Monday, 11 September 2017

September book: Commonwealth by Ann Patchett

Commonwealth
by Ann Patchett

(Discussion led by KM)








Some background links to get you started:


Wednesday, 16 August 2017

August book: Big Little Lies by Liane Moriarty

Big Little Lies
by Liane Moriarty

(discussion led by JC)






Some background links to get you started:


Thursday, 10 August 2017

Top rated books 2007 to date

A question came up after we read All the Light We Cannot See as to whether that was our highest rating book ever? So…I’ve gone back through our records to 2007 (when the blog began), and pulled out the top-rating books (see below). No, All the Light We Cannot See is not our highest…that honour goes to The Book Thief Interesting to reflect on whether there are any common genres/themes/styles/periods etc within this list?

The Book Thief by Marcus Zusak (9.06)

The Road by Cormac McCarthy (9.0)

The Secret History by Donna Tartt (9.0)


The Portrait of a Lady by Henry James
 (9.0*)
*only two ladies finished the book, so this is based on two scores…

The Go-Between by L.P.Hartley (8.83)

The In-Between World of Vikram Lall  by M.G. Vassanji (8.79)

All the Light We Cannot See by Anthony Doerr (8.7)

Let the Great World Spinby Colum McCann
 (8.67)


The Transit of Venus by Shirley Hazzard (8.63)

The Other Hand by Chris Cleave (8.6)


Monday, 7 August 2017

July book: The Sellout by Paul Beatty

The Sellout
by Paul Beatty

Discussion led by CH




Some background links to get you started:

Wednesday, 14 June 2017

June book: Faithful by Alice Hoffman

Faithful

by Alice Hoffman

(discussion led by TG)





Some background links to get you started:
What we discussed about the book:
  • The themes of redemption and making your own family
  • Did Shelby make choices or did life make them for her? 
  • The writing style and the devices used
  • The rawness and sparseness of the lanaguage - what was the effect of that? How did it move the story along? 
  • The interactions with Marvelle and the kids - what did that show about Shelby?
  • Was teh power of the postcards in the idea of them rather than the actuality? 
  • What role did Helene play? Was she a vehicle to outwardly reflect Sheby's inner guilt?
  • Was this a book about religion?
  • Who was 'faithful' to Shelby? Who was she faithful to? 
  • What was the role of the tattooed girl in the bookshop?
  • Which (if any) characters did we empathise with and why? 
  • What did Shelby look like?
Then we were distracted to discuss: 
  • Why are we so polarised in our experience of this book - lovers vs haters? (as reflected in ratings)
  • Do you need to have personal experience of dysfunction in order for a portrayal of it to resonate?
  • The idea of one moment where a life changes course permanently
And in other news we chatted about: 
  • OAMs, AMs, etc - what is the Australian award system all about? What do you need to do to get one? Do the right people get them?
  • The pleasures and perils of new puppies
  • The quote 'life just grows around your wound' - what does this mean? 

Ratings
Range: 2 to 9
Average: 6.19

Friday, 12 May 2017

May book: Judas by Amos Oz

Judas 
by Amos Oz

(Discussion led by BC)




Some background links to get you started:

What we discussed about the book:

  • The themes of treachery and loyalty - how were they explored?
  • Are traitors always bad?
  • What do we know about Judas? 
  • The juxtaposition of Atalia's story with that of Judas
  • The language devices used - e.g. repetition of phrases
  • How the book interweaves the personal and the political
  • What did the stray cats and dogs represent?
Then we were distracted to discuss: 

  • A potted history of Israel/Palestine
  • The current politics of the Middle East 
  • The mechanics of the two-state solution
  • Are there any conflicts in the world that don't have an element of religion as a factor?
  • How appropriate are the 10 commandments today? Are they all applicable to our lives?
And in other news we chatted about: 

  • The hierachy of Victorian skifields - where does Mt Buller sit in that heirachy?
  • The similarities and differences between Greek biscuits and Scottish ones. 
  • Issues the ACCC should be investigating


Ratings
Range: 5 to 7.5
Average: 6.63

Saturday, 22 April 2017

April book: The Dry by Jane Harper

The Dry
by Jane Harper
(discussion led by MH-C)





Some background links to get you started: 



What we discussed about the book:

  • Where did we think this was set? Was it the Mallee?
  • What were the clues revealed throughout the book? Who spotted them? Did anyone pick the killer before the reveal?
  • How could we explain the note with 'Falk' written on it? How would that have been motivated?
  • Did we think this book vilify country town life? Did it reflect our own experiences of country life?
  • Were we happy with the resolution? 
  • Could there be a sequel to this book...or would that be a mistake? If so, what direction should it take? 
  • Structurally, the italic sections initially were memory or explanation as viewed by a character...then part way through they swapped to omniscient narrator - did this make sense?
  • Is shooting rabbits a regular past-time during a drought?
  • Why was it suggested the Luke may have been cruel to a rabbit in the past? 
  • Was Luke the father of Gretchen's baby? 
  • Appreciation of the writing style - a descriptive, but pacy narrative. 

