings average: 7.55
(one DNF was a midrange score)

Next book: The People of the Book by Geraldine Brooks

Friday, 21 November 2008

Minutes November Book: The Time Traveler’s Wife by Audrey Niffenegger


Minutes November Book: The Time Traveler’s Wife by Audrey Niffenegger

(chosen by Domestic Goddess)


Domestic Goddess chose this book because she wanted something uplifting. She liked the science-fiction aspect to it, combined with a love story.

Audrey Niffenegger is an artist and a professor at the Columbia College Chicago Center for Book and paper Arts, where she teaches writing, letterpress printing, and fine edition book production. She is in her thirties. The Time Traveler's Wife is her first novel.

(biographical details sourced from readinggroupguides.com)

What the publisher says about the book:

This extraordinary, magical novel is the story of Clare and Henry who have known each other since Clare was six and Henry was thirty-six, and were married when Clare was twenty-two and Henry thirty. Impossible but true, because Henry is one of the first people diagnosed with Chrono-Displacement Disorder: periodically his genetic clock resets and he finds himself pulled suddenly into his past or future. His disappearances are spontaneous and his experiences are alternately harrowing and amusing. The Time Traveler's Wife depicts the effects of time travel on Henry and Clare's passionate love for each other with grace and humour. Their struggle to lead normal lives in the face of a force they can neither prevent nor control is intensely moving and entirely unforgettable.
What we discussed about the book:

  • The non-linear nature of the book. How did we read it? Were we able to rationalise the interlocking time-frames?
  • Was Henry’s violence a survival mechanism? Did his lack of clothing highlight his vulnerability?
  • Did the book “transport and transfix “us?
  • Why did stress seem to trigger the time travel?
  • In what ways did the time-travel explore different perspectives on Clare and Henry’s relationship?
  • Is this science-fiction? What constitutes science-fiction?
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • How would the ability to time-travel alter your perspective on events?
  • Would the ability to time travel be a curse? Knowing things but being powerless to change them.
And in other news:
  • Is the Thermomix the eight wonder of the world?
  • How many of us admit to having watched Bold and the Beautiful, Days of our Lives and/or The Young and the Restless at some point in our lives? And how easy is it to pick the storyline right up again after 10 years break?
Ratings:

Ratings range: 5 to 10
Ratings average: 7.44
(three DNFs were the lowest three marks)

Next book: Diary of a Bad Year by J.M Coetzee

Saturday, 15 November 2008

November book: The Time Traveler's Wife by Audrey Niffenegger



The Time Traveler's Wife
by Audrey Niffenegger

(Chosen by Domestic Goddess)



Some background links to get you started:

Wednesday, 12 November 2008

Minutes October Book: In Defence of Food by Michael Pollan



Minutes October Book: In Defence of Food by Michael Pollan

(chosen by Fairlie)


In memory of our friend, S



Fairlie chose this book because she heard Michael Pollan speak at the Sydney Writers Festival and he was very impressive. He has a science/journalism background and as a result has done a lot of research into nutrition. Fairlie saw and heard him speak another time (also at the Writers Festival) and this clinched it for her - it was a book for her bookclub!

Michael Pollan is the author, most recently, of In Defense of Food: An Eater's Manifesto. His previous book, The Omnivore's Dilemma: A Natural History of Four Meals (2006), was named one of the ten best books of 2006 by the New York Times and the Washington Post. He is also the author of The Botany of Desire: A Plant's-Eye View of the World (2001); A Place of My Own (1997); and Second Nature (1991). A contributing writer to the New York Times Magazine, Pollan is the recipient of numerous journalistic awards. Pollan served for many years as executive editor of Harper's Magazine and is now the Knight Professor of Science and Environmental Journalism at UC Berkeley. His articles have been anthologized in Best American Science Writing (2004); Best American Essays (1990 and 2003) and the Norton Book of Nature Writing. He lives in the Bay Area with his wife, the painter Judith Belzer, and their son, Isaac.
(biographical details sourced from the author's website.)

What the publisher says about the book:

"Eat food. Not too much. Mostly plants." These simple words go to the heart of Michael Pollan's In Defence of Food. Humans used to know how to eat well, Pollan argues. But the balanced dietary lessons that were once passed down through generations have been confused, complicated, and distorted by food industry marketers, nutritional scientists, and journalists – all of whom have much to gain from our dietary confusion. Indeed, real food is fast disappearing from the marketplace, to be replaced by "nutrients," and plain old eating by an obsession with nutrition that is, paradoxically, ruining our health, not to mention our meals. Michael Pollan's bracing and eloquent manifesto shows us how we might start making thoughtful food choices that will enrich our lives and our palates and enlarge our sense of what it means to be healthy.