Then we were distracted to discuss: 

  • Who do we think Hollywood will cast to play each of the characters in the film version of this book? But who would we actually LIKE to play each?
  • Crime-writing as a genre. What are the 'rules'? And how closely did this book, stick to the rules?
  • If you liked this book - The Broken Shore by Peter Temple is recommended
  • How long a grave has to be left to 'settle' before a gravestone can be erected.


And in other news: 

  • We were educated about 'Netflix and chill'
  • We discussed profiling of psycho-killers. In real life, can anyone pick a killer in their midst?


Ratings
Range: 7 to 9
Average: 7.85

Monday, 13 March 2017

March book: The Riviera Set by Mary S. Lovell

The Riviera Set

by Mary S. Lovell

Discussion led by JP




Some background links to get you started:



What we discussed about the book:

  • Is this the story of a house? Or a biography?
  • Aly Khan - how fascinating he was?
  • Did this story bring 'interesting bits to life'?
  • How could we see the author being influenced by her sources as to how to shape the book?
  • What is the point of the book? What did we take away from it?
  • How was the backdrop of historical events portrayed? (WW2, Great Depression etc)
  • What did we think the author's opinion of Churchill was? Which characters did we as readers like/dislike? 
  • Why do readers continue to be fascinated by this set of people and this era? What is it that captures imaginations?
  • How did this book reflect social structures in England?
  • Why did we think the post-scripts were included? 
Then we were distracted to discuss:
  • Class mobility in the early part of the 20th Century - what did it take to breach boundaries?
  • Differences between English reviews and non-English reviews of the book - what influences these differences?
  • How difficult is it to construct a continuity of narrative when writing non-fiction?
  • How quickly huge 'celebrities' are forgotten - e.g. Sheila Milbanke etc. Will the Khardasians ever suffer the same fate? 
And in other news:
  • We mused about DNA and genetics
Ratings
Range: 3 to 6
Average: 4.61


Monday, 13 February 2017

February book: All the Light We Cannot See by Anthony Doerr

All the Light We Cannot See 
by Anthony Doerr 

Discussion led by JM






Some back ground links to get you started:
What we discussed about the book:

  • Did we feel the characters were fully rounded? Which ones were/were not?
  • In what ways did the narrative resemble a radio play?
  • What does the title refer to? What is the light we cannot see? Imagery of blindness, underground (mining, the collapsed building)
  • Is there perception beyond what you can physically see? i.e. spectrum of light that we cannot see?
  • What was the purpose of the Jules Verne references?
  • In what ways did the book create an atmosphere of growing dread as the war approached?
  • What motivated Frederick's mother?
  • Did we like the style of the narraitive, with the to/fro between stories and variety of perspectives?
  • Why was American terminology used in French and German character dialogue?
  • What is an 'Epigraph'?
  • Who were our favourite characters?
  • Should the book have ended sooner than it did? Did we need to know what happened into the future?
Ratings
Range: 8 to 9.8
Average: 8.7

Saturday, 31 December 2016

Books read in 2016

The ratings recorded below reflect an average of the members' ratings (out of ten) of their personal experience of the reading of that book. The links take you to the post that contains the background/minutes for that book's discussion.

Olive Kitteridge  By Elizabeth Strout
Rating: 8.28

We Are All Completely Beside Ourselves by Karen Joy Fowler
Rating: 7.44

My Brilliant Friend by Elena Ferrante
Rating: 7.86

The Golden Age by Joan London
Rating: 8.31

Ghost River by Tony Burch
Rating: 7.83

The Heart Goes Last by Margaret Atwood
Rating: 5.83

The Girl on the Train by Paula Hawkins
Rating: 7.58

Rush Oh! by Shirley Barrett
Rating: 5.00

Fates and Furies by Lauren Groff
Rating: 7.93



Thursday, 1 September 2016

September book: Rush Oh! by Shirley Barrett

Rush Oh!

by Shirley Barrett

(discussion led by KM)





Some background links to get you started:




Friday, 10 June 2016

July book; The Heart Goes Last by Margaret Atwood

The Heart Goes Last

by Margaret Atwood

(discussion led by CH)






Some background links to get you started:




Friday, 3 June 2016

June book: Ghost River

Ghost River

by Tony Birch

(discussion led by MH)




Some background links to get you started:




What we discussed about the book:

  • the theme of male relationships - shown many different ways
  • how much has the Yarra River changed (or been changed) over the years?
  • aspects of the book that draw on the author's own experiences
  • representations of Aboriginality - were Sonny and Ren Indigenous? What evidence is there to support this? 
  • how this captures a snapshot of Melbourne life at that time
  • corruption, mafia, police, authorities and their interactions with the wider communitiy
  • the art of storytelling - in what ways is this a 'great tale'?
  • who were the river men?
  • metaphors and images of birds throughout the book
  • the role of the river itself. was it a character? what did the river symbolise?
  • what was the point of the Della story and the evangelical ministry?

And we were side-tracked into:
  • Great TV shows - Outlanders, The Night Manager, House of Cards
  • How to subscribe to podcasts on your phone (and listen in the car)
  • Near-misses and risk management, in the workplace, school camps, life..
  • Password keeper software: e.g. LastPass, 1Password

Ratings
Range: 6 to 9 
Average: 7.83

Wednesday, 11 May 2016

May book: The Golden Age by Joan London

The Golden Age

by Joan London

(discussion led by JM)



Some background links to get you started:

What we discussed about the book:
- What 'the golden age' is in mythology
- how recognisable was this version of Perth?
- Polio - what it is, how it is prevented, do we require booster shots?
- The real Golden Age home - where was it? what was it?

Ratings
Range: 5 to 9.5
Average: 8.31


Friday, 1 April 2016

April Book - My Brilliant Friend by Elena Ferranti

My Brilliant Friend 

by Elena Ferrante 

 (Discussion led by LD) 




Some background links to get you started:

What we discussed about the book:
- is this a book people either love or hate?
- does it stand alone, or do you need to read the other three parts?
- do we want to know what happened?
- who is Elena Ferrante? Why the anonymity?
- Is it memoir or fiction?
- Does it stray into magic realism? (copper pot exploding)
- how did Marcello get the shoes?
- what did we think of the characterisation?
- Were we confused by the switching of names (Lina/Lila/Raffaela...)
- did it read like a soap opera?
- what has really happened at the start?
- is this a reliable narrator?

Ratings
Range: 7 to 9
Average: 7.86

Sunday, 6 March 2016

March book: We Are All Completely Beside Ourselves by Karen Joy Fowler

We Are All Completely Beside Ourselves 
by Karen Joy Fowler

(discussion leader: Fairlie)





Some background links to get you started:

What we discussed about the book:
- at what point did we realise who Fern was? How did that affect our reading of it?
- does knowing how a story ends change the way you read it?
- Why does Rosemary start telling this story from the middle?
- What hints did we have about Fern's true nature?
- Is Rosemary a reliable narrator? Why not?
- Does unfairness bother the characters in this book? How?
- Did Rosemary have anything to atone for? If so, has she by the end of the book?
- is it reasonable to want a child to have 'an extraordinary life'?

Ratings
Range: 6 to 8
Average: 7.44

Wednesday, 10 February 2016

February book: Olive Kitteridge by Elizabeth Strout


Olive Kitteridge 
by Elizabeth Strout



(discussion leader: Gypsy)





Some background links to get you started:
What we discussed about the book:
- how is generational conflict highlighted?
- is there a generational change in parenting and relationships?
- how do approaches to mental illness change between the generations
- how is suspense built through the structure of these 13 stories?
- in what ways is Olive essential as the link?
-What was it with the donuts?
- the themes of suicide, eating disorders 'we're all starving', hunger, death, aging, flawed relationships
- how sad was the wedding story?
- was Christopher's father ineffective?
- small town life and the interconnected-ness of such communities
- how painful would it have been for Olive to revisit the house they'd built for Christopher?
- why does Henry tolerate and stand by Olive? Does he believe that commitment is for life?
- Was Olive actually overweight or was she just a large woman?
- Olive's propensity to save younger people. Why?
- how does Olive's interaction with Jack Kennison reflect change in her personality?
- do we allow people to be sad?

Ratings:
Range: 8 to 9
Average: 8.28

Thursday, 31 December 2015

Books read in 2015

The ratings recorded below reflect an average of the members' ratings (out of ten) of their personal experience of the reading of that book. The links take you to the post that contains the minutes for that book's discussion.

The Bolter By Frances Osborne
Rating: 7.69
(Theme: women behaving badly)

A City Lost and Found, Whelan the Wrecker's Melbourne by Robyn Annear
Rating: 6.5
(Theme: this is Melbourne)

Foe By J.M. Coetzee
Rating: 7.19
(Theme: a classic rewritten)

Only Child (Stranglehold) By Jack Ketcham
Rating: 7.625
(Theme: one that would shock your grandmother)

The Coat Route by Meg Lukens Noonan
Rating: 8.11
(Theme: a good cover)

Hello Beautiful By Hannie Rayson
Rating: 7.38
(Theme: a good laugh is sunshine in the house)

The Museum of Extraordinary Things by Alice Hoffman
Rating: 7.36
(Theme: a fairytale ending)

The Rehearsal By Eleanor Catton
Rating: TBA
(Theme: author under 30)

A Personal Matter by Kenzaburo Oe
Rating: 5.5
(Theme: translated from...)

The Most Good You Can Do by Peter Singer
Rating: 7.83
(Theme: the price of privilege is poverty)