What we discussed about the book:
  • The message of the book was simple and it was not rocket science - we knew or suspected the message but having it in black and white really brought it home.
  • When you take out all of the fat in foods what do you put back in?
  • Is what manufacturers put back in "good" for human consumption?
  • Food lobbying - is it as strong in Australia as in USA and other countries?
  • Is corn syrup in everything?
  • Why has the meat industry changed so dramatically in Australia in last 5 yrs - with increased use of antibiotics and hormones?
  • National Heart Foundation health tick - what do companies have to do (or not do) to get the tick?
  • Upsizing of meals - is this tied to commodity prices? Are supermarkets downsizing their packaging whilst increasing price of manufactured food items?
  • Lengthy discussion regarding full fat (yogurt, cheese etc) versus skim or low fat products and number of eggs that are now considered healthy in daily diet.
  • Chemical processes to produce powdered egg or a substitute product (eg fruit flavours) - is it as healthy as using fresh egg or fruits in manufactured products? Does this apply to whole host of other products - eg milk, yogurt?
  • Are we losing our sense of community due to shopping in supermarkets - no longer knowing local butcher, baker etc?
  • Are the range of products available in Australia declining? Is this a positive development? Is it squeezing smaller (perhaps organic focused) manufacturers out of the market?
And then we were sidetracked into:
  • Are the burgers really bigger and tastier at Hungry Jacks'?
  • What sort of food colouring and "make up" for the food do advertisers (via professional food stylists) use in those gorgeous photos of succulent food?

And in other news:

  • Muck up days - why was a whole Yr 12 Grade suspended at a prominent boys school in Melbourne?
  • Boarding school in Perth - one member reminisced about a headmistress who had a really strict view of life and really enforced the rules but deep down had a soft spot in her heart.
  • We discussed the rumour that there may be a document dating back to the late 90s regarding the "rules" of our bookclub. Some members will search their archives and report back - this drew great peels of laughter....and led us into a discussion that there may also be a "briefing document" that was provided to one new member with a run down of the personalities of other members!
  • Type 2 diabetes - explanation of the difference between this and Type 1. Symptoms - thirsty, loss of concentration, tiredness. We had a look at an insulin kit and explanation of what a person with Type 2 diabetes has to do each day to maintain their insulin level.
  • And then we decided that we really should stop chatting at 11.00 pm so the host can get us out of their home...

On a very sad note:
We discussed the funeral arrangements for our dear friend and previous administrator and minute secretary - S. She was loved by many and will be so greatly missed. Our love and thoughts go to her husband, her daughter and their families.

Ratings:

Ratings range: 6.5 to 8.5

Ratings average: 7.43

Next book: The Time Traveller's Wife by Audrey Niffenegger

Thank you to Domestic Goddess for compiling these minutes!

Tuesday, 14 October 2008

October book: In Defence of Food by Michael Pollan



October book: In Defence of Food by Michael Pollan

(chosen by Fairlie)


Some background links to get you started:

Tuesday, 30 September 2008

Minutes September Book: Water for Elephants

Minutes September Book: Water for Elephants


by Sara Gruen


(chosen by KM)


KM chose this book on the recommendation of her GP who is also in a bookclub and often shares advice and feedback about book choices. She said that she had flown through this book and that it was a great read.


Sara is a Canadian-born dual citizen (Canadian and American) who moved to the United States in 1999 for a technical writing job. When she was laid off two years later, instead of looking for another job, she started writing fiction full-time. She’s currently working on Ape House, her fourth novel.

Sara lives with her husband, three children, two dogs, two cats, three goats, and horse in an environmentalist community.


(biographical details sourced from the author's own website)


What the publisher says about the book:


A great, glorious, big-hearted novel set in a travelling circus touring the back blocks of America during the great depression of the early 1930s. It's a story of love and hate, trains and circuses, dwarves and fat ladies, horses and elephants - or, to be specific, one elephant, Rosie, star of the Benzini Bros Most Spectacular Show on Earth . . .

What we discussed about the book:
  • The extent to which the detailed research of the depression era and circuses enhanced the atmosphere and experience of this book
  • The manner in which Sara Gruen wrote this book - she started with a very detailed outline
  • The inclusion of mini-plots and themes within the story -e.g prohibition, elderly care
  • Did Jacob have dementia?
  • What was the nature of August's mental state? How did we feel about his treatment of animals?
  • Was Walter the archetypal clown - happy smile, but so sad?
  • The careful observation of the dialogue between the working men. In what ways was this created by Gruen?
  • Were there parallels between this story and that of Jacob in the Bible?
  • The use of symbolism in the story - eg the crossover between Rosie/Rosemary...rosemary is the symbol for remembrance.
  • What did water represent throughout the book?
  • Was the ending credible? Could it only happen in a circus?
Then we were sidetracked into:
  • The issue of homelessness during the Great Depression. What type of people became hobos? What were the circumstances that caused this?
  • Elderly care. Why are there not enough places? Is the standard of care offered adequate? How do we wish to be cared for when we are elderly?
  • Can elephants physically smile?
  • Do circuses still have animal performances?
  • Our own memories of childhood circuses: popcorn, sawdust, circus trucks, animals.
  • Why do clowns scare children?
And in other news:
  • We discussed the paucity of good part-time jobs for mums returning to the workforce
  • We talked about night-nannies and sleep schools to train babies and toddlers to sleep through the night
Ratings:

Ratings range: 7 to 9.5
Ratings average: 7.94

Next book: In Defence of Food by Michael Pollan